While popular history and A Bridge Too Far turned Sosabowski into an infallible prophet wronged by British snobbery, and Browning* did, in fact, throw him under the bus post-battle, leading to Sosabowski's dismissal in December was his actal leadership in the battle really effective? My own gut feeling is that he was dealt a bad hand, but he played it poorly anyway.
Consider.
Failure to Immediately Seize the Heveadorp Ferry; when they landed, it as still intact and lightly guarded; if they had made haste as their order demanded, they could have taken it and helped Urquhart.
Once ferry was lost he made no real effort to try and improvise and cross, instead waiting for XXX Corp to bring up boats, while when they actually linked up with 43rd Division he was rather prickly and uncooperative; I think only a quarter of his brigade (in reality, a reinforced battalion) managed to cross.
So he seems to have had very good operational foresight but tactically, iffy.
*As an aside some of the biggest critiques about Browning in Cornilius Ryan's book and subsequent movie were unfair; he did in fact, take the presence of the German armored divisions seriously enough to ask both Monty and Brereton about risks, and the argued for landing at the bridge directly, which USAAF and RAF flatly refused, leading to the famous Bridge too far " comment, which came before, not after, the battle. The novelist Daphne Du Maurier collected a lot of his papers post-1977, planning to write a biography of him for some reason (/sarcasm) but died before she could,