For those of you who don't know Diplomacy, I won't bore you with the rules. Suffice it to say, this map is a strategic representation of the military positions and economically relevant positions for every faction in World of Warcraft.
It invites conversations on how different alliances between the factions, not matching those of the post-Warcraft-3 Alliance and Horde, would play out in a real extended war that takes into account as many variables as possible for realism.
Hope you Enjoy looking at it! And please offer any recommendations for better names for the sub regions and coastal regions I spelled out, as well as which spaces deserve to have supply centers more than some of the ones I picked!
Below is the FAQ for the nerds who are curious about the rules of the map:
Q1: So, how does it work?
A: Everyone discusses what their moves are going to be / should be. With what they agreed upon and learned in mind, everyone writes down moves for their armies and fleets, and everyone's moves happen at once. In short, the only way for your moves to win, is if you have more armies fighting for the same objective than anyone else does. Because factions are relatively equal in size to their neighbors, this means the ONLY way to win in this game is to convince the most people into working for you and with you, rather than against you.
Q2: Why are some zones like Loch Modan not the color of their faction?
A: Loch Modan is certainly Dwarven Land! but unfortunately very few dwarves live there nor is it particularly economically productive or a relevant choke point for trade. Therefore, even though it would be Dwarf colored, it doesn't deserve a supply center, and therefore it's color is irrelevant.
Q3: What's with the weird circles inside the Ocean Tiles? Are those the same thing I see in the Barrens?
A: These are "High seas Tiles". They represent land or water that is connected to everything it touches, but unlike other tiles has room for multiple armies. Essentially, these Circles all act as copies of the same space on the map, and players can move into separate circles in the same ocean at the same time without interrupting or attacking each other. A faction with many armies or fleets in the same high seas tile, can attack with great strength into a tile that it is touching.
Q4: What's with the few triangles that have color inside?
A: These represent zones that while not already belonging to a faction at the start of the game, (perhaps due to strong presence of monsters or other factions), possess a cultural tie to a faction that has home centers nearby. If the faction with specifically the matching color of a "pre-cored" center owns it, they can then use it as a home center, from which they can resupply and place armies or fleets at the start of each year, if they are not at build limit.
Q5:But you can't really get from Mulgore to Shen'Dralas or Desolace? Hang on, nor can you...
A: I know, a lot of the pathing in this game is restrictive, by the geography of the continents. Unfortunately if I kept every border as it is, there would be too many choke points that can't be attacked into by multiple armies at once from either side, which would stop the game from progressing. I tried to keep a balance between the real restrictions of the geography, by narrowing the connectivity of zones as they approach my new choke point connections, while also trying to add connections where it actually makes sense. (E.G. Azshara to Everlook, I'm sure the Goblins could figure out a way to get their Everlook booty to the ocean. Probably a way involving dynamite.)
Q6: Which home centers start with a fleet versus an army!
A: I haven't made that visible on this map yet! But essentially in most cases, it's what you would expect based on the lore of the game. For instance, Auberdine has a fleet, and this actually means that the Night Elves only start with one army, and are therefore very limited in inland expansion early on. Fleets need the tile they are moving to to be touching the water they are on, in order to be able to move there.
Q7: Where are the Gnomes? Why aren't they a faction on this map?
A: 😏
Q8: How is it Fair that some factions are bigger? A: the win conditions in this game require more supply centers to win if you start out bigger.
A: Like in the variant "Imperial Diplomacy" Factions that start with more starting centers, have tougher win conditions. After more playtesting I would adjust, for now working numbers are:
Tauren/Dwarf/Undead = 21 to Win
Night Elf/Blood Elf = 25 to Win
Orc = 28 to Win
Troll / Human = 30 to Win
👀