r/singing • u/Practical_Ask4337 • 1h ago
Conversation Topic Does any part of your skill as a singer feel replaced by AI?
In light of recent years, for you personally, what is your feeling? I'll share my feelings below because I honestly need to get it out, it's kind of eating me up. You don't need to read that - I just want to share for anyone to read if they are interested.
I have been feeling quite a bit of anxiety since last week about AI generated vocals. I have been exposed to anti and pro AI threads in my homefeed recently and I was curious, so I read from both sides to get some perspective. I don't like to keep myself under a rock. For some context, I heard AI-generated vocals in the past, which shocked me in how life-like they sounded. That was over a year ago (I don't know how much the tech has progressed since).
Reading those threads and reflecting, it all created the bigger-picture realisation. I don't think I believe anymore the 'bubble is going to pop' stuff. It's too convenient for being productive to not use. And there's too much uptake by too many people. I think AI is here to stay. I don't know if the companies will keep investing money into products like AI Suno, which specialise in generating the sounds of instruments and songs. Maybe that was the flashy part of their campaign. But for where it got to, I think the cat's out of the bag with AI generated music. I don't think the cat can go back in the bag.
I did some self-confrontation anyway. I asked myself why do I sing and what do I enjoy about singing. Because if I feel my own singing is (in some part) replaced by some machine's emulation of singing, what does this say about my singing?
I started singing as a child from a place of loving the technique. I loved and still love the challenge of learning a new technique, practicing it over and over until I feel confident, then maybe using it artistically to do something fun or creative. It is only since I turned 20 (I'm 27 now) that I started channeling more of an emotional outlet through singing. I started singing when I was six, so honestly my 'roots' as a singer have been mostly in finding enjoyment in the technical aspect.
It's not black and white though. I dislike pristine singing and the over-produced, 'perfect' vocals that are on a lot of pop songs. I prefer when emotion is channelled through technique, like technique is the vehicle carrying the feeling. That's my sweet spot. It actually encourages me to focus on technique, even while I'm valuing the emotional expression. It's a bit of a weird relationship.. Maybe it's like ying and yang. For me, technique feeds into emotion, while emotion feeds into my exploration or use of technique. Whatever it is, I'm very fulfilled having this relationship to singing.
I write of my anxiety here, but to be clear I'll continue to sing until I die. That part of my relationship to singing cannot be touched by the world and its constantly changing views and trends. Singing in the privacy of my home, I am one of the happiest human alive on earth. I don't feel like that part is threatened by AI. It's the craft itself and how we engage with it in the future, with AI generated vocals now in the picture.
I honestly never would have believed 5 years ago that this would be the reality in 2026 if anyone had told me it was coming. How can a machine sing? Singing has been the most human form of expression to my mind for so many years.
I'm starting to think I've had the wool pulled over my eyes a bit by art critics and audiences, who pushed singers and performers on pedestals to build hype. 'Oh look how they pour the emotion out in their voice!' Don't get me wrong, I have felt emotion pouring out of me while singing, as if through the notes themselves. As I describe, that's my internal relationship with singing. Technique is married with the expression. But when i think back, rarely when I share those recordings do the people who comment ever say they felt the emotion I felt too. Do I always feel the emotion a singer was feeling when I watch a live recording or attend a concert? It makes me question if the emotion (the human part) was never actually central to singing. Which is the only part not replaceable by AI (as of now) because AI cannot feel emotion.
I'm not saying it can't be important, just that maybe the technical part is at the centre and always was. Which can be replicated and emulated by a machine now.
So, speaking solely about the technical skill of being a singer, are we being replaced? What do you think? Do you see things similarly to me or has my perspective and critical thinking taken a few blows from being in too many echo chambers?
I understand if you who ends up reading this don't care about AI and this topic because you just like to sing. But I want there to be some discussion about it in this community, because it's a very real concern for the value of our craft and its place in the world moving forward.
I think singing is too central to human expression to become 'lost' to machines, I think people will always sing, but how and where will we keep singing?