Edit: Apparently, r/India cannot have a reasonable, fact-based, non-pejorative back and forth and must instantly resort to slurs. That's pathetic. Please grow up and learn to talk like adults.
I'd like to start off by saying that this is probably a minority opinion. And I actively welcome your disagreement.
India has achieved remarkable things in the time it has been free. The space program, led by ISRO, is one of the finest in the world, and that at a fraction of the cost of other comparable space programs. The infrastructure growth has been remarkable. And it is not a trivial achievement that India became nuclear capable without begging, borrowing or stealing the technology needed for it. I'm starting off with the accomplishments because I want to make a hard pivot to the road ahead: The AI race.
It is unlike any of the other things that India has competed in (and often won with its dignity intact). I submit that AI is a problem looking for a solution. When ISRO engineers transported rocket parts on a bicycle and bullock carts, the end goal was clear. India wanted space sovereignty. We could draw a clear line under the project and call it mission accomplished. AI is not like this: The first question we must ask is - when is it mission accomplished? When we have the first frontier model? Where do we draw the line and say, "This suffices"? This is the first inherent danger of entering this race - it is a race without a finishing tape. This means, we must be extremely cautious about diverting sparse resources into something that may not ultimately serve the people.
Second, let us, for a moment, say, that we have decided to enter this race in earnest. The question then becomes: Do we have everything we need? Can we stay in the race for the long haul? Because, as I said, this is a race without a finish tape. Can we commit hundreds of billions of rupees for decades into maintaining the edge, which we hypothetically achieve? New models become old in months. It is not a a nuclear warhead you can store in a warehouse somewhere safely for decades to come with just maintenance. You need to constantly up the game. Can we do that? Do we have the resources for it? I submit we don't. We lack the infrastructure for it. We also lack the technology for it. And there is zero shame in admitting it, because only a sliver of the top 1% of countries possess this.
I call your attention to the ailing project of Kaveri, the indigenous jet engine, which still has not taken off - pun intended. Developing a jet engine requires extraordinary institutional knowledge in material sciences we don't have. The project is plagued by technical deficiencies. And again, there is zero shame in admitting that. But I believe that Kaveri still is a success. Why? We have a working engine. It's just not ready for deployment. We can fix it. We can develop the knowledge necessary, or borrow it.
AI provides a stark contrast for this: There are increasingly complex tiers of problems. The first complexity is Infrastructure. AI requires huge data centres. Where are we going to put them? Have you ever visited a data centre. I have. They're monsters. And people in the towns where they exist hate them with a vengeance. If you are happy with inflicting this upon another city, you should be willing to have it put in your town, next to your place. I certainly don't want a data centre in my town, even less, my neighbourhood.
But let us say, you've found the ideal spot for a data centre: We need to feed this monster with electricity. Not just today. For years, and years, and years. Is it worth it? I am not convinced it is.
Fine, we've found an infinite supply of free electricity, we need to cool the data centre down. Water is not infinite. Saline water is unusable. Where are going to find the water for this?
Okay, we've found both electricity and water, and space for data centres, we still haven't even crossed the threshold. We still need the chips. They cost billions, and we don't make them. Not only do we not make them, we don't even the designs for them. There are very, very few fabricators. TMSC is one of the main ones. Can we just buy the lithography machines? They're not cheap either. ASML in Netherlands make them. And I am not sure they'll even sell us one that easily. But let us say, hypothetically:
We have the designs, we have the lithography machines, we can now manufacture them. And this is still not enough. Getting it right is extremely difficult. More difficult than a thousand jet engines. Intel tried to get into fabrication - you know the company that designed the first commercial single-chip microprocessor? It failed SPECTACULARLY, with the CEO, Pat Gelsinger, leaving. But let us say, hypothetically, we get it right. We STILL have not got a working LLM on our hands!
(I want to add. Running lithography machines puts extraordinary strain on the power grid. Only recently Okinawa University in Japan found a slightly more efficient way of doing it. And this is yet to be commercialised. Fabrication plants take years to set up and become commercially viable. Meanwhile, they suck money, effort and resources. And this is just the first step.)
We only have the foundations. We still have to train our LLMs, which, are not easy. ChatGPT did not sprout overnight. Neither did GLM models of Z.ai. ChatGPT emerged from Google's foundational research. GLM emerged from Tsinghua University's Knowledge Engineering Group (KEG) and computer science research, building on projects like AMiner. Do we have the academic foundations for this.
I humbly submit we don't.
But let us say, we figure it all out. This still does not guarantee long term success. Because AI depends heavily on stability of government. A new government pulling the plug on a project means billions of rupees going to waste. And let me remind you again: There is no finishing tape in sight.
We're still not sure how AI is going to benefit ordinary, middle-class working families - the bulk of India's population. We'd be astute and prudent to sit this out entirely and avoid a catastrophic mistake.