r/baseball
•
u/PM_ME_YUR_SALADS
•
1h ago
Every MLB team has been invited to Thanksgiving dinner.
All 30 MLB teams are invited to Thanksgiving dinner. Everyone was asked to bring one dish, arrive by noon, and please, for the love of God, behave themselves.
Here's how it goes.
11:00 AM — The guests start arriving
Yankees: Arrive an hour early with $3,000 worth of imported caviar, shaved truffles, and some French appetizer nobody can pronounce. Place it prominently in the center of the table. Nobody eats any of it. Spend the entire evening reminding everyone how much it cost.
Dodgers: Show up with three professionally catered turkeys, two private chefs, and a $400 million charcuterie board. Offer to buy the house. Announce they'll be paying for the food through 2047.
Mets: Pull into the driveway in a Lamborghini carrying a $75,000 bottle of wine. Announce that this Thanksgiving will finally be different. Trip on the front step, drop the bottle, and watch it shatter. Get back in the Lamborghini and leave without saying a word.
Athletics: Show up with a folding chair and a suitcase. Ask if they can stay through Christmas because they're currently between permanent residences. Nobody knows where to put them.
Blue Jays: Confused why Thanksgiving is happening in November. Explain that they already celebrated theirs in October. Bring maple syrup anyway.
Brewers: Arrive wearing their 2026 World Series championship rings. Bring beer, bratwurst, cheese curds, and a replica championship trophy. Spend the next six hours telling everyone about their incredible postseason. Nobody outside Wisconsin gives a shit.
Rays: Bring a homemade casserole that cost $8.43 to make. It's absolutely delicious. Everyone agrees it deserves to win something. Unfortunately, the Brewers brought something slightly better, so the Rays finish second again.
12:30 PM — Appetizers and the first arguments
Red Sox: Bring warm Sam Adams and baked beans. Immediately start complaining about how the Yankees are ruining Thanksgiving by spending too much money. Say this while wearing a $900 sweater and checking the time on a $15,000 watch. Yankees point this out. Red Sox tell them to go fuck themselves.
Phillies: Show up already drunk in an Eagles jersey. Bring a case of Yuengling and absolutely no food. Immediately take control of the television. Inform everyone that the Eagles play the Cowboys at 4:30 and that Thanksgiving dinner WILL NOT interfere with the game.
Astros: Bring a beautiful homemade-looking macaroni and cheese. Everyone loves it until somebody catches them peeling a Costco label off the bottom of the pan. They're accused of cheating, and the entire dish gets thrown in the trash. Astros spend the rest of the afternoon insisting that everyone else does the same thing and they're just the ones who got caught.
Pirates: Bring a single bag of store-brand dinner rolls. Ask the host for $20 to cover their gas money. Later sell the remaining rolls to the Dodgers for cash and two promising appetizers.
Orioles: Bring a gorgeous seven-layer dip in an expensive serving dish. Everyone takes pictures of it. Once they actually taste it, it's somehow bland, watery, and deeply disappointing. Orioles insist it's still a young dip and everyone needs to be patient.
Guardians: Bring a sack of potatoes, half a stick of butter, and a $12 grocery receipt. Somehow produce the best mashed potatoes anyone has ever tasted. Refuse to explain how.
Tigers: Bring an incredible homemade stuffing recipe that's been passed down for generations. Dodgers immediately offer $90 million for exclusive rights to the recipe. Tigers reluctantly agree.
2:00 PM — The kitchen is becoming a problem
Rangers: Bring 40 pounds of smoked brisket. Refuse to acknowledge that turkey is the traditional Thanksgiving meat. Spend most of the afternoon explaining that everything is bigger and better in Texas.
Royals: Also bring barbecue. Get into a 90-minute argument with the Rangers about what constitutes real barbecue. Eventually both sides agree that everyone else's barbecue is terrible.
Reds: Bring Skyline chili. Pour it directly onto the mashed potatoes. Everyone watches in horror. Cincinnati insists this is perfectly normal behavior.
Cardinals: Bring a handwritten recipe from 1942 and insist everyone follow it exactly. Spend the afternoon explaining that Thanksgiving isn't done the right way, with fundamentals, discipline, and respect for tradition. Nobody asked.
Cubs: Bring six Chicago-style hot dogs, exactly enough for themselves. Refuse to share. Spend dinner explaining why ketchup is a crime against humanity.
White Sox: Also bring Chicago dogs, only for themselves. Sit at the opposite end of the table from the Cubs. Somehow the hot dogs are worse. Nobody is surprised.
Twins: Bring a lime Jell-O salad containing shredded carrots, cottage cheese, and something that might be mayonnaise. Nobody touches it. Spend the entire afternoon bitching about the Brewers switching to the National League in 1998.
Angels: Arrive carrying what looks like a magnificent homemade pumpkin pie. Twist an ankle stepping onto the porch. Drop the pie directly onto the concrete. Announce they'll bring another pie in six to eight weeks, pending further evaluation.
4:00 PM — Dinner is finally served
Padres: Haven't spoken to anyone all afternoon. Have set up a portable UV lamp in the corner of the living room and are sitting underneath it, drinking expensive tequila and wearing designer sunglasses. Dodgers ask if they're okay. Padres tell them to mind their own fucking business.
Giants: Bring fresh San Francisco sourdough. Spend the entire meal complaining about the Dodgers buying their way to success while eating four servings of the Dodgers' catered turkey.
Diamondbacks: Bring a rattlesnake appetizer nobody wants. Spend the rest of the evening loudly reminiscing about Thanksgiving 2001. Make sure to do it directly in front of the Yankees. Ask the Yankees if they remember what happened in Arizona that year. Yankees pretend not to hear them. Diamondbacks ask again.
Braves: Bring an incredible homemade peach cobbler. Announce that absolutely everyone is welcome to have some except the Mets. Mets aren't even there anymore. Braves put a handwritten "NO METS" sign on it anyway.
Marlins: Bring a cooler full of freshly caught seafood. Halfway through dinner, trade everything in the cooler to the Dodgers for three frozen fish sticks and a shrimp prospect who won't be ready until 2031.
Nationals: Bring a tray of cupcakes decorated with 2019 World Series championship rings. Spend the evening giving the Phillies dirty looks and periodically glaring at the Mets' empty chair. Keep asking everyone, "Remember when we won the World Series?" Toronto keeps calling them the Expos. Nationals repeatedly explain that they're not the Expos anymore. Toronto apologizes and calls them the Expos again ten minutes later.
Mariners: Arrive early to help set the table. Make sure everyone has a chair, enough silverware, and a full glass. Spend dinner running back and forth between the kitchen and dining room helping everyone else. By the time they finally sit down, all the turkey is gone. They announce that next Thanksgiving will be different.
4:30 PM — The wheels come off
The Eagles-Cowboys game starts.
The Phillies are standing six inches from the television screaming obscenities at people who cannot hear them.
The Yankees are demanding to know why nobody has touched their $3,000 caviar.
The Red Sox are screaming that the Yankees bought their way into being invited.
The Diamondbacks lean over and whisper "Luis Gonzalez" into the Yankees' ear.
The Astros have been caught digging their macaroni and cheese out of the trash can.
The Cubs and White Sox are arguing about which side of Chicago makes a better hot dog, despite neither offering anyone else one.
The Twins are drunkenly demanding the Brewers return to the American League.
The Brewers are drinking beer out of their World Series trophy and explaining why they're the greatest team in baseball. Again, nobody cares.
The Padres are now visibly sunburned from their UV lamp but refuse to turn it off.
The Dodgers have purchased the dining room, living room, and rights to next year's Thanksgiving.
The Pirates are selling leftovers on Facebook Marketplace.
The Nationals ask if everyone remembers 2019.
Toronto calls them the Expos.
The Phillies throw a dinner roll at the television.
The Mets send a group text saying they're fine and that next Thanksgiving will be their year.
7:00 PM — Dessert and the aftermath
The Angels' pie is still on the driveway.
The Braves refuse to let anyone take peach cobbler home to New York.
The Yankees' caviar is untouched.
The Red Sox are in the driveway drinking warm beer, still complaining about the Yankees.
The Diamondbacks have brought out a DVD of the 2001 World Series.
The Brewers have brought out a DVD of the 2026 World Series.
Nobody wants to watch either one.
The Athletics ask which bedroom they'll be sleeping in.
The Phillies have fallen asleep in a recliner, still clutching a Yuengling.
The Mariners are in the kitchen doing everyone's dishes.
Friday, 11:00 AM — One final guest
There's a knock at the door.
It's the Colorado Rockies.
They explain that the drive took longer than expected because they're coming from a higher altitude.
Ask if there's any free food left.
The only thing remaining is the Twins' lime Jell-O salad.
They eat the entire thing.
It's the best they've performed away from Colorado all year.
