r/theroamingdead • u/Upstairs-Bug-3052 • 8h ago
Discussion Best Carl Grimes arc?
What is the best arc for Carl Grimes's character? When was he at his peak?
r/theroamingdead • u/bloodisrage • Mar 20 '26
🏆 Yesterdays Result: Volume 21 - “All Out War Part Two” - S Tier
Community mean score: 5.25 placing it at the top of S tier
Welcome back to our month long community project!
Over 32 days, The Roaming Dead community is ranking every volume of The Walking Dead comics until we have a complete tier list decided by YOU.
Each day we vote on where that volume belongs:
SS - Perfect
S - Amazing
A - Great
B - Good
C - Average
D - Weak
Voting is open for 24 hours.
Results lock in tomorrow and the updated tier list will be posted with the next volume.
Let’s keep building the definitive community ranking!
r/theroamingdead • u/EmpleadoResponsable • Nov 10 '25
Hey everyone!
I've opened a Discord server dedicated to The Walking Dead Comic Universe, a place for us to to talk, share, and hang out beyond Reddit.
The server will be mainly comic-focused, but we also have spaces to discuss the games, show, and fan projects, and any off-topic theme as long as we stay respectful to it, so everyone can feel at home.
If you enjoy thoughtful conversations and a chill community vibe, join!
r/theroamingdead • u/Upstairs-Bug-3052 • 8h ago
What is the best arc for Carl Grimes's character? When was he at his peak?
r/theroamingdead • u/ComfortableFit5610 • 20h ago
What I mean is what 4 characters do you think had the most impact on the story of the comics overall?
r/theroamingdead • u/theUndeadartist12222 • 1d ago
How long do you think you'd last on the road? How many days, weeks or months till you call it quits?
Would the hunters be to much? The heat? Hunger?
scenario 1
You will be with the group after the prison falls
scenario 2
you're alone after the prison falls
r/theroamingdead • u/Reddevil8884 • 2d ago
Seriously, what the heck is his face like that? There's no way this was not made on purpose lol 😆
r/theroamingdead • u/theUndeadartist12222 • 3d ago
Do you think Comic Rick could've talked him down? Either at their first meeting (when they shared whiskey) or at the final fight for the prison, & if he couldn't have done it could he beat him in H2H?
r/theroamingdead • u/theUndeadartist12222 • 4d ago
Like relationships, quotes, speeches, wardrobe, weapons, arc, loss etc
r/theroamingdead • u/theUndeadartist12222 • 4d ago
Figures, wardrobe pieces, signed comic etc
r/theroamingdead • u/theUndeadartist12222 • 5d ago
Tyreese vs Lee in a fight, who do you think takes it?
(No guns | Just hammer & cleaver)
r/theroamingdead • u/theUndeadartist12222 • 6d ago
Tyreese vs Abraham
Who do you think would win in a fight?
(No guns | Just knife and hammer)
r/theroamingdead • u/theUndeadartist12222 • 6d ago
Comic or show?
Who's belt is better in your opinion?
r/theroamingdead • u/PitifulPeach7659 • 8d ago
Pretty much everyone agrees that the commonwealth arc is one of the weakest points in the comics, it’s very rushed and none of the recent add to the cast get anything to do, not even Magna’s group despite them being introduced a while ago now. The show attempted to expand on it but in some very questionable ways, making Lance Hornsby of all people a main antagonist and having the commonwealth kidnap all of children For some reason. It also didn’t help that half of the season which could’ve helped flesh out the commonwealth was dedicated to the Reapers. So I’ve been left to wonder, if there was an opportunity to give this storyline more time to develop, how would you improve it? What changes would you make?
r/theroamingdead • u/ComfortableFit5610 • 8d ago
r/theroamingdead • u/Bitter-Stretch-702 • 9d ago
I know it's an unpopular opinion but I prefer reading TWD in color. I woulda loved to have this for my shelf. (Yes I know I can collect the issues, but I prefer this format)
r/theroamingdead • u/theUndeadartist12222 • 10d ago
Who do you think suffered the most mentally? Comic Rick or TV Rick?
Comic Rick loses Lori, Andrea, Abraham, Glenn, his people on the pikes etc. We see Rick struggles a lot with loneliness and the burden of being a leader, constantly blaming himself for every mistake and death.
TV Rick loses Glenn, Lori, but most importantly Carl. We see eventually his people betray him which leads to him getting imprisoned by some military group for 6+ years forcing him to do their labor.
Of course that's not all both versions have went through but just some notable losses, overall who do you think had it harder mentally?
r/theroamingdead • u/Independent_Bid2101 • 10d ago
mine is
01 issue 100#
02 Issue 84#
03 issue 167#
r/theroamingdead • u/Professional-Web-934 • 10d ago
4🥇
2🥈
1🥉
3
my full rank
r/theroamingdead • u/theUndeadartist12222 • 11d ago
Out of all the characters (excluding Rick), whose mental health struggles did you find the most interesting to read about?
Whose story and portrayal of dealing with things like loneliness, depression, stress, anger, or other personal struggles did you enjoy the most?
r/theroamingdead • u/Independent_Bid2101 • 11d ago
r/theroamingdead • u/ExperienceSpecial769 • 12d ago
Today I just thought if Commonwealth arc and Whisperer arc switched places in comics. Could it be a better ending? Let me tell you how it could go:
After All-out war there were few years of quiet. Then Rick & co. found out about Commonwealth and thought about the full rebuilding of civilization, a road to Ohio, meeting with Pamela, everything that happened in comics (with Negan just for a fun part) til Rick's death. Then starts The Whisperers War against everyone: Alexandria, Commonwealth, Hilltop, maybe even New Richmond (for a crossover with a Telltale's game), literally everyone, while Carl and Andrea are trying to live without Rick and to protect the world that Rick started to rebuild. And everything that was in comics in Whisperer arc (but instead of Rick, Carl becomes a great leader, just like his father was; and maybe some cool pages about Sebastian so he could be kinda Negan 2.0 or something like that, I just think there could be something very interesting about him). And after Beta's death (that could be better, like in AMC series, or maybe better) there is an issue 193. The end
So what do you think? Could it be a better ending for the comics?
r/theroamingdead • u/theUndeadartist12222 • 13d ago
How do you think Comic Rick would have reacted if Comic Carl passed like show carl. Do you think he would've been able to carry through for him? Been s*icidal? Be filled with hatred? How would he have been?
(Say it happens during the Whisperers arc from him helping someone at hilltop)