r/Trigun • u/Meltlilith_ • 6h ago
Discussion Finished reading the manga... is it just me or is the 98 anime better? Spoiler
Don't get me wrong I enjoyed the manga for the most part but it felt very underbaked to me? There were many times where it felt like the mangaka didn't know what they wanted to do, were making things up as the story went on and were very much rushing the last 4 volumes to get to the ending which made the story feel like a mess. The art being near indecipherable didn't help either
The anime with the little chapters they had to go off of and then go into it's own direction made up a pretty good story for itself. While it's not perfect by any means be it the outdated cliches, superficial lore and worldbuilding, the very open ending or animation that hasn't held up even comparing it to other 90s anime at the time... i honestly felt like the anime told a better story and was a more satisfying experience than the manga. The anime felt like it knew what it wanted to be and what it wanted to tell and in result told a pretty consistent story despite its limits
Whereas the manga it was mostly the mangaka coming up with random ideas and just kinda dropping them or barely expanding on them at all, like the weird coin system with Legato, everything about the Eye of Michael, Milly and Meryl being forgotten until the ending or giving any reason on how Vash is still alive despite his hair being completely black. Like the entire manga it feels like things kinda happen just cause the mangaka thought it was cool.
Sure it has more content than the anime but i only really liked the expansion of the gung ho guns, plants and the inclusion of Tesla. Livio was better as an antagonist, his switch up was done too fast i didn't like him as a sidekick at all, Elendira just kinda stands around till near the end and we never really learn much about her, the fight scenes actively make this manga a slog to get through, pacing is all over the place and everything else feels like missed potential. To me this is a case of less is better, which is what the anime is
While I have yet to watch them i feel like Stampede and Stargaze know this since they went out of their way to change so much. It feels like they knew the manga was kinda all over the place and needed some sort of overhaul if they were gonna make an anime that would follow the mangas ideas more closely. Whether the changes were actually good or not I'll find out next month I guess
