r/thewalkingdead • u/m1stymajora • 11h ago
Show Spoiler What’s the hill you are willing to die on?
What’s your personal hill you are willing to die on when it comes to TWD?
I was thinking over the show and remembered how mad I was for Rick letting Negan survive. It’s not even that I wish that the show ended earlier, but him letting him go just threw me off. But I can justify it being “for Carl’s cause”, what I disliked was Negan’s redemption.
I’m not a fan of redemptions as a whole. I cannot say I never enjoyed his scenes post s8 tho. He’s a charming motherfucker and JDM does amazing job, anytime Negan was on screen just the pure amount of tension reeled me in.
But I still think that him surviving and “turning good” was lazy, he was only sorry because he got caught, and while of course, redemption is there to become a better person there are some things that cannot be forgotten in my opinion. And Negan’s redemption ultimately desensitised both fans and other characters into “being okay” with him, like what? I can at least respect the Governor with staying a piece of shit till he died lol.
While fiction wise leaving him in is more entertaining and comic accurate, in real life I’m not just taking Maggie’s side, but we’re taking him out while he’s still in a vegetable state with a slit throat.
To add, I don’t hate him, I actually enjoyed Saviours storyline very much, and could technically see justification for him attacking the group after they killed his men, I still think that the redemption after his whole story was just not the best