r/classicwow • u/Riotgrrlia FOR THE FORSAKEN • 2d ago
Catching Up On Classes | Episode 8 - The WoW: Forever Podcast
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=67dDe3QgJtM
153
Upvotes
r/classicwow • u/Riotgrrlia FOR THE FORSAKEN • 2d ago
117
u/BitGalaxy_ 2d ago
TL;DW – WoW: Forever Podcast Ep. 8 "Catching Up On Classes" (Countdown to Classic with Aidan Moon and Kris Zierhut)
00:00 – Systems
14:12 – Itemization
28:51 – PvP
37:13 – Rogue rework
45:47 – Balance Druids
53:31 – Arms Warriors
59:55 – Stormstrike
1:01:39 – Disc Priests
1:04:42 – Hunters
1:07:19 – Warlocks
1:09:17 – Mage Ice Lance
1:10:42 – Holy Paladin
No episode next week because of US Thanksgiving. The episode after that is about raids.
73
u/kaw_kaw_kaw_kaw 2d ago edited 2d ago
"Right now players have to do an arithmetic problem to figure out whether a piece of loot is an upgrade or not. 90% of our players can't consistently get the answer correct without an addon or outside help. To solve this we are replacing the arithmetic problem with a differential equations midterm"
92
u/Emotional-Rip441 2d ago
The spell power conversation is so weird. Kris talks about how other classes want Strength to do more damage and casters' stats don't provide a damage buff. Instead of taking the obvious path of changing the caster stats to provide damage(i.e intellect and spirit give spell power at different rates), they are spending a ton of effort re-itemizing everything.
84
u/Affectionate_Neat868 2d ago
The elephant in the room being that it’s still BiS, just multiple needed per slot
35
u/Rough_Class8945 2d ago
So Holy Paladin has a weakness, namely multi-target healing. Holy Paladins are mostly OK with this, as that's been a known issue for a long time and not really part of their identity. But they're struggling with what they're supposed to be very strong at, which is efficient single target healing. And instead of their capstone talent addressing their strengths and letting other classes fill in the gaps with their strengths, Holy Paladin gets a clunky mana hog AoE heal tied to an objectively bad spell (holy shock) that no one asked for?
What in the world is going on here?
38
u/Vinticore 2d ago
Ok, so, good episode! Glad they're makin' these but a few pain points.
Optimistic about what they said for my boi balance. Boomie felt very skippable as a capstone and the tree has too many mandatory "just damage"-talents and no room to take situational ones. Also lacks situational fun talents, so put power into boomie and fun into the tree, good.
They fucked up on spellpower gear, no way around it, and trying to swerve it as "players dont understand the crafting faction or the best places to go", no. Physical classes are just having a way easier time rn. And even with more SP gear added in future, just to get to baseline classic power casters are nerfing themselves on stam/spirit/int, not fun gearing just fixating on SP to become "ok".
Very glad Countdown was there, grilled them on a few they needed to be & no pointless mindless "scratch-my-head-at-this-choice" yes-man streamer.
Overall, I cannot get over that this game was clearly rushed out with many key basic aspects of the game still lacking a "north star" goal, but lets see what they make of it.
26
u/Neox772 2d ago edited 2d ago
That was a lot of "we don't know what to do with this spec at the moment" ... like what?
Also the answer on pvp balance should not be to "get lvl 60, get stamina and pvp gear". More HP is not the answer to this horrible pvp balance. You just gave most of those melee classes too many tools, range spells, range CC, healing, movement speed and gap closer. Most casters can't even cast a spell because there is too much CC and spell pushback ffs
24
u/NestroyAM 2d ago
You know, classes, their tool kits, and individual fantasies are kind of at the core of this game and their rebalancing was a pillar ofwhat people wanted from Classic+.
All the more surprising that after supposedly 3 years of development they just straight up don’t have a clue what they want to do with certain specs.
It’s probably the worst aspect of a game to rely on — and indeed make changes primarily through — player feedback.
What happened to Kris saying with his chest pre-release that they thought of everything already and are 10 steps ahead? Looks like they are hobbling through this…
82
u/DomagojDoc 2d ago
We are well aware of this.
36
u/Aszolus 2d ago
But they nerfed casters so much so you have to basically be a twink to get back to baseline. What does a twink caster look like compared to a twink rogue....the twink rogue is a god and the twink caster is back to being a normal Classic class.
50
u/pfSonata 2d ago edited 1d ago
I wish someone would just ask them WHY they felt that casters should be just as reliant on gear as melee for damage. It doesn't make sense. Casters already need gear for longevity since they require mana while melee doesn't. They're different systems! It's fine to have classes level differently, why do they want to try to homogenize the scaling?
29
u/Retriak 2d ago
Them just shrugging at the current state of arms warriors and having no idea what to do with the spec is insane. It’s a dude in plate armor with a big ass sword. I can think of a million things to make that class fantasy feel sick as hell. What are you talking about dude
8
u/Financial-Arm9699 2d ago
Now the question is just when the big patches are comming. Owl needs more love
8
u/UnfairGerman 2d ago
They clearly show that they have no fucking clue about Healpalas.
8
u/mrdeadsniper 1d ago
I love that the healing problem is "A ui problem"
ITS BECAUSE YOU CANNOT LEVEL WITHOUT BEING A DPS.
GOD Biome sounds insulting and has nothing to do with Wow Classic.
75
u/kaw_kaw_kaw_kaw 2d ago
I am not sure this boss biome gear stuff is a good idea. The biomes are binary so its literally just asking players to do a math problem before each boss.
If you are a player who cares about optimizing, which presumably is everybody who cares about loot, look forward to running a Top Gear sim for each boss individually to figure out what you should be wearing on each boss and then an individual Droptimizer sim for each boss in each of your Top Gear sims to figure out what boss drops an upgrade for one of your gear sets for some other boss.
21
u/kpiaum 2d ago
This change to spell power is just plain stupid in every way it was conceived and implemented. The dev himself says he didn’t have time to test it properly, and yet he went ahead and broke the early-game balance in such a way that now any spell power on gear is a power boost, and we have pure DPS casters competing with hybrid healer gear just because it has spell power.
On top of that, early in the game and through much of the leveling process, the gear we get from quests is purely a stat boost, which is why the spell power formula in Classic worked for casters. Now, any melee player is playing the game in speed-leveling mode, since the gear benefits melee players more than casters.
The dev also mentions that several crafting recipes were implemented to compensate. He just doesn’t mention that the crafting cost for this gear is absurdly high for early-game crafts. Early crafts costing nearly 1 gold or more are not balanced.
164
u/naima59 2d ago
While they may be aware of the problems players are currently facing, it's pretty clear this game was not anywhere near ready to ship.
14
u/IIIDEFAULTIII 2d ago
I’m glad balance Druid is getting talked about a little more in depth.
But also holy pally needed more time and a little more deep dive.
18
u/Unluckyfol 2d ago
Actively creating more BIS sets by doing the biome item stuff. His theory is sadly lacking and will make this game hell. This is a repeat of what sod tried. Please don’t lean into biome gearing
12
u/Rhaps0dy 2d ago
"Below roughly level 35 you don't need a healing spec to heal dungeons"
Yeah, and then what? What is the vision of a healer's journey past that?
6
u/Rytnek 2d ago
5 frostbolts before a coc ? did they play any pvp ? no one survives for that long
24
u/pokepat460 2d ago
This one made me feel less confident for the future. A lot of the ideas expressed feel shortsighted. No one wants anyi Murdock swords and stuff, no one wants to carry multiple sets of gear per raid. Why are they going in this direction?
37
u/AberrantMan 2d ago
WoW is NOT low fantasy how is that ever said?
105
u/Imaginary_View_1956 2d ago •
i just don't understand the niche gear man. everyone hated that shit in SoD. i thought they they were going to go the set bonus way, which would have been awesome, but instead they are going with this stupid "biome" direction which just seems incredibly unfun. i HATE carrying tons of gear around and it sort of ruins immersion. i don't want gimmicky gear
does anyone actually like this?
20
u/Vivid_Succotash_6298 2d ago
Jesus Christ, can these guys stop trying to reinvent the wheel?
You dont need to change things for the sake of changing things.
9
u/nemestrinus44 2d ago
this niche biome gear is only good when its a minor bonus. take the Forsaken Greataxe for example, its a complete item for a level 15 with its +8 Strength and +4 Stam but it also provides the bonus of 2% movement speed in Silverpine forest and Hillsbrad foothills.
we don't need gear that are only worth using when fighting a blue dragon inside a snowy cave on thursday when the moon is in retrograde, we need gear that is worth using at all times, and just happens to get a buff when fighting blue dragons in snowy caves on thursday while the moon is in retrograde
4
u/rogbog22 2d ago
They're going to make this awful merchants favor rep mandatory for every profession as opposed to just alchemy/enchanting/engineering like it is now. Brutal lmao.
4
u/lookzlike 2d ago
Game wasnt ready for release and with all the content added just for the beta it feels kinda like bait. The amount of content after 30 is nowhere close to what we had in beta. This goes especially for professions, the pre lvl 10 blues made it look like crafting is gonna be great from 1-60 but its really not.
4
u/RaZeRR77 1d ago
ngl im bit worried after this one
38
u/caelfrmda613 2d ago
Been playing for 25 years and I've never heard a worse idea as biome specific gear, like yeah lemme grind after 7 different sets of gear so I can raid in each biome. " getting rid of bis " is a terrible take.
11
u/SoungaTepes 2d ago
I need rotating BiS, but there’s always going to be a best
22
u/matt1918 2d ago
The worst thing about this is the more they talk, the more it is clear this game wasn’t even close to be ready for release. 6 months in classes will finally feel like they should have felt on release.
It’s so sad bc classic plus could have been insane. Forever is still barely beta level.
3
u/EarlyInsurance7557 2d ago
Make healing fun again.
3
u/morduk89 2d ago
Whats the point of locking dual/retalent behind gold? It could make the game more game and less "strict" or "jobish" feeling. If is about goldsink, they could add probably other options.
3
u/Vivid_Succotash_6298 2d ago
Didn't we already to this i SoD with the Naxxramas 6-set bonuses and sanctified gear?
It was a bad idea back then, and making it even more specific is not gonna make it any better.
I mean, i basically cleared SE on 20 in a mix of tier 2 and tier 2.5 because the Naxxramas set got its power spike from its 6-set bonus, and that 6-set bonus was useless for anything that did not have the undead prefix.
3
u/iholuvas 2d ago
The caster gear discussion missed something important. Having to prioritise sp to deal damage means casters are having to give up raw stats even if they can get the gear. Increasing the amount of sp gear won't help unless they start adding more stats in addition. Right now casters are leveling with less hp, mana and spirit than before.
3
u/MaxtheGrape 1d ago
"Sorry guys, I forgot my 'Mace of Gnoll Bashing on a Tuesday in The Rain on a Fullmoon in Grasslands' main hand. Hearthing brb."
3
u/Yasuchika 20h ago
Some of the things they are saying just come off as delusional, like the caster nerfs because of spellpower gear.
You need to craft the new gear to compensate, or farm for it in dungeons. But then they also nerf dungeons to the point that they are not worth running for xp.
So in the end all they did was nerf casters.
5
u/Equanimity_779 2d ago
I absolutely hate that ice lance and fire last share a CD. Just feels awful. Nerf ice land if you need to.
5
u/ibrown22 2d ago
Yo they got no clue what to do with Arms. The bladestorm channel idea was embarrassing.
Make more benefit to stance dancing for arms that's their core identity
15
u/Imaginary-Arguments 2d ago
Gotta love this one.
Countdown is on fire this episode. Burning questions, and honestly I like the developer's answers. It has been so, so long since I've actually trusted the developers of a WoW game.
Aiden (sorry for spelling if wrong) seems so passionate and hearing someone talk about Rogue design at all has been missing from the game for like 10+ years at this point. He knocked it out of the park with Shank and I'm excited to see what kind of items he brings into the game.
11
u/Aszolus 2d ago
"...you don't need to be a healing spec to heal dungeons". Maybe that's why nobody wants to play a healer. A dps can replace you easily while also doing a ton more damage. Why would you ever heal spec?
4
u/smooshtheman 2d ago
I think behind the scenes Ion is intentionally forcing bad things into Forever because it's success highlights his failures all these years. He probably wants it to fail so his bosses don't realize he was the problem all along and costed millions of lost revenue due to his retardation.
2
u/ClassicKrova 2d ago
Interesting mmarkers intro reference.
2
u/DudeIsThisFunny 2d ago
It's good for keeping content alive too, could think of it as a necessary evil if you think it's bad, you'd be trying to que for entry-level max level dungeons and most people would have already moved past that content making it hard to find a group, but any alt you make you'd want to do that content
Be nice if there was something keeping them coming back, should make it univeral on the drop table so they want to do all the bosses and not freaky 1 boss HR runs
2
u/fmal 2d ago
Healer shortage: Prot paladin and prot warrior feel so good that tanks are no longer scarce, but healer numbers haven't gone up. Healing gear has about a third of its healing value as spell damage so healers can still quest. Below roughly level 35 you don't need a healing spec to heal dungeons. The team is weighing ways to make healers easier to level in the open world.
Blizzard needs to pull the entire team together to come up with how to make playing a Healer in a group a productive and rewarding experience instead of just making Dungeons worth running again.
2
u/BigHeadDeadass 2d ago
Any word on the tauren druid forms vs night elf druid forms?
2
u/Elipson_ 2d ago
I think my ideal scenario is horizontal progression via gearsets that enable different playstyles. But I'm not sure if WoW's talent system permits enough design space for something like that
2
u/Schkrasss 1d ago
There is just one actual issue that makes Healers undesireable.
Healers, outside of Dungeons, are just plain undesireable.
Elite Quests in the open World are a joke (and way too few on top) for Healers to matter. Grouping with a Healer when compared to grouping with an offspecc-Healer or Damagedealer is just worse.
Classes specced into Healing are just worse for EVERYONE.
5
u/D3Construct 2d ago
Disappointed that was all what was said about Enhancement. With PvP damage being high across the board and mob damage being scaled up the niche is just gone. Back to back windfury procs all crits wont even kill a level 60 mob.
I want less reliance on totems, not more. So no i'm not happy with weapon enhancement stacking with totem enhancement, give me more reliable throughput now the niche is gone.
They didn't want to do anything for Arms Warriors because yada yada mobility creep. But you will give druids 3 roots and you're "excited" what they will do with them. Well just like anything else in this game, perma root the melee classes without hand of freedom and 100-0 them. Duhhh. Which way is it, Dorothy?
Enhancement is doing comparatively high DPS right now because totems and weapon enhancements give flat and relatively high values. But those don't scale, so as we go on the spec is going to fall off. And not a mention of the capstone talent? 30% attack speed for 25 seconds is so uninspired.
Totemic Call costs 15% of my mana. So does Lesser Healing Wave. If mobs aren't in the immediate vicinity I last 3 casts beween them. If I also use Shocks, 2.
And where is our gear?! You added a ton of items especially for Ret and Shockadin Paladins. I've yet to find the Strength, Int, Stamina and optional spell power items you've alluded to. It's just Hunter or Rogue hand-me-downs all the way.
Chris needs to take his Enhancement Shaman and duel his Frost Mage friend a bunch of times.
3
u/SpunkMcKullins 2d ago
The sign is interesting, given I saw this post pop up in r/wow just a little while ago.
https://www.reddit.com/r/wow/comments/1y0dekq/every_portal_suddenly_began_to_look_like_a_portal/
2
u/bca327 2d ago
Really sad to hear about the set bonuses. Instead of removing them, why not give us a way to customize gear with set bonuses we have earned so we can wear the new gear and have the set bonus we want active? Needing snow gear and fire gear and air gear or whatever just sound boring and uninspired.
2
u/Ruby_Rhods_Hair 2d ago
Reddit continues to complain while the majority of us are having a great time
2
u/dontwantanaccount86 2d ago
Holy paladin needs so much more to be dynamic.
Lights vigil getting its original design back to be usable as an offensive spell would make our decision making way more interesting.
Infusion of light needs to reduce the mana cost of holy light and make its over healing give an absorb shield. That will make us actually respond to the proc and use it, where as right now it procs and holy light is still an expensive spell that we often don’t need, so we just end up continuing to spam flash of light while the 15 second proc tics away.
2
u/gannacrydotjpeg 2d ago
Guild wars 3 can't come fast enough
1
u/Not_Adam__ 2d ago edited 2d ago
Love to hear they are looking at the later half of the balance tree. 0.5s starfire cast and +10%dmg are both mandatory and cost 10 talents, and if you take the root talents too you miss +intellect / pushback reduction and in-combat mana regen from resto, all of which is desperately needed by the spec to come online.
1
u/Aflyingmongoose 1d ago
I don't see how raising player health in pvp is a big job.
In ESO when you're in a pvp game mode you just have a buff that adds 5k max hp, which helps normalize survivavility for squishier builds.
1
u/SwimmingBrief4438 1d ago
1
u/nutzhell51 1d ago
How is this possible to change some major things like that when the game is not in alpha it just give me the feeling that Blizzard don't know what to do with Forever and this is going nowhere
1
u/Ramn_ 1d ago
Friendly reminder to everyone in this thread: turtle wow (where 90% of forever is based on) managed several years without biome gear or just having cosmetic rewards, mounts, fluff. You don't need to reinvent the wheel.
1
u/sandleaz 1d ago
The developers are still lying about caster damage. I guess they are happy that more people are leaving or avoiding the classes that the developers made gimp.
1
u/Gassenger 19h ago
With what fuckin bags am I supposed to carry so many sets of heckin wholesome B I O M E gear if I'm a prot warrior that will DPS some fights? Especially with consumables?
Thank god I don't need a fuckin flask set anymore
1
u/whiterabbit-redeyes 15h ago
Yikes. Here we go the game is ruined. Oh and if you think just Pve is ruined they ruined Pvp system as well with weekly gated rank 14 gear for everyone doing the quests kekw
•
u/EaglePete 3h ago
In regards to the healer shortage:
Just make dual spec at a lower level and lower cost, so players can get it earlier?
That would fix so much healer shortage issues. If you can get it at 20 or 30 (where some of the newer dungeons starts to hit harder), then more people will try healing out. The fact that it competes with mount at 40 is such a wild idea. (Also just before people call it "friction and stuff to work towards" there is clearly a reason why we are seeing this healer shortage, so maybe making the game fun and approachable on this topic is warranted)
Because having dungeons that require healing is actually fun, doing Drowned city and alcaz prison was a fun experience BECAUSE there where some damage to heal.
Also, blizz should think about making "raid frames" the standard party ui. I can't imagine a new player trying to heal with the standard ones, what an awful time that would be.
•
u/spooky_office 1h ago
ele does nothing
1
u/Dry_Individual1516 2d ago
Here's the recap: class balance is gimped, our hands are tied lol!
1
u/santc 2d ago
It really seems like level 60 balance is their main priority and they don’t care how a class actually FEELS to play
1
u/disastrous_hyena759 2d ago
I think this whole itemization philosophy is missing the point a little.
I'm all for RPG elements, flavor and items having some lore behind them. That's great. But at the end of the day, this is still an MMORPG. The items actually need to be worth using.
What's the point of adding something like an Ogre Loincloth with Strength and Spell Damage just because there's a story behind it? Okay, it's flavorful, I get it. But who is actually going to use that thing? And why should it take up a spot in a dungeon boss's loot table when it could have been something players would actually be excited to get?
That's what bothers me. Some of these dungeons are things people might only run once while leveling, and the loot is part of what makes those runs rewarding. Getting an item with completely random stats that nobody has any reason to equip just feels like a wasted drop.
And I don't really buy the whole "RPG first, gameplay second" argument either. If we're going to take RPG logic that seriously, then why don't Frost spells do extra damage to Fire elementals? Why don't Holy spells do extra damage to Undead and Demons? Why don't skeletons take extra damage from bludgeoning weapons?
I'm not asking for every item to be BiS or for everything to revolve around min-maxing. Weird items can be fun, and situational gear has its place. But there's a difference between an unusual item that someone might actually find a use for and an item that's just dead loot.
I really hope this philosophy doesn't carry over into raid itemization, because I don't want to see the same thing happening with epic gear.
An item having a story behind it is nice, but that doesn't automatically make it a good reward. Flavor is great, but it shouldn't come at the expense of actually having good loot.