r/classicwow • FOR THE FORSAKEN • 2d ago

Catching Up On Classes | Episode 8 - The WoW: Forever Podcast

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=67dDe3QgJtM
153 Upvotes

572 comments sorted by

117

u/BitGalaxy_ 2d ago

TL;DW – WoW: Forever Podcast Ep. 8 "Catching Up On Classes" (Countdown to Classic with Aidan Moon and Kris Zierhut)

00:00 – Systems

  • Caster spell power: Kris admits there isn't enough spell power gear while levelling, especially from level 15 to 40. He plans to add more in future patches. Base spell power on spells was lowered to make up for the new gear, but he thinks players are also blaming that for nerfs that happened for other reasons.
  • Healer shortage: Prot paladin and prot warrior feel so good that tanks are no longer scarce, but healer numbers haven't gone up. Healing gear has about a third of its healing value as spell damage so healers can still quest. Below roughly level 35 you don't need a healing spec to heal dungeons. The team is weighing ways to make healers easier to level in the open world.
  • Trade Authority: There are bugs where turned-in writs don't give reputation. The system designers are meeting right after the podcast to make reputation easier to earn and recipes unlock sooner. Every patch will add more recipes there, so the rep is worth earning.

14:12 – Itemization

  • Aidan says items are "fantasy first, optimization second": flavourful stats like strength on the Ogre Loincloth and themed loot added to Stockades. They'll balance around gear you can actually get, not theoretical gear.
  • Raids: some rare chase items with very low drop rates. Different raid wings have different biomes (snowy, haunted, cavernous), so BiS will depend on the boss's creature type and biome. Bigger bags and better gear sorting are planned eventually.
  • Tier sets: class problems won't be fixed with set bonuses, to avoid the SoD situation where people never wanted to take a set off. Changes that transform a class will come through talents or new systems instead.
  • Weekly quest: run 3 dungeons for a bit of gold. It's optional, deliberately not the most efficient use of time, and has no badges, rep or story attached. It's weekly only to cap it, not to create a chore.

28:51 – PvP

  • Every class now performs about as well as a 2005 fire mage, plus 10% from a raised damage target. Levelling gear also has little stamina. Some viral clips came from bugs (Windfury was ignoring armour) or were selectively edited.
  • The fix will come through more stamina-heavy gear first. A PvP damage reduction is a last resort, and raising player health across the board is possible but a big job.
  • Extra honor for a close battleground loss has been discussed but not decided.
  • Legacy respecs stay expensive so players can't swap perks for profit and so the choices matter.

37:13 – Rogue rework

  • Relentless Strikes was a mandatory 11 points in Assassination with no felt impact. It was replaced by Shank, a low-damage button that gives energy back, and each spec has a talent that enhances it differently.
  • This was only possible because the overall damage target was raised late in beta.
  • Bleed and poison immunities on elementals and undead are being tested with the encounter team.

45:47 – Balance Druids

  • Levelling flow is the problem: Starfire pushback protection sits in the Resto tree, and the Improved Starfire row needs too many points.
  • Likely changes: merge the Wrath and Starfire cast-time talents into the first talent, replace the plain +10% Moonfury talent with something more interesting, and move that damage into Moonkin Form. These are big changes, so the timing (hotfix or patch) is undecided. Elemental Shaman is also being looked at.
  • Each patch, the team will pick one class for a deep rework.

53:31 – Arms Warriors

  • Aidan doesn't have the right idea for Arms yet and doesn't want to add something that's hard to take back. Arms won't get more mobility, though tools to lock targets down are possible.
  • Wild Growth and Riptide: they were deliberately weakened (Wild Growth has a cast time, Riptide has no initial heal) to slow healing power creep. Riptide's main job is now its Chain Heal buff.

59:55 – Stormstrike

  • The 8s → 6s → 8s changes happened because buffs pushed Enhancement towards spell power instead of big two-handers. Allowing a double Windfury setup brought back physical stats, so the buffs were reverted. Spell-based Shaman builds still work.

1:01:39 – Disc Priests

  • No firm direction yet, so it's being left mostly as is. Power Infusion was moved deeper into the tree so it isn't forced. Aidan floated an idea of Disc as a dedicated support spec, clearly labelled as not a promise.

1:04:42 – Hunters

  • The Survival capstone (a DoT from Mongoose Bite) is undertuned. Kris suggests around 100–200% of Mongoose Bite's damage, stacking instead of overwriting. Expect a buff once raid data comes in.

1:07:19 – Warlocks

  • Combining the separate demon talents is a valid idea, but the feedback came too late in development. It will be looked at in a future Warlock rework.
  • Soul shards won't stack for now, but you can put a soul shard bag in the reagent bag slot.

1:09:17 – Mage Ice Lance

  • Ice Lance shares a cooldown with Fire Blast to limit instant casts while moving, especially in PvP. A Fire Blast alternative was explored but was more complicated.

1:10:42 – Holy Paladin

  • The capstone being an AoE heal is intentional. Paladins historically had no answer to damage hitting the whole group. Beacon of Light was considered but felt too Wrath-era.

No episode next week because of US Thanksgiving. The episode after that is about raids.

103

u/gibby256 2d ago

00:00 – Systems - Caster spell power: Kris admits there isn't enough spell power gear while levelling, especially from level 15 to 40. He plans to add more in future patches. Base spell power on spells was lowered to make up for the new gear, but he thinks players are also blaming that for nerfs that happened for other reasons.

Damn. it REALLY IS the true vanilla experience, lol. We're even recapitulating needing to itemize spellpower for casters.

85

u/Esarus 2d ago

It’s fucking bizarre how spell power is an afterthought AGAIN

→ More replies (30)

31

u/crmsn_kng 2d ago

At least we know our alts (that I could fund with my main's gold anyway) will have more gear. Isn't that lovely to hear as a caster playing right now?

19

u/Sea_String8534 2d ago

So the answer right now, is re-roll melee until they fix this?

→ More replies (5)

13

u/Remos_ 2d ago

Imagine me, a new player, who chose to level as a holy spec priest lol

→ More replies (8)

4

u/TenshiBR 2d ago

They are even doing deep class reworks every 4 months with big patches! It can't get more classic than this!

43

u/CorrectZombie583 2d ago edited 2d ago

00:00 – Systems - Caster spell power: Kris admits there isn't enough spell power gear while levelling, especially from level 15 to 40. He plans to add more in future patches. Base spell power on spells was lowered to make up for the new gear, but he thinks players are also blaming that for nerfs that happened for other reasons.

  • Healer shortage: Prot paladin and prot warrior feel so good that tanks are no longer scarce, but healer numbers haven't gone up. Healing gear has about a third of its healing value as spell damage so healers can still quest. Below roughly level 35 you don't need a healing spec to heal dungeons. The team is weighing ways to make healers easier to level in the open world.

The easy fix to the both of them would be to fuse spell power gear and healer gear up until lvl 40, since you don't need all that healing power anyway, casters complain that some of the SP gear became HP gear, and people focus on the damage instead.

27

u/Spyger9 2d ago

YES! Why even have healing gear before 40? It should be like Plate armor.

Like I said in another comment, I'm skipping my healer weapon and down-ranking spells to avoid overhealing, when I don't even have any talents to boost my heals.

→ More replies (4)

26

u/rageharles 2d ago

Holy Paladin - while I respect that they answered a direct question, holy paladin isn't being played because it's bad, not because prot and ret are being played. Spamming R1 FoL is still the most efficient heal per mana spent, except the throughput is really low even with a full +heal set. The meaningful heals cost too much. Holy Paladin has played exactly the same between era, SoD, and now Forever. In SoD, they only worked because you could juice crit to the point where they never oomed even when casting their biggest heals constantly (and yes, you still FoL spammed anyway). So they've reinforced that holy paladin will be a 1-button spec and will suck either in perpetuity or until they become functionally mana-less. For context, I am level 42 and my dual spec is full holy. It feels like it's almost useless to go past Illumination because you either crit or you oom. Holy shock is weak and expensive and lights vigil + holy shock combo costs almost 1k mana. i have no clue how big mana pools are going to get in Forever but right now, stacking full eagle gear, that's like 1/3rd of my mana bar. stacking full +heal it's about half the bar. I'm going to keep testing, but right now holy paladin feels like you're playing a math problem more than a class. And worse than that, it does not feel any different than every other version of classic. I don't blame people from not wanting to play another round of the same exact thing, except worse compared to other healers. I'd buy a 'hybrid tax' argument if they weren't good from a numbers standpoint but right now they aren't fun either.

7

u/IIIDEFAULTIII 2d ago

Yea holy pally needs help. Maybe at 60 with full gear it gets better sure ok maybe. But getting to that point in a game about the “journey” is terrible for the class to essentially come online.

I love holy pally but it is rough right now it needs serious help.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/b4dkarm4 2d ago

Chad comment <3 I'd heal you if you pulled aggro from the tank every pull.

31

u/KeyMap8 2d ago

healer numbers haven't gone up. Healing gear has about a third of its healing value as spell damage so healers can still quest. Below roughly level 35 you don't need a healing spec to heal dungeons. The team is weighing ways to make healers easier to level in the open world.

ah good so they have no idea how to fix it and are just regurgitating the same brain dead talking points as on here

20

u/Winterough 2d ago

They said just heal as enhance. They said that.

12

u/desperateorphan 2d ago

He also said to just grab cheap +healing gear and it would be more than enough to heal pretty much any lower level dungeon…. Which is completely correct.

15

u/SwarmOfRatz 2d ago

Healing drowned city not as a healer spec is kinda of miserable

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

7

u/Halinn 2d ago

Riptide being mostly there for the chain heal buff is fine in terms of numbers, but I really don't dig it in terms of how it feels as a capstone.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Crazymage321 2d ago

Are the devs playing the same Prot paladin?

48

u/litnu12 2d ago

Healer shortage: Prot paladin and prot warrior feel so good that tanks are no longer scarce, but healer numbers haven't gone up. Healing gear has about a third of its healing value as spell damage so healers can still quest. Below roughly level 35 you don't need a healing spec to heal dungeons. The team is weighing ways to make healers easier to level in the open world.

Spell power on gear still doesnt allow to heal mobs to death. Healers can play heal in group activities like hmmmmm hmmm I dont know hmmmmmmm hmmm like Dungeons. Which are also one of the most social aspects of the game because people group up willingly.

Also people dont play healer to do stuff in the open world, they either play off spec or play an alt for that.

21

u/bigheadsfork 2d ago

Exactly. I'm a priest. I've had dps casters win multiple pieces of healing gear in dungeons. And pair that with getting only 35% of xp in dungeons? Yeah fuck that . Waste of my time

7

u/Skore_Smogon 1d ago

It's a double Fuck You.

They introduce this delta on spells base damage compared to classic to be made up with SP gear, but then healing gear only gets you 1/3 of the way towards combating that delta.

Honestly someone said it elsewhere in the thread but I think up to level 40 there shouldn't be any +healing gear. Just have spellpower gear, and they should adjust the lower rank healing spells up a bit.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/litnu12 2d ago

Raids: some rare chase items with very low drop rates. Different raid wings have different biomes (snowy, haunted, cavernous), so BiS will depend on the boss's creature type and biome. Bigger bags and better gear sorting are planned eventually.

I see they learned a lot from the failed Diablo 4 version

→ More replies (4)

10

u/TheFrozenPoo 2d ago

Yea that’s where I stand with it too. Healer isn’t a leveling spec.

3

u/Possible_Squirrel_28 2d ago

I was gonna respec from Ret to Holy/prot around 40 but now I just want to heal with Ret until I hit a wall lol

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (34)

9

u/NightProfessional800 2d ago

yikes.

Damage on tuesdays is back.

16

u/SoungaTepes 2d ago

I would like them to address the talent tree of Enh Shaman to synergize more effectively with Str as the main stat.

Good write up 

14

u/JeDi_Five 2d ago

They didn't want to completely gut spellhance, which makes me happy from a class design perspective. But still some changes are needed.

13

u/gibby256 2d ago

Yeah, the entire spec tree still heavily signposts int as the relevant stat to build toward.

4

u/Halinn 2d ago

I wish the SP conversion talent was strength based instead of int.

→ More replies (15)

4

u/FunYou4047 2d ago

Beacon of Light was considered but felt too Wrath-era.

Shamans, priests and druids nervously look at their Riptide, penance and wildgrowth spells

6

u/Skore_Smogon 1d ago

Me a Shaman, looking at Riptide and wishing it was something that was fun to press instead of a mandatory anchor for chain heal.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/jntjr2005 2d ago

Make it easier for healers? Give dual spec at 20 and no gold, done.

6

u/Jooylo 2d ago

I don’t think that’s the issue for most people leveling since you don’t need to spec into it for the most part. Or at least it wasn’t the issue for me. I almost mained a healer, but my reluctance to do so mainly stems from their kits looking fairly lackluster. Resto Druid looked real fun until they took out everything that made it look fun.

16

u/nemestrinus44 2d ago

they're gonna make a lot of people mad if they do that 2 weeks after launch since a lot of people already bought it for 50g

31

u/AntonineWall 2d ago

They could do a mail-based refund (go to your mailbox, get a refunded 50G + some in-universe blurb from your respective faction saying there was an accounting oversight and here’s your gold back)

Solved that problem.

9

u/admirabladmiral 2d ago

New quest to kill the corrupt class trainer that requires the gold cost

18

u/-Googlrr 2d ago

Just refund gold back to those that bought it. Easy change

8

u/Bohya 2d ago

Then just refund those who already purchased it 30 gold then? A complete non-issue.

→ More replies (13)

3

u/FL14 2d ago

Soul bag in reagent slot Yes

9

u/rogbog22 2d ago

Trade Authority: There are bugs where turned-in writs don't give reputation. The system designers are meeting right after the podcast to make reputation easier to earn and recipes unlock sooner. Every patch will add more recipes there, so the rep is worth earning.

lmao they're going to make this mandatory for everyone to grind, fuck.

Raids: some rare chase items with very low drop rates. Different raid wings have different biomes (snowy, haunted, cavernous), so BiS will depend on the boss's creature type and biome. Bigger bags and better gear sorting are planned eventually.

this sounds incredibly stupid and tedious.

3

u/D3Construct 2d ago

lmao they're going to make this mandatory for everyone to grind, fuck.

Account wide reputations please and thanks.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/pigzyf5 2d ago

imo the only reason there is a healer shortage is because people don't feel like healing. There are enough people running around that COULD heal. changing gear and what not won't fix it.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/TJMadd 2d ago

seems like they've got some good ideas cooking. I'll be patient. it would be awesome if the game was perfect at launch but I'm having a ton of fun and I imagine this time next year it'll be even better

3

u/Soulerous 2d ago

“replace the plain +10% Moonfury talent with something more interesting, and move that damage into Moonkin Form.”

Oh no. They’re going to force me into moonkin form. NOOOO please let it be optional!

4

u/ClassicKrova 2d ago

Don't care about playing Moonkin form, but am worried about Resto-kin being nerfed.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (20)

73

u/kaw_kaw_kaw_kaw 2d ago edited 2d ago

"Right now players have to do an arithmetic problem to figure out whether a piece of loot is an upgrade or not. 90% of our players can't consistently get the answer correct without an addon or outside help. To solve this we are replacing the arithmetic problem with a differential equations midterm"

92

u/Emotional-Rip441 2d ago

The spell power conversation is so weird. Kris talks about how other classes want Strength to do more damage and casters' stats don't provide a damage buff. Instead of taking the obvious path of changing the caster stats to provide damage(i.e intellect and spirit give spell power at different rates), they are spending a ton of effort re-itemizing everything.

41

u/CorrectZombie583 2d ago

I could have seen spirit give healing power instead if we're going by that logic. I personally still like the idea of separating spell power from INT/Spirit because it lets you think about burst vs sustain and resources vs impact of individual button presses.

20

u/Emotional-Rip441 2d ago

Yes Spirit giving healing power feels very natural. It doesn't have to be stats or SP on gear: you can still have Spell Power/Healing Power on gear just like Attack Power still shows up.

26

u/litnu12 2d ago

the could also just buff the base dmage from spells, at least the early version were people dont have spell power instead of trying to fix a problem they created in the first place.

17

u/Emotional-Rip441 2d ago

The goal of wanting casters to feel more powerful with gear is a good one. The execution is just lackluster.

22

u/[deleted] 2d ago

was it though? I have literally never once thought "man I wish I scaled better with gear" as a caster. Especially not at the expense of rankups doing literally like 20 more damage for 50 more mana.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/pfSonata 1d ago

It really isn't a good goal though.

Casters were designed to scale (while leveling) more via spell ranks than melee.

This is an RPG design as old as RPGs themselves (D&D). It makes training new ranks feel awesome, which is not something you really get on melee. It gives you clear rewards at the cost of increased mana cost. It did not need to be changed.

Melee has infinite juice, casters don't. Casters need gear to scale their longevity. That is the original design and it worked great.

4

u/RegularFeeling8389 2d ago

Idk why there wasn't a baseline level of spellpower on caster gear based on its ilvl.

13

u/Sharizord 2d ago

This is the obvious solution but it's the solution retail came to so it's forbidden to do sadly.

84

u/Affectionate_Neat868 2d ago

The elephant in the room being that it’s still BiS, just multiple needed per slot

14

u/girlsareicky 2d ago

I think the idea is to throw so much different gear out there that the average player will get overwhelmed and just go for a generic set to not need to worry about it

And then the degen can create specific sets for when they are fighting a giant in a snowy biome or whatever.

That's like....hundreds of bis sets btw. You won't have enough bag space for it all. Or even bank space to keep all the sets. Hopefully more space comes sooner than later. I'm already stressing about saving weird leveling trinkets

8

u/Cheesedude666 2d ago

I personally think this biome and creature specific sets and stats is the worst idea ever. For me those kind of items has always been the first to go into the bin. And in the end, who the hell enjoys having their bags full of gimmicky items and situational sets? If that stuff starts to become commonplace, and even required going into raids I'm turning into a pvp hobo real quick. Fuck that shit

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Ididitthestupidway 1d ago

I think the principle of making things more complex so that there isn't a definitive "that item is the best" list is a good thing. We'll see how it goes in practice.

16

u/rogbog22 2d ago

Bingo. I'm a bit stunned that this wasn't even a consideration before floating it to the public as a way to "kill BiS"

Like what the fuck, do these guys even play this game

→ More replies (1)

4

u/pfSonata 2d ago

The goal is likely to make it unrealistic (or impossible) to actually have full bis for every situation due to the sheer numbers of items yiu'd have to obtain.

→ More replies (3)

35

u/Rough_Class8945 2d ago

So Holy Paladin has a weakness, namely multi-target healing. Holy Paladins are mostly OK with this, as that's been a known issue for a long time and not really part of their identity. But they're struggling with what they're supposed to be very strong at, which is efficient single target healing. And instead of their capstone talent addressing their strengths and letting other classes fill in the gaps with their strengths, Holy Paladin gets a clunky mana hog AoE heal tied to an objectively bad spell (holy shock) that no one asked for?

What in the world is going on here?

10

u/IIIDEFAULTIII 2d ago edited 2d ago

Yea as someone who loves holy paladin in vanilla and classic. It needs some help right now. Maybe at 60 with gear it gets better but getting to that point it’s clear they are struggling compared to other healers and are also one of the rarest specs right now. Was hoping they would go a little more in depth with them more so with the healer shortage.

4

u/TrailRidgeTurn 2d ago

At 60 it doesnt get solved with gear. They’ve not provided any new plate healing gear outside of blacksmithing so you’re stuck wearing the same cloth gear or green “of healing” gear as classic prebis.

Or you have to grind out the dungeon set pieces to upgrade to the healing set, while needing on them over ret paladins and prot paladins trying to build their dungeon set. (Then you get abused for it)

It’s honestly miserable how bad holy paladin feels just from its healing toolkit, then they’ve repeated all the same gear design problems it had in most of the phases of classic.

5

u/Slurm11 2d ago

The healer shortage has to be tied with the dungeon xp nerf. Leveling as a healer sucks without spamming dungeons for xp. But of course blizzard doesn't want to admit that

4

u/Slurm11 2d ago

at least they admit the mana is too high. 1300 mana is insane

→ More replies (2)

38

u/Vinticore 2d ago

Ok, so, good episode! Glad they're makin' these but a few pain points.

Optimistic about what they said for my boi balance. Boomie felt very skippable as a capstone and the tree has too many mandatory "just damage"-talents and no room to take situational ones. Also lacks situational fun talents, so put power into boomie and fun into the tree, good.

They fucked up on spellpower gear, no way around it, and trying to swerve it as "players dont understand the crafting faction or the best places to go", no. Physical classes are just having a way easier time rn. And even with more SP gear added in future, just to get to baseline classic power casters are nerfing themselves on stam/spirit/int, not fun gearing just fixating on SP to become "ok".

Very glad Countdown was there, grilled them on a few they needed to be & no pointless mindless "scratch-my-head-at-this-choice" yes-man streamer.

Overall, I cannot get over that this game was clearly rushed out with many key basic aspects of the game still lacking a "north star" goal, but lets see what they make of it.

5

u/iholuvas 2d ago

Well said. Even if you can get enough sp to deal damage, your sustain and survivability suffer a lot as a caster right now.

2

u/Aulait1 2d ago

Yea I'm using GearQuest addon so I can literally see what's the best gear available at each level... Still hit like shit on my level 31 shadow priest.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/Neox772 2d ago edited 2d ago

That was a lot of "we don't know what to do with this spec at the moment" ... like what?

Also the answer on pvp balance should not be to "get lvl 60, get stamina and pvp gear". More HP is not the answer to this horrible pvp balance. You just gave most of those melee classes too many tools, range spells, range CC, healing, movement speed and gap closer. Most casters can't even cast a spell because there is too much CC and spell pushback ffs

24

u/NestroyAM 2d ago

You know, classes, their tool kits, and individual fantasies are kind of at the core of this game and their rebalancing was a pillar ofwhat people wanted from Classic+.

All the more surprising that after supposedly 3 years of development they just straight up don’t have a clue what they want to do with certain specs.

It’s probably the worst aspect of a game to rely on — and indeed make changes primarily through — player feedback.

What happened to Kris saying with his chest pre-release that they thought of everything already and are 10 steps ahead? Looks like they are hobbling through this…

4

u/gibby256 1d ago

Yeah, biggest thing I came away with from the class section is that the devs don't really have a solid vision on how specific specs should be playing (or, sometimes, even itemizing).

But that seemed clear after the enhancement whiplash changes week 1.

82

u/DomagojDoc 2d ago

Aidan doesn't have the right idea for Arms yet

We are well aware of this.

9

u/Magres 2d ago

Glad to hear that Arms is "mildly competitive," if that isn't damning with faint praise I don't know what is. I'd describe MM Hunter, Feral, and Warlock as "mildly competitive" in Vanilla Naxx. Sure, if you sweat your ass off you might be able to do what a blue parsing Rogue or Mage can do, that's mildly competitive!

Like, it's good to hear them at least admit SOMEWHAT admit that Arms needs (a ton of) love, but also very much both humorous and frustrating to listen to them try to spin it. I don't get how it feels rewarding to keep a Warrior at a distance when they don't DO ANYTHING if they get onto you.

Arms is definitely devastating in PvP, to the person playing Arms.

2

u/mattyisphtty 2d ago

It feels like there's one guy for each class and then a larger team to do the bigger reworks. Maybe when it's warriors time some additional eyes will give some better ideas.

→ More replies (1)

36

u/Aszolus 2d ago

But they nerfed casters so much so you have to basically be a twink to get back to baseline. What does a twink caster look like compared to a twink rogue....the twink rogue is a god and the twink caster is back to being a normal Classic class.

50

u/pfSonata 2d ago edited 1d ago

I wish someone would just ask them WHY they felt that casters should be just as reliant on gear as melee for damage. It doesn't make sense. Casters already need gear for longevity since they require mana while melee doesn't. They're different systems! It's fine to have classes level differently, why do they want to try to homogenize the scaling? 

14

u/Aulait1 2d ago

I don't agree with what they did but I disagree with you even more. The whole game is about upgrading your power through (mainly) gear and that's where players get their main dopamine hit. The gear chase is the funnest part of this game for me

21

u/pfSonata 2d ago

Historically casters got that "dopamine hit" from leveling up and getting a new rank. Now you often feel like higher ranks are just paying more mana and the damage boost isn't commensurate.

Casters scaling with level vs attackers scaling with items is an RPG paradigm going back to dungeons & dragons.

Also, gear upgrades literally feel worse for me in Forever than they did in vanilla, where the rarity of spell damage on gear made it feel like an actual bonus (since leveling was balanced around base spell damage).

Getting shadoweave gear while leveling in vanilla IS the warlock/priest version of getting whirlwind axe at 30.

→ More replies (12)

9

u/SenorWeon 2d ago

I loved seeing my mana pool grow as a mage so I could blast for longer, same with stam as I could play riskier. Now, I need to work my ass off, scrapping every bit of available spell power the devs decided to add just to be even.

→ More replies (2)

29

u/Retriak 2d ago

Them just shrugging at the current state of arms warriors and having no idea what to do with the spec is insane. It’s a dude in plate armor with a big ass sword. I can think of a million things to make that class fantasy feel sick as hell. What are you talking about dude

12

u/barbarianbob 2d ago

I can think of a million things to make that class fantasy feel sick as hell.

Are these ideas balanced around PvE AND PvP? Do they contribute to a fun rotation? Are they just as balanced at level 40 as they are with BiS gear?

They said the biggest hurdle is implementing these ideas without having to remove them at a later date.

2

u/smooshtheman 2d ago

I think biggest issue is still rage generation and the guys idea is for a buon you hold down to drain the rage...

→ More replies (5)

8

u/Financial-Arm9699 2d ago

Now the question is just when the big patches are comming. Owl needs more love

8

u/UnfairGerman 2d ago

They clearly show that they have no fucking clue about Healpalas.

8

u/mrdeadsniper 1d ago

I love that the healing problem is "A ui problem"

ITS BECAUSE YOU CANNOT LEVEL WITHOUT BEING A DPS.

GOD Biome sounds insulting and has nothing to do with Wow Classic.

2

u/Simple_Technique 1d ago

wat so you mean? leveling as a resto shaman has been super chill.

→ More replies (2)

75

u/kaw_kaw_kaw_kaw 2d ago

I am not sure this boss biome gear stuff is a good idea. The biomes are binary so its literally just asking players to do a math problem before each boss.

If you are a player who cares about optimizing, which presumably is everybody who cares about loot, look forward to running a Top Gear sim for each boss individually to figure out what you should be wearing on each boss and then an individual Droptimizer sim for each boss in each of your Top Gear sims to figure out what boss drops an upgrade for one of your gear sets for some other boss.

33

u/litnu12 2d ago

"Sorry guys I forgot my snowy winter human defias bandit gear but I have my rainy winter goblin defias thief gear at least"

5

u/Winterough 2d ago

I really could use an umbrella though.

27

u/TheAngryCrusader 2d ago edited 2d ago

I was going to say, doesn’t this just sound like it’s gatekeeping even more from the average player? Why should I have to watch 10 YouTube videos to figure out what I need to gear with

10

u/Gulrakrurs 2d ago

If the bonuses are minimal enough to not matter to the average player, then it would mean more sources of generally good gear that will allow you to raid while giving the top 1% of parsers something to chase for and to keep them coming back every week.

Now if they go crazy and make the bonuses large, it could become a mess, but they can always change numbers.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

13

u/handiman87 2d ago

All while rocking 4x 14 slot bags. Hope you enjoy zero fucking inventory space lol

→ More replies (7)

6

u/HighPriestDaughter 2d ago

It's reforging all over again.

→ More replies (5)

21

u/kpiaum 2d ago

This change to spell power is just plain stupid in every way it was conceived and implemented. The dev himself says he didn’t have time to test it properly, and yet he went ahead and broke the early-game balance in such a way that now any spell power on gear is a power boost, and we have pure DPS casters competing with hybrid healer gear just because it has spell power.

On top of that, early in the game and through much of the leveling process, the gear we get from quests is purely a stat boost, which is why the spell power formula in Classic worked for casters. Now, any melee player is playing the game in speed-leveling mode, since the gear benefits melee players more than casters.

The dev also mentions that several crafting recipes were implemented to compensate. He just doesn’t mention that the crafting cost for this gear is absurdly high for early-game crafts. Early crafts costing nearly 1 gold or more are not balanced.

164

u/naima59 2d ago

While they may be aware of the problems players are currently facing, it's pretty clear this game was not anywhere near ready to ship.

99

u/xxxnumxxx 2d ago

While i don't completely disagree I have a feeling this is one of those types of projects that even if it got another 2 years of development it still wouldn't have been ready to ship and at some point you just put it out and tend to the fires it makes.

34

u/RedditClout 2d ago

I mean, you're not wrong, but fundamentals like how stats work and where they want their balance is a pretty egregious error in my view. We shouldn't be at this point of doing 3.0 Shaman reworks two weeks into release. Not having a North star right now is not a great look.

 

The game absolutely could have cooked another 6 months with multiple closed betas for end-game functions and had a huge summer release.

23

u/litnu12 2d ago

And its not a new game. Blizzard has 20 years of experience and data to work with and still cant do basic math.

14

u/alwaysleftout 2d ago

They did SOD then left a lot of what made that interesting out.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/kpiaum 2d ago

The panic nerfs when the beta was released is what turned this mess. They even acknowledged this in the video, we got a good itemization and they nerfed and we are on this mess leveling

6

u/Optimoprimo 2d ago

Yeah I can't believe the number of times in this interview they basically admitted they had or have no plan and are just going to figure it out as they go. For entire specs and gear sets.

17

u/Agent-Vermont 2d ago

I mean you could tell that just from all the bug in the game currently. They clearly needed more time but that's also a bit contradictory seeing as they have no clear vision for how things should be.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/handiman87 2d ago

Very clearly, especially noticeable as you get above level 40.

2

u/frostnxn 2d ago

Question is why do they feel forced to rush oht the raids so soon after release. Let the game run for 2 months, optimize things a but more and release them after xmas.

9

u/sarpeishans 2d ago

bullshit, if your game is 80% ready you just ship it. There is no point in waiting. Classic was great, Forever is great, you guys just nitpick every single thing on reddit instead of playing the game

7

u/Rainy_Day_Live 2d ago

I mean multiple items that the community has ‘nitpicked’ turned out to be a real issue that Blizzard has addressed starting with the Druid forms. So, nah, not bullshit.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Binki96 2d ago

Agreed but even in its “unfinished” state it’s super fun. I also like the fact that a lot of the changes seem based off of player feedback instead of 100% dev vibes. With that said there’s some things they’re uncompromising on but that’s fine too

→ More replies (3)

14

u/IIIDEFAULTIII 2d ago

I’m glad balance Druid is getting talked about a little more in depth.

But also holy pally needed more time and a little more deep dive.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/Unluckyfol 2d ago

Actively creating more BIS sets by doing the biome item stuff. His theory is sadly lacking and will make this game hell. This is a repeat of what sod tried. Please don’t lean into biome gearing

12

u/Rhaps0dy 2d ago

"Below roughly level 35 you don't need a healing spec to heal dungeons"

Yeah, and then what? What is the vision of a healer's journey past that?

5

u/Elfeden 2d ago

Not the point. They're saying, that's not why there is a healer shortage before 35.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/Rytnek 2d ago

5 frostbolts before a coc ? did they play any pvp ? no one survives for that long

24

u/pokepat460 2d ago

This one made me feel less confident for the future. A lot of the ideas expressed feel shortsighted. No one wants anyi Murdock swords and stuff, no one wants to carry multiple sets of gear per raid. Why are they going in this direction?

→ More replies (5)

37

u/AberrantMan 2d ago

WoW is NOT low fantasy how is that ever said?

9

u/ComboPriest 2d ago

I think that comment is more in reference to the tone of Classic vs. Retail Class Fantasy.

Retail classes have lots of hugely flashy, very powerful spells - Classic classes are meant to have a fewer of those.

28

u/Glebk0 2d ago

That's actually insane to hear from wow devs

11

u/AberrantMan 2d ago

It honestly makes me think that particular dev is the most full of himself hipster IRL that I'm kinda worried about the future of the game

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Rhaps0dy 2d ago

Powerful flashy magical spells, incredible healing powers, transformations, flying cities, demon invasions, dragons, living embodiments of the elements, all the other races, and everything else.

Yeah, I see how the devs could say this is low fantasy. I see all of the above on my drive to work every day.

10

u/Elfeden 2d ago

They have a baseline they're comparing to, which is retail. They meant "lower fantasy" than retail, quite obvious. Damn this sub sometimes.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

105

u/Imaginary_View_1956 2d ago • Bravo

i just don't understand the niche gear man. everyone hated that shit in SoD. i thought they they were going to go the set bonus way, which would have been awesome, but instead they are going with this stupid "biome" direction which just seems incredibly unfun. i HATE carrying tons of gear around and it sort of ruins immersion. i don't want gimmicky gear

does anyone actually like this?

51

u/galygher 2d ago

Damage on a Tuesday was a massive complaint when d4 launched and everyone everywhere was spamming d4bad. It was reworked after 3 seasons

14

u/TempDanielle 2d ago

Blizzard never learns lessons. We’re just doing D4 all over again. This shit won’t be forever, they just killed D4

11

u/RedditClout 2d ago

I don't mind the concept or principle behind it, but I certainly don't like the idea of feeling like I need to carry all sorts of varying items to get the most out of my build or role in any particular dungeon or raid. You will never, ever get away from BIS mentality. Not everyone will interact with it for sure, but the whole point of playing games where stats matter is generally wanting your character to feel as powerful as it can.

 

Having quirky items like the swim cloak, or faster cooking staff, or whatever is great. Super cool. I just don't think most people want to play pseudo-Druid long term. Nor do I think its a healthy mechanic for the game.

 

That said, I certainly think they could absolutely introduce this stuff in a profession manner. Like end game raids or dungeons you can drop a camp and then you need a combination of all sorts of materials across all professions to make a 'giga' campfire that specifically enhances your "Snow" biome stats, for example. Hell, even something where temporary items are made on the spot you wear for that instance.

 

It makes sense on paper, but they certainly should figure out a better more elegant way to approach it because bag space go up with an ever-expanding gearsets is going to be cumbersome.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/hyperion_x91 2d ago

I think if they make armor/equipment management easy and swappable with those pieces being stored in the templates then it could work, but it still sounds like a lot for little gain

28

u/Quirky-Speaker-6166 2d ago

So dumb. It's wild how they say they want you to feel like your choices matter with talents, with classes, with so much else, then say "you'll need multiple pieces of gear for each slot and be expected to constantly switch". That doesn't feel like gear matters It doesn't feel like an investment or fun.

There is no feeling like getting hand of rag or azuresong mageblade or whatever in this world (probably a few exceptions aside). There's no feeling like "this is my character with this cool set" when you have sets you keep cycling through.

A few exceptions, a few niche pieces? Sure. In small amounts. But doubling and tripling down on it is dumb and ruins it.

→ More replies (12)

16

u/Give_Me_McKee 2d ago

Yeah sounds tedious to me.

10

u/No-Lifeguard-7086 2d ago

How does having multiple sets of gear ruin immersion for you? Not being a smartass just genuinely curious as I’ve always been a Druid for 20 years so I know no other way of playing than to always have / acquire different sets.

→ More replies (5)

14

u/Jacklick 2d ago

just wear the 0.5% worse biome-agnostic piece then?

11

u/rogbog22 2d ago

It's gonna be a fuck of a lot more than .5% or they wouldn't bother.

10

u/Richard_TM 2d ago

No, it's going to be marginal. That's the point.

16

u/barbarianbob 2d ago

These people didnt watch the video lmao.

They straight up said you don't have to gear switch, but if you're a minmaxer, the option is there.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/Vinticore 2d ago

Nah 100% with you there, can be fun for a few pieces maybe but he made it sound like a major focus on gear, annoying.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Doctor_Box 2d ago

I'd prefer if you could get what you need with enchants/armor kits rather than having to have a massive collection of swords in case the next raid is a troll raid.

4

u/ClassicKrova 2d ago

I actually like this because it prevents every new raid being required to have +N item levels above the last raid, and it prevents PvP power creep.

That being said, I do think that "Biome" or "Increase Damage in this raid specifically" is boring. To me the upside of not causing PvP power creep is worth it though. It also means if I think a raid is lame I can entirely ignore it and keep doing what I'm doing.

3

u/Specialty_ERP 2d ago

The horizontal content in this game is -30 bag slots. You WILL like it :)

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Lockenheada 2d ago

I do like aspects of it. I would not mind like for instance a 2 or 3 set gear set with fire resistance bonus on that also gives me a cool effect that's fun. heck of its really fun I might use that gear when not fighting fire enemies.

That's where I personally would see a more horizontal progression. Instead of "you do x% more against the snake boss in raid y"

I want like "the snake boss is weak against ice get your the gloves and the headpiece that convert 18% of your damage into cold and converts your flame totems into ice totems giving you a chance to chill enemies"

stuff like that. yes it's obviously optimal against the ice vulnerable boss but it's also just a cool mechanic outside of that

→ More replies (15)

20

u/Vivid_Succotash_6298 2d ago

Jesus Christ, can these guys stop trying to reinvent the wheel?

You dont need to change things for the sake of changing things.

8

u/smooshtheman 2d ago

But then how will they justify their highly paid jobs in this modern "move fast at all costs cuz ai" industry?

→ More replies (4)

9

u/nemestrinus44 2d ago

this niche biome gear is only good when its a minor bonus. take the Forsaken Greataxe for example, its a complete item for a level 15 with its +8 Strength and +4 Stam but it also provides the bonus of 2% movement speed in Silverpine forest and Hillsbrad foothills.

we don't need gear that are only worth using when fighting a blue dragon inside a snowy cave on thursday when the moon is in retrograde, we need gear that is worth using at all times, and just happens to get a buff when fighting blue dragons in snowy caves on thursday while the moon is in retrograde

→ More replies (3)

4

u/rogbog22 2d ago

They're going to make this awful merchants favor rep mandatory for every profession as opposed to just alchemy/enchanting/engineering like it is now. Brutal lmao.

4

u/lookzlike 2d ago

Game wasnt ready for release and with all the content added just for the beta it feels kinda like bait. The amount of content after 30 is nowhere close to what we had in beta. This goes especially for professions, the pre lvl 10 blues made it look like crafting is gonna be great from 1-60 but its really not.

4

u/RaZeRR77 1d ago

ngl im bit worried after this one

38

u/caelfrmda613 2d ago

Been playing for 25 years and I've never heard a worse idea as biome specific gear, like yeah lemme grind after 7 different sets of gear so I can raid in each biome. " getting rid of bis " is a terrible take.

15

u/Azzriell 2d ago

BIS for situation is an horizontal take.

If you need to get a specific gear on previous dungeon to be MORE efficient (not viable) its quite a good game design and something we could have to make the end game horizontal.

Having "biome" with like dragonslayers gear giving bonus to killing dragons to go to bwl I guess its quite fine.

Osrs use this so you can get the best gear for a difficult task. I guess the game need more small group content to fit this

4

u/caelfrmda613 1d ago

In theory, until you quite literally have 7 different set's of gear to keep track of and swap between constantly, That is not fun, that sir is a fuckin nightmare.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/jkick365 2d ago

Agreed it’s a cool idea in theory, but will end up being a casual’s biggest nightmare.

→ More replies (19)

11

u/SoungaTepes 2d ago

I need rotating BiS, but there’s always going to be a best 

7

u/Zestyclose_Way_6607 2d ago

yeah, its a clickbait question. hate it.

"simply watch this hour+ video to find out the context of this nonsense question"

22

u/matt1918 2d ago

The worst thing about this is the more they talk, the more it is clear this game wasn’t even close to be ready for release. 6 months in classes will finally feel like they should have felt on release.

It’s so sad bc classic plus could have been insane. Forever is still barely beta level.

3

u/Human-Implement-5655 2d ago

And because of the big launch success, the bean counters at Blizzard are going to monetize the hell out of this and cause even more issues. I don't think anyone at Blizzard thought this would be the biggest MMO release since WOTLK.

3

u/EarlyInsurance7557 2d ago

Make healing fun again.

3

u/morduk89 2d ago

Whats the point of locking dual/retalent behind gold? It could make the game more game and less "strict" or "jobish" feeling. If is about goldsink, they could add probably other options.

3

u/Vivid_Succotash_6298 2d ago

Didn't we already to this i SoD with the Naxxramas 6-set bonuses and sanctified gear?

It was a bad idea back then, and making it even more specific is not gonna make it any better.

I mean, i basically cleared SE on 20 in a mix of tier 2 and tier 2.5 because the Naxxramas set got its power spike from its 6-set bonus, and that 6-set bonus was useless for anything that did not have the undead prefix.

3

u/iholuvas 2d ago

The caster gear discussion missed something important. Having to prioritise sp to deal damage means casters are having to give up raw stats even if they can get the gear. Increasing the amount of sp gear won't help unless they start adding more stats in addition. Right now casters are leveling with less hp, mana and spirit than before.

3

u/MaxtheGrape 1d ago

"Sorry guys, I forgot my 'Mace of Gnoll Bashing on a Tuesday in The Rain on a Fullmoon in Grasslands' main hand. Hearthing brb."

3

u/Yasuchika 20h ago

Some of the things they are saying just come off as delusional, like the caster nerfs because of spellpower gear.

You need to craft the new gear to compensate, or farm for it in dungeons. But then they also nerf dungeons to the point that they are not worth running for xp.

So in the end all they did was nerf casters.

5

u/Equanimity_779 2d ago

I absolutely hate that ice lance and fire last share a CD. Just feels awful. Nerf ice land if you need to.

5

u/ibrown22 2d ago

Yo they got no clue what to do with Arms. The bladestorm channel idea was embarrassing.

Make more benefit to stance dancing for arms that's their core identity

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Imaginary-Arguments 2d ago

Gotta love this one.

Countdown is on fire this episode. Burning questions, and honestly I like the developer's answers. It has been so, so long since I've actually trusted the developers of a WoW game.

Aiden (sorry for spelling if wrong) seems so passionate and hearing someone talk about Rogue design at all has been missing from the game for like 10+ years at this point. He knocked it out of the park with Shank and I'm excited to see what kind of items he brings into the game.

22

u/joshcorbo82 The Legend - Countdown to Classic 2d ago

Appreciate the kind words, bit of pressure on me in this one, glad it worked out!

5

u/Zumbert 2d ago

Was better than the others tbh

3

u/Pretend_Chair_2389 2d ago

You did an excellent job.

19

u/Blitz-Lexikon 2d ago

The podcast is so much better without the streamer guests, this was a great one

3

u/desperateorphan 2d ago

Sooooooo much better without the streamers. I don’t need a long drawn out story. Just ask the question and let them answer it with their thoughts and intent.

11

u/Aszolus 2d ago

"...you don't need to be a healing spec to heal dungeons". Maybe that's why nobody wants to play a healer. A dps can replace you easily while also doing a ton more damage. Why would you ever heal spec?

6

u/litnu12 2d ago

Healer spec just makes healing better but the main problem is that people that wanna play healer might wanna level as healer as well, which people did via dungeon leveling

3

u/tumblew33d69 2d ago

I ran a dungeon the other night for over an hour and gained 20% of my level in mob experience...at level 21. We couldn't even complete all the quests because there weren't enough drops to go around. I'd have to go back into the dungeon again, hope it goes faster this time, and that we all get our items to get any reasonable amount of experience. Knowing I'll only get 20% of my level from mobs while I'm in my early 20s is pretty disheartening.

I've decided to just quest instead, that's one less healer queueing now

4

u/litnu12 2d ago

Playing a ret pala and got the 2h axe with 48 healing power in Deadmines, I would have healed other runs just for fun but if I wanna spent 30min-1h not progressing my character I could just Afk.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/smooshtheman 2d ago

I think behind the scenes Ion is intentionally forcing bad things into Forever because it's success highlights his failures all these years. He probably wants it to fail so his bosses don't realize he was the problem all along and costed millions of lost revenue due to his retardation.

2

u/ClassicKrova 2d ago

Interesting mmarkers intro reference.

2

u/DudeIsThisFunny 2d ago

It's good for keeping content alive too, could think of it as a necessary evil if you think it's bad, you'd be trying to que for entry-level max level dungeons and most people would have already moved past that content making it hard to find a group, but any alt you make you'd want to do that content

Be nice if there was something keeping them coming back, should make it univeral on the drop table so they want to do all the bosses and not freaky 1 boss HR runs

2

u/fmal 2d ago

Healer shortage: Prot paladin and prot warrior feel so good that tanks are no longer scarce, but healer numbers haven't gone up. Healing gear has about a third of its healing value as spell damage so healers can still quest. Below roughly level 35 you don't need a healing spec to heal dungeons. The team is weighing ways to make healers easier to level in the open world.

Blizzard needs to pull the entire team together to come up with how to make playing a Healer in a group a productive and rewarding experience instead of just making Dungeons worth running again.

2

u/BigHeadDeadass 2d ago

Any word on the tauren druid forms vs night elf druid forms?

2

u/Elipson_ 2d ago

I think my ideal scenario is horizontal progression via gearsets that enable different playstyles. But I'm not sure if WoW's talent system permits enough design space for something like that

2

u/Schkrasss 1d ago

There is just one actual issue that makes Healers undesireable.

Healers, outside of Dungeons, are just plain undesireable.

Elite Quests in the open World are a joke (and way too few on top) for Healers to matter. Grouping with a Healer when compared to grouping with an offspecc-Healer or Damagedealer is just worse.

Classes specced into Healing are just worse for EVERYONE.

5

u/D3Construct 2d ago

Disappointed that was all what was said about Enhancement. With PvP damage being high across the board and mob damage being scaled up the niche is just gone. Back to back windfury procs all crits wont even kill a level 60 mob.

I want less reliance on totems, not more. So no i'm not happy with weapon enhancement stacking with totem enhancement, give me more reliable throughput now the niche is gone.

They didn't want to do anything for Arms Warriors because yada yada mobility creep. But you will give druids 3 roots and you're "excited" what they will do with them. Well just like anything else in this game, perma root the melee classes without hand of freedom and 100-0 them. Duhhh. Which way is it, Dorothy?

Enhancement is doing comparatively high DPS right now because totems and weapon enhancements give flat and relatively high values. But those don't scale, so as we go on the spec is going to fall off. And not a mention of the capstone talent? 30% attack speed for 25 seconds is so uninspired.

Totemic Call costs 15% of my mana. So does Lesser Healing Wave. If mobs aren't in the immediate vicinity I last 3 casts beween them. If I also use Shocks, 2.

And where is our gear?! You added a ton of items especially for Ret and Shockadin Paladins. I've yet to find the Strength, Int, Stamina and optional spell power items you've alluded to. It's just Hunter or Rogue hand-me-downs all the way.

Chris needs to take his Enhancement Shaman and duel his Frost Mage friend a bunch of times.

5

u/gibby256 2d ago

I don't even want them looking at duels or PvP for balance. Just have a dang vision on what the spec is supposed to be, please. And, ideally, not something that's just "pray to the RNG gods that you can do decent damage this pull".

2

u/D3Construct 2d ago

I dont want them looking at duels for balance either, but their global changes meant we went from killing one mob quickly and the other somewhat slowly and compensating with Maelstrom/Shocks, to needing multiple windfury procs in any case to have an average kill speed. The duel will emphasize how poor we are at delivering damage at the slightest inconvenience.

Before release I figured we would get the nerf hammer as soon as one shaman got a highlight reel in PvP. I was wrong, we got a pre-emptive nerf hammer before it even released by completely breaking the spec dynamic.

I just got my first piece of Bloodmail btw. 1 out of 6 scholo bosses even dropped any loot at all, and thank god it was one I needed.

3

u/SpunkMcKullins 2d ago

The sign is interesting, given I saw this post pop up in r/wow just a little while ago.

https://www.reddit.com/r/wow/comments/1y0dekq/every_portal_suddenly_began_to_look_like_a_portal/

2

u/bca327 2d ago

Really sad to hear about the set bonuses. Instead of removing them, why not give us a way to customize gear with set bonuses we have earned so we can wear the new gear and have the set bonus we want active? Needing snow gear and fire gear and air gear or whatever just sound boring and uninspired.

2

u/Ruby_Rhods_Hair 2d ago

Reddit continues to complain while the majority of us are having a great time

2

u/dontwantanaccount86 2d ago

Holy paladin needs so much more to be dynamic.

Lights vigil getting its original design back to be usable as an offensive spell would make our decision making way more interesting.

Infusion of light needs to reduce the mana cost of holy light and make its over healing give an absorb shield. That will make us actually respond to the proc and use it, where as right now it procs and holy light is still an expensive spell that we often don’t need, so we just end up continuing to spam flash of light while the 15 second proc tics away.

3

u/misterrpg 2d ago

The original version of Lights Vigil was so cool. I almost decided to play Holy Paladin because of it.

2

u/dontwantanaccount86 2d ago

It looked amazing dude, watching them completely gut the spell 2 days before release was just so jarring.

3

u/misterrpg 2d ago

They fucked so many classes over just days before launch. It was insane. X_x

2

u/gannacrydotjpeg 2d ago

Guild wars 3 can't come fast enough

1

u/Not_Adam__ 2d ago edited 2d ago

Love to hear they are looking at the later half of the balance tree. 0.5s starfire cast and +10%dmg are both mandatory and cost 10 talents, and if you take the root talents too you miss +intellect / pushback reduction and in-combat mana regen from resto, all of which is desperately needed by the spec to come online.

1

u/Aflyingmongoose 1d ago

I don't see how raising player health in pvp is a big job.

In ESO when you're in a pvp game mode you just have a buff that adds 5k max hp, which helps normalize survivavility for squishier builds.

1

u/nutzhell51 1d ago

How is this possible to change some major things like that when the game is not in alpha it just give me the feeling that Blizzard don't know what to do with Forever and this is going nowhere

1

u/Ramn_ 1d ago

Friendly reminder to everyone in this thread: turtle wow (where 90% of forever is based on) managed several years without biome gear or just having cosmetic rewards, mounts, fluff. You don't need to reinvent the wheel.

1

u/sandleaz 1d ago

The developers are still lying about caster damage. I guess they are happy that more people are leaving or avoiding the classes that the developers made gimp.

1

u/Gassenger 19h ago

With what fuckin bags am I supposed to carry so many sets of heckin wholesome B I O M E gear if I'm a prot warrior that will DPS some fights? Especially with consumables?

Thank god I don't need a fuckin flask set anymore

1

u/whiterabbit-redeyes 15h ago

Yikes. Here we go the game is ruined. Oh and if you think just Pve is ruined they ruined Pvp system as well with weekly gated rank 14 gear for everyone doing the quests kekw

•

u/EaglePete 3h ago

In regards to the healer shortage:

Just make dual spec at a lower level and lower cost, so players can get it earlier?

That would fix so much healer shortage issues. If you can get it at 20 or 30 (where some of the newer dungeons starts to hit harder), then more people will try healing out. The fact that it competes with mount at 40 is such a wild idea. (Also just before people call it "friction and stuff to work towards" there is clearly a reason why we are seeing this healer shortage, so maybe making the game fun and approachable on this topic is warranted)

Because having dungeons that require healing is actually fun, doing Drowned city and alcaz prison was a fun experience BECAUSE there where some damage to heal.

Also, blizz should think about making "raid frames" the standard party ui. I can't imagine a new player trying to heal with the standard ones, what an awful time that would be.

•

u/spooky_office 1h ago

ele does nothing

1

u/Dry_Individual1516 2d ago

Here's the recap: class balance is gimped, our hands are tied lol!

1

u/santc 2d ago

It really seems like level 60 balance is their main priority and they don’t care how a class actually FEELS to play

1

u/disastrous_hyena759 2d ago

I think this whole itemization philosophy is missing the point a little.

I'm all for RPG elements, flavor and items having some lore behind them. That's great. But at the end of the day, this is still an MMORPG. The items actually need to be worth using.

What's the point of adding something like an Ogre Loincloth with Strength and Spell Damage just because there's a story behind it? Okay, it's flavorful, I get it. But who is actually going to use that thing? And why should it take up a spot in a dungeon boss's loot table when it could have been something players would actually be excited to get?

That's what bothers me. Some of these dungeons are things people might only run once while leveling, and the loot is part of what makes those runs rewarding. Getting an item with completely random stats that nobody has any reason to equip just feels like a wasted drop.

And I don't really buy the whole "RPG first, gameplay second" argument either. If we're going to take RPG logic that seriously, then why don't Frost spells do extra damage to Fire elementals? Why don't Holy spells do extra damage to Undead and Demons? Why don't skeletons take extra damage from bludgeoning weapons?

I'm not asking for every item to be BiS or for everything to revolve around min-maxing. Weird items can be fun, and situational gear has its place. But there's a difference between an unusual item that someone might actually find a use for and an item that's just dead loot.

I really hope this philosophy doesn't carry over into raid itemization, because I don't want to see the same thing happening with epic gear.

An item having a story behind it is nice, but that doesn't automatically make it a good reward. Flavor is great, but it shouldn't come at the expense of actually having good loot.