r/cogsci • • 1d ago

Is psychology considered a soft science simply because we don't yet have the computational power to measure it properly?

6 Upvotes

For years, psychology has been considered a soft science, while fields like physics are considered hard sciences because their phenomena can be measured, calculated, and experimentally verified.

But what if this distinction is based on a cognitive bias?

What if the human mind is, paradoxically, far more complex than any of the systems we can currently measure and model? What if it involves an almost infinite number of combinations, interactions, dependencies, and feedback loops, making it practically impossible to measure and predict accurately with our current capabilities?

For example, imagine someone making a particular decision. Now imagine that exact same person having to make the same decision under slightly different conditions: the temperature is one degree lower, the humidity is a little higher, the wind is blowing from the west instead of the east, they slept one hour less, had a stressful experience that morning, and their arm happens to be itching.

Would they make exactly the same decision?

The number of environmental and historical factors involved is enormous, and the possible combinations are practically endless. While each individual factor might have little or no significant influence on the decision, a combination of several factors could potentially change the outcome entirely.

And that's exactly what I'm talking about: the entire system — the environment, external factors, personal history, current internal state, and all the interactions between them.

What if all of this is actually deterministic and just as mathematically calculable as physical or chemical phenomena, but the system is so incredibly complex that we simply don't have the computational power or the ability to account for enough variables to model it accurately yet?

So perhaps psychology, which has often been dismissed as a "soft science," isn't inherently less rigorous or less mathematically predictable. Perhaps the phenomena it studies are simply so complex that they're much harder to calculate than many of the systems studied in the hard sciences.

What do you think?

BTW: I'm not some psychology fanatic. I'm equally interested in physics and other hard sciences. This is just a thought I had today, and I'm curious to hear other perspectives.


r/cogsci • • 1d ago

[D] Can AI learn to sleep like the brain does?

0 Upvotes

The brain replays memories during sleep, which is one reason we don’t forget old things when we learn new ones. Neural nets don’t have anything like that, so they forget badly (catastrophic forgetting).

I went through some of the papers that try to borrow this idea (generative replay, LAMOL, van de Ven et al. 2020) and ran a few small experiments on GPT-2 to see how it plays out on a language model.

One thing surprised me: where the “dreams” come from matters a lot. When the model generated replay from a frozen copy of itself, it kept about 58% of the old facts, vs 6% with no replay. When it dreamed from the version that was still training, the dreams turned into false facts and it barely helped (9%).

It’s a small setup (GPT-2 small, made-up facts, 3 seeds), so I’d love to hear if this matches what others have seen, or if there’s work I missed.

Write-up here if anyone’s curious: https://evo-quest.github.io/can-ai-learn-to-sleep/


r/cogsci • • 2d ago

APA dictionary definition of preconscious

Thumbnail dictionary.apa.org
1 Upvotes

r/cogsci • • 2d ago

Neuroscience Textbook incorrect? Please tell me if I’m losing my mind.

Post image
18 Upvotes

I’m a new professor teaching cognitive neuroscience to undergrads and have recently adopted the newest edition of The Student’s Guide to Cognitive Neuroscience as the textbook for my course. This description of fear conditioning has me second-guessing myself. The unconditioned stimulus would be the shock, right?

This book has had a lot of typos and errors, so I wouldn’t be surprised if this is just another mistake that was overlooked by the editors. But I’m questioning my own understanding of fear learning paradigms after teaching it for years. Is this book mistaken, or do I need to reevaluate my own understanding?

My understanding is this:
Tone = conditioned stimulus (CS- before conditioning, CS+ after conditioning)
Shock = unconditioned stimulus (US)
Fear response to shock = unconditioned response
Fear response to tone after association = conditioned response.

Please help me verify which is mistaken - me or this new edition of the textbook! Thank you


r/cogsci • • 3d ago

Psychology What Psychological and Cognitive Factors Influence Human Memory Retrieval, and How Can Recall Be Improved?

9 Upvotes

What does cognitive psychology research reveal about the processes involved in encoding, storing and retrieving information?

In particular:

* What causes difficulties in recalling names, dates and previously learned information?

* How does stress or performance pressure affect memory retrieval?

* What is the distinction between poor information retention and retrieval failure?

* What evidence-based techniques have been shown to improve long-term retention and spontaneous recall?

* Can memory retrieval abilities be systematically strengthened through cognitive training?


r/cogsci • • 4d ago

Misc. 100% Free, comprehensive spatial reasoning tool

12 Upvotes

Hey y'all I'm Mighty and I am passionate about brain training(i know i know many think it doesnt work). But many studies have shown improving spatial abilities specifically is actually very possible! But the problem was that I couldn't find a free, comprehensive and fun tool online that can do that.

That's why I focused my energy on creating this 100% free(and will remain free as i update it) tool that is meant to improve your spatial reasoning and awareness.

You also have a spatial check test you can do before starting training and after, so you can see for yourself if there was transfer.

Have fun yall

https://mighty-iq.github.io/Parallax/


r/cogsci • • 5d ago

Should I switch to cognitive science from data science?

20 Upvotes

I am a freshman in college doing a double major in music performance and data science right now. I originally came in as an engineering/music double major but immediately switched to data science since it would be "easier" to do with music than engineering. However I HATE math. I'm literally in calc 1 and am struggling so much even though I took Calc 1 and 2 in high school. But I like coding for some reason, I'm doing super well in my programming class. My real passion is music, but I'm scared that I won't be able to support myself as solely a musician later on in life. Cognitive science seems super interesting, and at my university I won't need to take any higher level math classes and it has a lot less crazy requirements than data science. I don't know if cognitive science could possibly give me any financial stability later on in life. I'm so lost and I need some advice.


r/cogsci • • 4d ago

Psychology Can children really remember past lives? What’s behind the reincarnation headlines

Thumbnail doi.org
0 Upvotes

r/cogsci • • 6d ago

Even Four-Year-Olds May Stick With a Wrong Answer to Belong to a Group

Thumbnail humanumi.com
47 Upvotes

Four-year-olds may be prone to cling to an incorrect answer, even when presented with obvious evidence to the contrary, reveals a new study by Duke University.

Children were asked to guess which coloured block would activate a machine. Children whose place on the team depended on a shared belief were more likely to stick with their original wrong answer.

This study, published in PNAS, looked at 192 children aged 4-5 years old. It brings up an interesting question about how young children start to be influenced by their desire to belong.

One might also wonder whether the same tendency can be seen in adult group behaviour?

https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2622764123


r/cogsci • • 7d ago

Pls help me understand this cog sci paper!!

Thumbnail gallery
50 Upvotes

Undergrad student here, looking for help in understanding what’s going on in the first experiment of the following research paper for a cognitive science assignment. I’m currently struggling to comprehend what is actually being done in the experiment and when I try to do external research, I get mixed results which don’t seem to match the context. Please share any ideas you may have! Thanks!!


r/cogsci • • 7d ago

Psychology Need participants for my thesis research [Everyone 18+]

2 Upvotes

Hello! I'm a cognitive science and psychology student collecting data for my bachelor thesis on how people read and evaluate written information.

You'll have to read some short texts on various topics and complete a few questionnaires. It takes 20 to 35min depending on your speed. The full details of the study are available at the end of it.

https://forms.gle/5ty2nbMLETWe9BVXA

I know it's on the longer side, so I really appreciate anyone who takes the time to do it!! Happy to answer any questions in the comments!


r/cogsci • • 7d ago

How is AI affecting our brains?

9 Upvotes

Ever wonder how your use of AI is affecting your brain long-term? For example, the area responsible
For handwriting and navigation has already shrunk. However, knowing how to ask the right questions will be more important than ever. I am starting a video series where I talk to experts about this: https://www.instagram.com/themindandthemachine?cplk=MWZocWlncmFxMzV2MQ%3D%3D&utm_source=qr


r/cogsci • • 7d ago

Neuroscience I wanna learn more about NLP. But I don't know where to start. Where do I start? 🤍

0 Upvotes

Hello!

I'm very interested and new to NLP. I'm in sales, customer relations, business to business industry and I'm starting my own little team.

And i personally like self development stuff.

I think my mentor before introduced NLP (like 5yrs ago already) or maybe used it to mentor me, but i wanna refresh myself, learn more, deep dive so i can use it for myself and growth, my business and my own team.

I don't know where to start. I'm so overwhelmed.

Where should i start? What do i read? Watch or listen?

Thank you so so much 🤍


r/cogsci • • 8d ago

Request: Empirical studies (outside economics) on how mood affects the valuation of money, gambles, stocks, etc.

2 Upvotes

Shiller (1981) showed that stock prices are far more volatile than conventional economics can justify. One explanation for this excess-volatility puzzle is the mood hypothesis of Mehra and Sah (2002). It rests on the premises that investors' moods fluctuate involuntarily (for example, between fear of the future and boldness) and that investors involuntarily treat their current mood as permanent, even though it is not. As a result, the value an investor places on stocks, and hence the price he or she is willing to pay for them, moves with mood. The outcome is excessive volatility in stock prices.

I am familiar with the economics and finance literature on the Mehra–Sah hypothesis. I am looking for empirical work in other disciplines, such as consumer behavior, neuroscience, organizational behavior and psychology, on how mood affects the valuation of monetary objects such as money, gambles and stocks, as well as on related topics. I would be grateful for any references.


r/cogsci • • 9d ago

A 52-minute documentary on metacognition: from Nelson & Narens to dolphins, monkeys, LIP neurons and language models

Thumbnail youtu.be
1 Upvotes

I made a documentary on metacognition and tried to stay close to the primary literature. The thread is Nelson & Narens' framework (object level, meta level, monitoring, control), followed through:

  • Hart's feeling of knowing, Brown & McNeill's tip of the tongue, and Koriat's point that these feelings are inferences from cues;
  • Smith et al.'s dolphin and the uncertain response, Hampton's monkeys declining memory tests, Kornell, Son & Terrace's betting;
  • Kepecs et al. and Lak et al. on confidence in rat orbitofrontal cortex, Kiani & Shadlen on LIP;
  • the error-related negativity, meta-d' (Maniscalco & Lau), Fleming's work on anterior prefrontal cortex, blindsight and anosognosia;
  • And in the last act, the same questions asked of a language model, with measurements I ran myself.

Corrections welcome. That is rather the point of the film.


r/cogsci • • 11d ago

1-minute survey in Spanish for a university experiment (Native or bilingual Spanish speakers, 18+)

3 Upvotes

Hi! We're students at CUNEF (Madrid) running a short experiment for our Behavioral Economics course. The survey is in Spanish, anonymous and takes under a minute.

Who can take it: 18+, native or bilingual Spanish speakers.

https://www.soscisurvey.de/direkt/?r=sesgos

Please don't post your answers or guesses about the hypothesis in the comments. We'll happily share the results here once we're done. Thanks!


r/cogsci • • 12d ago

Work/Academia I have a craaazy idea

38 Upvotes

What if we made separate conferences for all these LLM-human brain alignment people and keep the usual conferences for the rest of us who are interested in human cognition? Just a thought, inspired by all the conferences attended this year.


r/cogsci • • 14d ago

Neuroscience Mixed Bag #27: Andrés Delgado-Ron on the Science of Near-Death Experiences

Thumbnail open.substack.com
10 Upvotes

r/cogsci • • 18d ago

How baby brain is able to understand concepts without language ?

9 Upvotes

How ?


r/cogsci • • 18d ago

How does psychology arrive at definitions for abstract constructs describing human behaviour?

1 Upvotes

And does cognitive science do this any differently, or rely on similar methods? Methodology question, related to construct validity.

I’m not so much asking how individual studies are designed or how researchers measure a particular construct. I’m interested in how definitions themselves are established.

How do researchers decide which aspects of human behaviour belong together under a particular concept? To what extent are these definitions derived from empirical observations, inherited from earlier theories, or influenced by philosophical assumptions?

If constructs are debatable or flexible, does that not make the process uniquely vulnerable to unconsciously shifting the definition until the observed results reinforce rather than test assumptions?

If researchers can revise a construct in response to unexpected findings, how do we distinguish legitimate theoretical refinement from protecting a construct against falsification?

The study associated with [this post](https://www.reddit.com/r/psychology/s/miqH3oQgga) made me wonder.


r/cogsci • • 18d ago

Could Anne Cleary’s research on déjà vu help explain the intense sense of familiarity reported in DMT experiences?

Thumbnail samwoolfe.com
5 Upvotes

Anne Cleary’s research suggests déjà vu can arise when a scene resembles an earlier experience (e.g. a similar spatial layout) that we fail to recall, producing familiarity without a known source. People who take DMT often report an intense and sometimes sustained sense of familiarity, as if they’ve been to the realm before.

This article looks at whether Cleary’s account could help explain this, alongside split perception and other memory-based theories. Her studies involved brief, sober déjà vu, so the link is tentative.

What do you think might explain DMT-induced déjà vu?


r/cogsci • • 18d ago

Looking for a video

2 Upvotes

Hi!

I remember seeing a video (maybe part of a documentary??) that did a really great job of demonstrating operant conditioning, differential reinforcement and superstitious behavior. The subjects were human and the reinforcer was a dollar bill. The person would walk into a "room" wherein they would have to figure out a button press, or lever or spot on the wall etc... or the reward would be released on a time delay. I remember it being less video documentation of a study and more of a demo for entertainment and understanding.

I'm having a hard time remembering where I saw it. I'm a dog trainer who trains other trainers and I remember this video being a great, accessible way to see some learning principals in action. I'd love to share it with my students.

Does this ring any bells? or am I barking up the wrong tree?


r/cogsci • • 21d ago

Psychology Does cognitive science have insights on how to reason better and how to understand the cause of beliefs ?

8 Upvotes

Right now behavioral science is a hot topic , specifically in policymaking circles regarding making policies based on how people actually behave , but what about cognitive science ? Can it be helpful in examining the foundation of peoples beliefs and develop better means of reasoning


r/cogsci • • 22d ago

Work/Academia Confused between Physics, Cognitive Science, Computational Neuroscience, and Complex Systems

30 Upvotes

I’m a 26-year-old Computer Science graduate with 3.5 years of IT experience, looking to transition into research. I’ve always been driven by the desire to understand why things happen the way they do, from the fundamental workings of the universe to human thoughts, behaviours, and societal patterns.

I believe everything is interconnected, and I want to understand those connections scientifically. My interests range from space, time, and physics to consciousness, lucid dreaming, out-of-body experiences (OBEs), human psychology, and brain-computer interfaces. I initially wanted to pursue physics to develop the mathematical thinking needed to understand these systems, but now I’m torn between Physics, Cognitive Science, Computational Neuroscience, and Complex Systems. I also love teaching and hope to start a science-based YouTube channel featuring documentaries, podcasts, and experiments exploring scientific and social questions.

I’m looking for a field that allows me to investigate the bigger picture without being restricted to one narrow discipline. I’d really appreciate advice from researchers or students who’ve navigated similar interdisciplinary interests. Which path would offer the strongest foundation and flexibility?