r/Metaphysics • u/Nuker3252 • 6h ago
r/Metaphysics • u/jliat • Jan 14 '25
Meta Welcome to /r/metaphysics!
This sub-Reddit is for the discussion of Metaphysics, the academic study of fundamental questions. Metaphysics is one of the primary branches of Western Philosophy, also called 'First Philosophy' in its being "foundational".
If you are new to this subject please at minimum read through the WIKI and note: "In the 20th century, traditional metaphysics in general and idealism in particular faced various criticisms, which prompted new approaches to metaphysical inquiry."
See the reading list.
Science, religion, the occult or speculation about these. e.g. Quantum physics, other dimensions and pseudo science are not appropriate.
Please try to make substantive posts and pertinent replies.
Remember the human- be polite and respectful
r/Metaphysics • u/jliat • Mar 17 '26
Meta **WHAT IS METAPHYSICS?**
WHAT IS METAPHYSICS?
We are getting posts here which seem to propose new and potentially revolutionary answers to problems in physics. I think [as a moderator] it might be beneficial if we might discuss some parameters. This is not to say science can not be discussed, but can we using metaphysics solve such problems, are we then transgressing into another domain. As a moderator I would like guidance from the community.
"Metaphysics: explaining the fundamental nature of being and the world"
The interpretation of this and not the context is often the cause of confusion. [of Being qua being and not the nature of an atom, or a human brain...etc.]
Higgs, Einstein, Penrose, Feynman, Hawking are not / were not Philosophers or Metaphysicians, they are / were physicists. Modern physics uses mathematics- quite complex! - to build models which are tested against experimental data. The main scientific method.
The 'photon', wave / particle duality, quarks and strings, are all subjects /problems of physics NOT metaphysics? And to address these problems requires detailed understanding of the mathematics and the data, and in doing so one is NOT doing metaphysics?
"Ontological" means what? Ontology is the study in Philosophy / Metaphysics of being qua being, not the nature of the existence or being of things, atoms, quarks, strings, branes, flowers, plants, the human brain, religions.
atoms, quarks, strings, branes = physics, flowers, plants = botany, the human brain = neuroscience, religions = theology, comparative religion.
Lay ideas re physics / science will probably be rejected in subs like r/physics for good reasons, they lack the detailed knowledge of the subject and misuse technical scientific terms. Should they be allowed here?
The nature of things, matter and energy are subject of science. What 'Being' is prompts the what is "IS" question... of Metaphysics.
Ontology is the study / creation of what 'Being' is, not specific 'things'. Harman has a 'flat ontology'...etc. Heidegger has Dasein...Hegel... etc.
To be clear of the domain I think you can get an overview from A.W. Moore's 'The Evolution of Modern Metaphysics: Making Sense of Things.' It had good reviews.
"Part two is devoted to philosophers of the analytic tradition, and contains chapters on Frege, Wittgenstein, Carnap, Quine, Lewis, and Dummett. Part three is devoted to non-analytic philosophers, and contains chapters on Nietzsche, Bergson, Husserl, Heidegger, Collingwood, Derrida and Deleuze."
For first hand source material - https://www.stephenhicks.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/heideggerm-what-is-metaphysics.pdf
For a contemporary example, Graham Harman - Object-Oriented Ontology: A New Theory of Everything. (Pelican Books) 1 Mar. 2018
Examples in the Analytical tradition, 'Counterfactuals', 'On the Plurality of Worlds.' David Lewis. ??
One last point - it is an interesting point as to if this divide still exists. N.B. Badiou uses set theory as his ontology, his student Quentin Meillassoux likewise sees mathematics as fundamental, Ray Brassier in 'Nihil Unbound' has chapters on Wilfrid Sellars, Paul Churchland, as well as Adorno and Horkheimer, Badiou, Meillassoux, Laruelle, Heidegger, Deleuze, Nietzsche, Lyotard, Levinas and Freud. !!
On a personal note I began my interest in philosophy in the 1970s, within the Anglo American tradition, reading Russell's 'History of Western Philosophy' etc. and then took a degree. I still have my Wittgenstein Books, Tractatus, Investigations, Blue and Brown, Notebooks 1914-1916. Carnap's 'The Logical Syntax of Language' etc. However my interest moved to what was called 'Continental philosophy.'- see non-analytical above. I appreciate the desire of Carnap of ‘The Elimination of Metaphysics through the Logical Analysis of Language’ failed? I have dipped into Lewis et al.
With my best wishes.
r/Metaphysics • u/Efficient-Chapter967 • 7h ago
Mind / Subjective experience Paul Davies - Is Consciousness Fundamental?
Paul Davies argues that consciousness being awake and aware is not just an accident inside our heads, but a basic building block of the universe. Everything we know starts with our own awareness, and at the tiniest level of physics, reality settles on how to unfold at the moment someone observes it something other theories try to avoid by claiming everything splits into endless extra universes instead
r/Metaphysics • u/Brilliant_Order5128 • 1d ago
Causality What is Causation? | Episode 1511 | Closer To Truth
the video shows that causing something doesn't always work like pool balls bumping together, because even your invisible thoughts can make your body move, just like different piles of coins all work the same way as a dollar to buy a soda
r/Metaphysics • u/Zestyclose-Chance896 • 1d ago
Matter My question is this:How does matter come to behave in accordance with the laws of physics?
And to those who might take the easy way out by claiming that “the laws of physics are an existential property of matter,” I ask: even if that were the case, how does matter manifest these existential properties without expending any energy?
r/Metaphysics • u/thewastedworld • 1d ago
Mind / Subjective experience A Narrative Précis of Hegel’s Phenomenology
A guide for the perplexed, walking through the key moments of Hegel's Phenomenology of Spirit.
r/Metaphysics • u/Zvukadi77 • 1d ago
Mind / Subjective experience A structural case for why consciousness exists
reddit.comr/Metaphysics • u/Cryptoisthefuture-7 • 2d ago
Ontology Drawing the Line: How Reality Folds Itself into Being
reddit.comr/Metaphysics • u/DifferenceNo3979 • 3d ago
Axiology I've long held the belief that if we exist in and are a part of reality, and reality must be true to exist, then there is no possibility of falsehood or deceit.
If the universe has to be true and logical in order to exist and we are a part of it, then how is it possible for human beings to introduce deceit and falsehood into it? I'm mainly looking at the idea that all physical law must answer to a law of information. It seems like deceit, corruption, and falsehood would break reality's need for logical consistency unless the universe has a way of healing itself from said problems. That, or our reality is a simulation being run inside a universe where falsehood isn't possible. I assume someone has already thought about these questions and discovered some answers to them.
r/Metaphysics • u/Small-Pomelo-840 • 3d ago
Free will / Intention if being human implies human action, is there free will?
To clarify my question, if being human means there are no other choices but to do what a human does. Is there such a thing as free will?
r/Metaphysics • u/errrrrrrrridk • 3d ago
History of metaphysics What do y’all think of Thomism as a whole?
I’m just curious about your opinion on Aquinas interpretation on Aristotle’s metaphysics and the substance, causality, and act and potency aspect of it. What are your thoughts on the intellectual rigour that goes behind his five ways?
r/Metaphysics • u/rarnoldm7 • 3d ago
Time Environmental Responsibility Arises From Our Experience of Time
reddit.comr/Metaphysics • u/RagnartheConqueror • 4d ago
Ontology What are objections to Truth being seen as the absolute ontological foundation?
I have heard of some people who see Truth as what everything is in. What are objections and thoughts on this "Truth is the foundation" ideology. This has to do directly with ontology. I know Tarski could be used as an objection, but Tarski wasn't a metaphysician nor an ontologist.
So from an ontological perspective what are disputes to seeing 'Truth as the absolute'?
r/Metaphysics • u/Famous_Mobile_9814 • 4d ago
Theoretical physics What If Time Is Fundamental, or Is It an Emergent Effect of Motion and Change?
drive.google.comI've been developing a philosophical and physical hypothesis about the nature of time, and I'd genuinely like to hear criticism, counterarguments, and scientific perspectives.
The central idea:
What if time isn't an independently existing dimension or entity, but rather an effect of motion and change?
We usually describe motion as something that happens within time. But I started questioning whether this relationship could be reversed: perhaps motion and change are more fundamental, and what we call time is the measurable consequence of them.
My reasoning begins with a few questions:
\- If every physical process, motion, and change in the universe stopped completely, would time still exist?
\- Is time something independent of physical events, or does it emerge from the relationships between changing states?
\- Could cosmic expansion, physical motion, and irreversible processes be connected to what we experience as the passage and direction of time?
\- Is time fundamentally real, or is it a framework we use to describe change?
My current hypothesis is that motion and physical change are fundamental, while time may be an emergent effect associated with them.
I have also explored possible connections to cosmic expansion, thermodynamics, gravitational time dilation, and the concepts of past and future. I realize some of these interpretations may conflict with established physics, and that's precisely why I want constructive criticism.
I'm not claiming to have discovered a new scientific theory. This is an evolving hypothesis, and I'm trying to determine whether its core idea can be developed into a logically consistent and potentially testable framework.
My main question:
Could time fundamentally emerge from motion and change, rather than motion occurring within time?
I'd appreciate serious discussion, criticism, references, and alternative perspectives.
I've attached my current document outlining the hypothesis in more detail.
r/Metaphysics • u/RoxNaNa17 • 4d ago
Academic community Feedback Request: A parsimonious, timeless multiverse model without "branching" — where are the logical flaws?
Hi everyone, I wrote a short (5-page) deductive thought model on modal realism and would love your honest critique.
The core idea:
If multiple outcomes are physically possible under identical conditions and there is no arbitrary selection rule (Principle of Non-Selection), all permissible possibilities must be actualized. To avoid contradictions without needing an overarching "meta-time" for universe-splitting, realities don't branch—they coexist immediately and timelessly, each with its own immanent spacetime and zero exchange of energy or information.
It’s strictly a conceptual exercise in internal consistency, not empirical physics.
Full 5-page paper (free PDF, no login): https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24323166
Where do you see the biggest logical vulnerability in replacing temporal branching with timeless coexistence? Tear it apart—I’d love to hear your thoughts!
r/Metaphysics • u/OkFlight9571 • 5d ago
Ontology Theoretic(Liter)ally: What is(n't) nothing?
reddit.comr/Metaphysics • u/Sevdat • 5d ago
Nothing How to Create Something from Nothing and Calculate Everything that could have Ever Existed
philpapers.orgr/Metaphysics • u/PhilosophyTO • 5d ago
Axiology Kant’s "Religion Within the Bounds of Mere Reason" (1792) — An online reading & discussion group starting Nov 2026, all welcome
r/Metaphysics • u/Beneficial-Path-3176 • 5d ago
Cosmology Difficulty understanding parmenides and zenos paradox
So parmenides says that the world never really changes and everything stays the same, because for something to change there has to be something that doesnt change? And that doesnt make sense because nothingness or no change is not possible, and is absurd, because how can something come to place where there is nothing to give its place.
Then there is zenos paradox with the turtle and some really fast god or something. I dont really get it, how can the turtle be ahead of the fast god; i know that the turtle gets a leap ahead of the fast god, but i dont get why the turtle always is a little bit ahead of the fast guy. Is it something to do with infinite division or something?
Because the point that zenos is trying to illustrarte is that, a absolut physical movement is impossible, idk.
r/Metaphysics • u/rarnoldm7 • 5d ago
Time The Mystery of “Open” Time—Steering Through Randomness
reddit.comr/Metaphysics • u/______ri • 6d ago
Ontology Bottom up and top down | true space and true time
What we think the world is, is separated by whether two are not one by themselves alone.
That things are not exclusions of any at all is the view of simples and complexes. Any complex at all is positive and is a positive [addition] from multiple simples. And that simples x and y are not identical is by them alone.
On the other view, two are not one by themselves alone, and thus we need higher principles. This extends until there is the only reality that everything else is from, which is simply where two are not one by only one of them.
There is one flaw in the simples and complexes view though, even when it can explain almost anything if you are creative enough, it cannot explain extension itself. For if a simple is fundamentally extended, is it simple? For if it is not extended, then no "structure" from them is extended.
But the flaw of the other view is worse, for it is aesthetical. For such a world lacks that which is absolutely new. Is it new because it is not everything older? No, for it is new that it is not everything older. No matter what you say, everything is just pale shadows of the one.
So with bottom up you have no space (in the truest sense of extension), with top down you have no time (in this sense of that which is new).
r/Metaphysics • u/srameshr • 6d ago