Hey everyone, here’s the situation. I live with my wife and 3-year-old toddler in a 1-story, 1,000 sqft house that she built herself and completed just before we met 7 years ago. We’ve started the foundation footers for a 2-story (22’x30’) addition, with framing starting in January. This will add about 1,320 sqft: 2BR/1FB on the first floor and 2 flex rooms + HB upstairs.
I’m a professional acoustic musician and builder, with about 14 years in the field, including residential green building project management and running my own GC company. Neither of us has paid much attention to true soundproofing methods beyond the basics.
I stay up much later than the family, and my wife is the lightest sleeper I’ve ever encountered. It’s beyond compare. The pressure change from a silent door opening in another room can wake her up. The slightest sound, and she can’t fall back asleep. We also share the bedroom with our toddler. I can’t open the fridge or move around at all after bedtime. My only refuge at night is the bathroom, where I spend hours exercising, eating, and generally hanging out. We’ve tried it all. Nothing works. More space is the key, and we’re making it.
The existing house has one bedroom (solid core door), but the walls don’t extend to the vaulted ceiling, so the only room that fully closes off is the bathroom. We plan to add blown-in cellulose to the current bedroom wall and frame the walls to the ceiling so it can eventually become a guest room/music room.
The existing house has 2x6 exterior walls with open-cell spray foam insulation. The entry into the addition hallway will have solid French doors where the only windows on that wall currently sit. We also plan to build a separate wall along the adjoining wall of the addition.
I’m butting heads with my wife about how far to go with soundproofing. She thinks I have “PTSD” from years of tiptoeing around (and maybe I do), but I want to make at least the primary bedroom a cave of silence. I also want to be able to play and sing in the existing bedroom without disturbing anyone.
We’re DIY and on a budget, so spending tons of extra money on soundproofing isn’t going to fly. She wants reasonable adjustments beyond normal building standards, but nothing too excessive.
I’ve been researching and mass seems to be the best way to get what I want. I’m just not sure what’s reasonable in terms of extra labor and materials (trim, screws, resilient channel, MLV, etc.). Any opinions are welcome.
Is double 5/8” drywall on the walls adjoining the primary bedroom necessary, or is there enough separation with a double wall? Putty pads on outlet boxes?
The second floor seems like a different beast, and I’d like to do something about that, but it may be out of budget. We’ll have standard lumber ceiling joists. I could do insulation, resilient channel, double 5/8” drywall on the ceiling, MLV, double second-floor subfloor, carpet/padding, etc. The upstairs will eventually be a theater room where our kid has friends over jumping around during sleepovers. Seems prudent to consider that stuff now rather than trying to address it later.
I’ve attached a Floor plan for context.
What should I prioritize, and what can I reasonably expect? Am I being crazy to really make this a thing?
Sorry for the long post….i thought context was important. Thank you