r/raspberrypipico • u/v40565 • 21h ago
[Review Request] 4 layer RP2040 + USB-C board, 50 x 49 mm, KiCad 10
galleryHi friends, I would like a review before I order this. It is a small RP2040 board with USB-C, 7 LEDs, BOOT and RESET buttons and a push switch.
Gallery order: 1 top composite, 2 to 4 3D views, 5 to 8 copper layers L1 to L4, 9 full schematic, 10 to 14 schematic zoomed in sections, 15 stackup and impedance table.
Board
- 4 layers, FR4 Isola 370HR, about 62 mil, 1 oz copper on all layers
- L1 parts and USB pairs, L2 solid GND, L3 3.3 V plane, L4 other signals
- 50 x 49 mm L outline, four M4 plated holes tied to GND, all parts on the top side
- USB pairs: 5.0 mil trace, 4.0 mil gap, 90 ohm differential, on L1 over L2
- 6 mil min track and space elsewhere, 8 mil min drill, 8 mil drill to copper, 12 mil tented through vias, IPC Class 2, 1 A max
- KiCad DRC and ERC are clean
- Layout was scripted and most non critical nets were autorouted, so it is not hand tidied
Questions
- USB pairs at 5/4 mil on L1. The fab table says 89.7 ohm, my field solver says about 94.5 ohm. Is that a yield risk?
- The stackup table shows 0.5 oz inner copper, but I am using 1 oz inner. Does that change the impedance enough to worry about?
- Five tented 12 mil ground vias in the RP2040 centre pad. OK, or should I move or fill them?
- The USB-C footprint is custom from the datasheet (0.40 mm holes, 5.5 mil annular ring, 0.60 mm shell slots). Anything wrong?
- 8 mil power neck downs at the RP2040 pads (16 mil elsewhere) with a 1 A max. Fine?
- L4 routing: return paths, anything crossing plane gaps, anything a fab would flag.
- One sided assembly with a through hole push switch and USB-C. Any assembly problems?
KiCad 10.0.8. I can share Gerbers or the project if that helps. Thanks!