In recent months, there have been an influx of proofs that seem to be technically correct, but are lengthy and difficult to comprehend due to you-know-what techniques.
The formal verification systems mostly utilize some notion of proof-irrelevance. A proposition is either proven or it's not and that's it, there's nothing more to look at.
But this is contrary to intuition and taste of mathematicians, who mostly have clear preference and even a somewhat of a consensus for what makes a proof elegant, valuable, or insightful besides it being just a mechanistically correct argument.
But to my knowledge, these notions themselves haven't been made formal, although it seems like they could be: A simple approach could be to measure the size of a derivation graph in a formal logic system that goes from the axioms to the theorem and try to minimize its size. This is not a very polished definition, perhaps a much better one could be proposed, but take it as some sort of baseline, or just one optimization criterion among many.
Then we could ask for not only "a proof" but for "the proof" and have a way to motivate alternative proof techniques to established theorems as truly novel contributions within a rigorous framework (in the sense that showing a proof is better according to a criterion than another proof or showing that it's the best one would be theorems on its own)
Maybe this hasn't really been practically possible until recently and that's why it hasn't been done, but I think some of these limitations are disappearing.
What are your thoughts?