For one of the biggest stages of the year, it's such a buzzkill to see just how much lipsyncing goes on in front of such a massive live audience and an even larger online audience.
The only artists I would say genuinely delivered proper live performances throughout the night were Treasure, Babymonster, and CL. A big shoutout to Treasure btw. I don't even listen to them that much, but their rapline brought so much energy to the stage. You could tell they're very accustomed to performing live. They were easily the most impressive group of Day 1. All three artists demonstrated how to give a good live performance using a backtrack.
ADP also delivered a decent live performance, although I wouldn't put them on the same level as the three acts mentioned above.
Now, onto the disappointing performances.
RESCENE – They lipsynced completely from start to finish for both WITH and Love Attack. The only times we actually heard their voices were when Minami shouted, "What's up, MAMA! You ready for this?", during the "one, two, three, four" countdown, and when they yelled, "Kyocera, make some noise!" A big disappointment overall. Their performance did very little to get me hyped.
H2H – They lipsynced to a standard backing track for Iconic Heart. There was a mix of live vocals and lipsyncing during RUDE!, although you could only hear their voices somewhat clearly during the rap/talk-singing section.
ILLIT – You could tell a lot of resources went into their stage, from all the elaborate props to the sheer number of backup dancers. There was practically an army of them out there. Unfortunately, the visual spectacle didn't translate into an equally impressive performance because they lipsynced completely from start to finish for both It's Me and You're Under Arrest. Really disappointing.
Tuide – The rookie group only had about two minutes on stage, and they lipsynced their entire debut song.
ENHYPEN – The AR was way too loud, but you could at least hear some of their vocals during I Want You. They lipsynced the entirety of Big Girls Don't Cry, while their vocals were drowned out for roughly 95% of Bloody Paradise. There were only occasional moments when you could make out a word here and there.
NCT WISH – They lipsynced both songs, with the exception of the rap section during I SPY, where they actually projected their voices for a few seconds.
Groups like Modyssey and ALD1 were quite disappointing as well.
To sum things up, all these backup dancers, dance breaks, and stage props did absolutely nothing for me. I genuinely think more groups on weekly music shows sing live than these groups did on some of the biggest stages of the year.
Some groups lipsynced from start to finish, others only rapped live for a few seconds, and some barely did anything beyond shouting to hype up the crowd. And no, I'm not naive enough to assume a performance was live just because I heard a few shouts here and there. At the end of the day, all the elaborate staging in the world means very little if the artists themselves aren't actually performing. I'd much rather watch a stripped down stage with live vocals than a flashy production where the artists barely sing, if at all. MAMA Day 1 was incredibly boring to watch.