Hello everyone,
I had been looking into eGPUs for the past few weeks, especially since I was planning to live in a dorm for college, I thought that buying a whole desktop case would be pointless and an eGPU would also save me money.
here's the specs:
Intel i9 11950H (8 core/16 threads)
48GB DDR4 (I added 16)
1 + 2 TB NVMe SSD (I added 2)
Integrated Intel UHD Graphics
NVIDIA RTX A2000 (iGPU)
MSI NVIDIA RTX 3070 ti (eGPU)
Although my Thinkpad P15 G2 already comes with an RTX A2000 (4GB ECC VRAM), and a 1920p x 1080p resolution with 60hz, which is decent for a laptop. I wanted something a little better, which I could game on when I'm at home, and so I bought the following (prices with shipping and taxes, in USD):
RTX 3070 ti - eBay ~$300
ADT-link K43SG (NVMe M.2 to PCIe 4.0x16 adapter) - eBay ~$90
Corsair CX450M (450W Power Supply) - eBay ~$15
Z-EDGE G274K (4K monitor, 160hz, 1ms, IPS) - eBay ~$200
The monitor particularly was a great purchase IMO, it really improves the experience and quality while also improving the frame rate when using an eGPU.
You also don't need to buy all of these items from ebay, the NVMe to PCIe 16 adapater and the monitor were new, and I was just looking for everything on eBay for cheaper prices, although it would have costed the same if I bought them elsewhere. In fact, I recommend getting your stuff elsewhere if it's not used or refurbished because eBay can be unreliable with shipping and returns.
My thinkpad has 3 NVMe M.2 SSD slots, 2 on the back panel and 1 under the keyboard. It does support Thunderbolt 4 as well but I didn't want to compromise on any performance while having these slots available. Also, a direct NVMe to PCIe 16 adapter is obviously much cheaper than OCuLink.
The particular challenge with my Thinkpad was that the only PCIe 4.0x4 slot is the one under the keyboard, while the ones on the back panel are PCIe 3.0x4, which don't provide drastically different theoretical bandwidth from the TB4; so I decided that if I was gonna get an NVMe to PCIe 16 adapter, I might as well use the PCIe 4.0 slot under the keyboard.
I didn't have any issues setting it up, for the most part. In particular, I had one problem, Windows was able to connect and detect the eGPU after putting in the adapter in the slot, turning on the Power Supply and rebooting it. However, it would not appear in Task Manager, and when I checked Device Manager, it would say "Windows has stopped this device because it has reported problems (43)". I was able to fix it with this: https://egpu.io/forums/expresscard-mpcie-m-2-adapters/script-nvidia-error43-fixer/ . The laptop also reports error 2100 about some "corrupted disk" whenever you boot, but you can just press escape and skip right past it.
Finally, for performance, I am able to play RDR2 on 4k and Ultra/High settings on 50-80 FPS (mostly around 60) on DLSS Quality settings, whereas before it was around 30 FPS on Medium settings with balanced DLSS on the native 1920x1080p display.
I'm very satisfied with the results and the setup, being able to use the Laptop at school/elsewhere and attaching the cable back and playing games on good quality with a big monitor when I'm home. I know the setup looks like attaching and detaching would be too much work to do everytime, and it's definitely more than just disconnecting a USB cable, but I think it's worth it. The PCIe ribbon is quite bendable/adjustable, I can keep the keyboard almost on the original laptop format (still disconnected, of course) while having the ribbon cable connected. Not that it matters anyways because I can just adjust the laptop to whatever position, since I'm using an external monitor.
I just need a little screwdriver, and it's helpful to have one of those electronics metal pry tools as well. I take the screw off on the back panel first, then losen up 2 screws on the back which allows me to take off the keyboard. Then I use the metal spudger to pull keyboard back towards the screen and take it out. Finally, I need to take off the metal panel under the keyboard to access the PCIe 4.0 (and ram) slot. It's also important to keep in mind that the metal panel under the keyboard has screws that come out all the way, so it's nice to have a little plastic zipper to keep them safe (same with the m.2 nvme screw but you screw it right back in after putting in the adapter). You also need to be a little more careful when installing or taking off the metal panel since if you drop the screws inside the laptop you might have to open it entirely to find them. In total, this takes me 2-4 minutes, and I don't really have to use my laptop a lot for highschool, so I say it's worth it.
I haven't tried the compatibility on Linux yet, will make another post if I see any major issues.
(I know the pic says 32gb but that's before I installed the additional memory)