r/dndnext • u/Obvious_Camera_9879 • 23m ago
Question new DM - My player refuses to use an element of the setting I chose for the Campaign
Heya, I think the title sums it up quite decently to be honest, but here's some context just to be safe:
Me and my group all pretty new to the game, I'm probably the most experienced one of the bunch, which is why they FORCED me to play the DM (no real grudge held for that lol), my relative inexperience is why I'm using the Forgotten Realms setting, it's popular, supported by WotC and a bunch of other shit, which overall saves me a good chunk of time with world-building.
This being said, I also do want to integrate my players' characters into the story as possible, and, considering we're most certainly gonna have a paladin and a cleric, and that I personally really like that concept, I know that the gods of Faerun are gonna play a decent role in tying them into the world, say with quests related to temples and other stuff like that.
Now here's the issue: the paladin player absolutely refuses to choose one of the gods in the pantheon listed for the Forgotten Realms as his, and no matter what I tell him he won't budge...
He insists i can just not tie his faith into the story, but as I said... I do want to do that. I know I should let my players do what they want, but since he expects me to have stuff ready for the adv., is impatient as hell with game scheduling etc. etc., I feel like he could at the very least help me by making my job easier following the ONE thing I'm asking of him, instead of making joke deities which I won't even be getting into cuz that's a whole other can of worms...
Who's in the wrong here? Am i too controlling like he says, or is this a reasonable expectation on my side? How do i handle this?? Please help me