r/fromsoftware • u/spectralblade352 • 1h ago
DISCUSSION The Soulsborne genre need a lot of innovation and improvements to keep up (read description)
Now, before any of y’all get me wrong, the Souls genre is my favorite, and Elden Ring is my favorite game of all time. I have hundreds of hours across every Souls game from DS1 to Elden Ring and even Nightreign. Anyways, the release of great titles recently like GTA VI and Zelda has gotten me wondering about the direction of the genre.
I think that the Souls games are incredible, but I do feel like they are stagnating a bit. There are certain things that I feel must be fixed to positively move the series and even the industry forward, just as ER did as one of the greatest video games of all time. There are a lot of things that can be borrowed and take inspire from GTA VI, which I think is one of the greatest games of all times and moves the industry forward, for example:
- Heavy emphasis on characters and relationships: not a silent protagonist that does nothing and has no personality, but one with dialogue, even voice acting. I want to see him interact with other characters more, instead of just “listening” to others.
- Interacting with the world more: finding points of interest, maybe a side mission, instead of just free roaming.
- More side content, better quests, and a way to keep track of what you’re doing and such (I’m not saying handhold me, but at least give me a damn quest log and don’t fail a quest if I go from point A to B)
- Better storytelling: I know, it’s part of the Souls charm and modus operandi to be cryptic and sparse in the storytelling, relying on visual storytelling from the world, dialogue, item descriptions, etc. but I do feel that sometimes it really doesn’t work. They did their best with ER, but there are still “gaps” and unexplained things that might be better off with better, more direct storytelling. VI showed the scope that can be taken.
- Better dialogue and personality, such as choosing what to say and such, being able to take specific actions at specific times such as executing a character or sparing them, etc. being able to build friendships with specific characters as well.
- More “grounded” things to do? Go check up on a character, take care of yourself and your weapons, etc.
- Better graphics, and I’m not saying better “eye-candy” or visuals (because ER does it best), but better raw graphics such as lip-synching, texture detail, etc.
- 8 Combat: not much to add and change here tbh, but I would love to see more variations of weapons: instead of 15+ greatswords where all have the same moveset, give me a bit more variation such as choosing with variation to use (the “normal” one or the “banished knight’s” one for example). Trick weapons from Bloodborne are a good idea to return to.
These are some of the points I thought I’d share. I do believe there should be a lot of changes over the board for Souls to move forward and not stagnate. Lastly, sorry for the bad English.
