I'm the most experienced at my table by far (12+ years vs couple months). Recently everyone has mentioned they wanted to try DMing and one of them has started their campaign (Percy Jackson themed). They'd been planning it for months and asking me questions about how I do my planning and mechanics, both in general and for homebrewing to fit the setting. I'm trying to avoid "backseat DMing" as much as possible, while letting the DM lean whatever knowledge I have whenever they want.
I've offered to help with monsters and encounters, but they've largely declined. I think they want to keep the surprise of encounters and make sure I get to enjoy the story too, without spoilers. I've suggested tactics like having me help prep 3 encounters at a time so I don't know which will be used or when, but they wanted to design the encounters on their own.
Last session, the DM made it clear that both encounters we faced were intended to be deadly.
The first was a wolf with like 50 hp and 2 attacks dealing like 5-10 damage per hit (probably like +5 to hit, 1d8+3). We're a party of 4 level 2 characters so we kill it in like 2 rounds.
The second was these vines. We had to make a dex save every time we moved or else we would be grappled and the DC was going up by 1 every round. There were two actual vine creatures to attack, but they had <25 hp each. We were rolling decently on our saves and damage, so we killed the first one in like 2 rounds. Some people were getting stuck in the vines out of range, but we still got to the second one and as it was getting hit the DM kinda got dejected and threw in the towel. Said fight was over, it doesn't matter. Apparently the intention was for the entire party to get trapped in the vines for the cliffhanger end of the session, but because we killed the creatures too fast, that wasn't going to happen. Effectively, ruining the planned end to the session.
DM was pretty upset at themselves. The mentioned to me before the session they we're excited to prove that they could design encounters well, and I guess the felt like they failed. (They didn't. The fights were fun and interesting). Everyone thought this was a really really cool encounter and I think they kinda felt bad that playing their characters well meant they messed up the DM's fun.
Soon as the party realized this, we all tried backing up the DM to let this happen. "Just spawn more enemies", "give them more hp", "maybe we all get caught in vines trying to leave", etc. Eventually, we hyped the DM up enough to let the cliffhanger happen as planned, but I think they still left the session disappointed with themselves and their encounters.
So couple things at play here.
I want to help them run the campaign they want to run. I just want them to have the tools and knowledge they need to play the game and then I want to shut up and let them be awesome.
I don't want to damage their growing confidence as a DM. I don't want to just list all the things they maybe should've done (#1 don't plan for a single result, but also more hp/lie about the hp, more enemies/second wave, minions, fear, poison, AoEs, resistances, etc). Even coming from a good place, I think they may feel worse that they didn't do those things. I think they kinda expected they would be a "perfect DM", even though they're new; even though no one else has that expectation and no one was really complaining about the encounter or any of the 5+ sessions so far. We we're all having a blast, that only kinda stopped when we realized the DM was upset.
There's also the part where I'm also kinda helping the rest of the party learn the game. Reminding them about hunter's mark or their focus points or tactical mind. Explaining rules and stuff. I try to also do that for the DM too (remind them when they have advantage on me because of reckless and stuff), but since I don't know the statblocks my ability to do that is limited. I'm tempted to just shut up because I don't want the DM to feel like they're just trying to outsmart me and my encyclopedic knowledge of the mechanics in every encounter. At the same time, I don't want to stop helping the players learn their characters.
I'm also playing a barbarian. -3 WIS but +4 CON, Tough Feat, 30 hp. So like that vines fight was literally something my character is built for. I had advantage on every dex save because of Danger Sense and would've had my crazy rage strength to get ungrappled anyways. I got a nat 20 on my initiative and rolled max damage on my first attack so I dealt like 15 damage, so I almost killed the first vine in the first round. I have plenty of weaknesses, but that fight played to my strengths. I kinda feel bad about playing a semi-optimized character now.
I think other players may also feel bad about playing their characters well and using their features. The monk was discussing using a focus point (for the first time ever) for flurry of blows to take out the second vine, when the DM just decided to give up on the encounter. In retrospect, I think the Fighter's action surge kinda seemed like it hurt the DM's confidence too (like it helped show the encounter wasn't going to go the DM's way).
TLDR: Me, being an experienced player, is helping the table learn D&D. Player's figured out their characters and won some fights utilizing their abilities. New DM's encounters were awesome conceptually, but maybe too easy mechanically (and we got lucky). It kinda wrecked their confidence in the mechanics. How can I help without overstepping?
Anyone handled the experienced player x new DM dynamic before? What's helpful? When should I just shut up?
Any new DMs have some resources that really helped them figure out how to design encounters and run combat?