r/mlb • • 2h ago

| Discussion If the Astros received a bigger punishment from the league, would fans dislike them less?

65 Upvotes

Offseason post as a non-Astros fan here. Let's suppose back in 2020, Rob Manfred decided to give harsher penalties to the Astros for their scandal instead of calling it a piece of metal. How would fans perceive the Astros? Would this ease the pain a bit?

I mean in the NBA, many teams effectively cheat the system, mainly with salary caps by signing under the table deals to get superstars for cheap. Yet those teams are forgiven by fans because they receive a harsh penalty (ie Kawhi Clippers).


r/mlb • • 22h ago

| News Gavin Sheets returns to Padres with $11 million, 3-year deal

Thumbnail
espn.com
53 Upvotes

r/mlb • • 3h ago

| History On This Day in Baseball History - November 22

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/mlb • • 5h ago

| Daily Thread [Daily Dugout + MLB Megathread] | MLB Offseason for Sunday, November 22, 2026

0 Upvotes

MLB Off-Season — 2026-27

Hot stove — last two weeks

Fri, Nov 20

  • RHP Jake Cousins elected free agency.
  • Colorado Rockies designated RHP Jimmy Herget for assignment.
  • LHP Andrew Saalfrank elected free agency.
  • RHP Garrett Hawkins elected free agency.
  • LHP Jared Simpson elected free agency.
  • LF Trevor Larnach elected free agency.
  • RHP Cole Sulser elected free agency.
  • RHP Michael Grove elected free agency.
  • RHP James Karinchak elected free agency.
  • LF Taylor Trammell elected free agency.
  • 3B Nolan Gorman elected free agency.
  • RHP Max Rajcic elected free agency.
  • RF David Fry elected free agency.
  • RHP José Buttó elected free agency.
  • LF Davis Schneider elected free agency.
  • RHP Fernando Cruz elected free agency.
  • RHP Luis Gil elected free agency.
  • SS Leo Balcazar elected free agency.
  • LHP Carson Palmquist elected free agency.
  • C Connor Wong elected free agency.
  • RHP Nick Mears elected free agency.
  • RHP Noah Murdock elected free agency.
  • RHP Moisés Chace elected free agency.
  • RHP Jimmy Herget elected free agency.
  • RF Luke Raley elected free agency.
  • RHP Rowan Wick elected free agency.
  • LHP Blake Walston elected free agency.
  • LHP Anthony Gose elected free agency.
  • LHP Jake Miller elected free agency.
  • SS Trey Sweeney elected free agency.
  • CF Matt Vierling elected free agency.
  • 3B Gabriel Arias elected free agency.
  • RHP Ethan Roberts elected free agency.
  • RF Matt Wallner elected free agency.
  • RHP Bailey Ober elected free agency.
  • LHP JP Sears elected free agency.
  • RHP Josiah Gray elected free agency.
  • 3B Brett Harris elected free agency.
  • C Hayden Senger elected free agency.
  • RF Bryan De La Cruz elected free agency.
  • RHP Andrew Hoffmann elected free agency.
  • 1B Christopher Morel elected free agency.
  • RHP Dylan Ross elected free agency.
  • CF Kyle Isbel elected free agency.
  • LF Victor Bericoto elected free agency.
  • Toronto Blue Jays traded RHP Chase Lee to Colorado Rockies for cash.
  • New York Mets claimed RHP Yunior Tur off waivers from Athletics.
  • Minnesota Twins traded 1B Royce Lewis to Los Angeles Dodgers for RHP Bobby Miller and C Francisco Espinoza.
  • San Francisco Giants traded SS Christian Koss to Tampa Bay Rays for RHP Cole Stokes.
  • Washington Nationals traded RHP Braxton Roxby to Chicago Cubs for cash.
  • New York Mets claimed RHP Gus Varland off waivers from Washington Nationals.
  • Arizona Diamondbacks traded LHP Luke Dotson and Future Considerations to Boston Red Sox for RHP Johan Oviedo.
  • Arizona Diamondbacks traded LHP Luke Dotson and Future Considerations to Boston Red Sox for RHP Johan Oviedo.
  • San Francisco Giants traded SS Christian Koss to Tampa Bay Rays for RHP Cole Stokes.
  • Minnesota Twins traded 1B Royce Lewis to Los Angeles Dodgers for RHP Bobby Miller and C Francisco Espinoza.
  • Minnesota Twins traded 1B Royce Lewis to Los Angeles Dodgers for RHP Bobby Miller and C Francisco Espinoza.
  • Chicago Cubs claimed C Joey Bart off waivers from Chicago White Sox.
  • Chicago White Sox traded RHP Jordan Leasure to Philadelphia Phillies for RHP Christian Coppola.
  • Chicago White Sox traded RHP Jordan Leasure to Philadelphia Phillies for RHP Christian Coppola.

Thu, Nov 19

  • Toronto Blue Jays designated RHP Chase Lee for assignment.

2027 season

Spring Training: first games February 19

Opening Day 2027: Thursday, March 25


Open this post on the Reddit app or new Reddit for the full hot stove, awards, leaders and the countdown.

Last updated: Nov 22, 6:00 AM EST


r/mlb • • 23h ago

| Discussion Alex Bregman and Matt Olson are low key building a HOF case

0 Upvotes

Before we start this sub has a strong take that 60 WAR is HOF level.

Bregman

will be 33 next year (his last prime year). He sites at 48.9 Career War.

Last year he finished 5.8 WAR. His defense alone gets him 2 WAR a year, he ahs above avg power (20+ hr a year) and usually .350+ OBP which is good for another 2 wins.

So he is likley 3 years away from 60 WAR. In those 3 years he may exceed 300 HR or be close to it. He will likely be at 1900 H. Similar numbers to evan lognoria who finished just shy of 60 WAr.

With his usual 4 war seaon he will have a higher career war then altuve by the end of next year.

I think he is an interesting case because Machado, Arenado, and Jram are considered locks at 3B. In comparison to them he fails the sniff test but he has a good shot at it.

Olson
will be 33 next year. Currently sits at 44.2 War.

Last year he had 4.4 WAr. his defense earns him a lot of WAR. He currently has 4 GG and is likley to just compile more as long as he plays.

He is a power hitter. He will finish his career with over 400 HR. He's not the best at getting on base but his defensive war gives him some slack there. Likely finish with this then 2000H. Is aiming to be third on the consecutive games played streak.

Seems like he has a long way to go and I think his shot at 60 is less then bregmans.

When put against guys seen as locks for the HOF Goldschmidt, Freddie and Votto he fails the sniff test.

Discuss what do you guys think? I'd like to see these guys hit 60 WAR just to see how much the debate will change once they hit 60 WAR and that number will likley be raised to 65. Which interestingly would lead to machado arenado, votto and maybe goldschmidt falling short of the new threshold.