r/fanedits • u/TriggeredPuppy • 1h ago
Updated Release The Two Towers - Slightly Less Extended Edition! Major lore improvements
No elves at Helm's Deep! Frodo doesn't offer the ring to the flying Nazgul!
Instructions to download can be found in my Reddit profile. DM me if you have issues. Link is in description texts of both the original 2022 release video as well as the recent Less Extended Hobbit video: The Hobbit - Significantly Less Extended Edition! Now available : r/fanedits
Fellowship updated release thread can be found here: https://www.reddit.com/r/fanedits/s/dkBiXXadGG
Technical Details:
Runtime is 3 hours 31 minutes, down from 3 hours 43 minutes (ignoring fan club credits)
Two file options (both SDR with English subtitles and 7.1 AAC audio):
Upscaled 4K 10-bit h265 plus lossless Dolby TrueHD 7.1 audio at 31gb
HD h264 at 7gb (for compatibility and a smaller download)
Full change list below!
As with Fellowship and Return of the King, this edit is really about selectively editing out some of the least popular moments from the film, mostly to remove egregious book inaccuracies but also to cut pieces that haven't stood the test of time. Above are the most sweeping alterations, new to this version of the edit. It's a beloved film series, just slightly trimmed for modern sensibilities.
See how I edited so Frodo doesn't visibly show the ring to the ring wraith: https://youtu.be/wLY5m7MQbPw
As with the Less Extended edits of The Hobbit and Return of the King, I was able to take the extended editions of the 2020s remastered Blu Ray and the release from a decade prior. This allowed me to pick and choose the visual presentation scene by scene and occasionally shot by shot. Flashbacks in particular were significantly altered in the remaster, so those have all been reverted to the original release's color. I also favored the original color for Edoras interiors while under Wormtongue's influence, scenes with heavy comp work (as the additional film grain and slightly less sharp image hides CG better), and some of the climax battle scenes at daylight, as the remaster made everything overly yellow. But overall, the remastered visuals are a welcome improvement to clarity and contrast, particular for later scenes in Rohan and during the night portions for the battle of Helm's Deep.
Check out how I removed the "cloak rock" sequence that was never quite convincing: https://youtu.be/6Lmtkb2wtE4
Regarding Helm's Deep and the removal of elves - while there are no visible elf ears or elf language (except a brief exchange between Legolas and Aragorn), viewers will have to accept some conspicuously well adorned archers, as it's not possible to excise them without removing much of the battle.
Regarding sound, I took the lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 track converted it to eight channels of 24-bit uncompressed LPCM audio. Once editing was complete, the 7.1 channel output was compressed with Dolby Media Encoder into a TrueHD MLP file, maintaining lossless quality from start to finish. An additional 7.1 AAC track was created for compatibility and smaller download size with the HD version.
The Lord of the Rings - The Two Towers (Slightly Less Extended Edition) detailed changes:
At 4 minutes - Added fan edit title
At 18 minutes - Cut Gimli falling, now it appears he's getting up from sitting
At 27 minutes - Cut Gimli "just keep breathing" line
At 51 minutes - Cut Gimli's line about squirrel droppings
At 1:04 - Cut Sam falling and fake looking cloak rock
At 1:07 - Cut Merry & Pippin tall water sequence
At 1:22 - Cut extended Theodred funeral; restored the more tragic theatrical scene
At 1:25 - Cut Aragorn questioning Theoden's decision + Gimli burping during tense scene
At 1:43 - Cut Gimli's line declining soup
At 1:44 - Recut Eowyn offering Aragorn soup (no more disgust, just her asking his age)
At 1:45 - Moved Arwen dream sequence
At 1:46 - Cut Arwen breakup scene from flashback (kept Elrond exchange)
At 1:47 - Repurposed Arwen dream as continued flashback
At 2:38 - Cut Gimli joke about chain mail not fitting AND cut elf army arrival
From here on: cut Haldir + all Elvish battle dialog (except between Legolas and Aragorn)
At 2:41 - Cut anachronistic use of "fire" to release a volley of arrows
At 2:43 - Cut Wilhelm scream shot
At 2:48 - Cut Legolas shield slide sequence
At 3:09 - Recut Frodo facing the Nazgul fell beast so he never visibly offers the ring
At 3:14 - Cut Gimli anachronistic line about nervous system
At 3:15 - Cut Merry & Pippin lines about "back to normal" (regarding tall water height)
At 3:16 - Cut joke about Treebeard's relatives being pipe leaf
At 3:31 - Cut fan club credits

