r/magicTCG • • 6h ago

Scheduled Thread Daily Questions Thread - Ask All Your Magic Related Questions Here!

4 Upvotes

This is a place for asking simple questions that might not deserve their own thread. For example, if you have a question about a rules interaction, want sleeve and accessory recommendations, or suggestions for your new deck, then this is the place for you.

We encourage that you post any questions that you may have concerning Magic the Gathering here rather than make a separate thread for each question, though for now we won't require that you do so.

Rules Questions

Rules questions and interactions are allowed to be posted here, but if you need an answer quickly it may be best to use a dedicated resource like the 24/7 Magic the Gathering Rules Chat.

Deckbuilding Questions

If you're trying to get help with a deck, it is recommended that you post your decklist to a deckbuilding website so that it is easier to view. Some popular sites are Aetherhub, Archidekt, Deckbox, Deckstats, Moxfield, MTGGoldfish, and TappedOut.

Additionally, please include some description of what you are trying to accomplish. Don't just give us a decklist with no explanation, and don't ask extremely vague questions such as "what cards should I add to my deck to make it better?", because it's hard to give good advice in those cases. Let us know details, the more the better. Are you building with a particular strategy or theme in mind? Are there any non-obvious combo lines or synergies that people should be aware of? Are you struggling with a particular matchup, or are you finding yourself missing consistency in an important area, and need some help specifically for it? Let us know.

Commonly Asked Questions

I opened a card from a different set in my booster pack, is this unusual?

Don't worry, this is completely normal. If you opened a set booster, you have a small chance of obtaining a bonus card from a previous set. This is an extra card that does not replace any of the other cards in your pack, and is from a curated set of past hits that Wizards of the Coast has selected, which they call "The List".

You can view the contents of The List on Wizards of the Coast's official website. For example, the contents of The List for Streets of New Capenna boosters can be found here.

My foil card has a shooting start symbol over the bottom left. I can't find anything about it online.

All old-bordered foils have the shooting star symbol. Most sites that display card images just overlay a generic foil graphic over all foil cards, which doesn't include the shooting star. Your card is normal.


r/magicTCG • • 40m ago

General Discussion Looking for Community in germany

3 Upvotes

Hello, i live in western germany and recently the only store i could actually reach more actively closed its doors permanently. I was trying to find any other community in my area but so far to no avail. So i wanted to ask if anyone here knows of any groups or servers or whatever that are situated in germany and preferably in the western regions.

I only recently started working on a commander deck which i have never played before but fear i might never get the chance to do so now as i am tied to public transport and dont really know anyone around my area who plays. So if anyone has any info that would be greatly appreciated :D


r/magicTCG • • 1h ago

Looking for Advice Reaper King Commander Deck Help

Thumbnail
moxfield.com
2 Upvotes

Looking for some advice on my reaper king deck. I usually play in bracket 3-4 pods and it does decent but def looking for some input. Theres def times I just get focused and can’t do much to stop it. Majority of time my card draw is fine But more is always nice. If anyone has any recommendations or general thoughts on artifact or reaper king decks it would be appreciated. Sometimes I just feel too slow and don’t do enough before game is over. Thank you.


r/magicTCG • • 1h ago

Looking for Advice In need of STURDY Deck Case

2 Upvotes

As the title implies, I am in need of a STURDY Deck Case, the bigger, the better. I tried using the Gamegenic ones, as they fit the Ultra Pro Guild deck boxes, but the bottom eventually gave out, and I am tired of reglueing it. I then upgraded to a CavernHold Fortress, which was pretty great, but over time the shoulder strap gave out and ripped off. I would love to hear any recommendations!

The requirement is that it needs to fit an Ultra Pro alcove deckbox, as I have over 15 of them.


r/magicTCG • • 2h ago

General Discussion Nauctis 'sunken treasure' speculation

Post image
282 Upvotes

One of the details from the Nauctis previews was that there will be 20 different 'sunken treasures' cards available as box toppers. We know these will all be Artifact cards and that 15 will be reprints and 5 will be new. So far only one reprint has been revealed, Crucible of Worlds. What else do you think will be in those 15 reprints?


r/magicTCG • • 4h ago

Looking for Advice Arena Phyrexian Unlife combo deck build

Post image
10 Upvotes

I love the concept of this deck since it came out with [nine lives] it’s been a while since I played MTGA and now getting back on. Wasn’t sure if my deck is outdated.

Are there any new enchantments or cards that are a must have? I mainly play Bo1 and want to get to higher ranked with this deck. Any thoughts?

Any help would be appreciated. I’m not good at building decks and don’t have the time to play test as much as I want.


r/magicTCG • • 4h ago

General Discussion Recommendations for App to search Magic Rules and Cards

0 Upvotes

Up until today I used the MTG Guide app on iOS, which had a locally stored text database of all cards, Comprehensive Rules, MTR, and IPG. It was a useful tool for judging and answering rules questions or getting card text because it only required internet to pull card images, so I could use it with poor or no service

The app switched to a subscription model a while back, but still worked as long as it wasn’t updated. I accidentally turned on updates after upgrading my phone and now can’t install the older version of the app, so I’m now locked out of what I had paid for

Are there any other apps on iOS that have similar functions, especially locally storing card and rules text?


r/magicTCG • • 6h ago

Looking for Advice Advice for finding a Burger King Deckbox while in Italy.

0 Upvotes

As the title implies I will be going to Milano soon and would really like to pick a BK deckbox while there but I read that they can be somewhat hard to find as scalpers have bought out a lot of stores as soon as the promotion started.

Italians and tourists who were in Italy, what were your experiences like?

Is there a way to check if a store has it without having to call every single Burger King in the city individually?

Thank you all in advance.


r/magicTCG • • 7h ago

General Discussion Using chess pieces for remembering the buffs

25 Upvotes

We just started playing Magic with my daughter. We just had the "Magic: The Gathering Foundations - Beginner Box" in a long train trip which was the cheapest option which had many archetypes that we can blend(I regret spending 100 dollars to 2 commander decks before that box as beginners.)

Buffs were getting a bit out of hand and we did not had too much space to write.

We used chess pieces on top of buffed creatures. +2 buff was 2 pawns of buffed creature. +3 buff was a bishop, +5 buff was rook.

I am sure you guys have better ways remember guys but we being chess fans that felt so good mix to hobbies we liked. Is this a well known trick or is there anything better when you can not write buffs?


r/magicTCG • • 8h ago

Looking for Advice Best Marker/Pen for a lasting signature?

37 Upvotes

TL;DR: I want to have a foil card signed and would like to ensure it won't fade/be accidentally scratched off. Are there pens/markers better than others for this purpose?

Long Story:

My mom is losing her battle against cancer. She came up with the idea of gifting me an advent calendar with magic cards and asked me to buy cards to fill the calendar with (she wanted to surprise me at first but she doesn't know much about MtG so she had to ask me).

I had the Idea of not just buying random cards but have all of the cards in the advent calendar be part of a commander deck and the final card is the commander.

I also wanted the commander to represent her and have her sign the card as a keepsake/tribute to her.

She also helped me decide the commander based on which artwork she liked.

Because I want the signature to last I wanted to ask if there are pens/markers that are maybe better than others/ensure the signature won't fade/be scratched etc... on a foil card (I also bought a non-foil version of the commander in case the effect won't be readable)

Thank you for reading.


r/magicTCG • • 10h ago

Looking for Advice Looking for some fresh eyes on Ms. Bumbleflower!

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I’ve been working on putting together a Ms. Bumbleflower deck, but I've hit a bit of a wall. I tried building it mostly out of cards I already own, so it's a bit of a collection-built list right now, and I could use some direction, and suggestions on how to smooth it out.
Since I am trying to work with what's in my binder, my focus feels a little all over the place. I definitely want to lean into her strengths (drawing cards, placing +1/+1 counters, and using flash/instant-speed spells on other player’s turns), and I’m trying to hit a balance with getting value from my commander.

Link (EDIT FIXED IT): https://moxfield.com/decks/CRV43vSvOkWcHmfH44GCQg

What I need help with:
Do I have enough draw and ramp to hit that second spell trigger on turns?
I’ve narrowed down my list, but I still need to axe 2 more cards.
If there are any cheap cards that I should run then let me know!
Any advice would be appreciated. Thanks!


r/magicTCG • • 11h ago

General Discussion Card storage question -3D printing

1 Upvotes

Does anyone have any recommendations for 3d prints for card storage?

I tried "Modular TCG Card Storage" by Jimpf2000 on makerworld. I really like the drawer system and modularity but I found it to be a bit too tight. Im looking for something that fits double sleeved cards and toploaders if possible.

I appreciate any recomendations.


r/magicTCG • • 14h ago

Rules/Rules Question Is Buckys ability a reflexive ability that can be responded to after say, going to put swiftwood boots on him?

Post image
22 Upvotes

As title says, do opponents have a window to respond to Winter Soldiers equip as part of the reanimation ability? I am under the impression that it is not a reflexive ability that cant be responded to before he gains hexproof from the boots. Judges pls discuss!

Thanks you!


r/magicTCG • • 15h ago

General Discussion The other spirit guides?

0 Upvotes

What do you think the other spirit guide creatures could be? White is probably angelic, blue maybe merfolk? But what would a black spirit guide be? Thoughts on any multi color one? Just curious on people’s thought!


r/magicTCG • • 15h ago

General Discussion Does anybody else think Magic's early success is owed in part to coming on the heels of the pog craze?

0 Upvotes

I was looking at a thread on r/AskHistorians https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/s/jPFR5bGRUR

about what factors led to Magic's success and I immediately thought of pogs. Pogs were intensely popular just before Magic and are the only other thing in the early 90s I can think of that combined a collectible aspect with a playable aspect. In my experience all the kids that were super into pogs were the same kids that were super into Magic. I think it also helped that the pogs players were getting older and would want a more complex and strategic, and less childish, game.

What do people think?


r/magicTCG • • 16h ago

Looking for Advice Looking for Deck Building Advice

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I'm a beginner Magic player who is looking forward to creating an affordable + aesthetic deck using Hylda of the Icy Crown as my commander. For all cards, I'm going for an icy/winter/snow aesthetic only. How does my deck look so far? I haven't tested it out yet and am looking for advice. I play casually with one other person and don't want it to be so strong that they don't have a chance.

As I said, I'm very new, so please be nice! Thank you!

Deck: https://moxfield.com/decks/OAKMeY1HdUSIDnEAzLKShA


r/magicTCG • • 17h ago

General Discussion Gift ideas

6 Upvotes

I don’t know if this is allowed but my husband is into playing magic and I’d love to get him a good gift this year. In the past I have gotten tcg gift cards, a custom magic card, and a nice deck box. I don’t know much about it so not sure where to go from here. He plays commander.

Any suggestions? My budget is 200. Thank you so much for helping me! I love that he has something he is so into and I want to make sure to celebrate that for him.


r/magicTCG • • 18h ago

Looking for Advice Can't find a deck I enjoyed playing against

9 Upvotes

I was in a match in mtga a couple hours ago, against a deck that I didn't know of and that I loved from the very first minute, sadly I couldn't find it on any websites I checked, and I wasn't smart enough to take a pic of the battlefield after the match, but since it played some pretty unique cards I hope someone can help me with this. This are a few of the cards my opponent played: Progenitus, Vaultborn Tyrant, Oko the Ringleader, the Walls of Ba Sing Se, Ancient Adamantoise. From my understanding, my opponent was trying to put creatures from his hand into the battlefield, I know that this is either not enough or it's the most well known deck ever, but I'm kinda new and I didn't know where to look for it honestly. Sincere gratitude to whoever will help me.


r/magicTCG • • 19h ago

Deck Discussion You either die a hero or live long enough to see yourself become the villain - Commander (Oloro, Ageless Ascetic)

Thumbnail
moxfield.com
0 Upvotes

r/magicTCG • • 19h ago

Official Competitive Magic Colluding players at RCQ event

89 Upvotes

Today, I attended an RCQ event with a relatively small turnout of 11 players. Despite the smaller attendance, it was still a competitive qualifying event.

Of the 11 players, five traveled together and were friends or family members. Two of those five players had already earned their Regional Championship invites.

Throughout the event, there appeared to be questionable conduct involving members of this group. Players were submitting intentional draws as 0-0 to avoid accumulating game losses. Additionally, in at least one round, a player who had already secured an RC invite conceded the round to another member of their group, effectively giving them a round win.

By the fifth round, the top four consisted of three players from that same group and one additional player who was not part of the group but had also already earned an RC invite. All four players intentionally drew their matches at 0-0.

While I understand that intentional draws and concessions can be part of competitive Magic, the circumstances surrounding this event raise serious concerns about the integrity of the competition. When players who are traveling and playing together appear to be coordinating results, particularly when some have already secured their invites, it creates an unfair environment for everyone else who is genuinely competing for a qualifying spot.

RCQs should provide a fair and competitive environment for all participants. I believe this situation deserves attention and a closer look to ensure the integrity of these events is being upheld.


r/magicTCG • • 19h ago

Humour Magic Boomer Waxes Nostalgic About Quality Set That Came Out 40 Days Ago

Thumbnail
commandersherald.com
634 Upvotes

r/magicTCG • • 19h ago

Looking for Advice Playing with Avatar beginner box

2 Upvotes

I got the Avatar beginner box this week. I thought it was like the same concept as the Lord of The Rings starter set and could play them against each other and not always have Aragorn vs Sauron, but also have Aang VS Sauron. Now I found out the decks are really different and avatar works with jump decks.

Now my question, are there decks that use the cards from the Avatar box, that I can play against my LOTR set?


r/magicTCG • • 22h ago

Looking for Advice Helping stepdaughter learn to play.

14 Upvotes

My stepdaughter has recently started learning to play Magic with her grandfather, my father-in-law. They play a couple times a week.

I think this is great and I really wanna help foster her interest in growth in the game. Unfortunately, I have never played the game so I do not know where to begin.

Any advice on where to locate condensed strategy guides, tips for playing, and especially recommendations for cards for building her own deck is greatly appreciated.

Thank you in advance for all your replies.


r/magicTCG • • 23h ago

General Discussion Looking to play some fun Commander around Amsterdam/Amstelveen in the Netherlands

1 Upvotes

Hi there! After not playing MTG for a few decades (mostly because of money and a lack of friends that like these kinds of games), since the beginning of the year I have been able to finally start picking up this awesome game again. I've bought a handful of pre-cons, had a ton of fun tinkering them to make them stronger and am working on building my own few commander decks as well.

While this has already been fun, I am still severely lacking people to play with! I know some lgs host commander nights every now and then and I have been to one in Delft recently, which was fun! It is however timeconsuming to have to travel relatively far each time.

Therefore I'm trying to find MTG enthousiasts that want to play commander near Amstelveen (where I live) or Amsterdam (or anything close), mostly playing bracket 2 or 3. I have a spacious apartment where I can easily host a nice commander night for 4 people and would love to do that!

Or maybe you're down a person in your commander group and are looking for an extra player? Please let me know!

I really hope there's a few people here that seek something similar like me or have space in their commander group. I'd love to meet you and see if playing this awesome game together is as much fun as it can be! DM me if you're interested!