r/singing • • 1h ago

Conversation Topic Does any part of your skill as a singer feel replaced by AI?

0 Upvotes

In light of recent years, for you personally, what is your feeling? I'll share my feelings below because I honestly need to get it out, it's kind of eating me up. You don't need to read that - I just want to share for anyone to read if they are interested.

I have been feeling quite a bit of anxiety since last week about AI generated vocals. I have been exposed to anti and pro AI threads in my homefeed recently and I was curious, so I read from both sides to get some perspective. I don't like to keep myself under a rock. For some context, I heard AI-generated vocals in the past, which shocked me in how life-like they sounded. That was over a year ago (I don't know how much the tech has progressed since).

Reading those threads and reflecting, it all created the bigger-picture realisation. I don't think I believe anymore the 'bubble is going to pop' stuff. It's too convenient for being productive to not use. And there's too much uptake by too many people. I think AI is here to stay. I don't know if the companies will keep investing money into products like AI Suno, which specialise in generating the sounds of instruments and songs. Maybe that was the flashy part of their campaign. But for where it got to, I think the cat's out of the bag with AI generated music. I don't think the cat can go back in the bag.

I did some self-confrontation anyway. I asked myself why do I sing and what do I enjoy about singing. Because if I feel my own singing is (in some part) replaced by some machine's emulation of singing, what does this say about my singing?

I started singing as a child from a place of loving the technique. I loved and still love the challenge of learning a new technique, practicing it over and over until I feel confident, then maybe using it artistically to do something fun or creative. It is only since I turned 20 (I'm 27 now) that I started channeling more of an emotional outlet through singing. I started singing when I was six, so honestly my 'roots' as a singer have been mostly in finding enjoyment in the technical aspect.

It's not black and white though. I dislike pristine singing and the over-produced, 'perfect' vocals that are on a lot of pop songs. I prefer when emotion is channelled through technique, like technique is the vehicle carrying the feeling. That's my sweet spot. It actually encourages me to focus on technique, even while I'm valuing the emotional expression. It's a bit of a weird relationship.. Maybe it's like ying and yang. For me, technique feeds into emotion, while emotion feeds into my exploration or use of technique. Whatever it is, I'm very fulfilled having this relationship to singing.

I write of my anxiety here, but to be clear I'll continue to sing until I die. That part of my relationship to singing cannot be touched by the world and its constantly changing views and trends. Singing in the privacy of my home, I am one of the happiest human alive on earth. I don't feel like that part is threatened by AI. It's the craft itself and how we engage with it in the future, with AI generated vocals now in the picture.

I honestly never would have believed 5 years ago that this would be the reality in 2026 if anyone had told me it was coming. How can a machine sing? Singing has been the most human form of expression to my mind for so many years.

I'm starting to think I've had the wool pulled over my eyes a bit by art critics and audiences, who pushed singers and performers on pedestals to build hype. 'Oh look how they pour the emotion out in their voice!' Don't get me wrong, I have felt emotion pouring out of me while singing, as if through the notes themselves. As I describe, that's my internal relationship with singing. Technique is married with the expression. But when i think back, rarely when I share those recordings do the people who comment ever say they felt the emotion I felt too. Do I always feel the emotion a singer was feeling when I watch a live recording or attend a concert? It makes me question if the emotion (the human part) was never actually central to singing. Which is the only part not replaceable by AI (as of now) because AI cannot feel emotion.

I'm not saying it can't be important, just that maybe the technical part is at the centre and always was. Which can be replicated and emulated by a machine now.

So, speaking solely about the technical skill of being a singer, are we being replaced? What do you think? Do you see things similarly to me or has my perspective and critical thinking taken a few blows from being in too many echo chambers?

I understand if you who ends up reading this don't care about AI and this topic because you just like to sing. But I want there to be some discussion about it in this community, because it's a very real concern for the value of our craft and its place in the world moving forward.

I think singing is too central to human expression to become 'lost' to machines, I think people will always sing, but how and where will we keep singing?


r/singing • • 17h ago

Conversation Topic New to singing – how do beginners build calm breath control and confidence?

Post image
2 Upvotes

I'm new here


r/singing • • 11h ago

Feedback (read rule 3 before posting or be banned) what is my top register?

0 Upvotes

i think the top register is flageolet but its extremely loud.

it cant be whistle because i have/had a whsitle register(it left but is coming back and isnt the same. it isnt shown in this video because it aint consistently available.

its loud and doesnt smoothly connect to my head voice but it also sometimes does if im doing a lip trill or something weird happens


r/singing • • 12h ago

Advanced or Professional Topic advice for baritone mix

0 Upvotes

im a baritone and my range is quite more comfortable in the 3rd to lower 4th octave but its still a little unstable. i think its my breath support but im not sure. ive never had a vocal coach before but ive been working on my voice for 5 years using youtube vocal coaches, ive used channels like jacobs vocal academy, aussie vocal coach, some random ones and recently im using jeff rolka's exercises because they make my voice feel good but i feel like ive reached a point where i feel stuck with an underdeveloped mix register, and id say i cant really access it, sometimes i stumble upon it but its never when i need it. im really desperate for advice from anyone who can help because i have a cover to record with a friend and the song is pretty much in a tenor range, it lives in the mid to upper 4th octave, the highest note being a#4 and recently i had to record an a4 in a cover of my own but i STRUGGLED. i had to do various takes and comp it so that it sounds just decent, and when testing my vocal range its strange but i can go from f#2 comfortable ascending on an ah vowel up to c5 or c#5 with zero strain, but trying to sing it its like i never reached that note, can anyone help me out? maybe with youtube videos that geniunely help or advice if u have any idea what could help. i should also say sometimes singing in the upper register for me is very shaky and unstable as well.


r/singing • • 22h ago

Just sharing my singing I just tried.. Na yeh chand hoga, Na taare rehenge.. Hemant Kumar, Bollywood old hindi songs

0 Upvotes

Just a try


r/singing • • 21h ago

Conversation Topic i need help from experienced singers to clear this confusion

0 Upvotes

i (19M) am from India. and there's something regarding singing that just confuses me.

so i used to learn guitar at an academy (since 2024, but left this year). there, our trainer tasked us with singing on guitar chords. i decided to not sing in a totally terrible or untrained voice, so i decided to train as much i can in the span of 4-5 weeks (cant stretch it for months, i was already gone past the deadline, and i had to show up).

my mother is trained at singing, but i decided not to ask her for guidance, and instead decided to go the self-taught route. discovered the tanpura which helped me stay on the note, and then i used an online tuner for better accuracy. i got the tuner figures from Chat GPT so i could know if i was doing it right.

i trained to sing on the C scale. i consistently did it, and learnt to sing 2 songs (and perform them on guitar). then i performed in front of my trainer, and both the times, he said that i sung well. all of this was in 2025.

now, more than a year later, when i decided to rerun through one of the performances (which was recorded), it sounded really bad, and i couldn't even sit all the way through with it. i feel like i did something wrong cuz i didn't sound even minutely good.

so this confuses me. when singers train, what scale do they train in? the scale of their resonant voice? or a random scale? or they don't train in any scale at all? and if that is so, what do they do then?

i really need some experienced singers on this sub to help me clear this doubt. thanks!


r/singing • • 5h ago

Conversation Topic Is there like a digital singing competition app i can use to showcase and practice.

2 Upvotes

I have been practicing singing solo for a while, so i am looking to find any app that provides live singing practice with other users and also learn from them


r/singing • • 16h ago

Conversation Topic Range questions

0 Upvotes

I just have a few questions on singing range and that stuff and it’s:

Based on my current singing “stats”
- Full range of F2-G5
- Comfortable/natural zone about A3-F4
- Current chest-mix or connected mix ceiling of around G4-G#4 or a strained unstable A4
- Quite bright twangy voice
- (I’m a 15 year old guy)

What voice type would i be?
How much is the mixed range trainable? Can you train to be a high tenor or sing close to or like one?
How much can the top of the singing voice increase with training?
Are my current singing qualities good or average?
And
As you move into adulthood, how much does your voice mature after the puberty changes, like as you get into your late teens/20s, does a higher range becomes easier? Harder? Does your sound just become thicker and if the range does shift how much by?

Thanks!


r/singing • • 18h ago

Feedback (read rule 3 before posting or be banned) Involuntarily switching between head and chest voice mid song, how to control this?

2 Upvotes

Need some professional advice because I think this is making my singing worse.

I (16, ftm) am in my school's choir and also trying out for the musical that our school is doing this year (it's Chess the Musical). For auditions they gave us some pieces and one of them is Anthem. I want to audition using this piece because I was kinda thinking about auditioning for the character who sings it (Anatoly, he's a Russian chess grandmaster).

I can hit all of the notes in the song just fine, but it does have a bit of a wide range of notes so sometimes I need to switch between head and chest voice. The only issue? It sounds bad. Like 2 different people poorly spliced together trying to sing one song. Sometimes when I try to sing, the head and chest voice switch mid sentence and I kinda hate it. How do I make it flow more naturally and make my voice sound better? Any exercises or tips that I can use?

Sorry if this is an amateur question, but I do really want to try and get good enough for this role


r/singing • • 23h ago

Conversation Topic It's so awkward trying to learn rap parts in songs.

2 Upvotes

I'm looking to learn BLACKPINK songs next year, and I'm realising how awkward it'll be to learn the rap parts.

I want to learn their songs as I dont think it's a huge amount of belting compared to girl groups like Little Mix. But while translating the songs into English and learning the singing parts wont be too difficult in terms of learning with a piano, the rap will be the hard part. Even in English the raps are quite fast.

Are there any singers here who have learn rap parts in songs?


r/singing • • 19h ago

Conversation Topic I keep hurting my voice every time I sing and idk what to do

3 Upvotes

I will say I mainly try to sing sings sung by dudes, but then I tried to sing a song by Tori from victorious and that hurt my voice too. It feels like I csnt sing anything. Im litterally recovering rn cuz i hurt my voice.

Ive been singing my whole life and this has never happened before

According to a music app im an alto


r/singing • • 16h ago

Feedback (read rule 3 before posting or be banned) How to practice breathing and consistency?

4 Upvotes

This is an original song - welcome to provide feedback on song itself. But man, this song took me 10 takes to get this and I still have spots where I'm just inconsistent. I think it's my breathing and support. I can get it right some lines then others I don't have it right at all.

It is admittedly a newly written song so I'm still finding how it sits, but I feel like I could do a lot better.

Any advice?


r/singing • • 15h ago

Conversation Topic finally started voice lessons again at 21!!

5 Upvotes

just feeling really excited to share that i finally took the leap to start voice lessons again! I started at 16 and have been doing it on and off because every single time I start to make progress I chicken out and stop.

this time around, I decided to really reframe my mindset and do it on my own terms. I’m doing this for the love of it and I’m gonna put no pressure on myself to see a certain amount of progress in a certain timeframe. Also sharing this to encourage anyone who has been wanting to start singing again! the only thing stopping you is yourself! you got this!


r/singing • • 18h ago

Conversation Topic Got sick now have no falsetto, concert in a week.

24 Upvotes

Hey guys.

I had a nasty cold for about a week and my voice was fine until the cold went away. I had no voice for three days. Now, it’s kinda important to note that I have a really large vocal range and that is the key to me being at this concert.

Flash forward a week ago to now, I have no head voice or falsetto. I just completely stop making noise if I try. I’ve tried everything. I have a concert in less than a week. Please give me all your methods, conventional or not.


r/singing • • 1h ago

Just sharing my singing A song about searching for an intimacy I've never quite reached — feedback appreciated

3 Upvotes

Hi! I wanted to share another original song I’ve been working on.
This one explores the recurring feeling of searching for a deeper kind of connection, particularly when you’ve encountered people you genuinely wanted to know and love, but never quite reached the intimacy you imagined could develop.
I’d love to hear any feedback on the songwriting, vocals, or overall feeling of the song!


r/singing • • 2h ago

Conversation Topic How do you work on emotional delivery singing in non-native language?

3 Upvotes

I've been taking vocal lessons for about 6 months. I can hit the notes fairly reliably now (with a few small pitch slips), but my singing sounds flat emotionally. English isn't my first language, though I'm fluent and fully understand the lyrics of the songs I sing. Still, I can't seem to translate what I feel into my voice, tho I really try.

Is this a matter of phrasing and dynamiс, or could it be related to singing in a second language (stress, rhythm, natural word flow)?

What exercises or habits helped you move from "singing the right notes" to actually conveying the song? Any advice for self-practice between lessons is appreciated 🗿


r/singing • • 3h ago

Conversation Topic I NEED ADVICE 😭

2 Upvotes

I’m a new singer and have never done choir but i am in a church band as one of the main singer, mainly because i have to as the pastors kids. My problem is i went to a freinds giving where i had lots of fun however there was screaming raging and yelling from playing a lot of intense uno and i have to sing tomorrow in front of people at 2:00 and have practice at either 12 or 1pm befor my performance and my voice dose not sound good. And it got even worse when i tried doing karaoke when i got home later cause why the hell not, until i realized my voice was acting weird were i would find out that i could be damaging my voice!? 😭. and now at 12:26 pm freaking out on how to fix my voice because i have some songs are that i worked hard on and now im worried i won’t be able to sing them tomorrow 😭. ( i need advice on what to do) and a scale of 1-10 just screwed i am preferabl)


r/singing • • 3h ago

Conversation Topic What mic is best for closet recording?

2 Upvotes

Currently im cast and an aspiring VA/Vocalist in which i love to sing theatre covers and covers in general. But with my current setup im in a very small closet (only enough room to stand in) with a bunch of clothes/towels/pillows all around me. My audio engineer friend tells me it definitely sounds like im recording in a closet and my current setup is a Blue Yeti nano connected to my laptop.

The main problems i have is that with the loud belting i have to do for theatre songs and other covers i often peak ALOT and can never find an easy way to remedy this. My previous mic was a tonor77 cheap mic. Im wondering if i upgrade to a Shure SM58 (Dynamic) or a AT2020 (condensor) itll help stop peaking.

Some people say dynamic sounds muffled and only for stage use which im worried about, But my experience with condensor mic or atleast with blue yeti nano being the nicest thing i own barely being able to control the gain and take control of my raw recordings that ill keep peaking.

Im always being told condensor is the best for studio recordings and i just dont want to buy the wrong mic whether it be an AT2020 or a SM58 i wanna belt and have good recordings without revisiting all of my current problems

(For suggested methods of helping recording i record with my mouth facing away and the mic pointed at me, My mic is off against the wall so adequate space, singing around 6 inches away from the mic along moving back more for loud belting parts. Yes its Cardoroid)

EDIT: I also have a current problem with my laptop only having enough space to be connected and show me everything i need to see being a few inches from my mic causing the fans to be picked up as a low but very noticable hum/hiss. I did try to shove a big memory foam pillow between my laptop and mic which helped a little bit but my audio friend constantly recommends an SM58 which can eliminate the hissing and help with my belting. But im also thinking of just buying an AT2020 and then a seperate screen display so i can connect it to my laptop without the fans being near.


r/singing • • 4h ago

Just sharing my singing Sorry I cried it’s bad

2 Upvotes

r/singing • • 6h ago

Just sharing my singing Original song! Should I share it online yet?

6 Upvotes

r/singing • • 8h ago

Feedback (read rule 3 before posting or be banned) have no idea what im doing, are the vocal flips helping or hurting?

1 Upvotes

im a graduating senior really regretting never having joined choir. i never stood out musically because i suck at reading sheet music lol. i love music with emotion in the vocals, and what i think are flips are one of my favorite things when well executed. i cant tell if its doing me good or not hahah, and im also wondering where on the scale im at? alto, tenor, baritone, whatever all those mean?

thanks so much, im just tryna improve because i truly do adore singing n writing n all the things!


r/singing • • 8h ago

Feedback (read rule 3 before posting or be banned) My voice has always had a strange “ringing” quality? Does anyone else notice this? Any advice or critique would be appreciated!

2 Upvotes

i feel like im a little blind to what is actually messing up my voice and would love some advice.

It sounds a little bit too ‘ring-y’ to me, if that makes sense? Like theres a faint tone of a mosquito in your ear?

sorry the video is very sloppy! i messed up the key at the end there and a few times in the middle.


r/singing • • 11h ago

Advanced or Professional Topic Adding Female vocals to the band

2 Upvotes

We’re The Silver Platters in Santa Barbara.


r/singing • • 11h ago

Feedback (read rule 3 before posting or be banned) Bought a mic so I can practice and join an open mic soon

4 Upvotes