Does anyone else have this problem? I try to ignore it and, when I'm playing the game, I can, of course, focus on the game and enjoy it. But whenever the game sits in the back of my mind, I can't enjoy the lore as much as I did way back in the 90's.
I first played Battletech in the 90's and, yes, even back then, people would say things like mechs make no sense and low profile tanks will always be better, etc, but the technology of Battletech seemed so futuristic and advanced that it didn't matter much. Of course, me being a kid also helped.
But now we have actual ground drones and aerial drones fighting in a war, IRL, in Ukraine, and jamming technology has forced both sides to start using AI to carry out missions. We're literally only years away from fully autonomous drone warfare. Armor and infantry are basically becoming obsolete.
Sometimes I just find it difficult to engage with the lore. It's almost getting to the point of like steampunk, where we have to pretend humanity went down an entirely different technological path. It's not that the Battletech lore is bad, per se, it's that real life just sucks so hard.
Seriously, AI driven aerial drones that hunt soldiers down on the battlefield? That shit sucks. Hard. It's nightmare fuel and it's also, from a tactical perspective, extremely boring. But that's where warfare is headed.
I run into this problem in other media as well, like it's a certainty that, if there ever is space combat between ships, the combat will be run by an AI program. That makes it harder to enjoy things like the TV show, The Expanse. But, for me, the problem is especially bad with Battletech. Nothing in the lore makes even the slightest sense.
Instead of filling my Leopard with aerospace fighters and battlemechs, I could simply just fill it with 20 000 drones, which would wipe out Grayson Carlyle's entire Merc company. I wouldn't even need any staff. It would literally just be me and my AI agents and my hardware, all of which cost next to nothing because it was designed and manufactured by an AI system on some backwater periphery planet.
Other than infantry, no one even aims anymore. There's no such thing as aim. Tank crews and ships stopped aiming decades ago, all fire control is done by a computer.
But now, a tank could be driven and commanded by AI and it could beat any human. If I wanted to engage in mech on mech combat, for kicks and giggles, my mech could just be operated by AI and it would win against the best mechwarriors. It would be able to predict their tactics and it would have faster reflexes than them.
This is why IP like Dune is cool, because Dune addresses the AI problem.
Lore wise, Battletech needs to have an answer to AI. There needs to be some reason why it doesn't exist in universe. Otherwise, like I said, it becomes some weird version of neofuedal atom punk.