r/cogsci • u/Andrzejwwa • 15h ago
Is psychology considered a soft science simply because we don't yet have the computational power to measure it properly?
For years, psychology has been considered a soft science, while fields like physics are considered hard sciences because their phenomena can be measured, calculated, and experimentally verified.
But what if this distinction is based on a cognitive bias?
What if the human mind is, paradoxically, far more complex than any of the systems we can currently measure and model? What if it involves an almost infinite number of combinations, interactions, dependencies, and feedback loops, making it practically impossible to measure and predict accurately with our current capabilities?
For example, imagine someone making a particular decision. Now imagine that exact same person having to make the same decision under slightly different conditions: the temperature is one degree lower, the humidity is a little higher, the wind is blowing from the west instead of the east, they slept one hour less, had a stressful experience that morning, and their arm happens to be itching.
Would they make exactly the same decision?
The number of environmental and historical factors involved is enormous, and the possible combinations are practically endless. While each individual factor might have little or no significant influence on the decision, a combination of several factors could potentially change the outcome entirely.
And that's exactly what I'm talking about: the entire system — the environment, external factors, personal history, current internal state, and all the interactions between them.
What if all of this is actually deterministic and just as mathematically calculable as physical or chemical phenomena, but the system is so incredibly complex that we simply don't have the computational power or the ability to account for enough variables to model it accurately yet?
So perhaps psychology, which has often been dismissed as a "soft science," isn't inherently less rigorous or less mathematically predictable. Perhaps the phenomena it studies are simply so complex that they're much harder to calculate than many of the systems studied in the hard sciences.
What do you think?
BTW: I'm not some psychology fanatic. I'm equally interested in physics and other hard sciences. This is just a thought I had today, and I'm curious to hear other perspectives.