r/math • • 9h ago

[Rant] This is just a sad time.

0 Upvotes

My reddit feed is a series of "Well, now GRH has been solved, what's next?" and "What is this GRH that stochastic parrots have solved" and related questions that claim "GRH is solved".

F*ck those companies and their sleazy marketing campaing, and screw education systems that couldn't (or even didn't care to) teach us the HUGE difference between a claim and what it takes to verify it, not only "average joe" have zero awareness of this distinction, but for god sake even some "educated" folks with math degree couldn't just keep their mouth shut and learn more about how much effort and time it takes to verify such matters. What's wrong with us?

Excuse the rant but I just feel so angry and disgusted.


r/math • • 18h ago

LLMs/AI AI In Mathematics: November 21, 2026

53 Upvotes

This recurring thread will be for discussion of AI in mathematics. This includes, but is not limited to, the following:

  • informal announcements of AI-assisted discoveries, such as those not yet published in a peer-reviewed journal, or not uploaded as a paper to arXiv;
  • informal announcements of discoveries related to AI architecture (if relevant to mathematics);
  • discussion of such announcements, such as proof breakdowns or other opinion pieces;
  • discussion of the impact of AI in mathematics in general.

AI-assisted mathematical papers published in peer-reviewed journals or as arXiv preprints may be submitted as their own posts.

Please keep in mind rules 1 and 6 of our subreddit.


r/math • • 12h ago

Could we rigorously define, study and optimize some notion of proof "elegance" or "simplicity"?

10 Upvotes

In recent months, there have been an influx of proofs that seem to be technically correct, but are lengthy and difficult to comprehend due to you-know-what techniques.

The formal verification systems mostly utilize some notion of proof-irrelevance. A proposition is either proven or it's not and that's it, there's nothing more to look at.

But this is contrary to intuition and taste of mathematicians, who mostly have clear preference and even a somewhat of a consensus for what makes a proof elegant, valuable, or insightful besides it being just a mechanistically correct argument.

But to my knowledge, these notions themselves haven't been made formal, although it seems like they could be: A simple approach could be to measure the size of a derivation graph in a formal logic system that goes from the axioms to the theorem and try to minimize its size. This is not a very polished definition, perhaps a much better one could be proposed, but take it as some sort of baseline, or just one optimization criterion among many.

Then we could ask for not only "a proof" but for "the proof" and have a way to motivate alternative proof techniques to established theorems as truly novel contributions within a rigorous framework (in the sense that showing a proof is better according to a criterion than another proof or showing that it's the best one would be theorems on its own)

Maybe this hasn't really been practically possible until recently and that's why it hasn't been done, but I think some of these limitations are disappearing.

What are your thoughts?


r/math • • 31m ago

Masullo on the Riemann Hypothesis - by John Baez

Thumbnail johncarlosbaez.wordpress.com
33 Upvotes

r/math • • 8h ago

Does the Riemann hypothesis for motivic L-functions imply the Hodge conjecture and Birch and Swinnerton-Dyer conjecture?

34 Upvotes

Looking over the recent discussion around the claimed Anthropic proof of the generalized Riemann hypothesis for Dirichlet L-functions, I was wondering about other conjectures that rely on the Riemann hypothesis being true. Considering that Hodge and BSD both concern cohomologies of algebraic varieties, and algebraic motives give a unified framework for the cohomologies of algebraic varieties, does the Riemann hypothesis for motivic L-functions provide the framework for answering these other Millenium Prize problems? This is not my area of expertise so I only have a partial understanding of the proof and how these other conjectures are formulated so I thought I’d ask the community here.


r/math • • 16h ago

"Many times already men have thought that they had solved all the problems" - Henri Poincaré

263 Upvotes

There are too many good quotes in the essay The future of Mathematics by Henri Poincaré.

Highly recommend


r/math • • 15h ago

What perspective are grad students taking towards research today?

137 Upvotes

With the recent developments in RH and NS, I am not sure how I, as a grad student, should be making use of AI. I feel like there are so many different lines of thought, each suggesting something different,

  1. If I treat math as a way to see new results: this tells me to use AI as a theorem producer: ask it a question and help refine its output until it produces a full proof.
  2. If I treat math as a way to develop myself as a researcher, in the traditional sense (developing questions, thinking of answers independently or under some sort of supervision, but not to the point of handholding), this tells me to use AI only to the extent that i might ask questions to my advisor, but nothing more.
  3. If I treat math as a vocation, in the sense of I need to get many papers out so I appear hireable, this tells me to use AI (as long as I’m understanding the output well)

I’ve heard a lot about how professors are talking about using AI, many of whom believe it should form part one’s tools (or at least will soon enough). Some people think mathematicians will simply be interpreting outputs given to us by AI oracles.

But professors are in a different boat than us grad students, who also are sort of “learning the ropes”. But this isn’t so simple, since we are also under pressure of publishing more important results, which are definitely made easier with AI.

So, to the grad students on this sub (and anyone else who might have an opinion on this, actually), how are you (or should you be) thinking about your role as a grad student these days, and what it means for how you do math on a daily basis with or without AI?


r/math • • 12h ago

Is there a nice generalisation of weight of a modular form to automorphic forms on adellic points of a reductive group?

17 Upvotes

Hi

I have quite a specific question about generalising (Siegel) modular forms to adellic automorphic forms that I‘ve been wondering about for a while.

Say we have G=Sp_2r the symplectic group of genus r, and take it’s points in the Adeles G(A), then let K be the maximal compact subgroup of G(A). For an automorphic form f:G(A)->C, by definition and some properties of profinite groups, if we look at the non Archimedean places, we are guaranteed an open compact subgroup of K(A_f) that leaves f invariant by right translation. This in some sense generalises the level of a modular form on H^r.

My question is about the weight. When we look at the Archimedean place, G(R), noting that K(R) acts by right translation on automorphic forms, by Peter Weyl theorem we can decompose the right regular representation into isotypic components. In the case r=1, G=SL_2 and K(R)=So(2) is abelian, meaning the isotypic components are dim 1 characters. If an automorphic form lives in one of these isotypic components, and the character has positive integer exponent (i.e rho(k(theta)= e^iktheta), we can recover a classical modular form of weight k and level determined by the open compact subgroup mentioned above.

I was wondering what happens when we don‘t have a positive integer exponent in the character, or if an Automorphic form lives in a sum of these isotypic components, what type of modular form on the hyperbolic plane can we recover? I assume in some of these cases we get non holomorphic modular forms, but don‘t know what happens otherwise.