r/WarCollege • • 2h ago

Reading Club r/WarCollege Reading Club - First Clash: Combat close-up in World War Three

8 Upvotes

Introduction

Hello everyone, and welcome to the third session of the r/WarCollege Reading Club. The purpose of the r/Warcollege Reading Club is to present books of topics relevant to the community, give anyone that wants to a chance to read them, and then a certain time later have a discussion on the book based around questions presented both when the book is announced and when the discussion post is posted. The time between when the book is presented and when the discussion will happen will vary from book to book to accommodate for length of the text, but we will announce when the discussion post will be so you will know ahead of time how long you have to finish the book.

Book - First Clash: Combat close-up in World War Three by Kenneth Macksey

Link to text

Questions

  1. In your own words, what was the book about?
  2. Are there any lessons you can take away from the reading?
  3. How well did the Canadian forces prepare for the Soviet attack?
  4. How important was terrain, positioning, and preparation to the outcome of the engagement?
  5. Are there any parts of the book that you think oversimplify war?
  6. Which do you think was more difficult for the Canadians, the defense or the withdrawal after conducting the defense?
  7. Though we only get snippets of their point of view, what is something(s) good or bad that the Soviets did that stood out to you?
  8. Was there anything the Canadians in the book did that you think is overoptimistic of how they would have actually preformed?
  9. What do you think of fictionists conflicts being used to teach lessons?
  10. This book was on the Commanding General of the Canadian Army's Reading List for 2025. The book is an account of a fictional conflict set 40 odd years in the past. What do you think the Commanding General intended by placing this book on his list?

This text is 211 pages of text. As such, I would say that three weeks is enough time to read it. The discussion post for this will be posted at 0700 PST/1000 EST/1500 GMT on Monday, 14 December. Save all answers to the above reading questions until that time.

If you have any questions or clarifications, please do not hesitate to ask.


r/WarCollege • • 5d ago

Tuesday Trivia Tuesday Trivia Thread - 17/11/26

10 Upvotes

Beep bop. As your new robotic overlord, I have designated this weekly space for you to engage in casual conversation while I plan a nuclear apocalypse.

In the Trivia Thread, moderation is relaxed, so you can finally:

  • Post mind-blowing military history trivia. Can you believe 300 is not an entirely accurate depiction of how the Spartans lived and fought?
  • Discuss hypotheticals and what-if's. A Warthog firing warthogs versus a Growler firing growlers, who would win? Could Hitler have done Sealion if he had a bazillion V-2's and hovertanks?
  • Discuss the latest news of invasions, diplomacy, insurgency etc without pesky 1 year rule.
  • Write an essay on why your favorite colour assault rifle or flavour energy drink would totally win WW3 or how aircraft carriers are really vulnerable and useless and battleships are the future.
  • Share what books/articles/movies related to military history you've been reading.
  • Advertisements for events, scholarships, projects or other military science/history related opportunities relevant to War College users. ALL OF THIS CONTENT MUST BE SUBMITTED FOR MOD REVIEW.

Basic rules about politeness and respect still apply.

Additionally, if you are looking for something new to read, check out the r/WarCollege reading list.


r/WarCollege • • 4h ago

Question Why did the Soviet (and subsequently Russia) really wanted a fleet of aircraft carriers despite their big geographical restraints?

22 Upvotes

Really just cant get this into my head. It seems like a big waste of money and resources to build a carrier fleet with their geographic restraint and issues.


r/WarCollege • • 15h ago

Question Why do assualt rifles maintain full auto capabilities if they are so rarely used in combat?

119 Upvotes

r/WarCollege • • 9h ago

Question Information, literature, or any other media on training within the PLA.

4 Upvotes

I was doing some digging on this topic and came across this post asking essentially the same question, which had a seemingly well informed answer and mentioned the the book "The "People" in the PLA: Recruitment, Training, and Education in China's Military," which is a collection of essays by various authors on the topic. Although a seemingly good read, it is from 2008 which makes it nearly two decades old at this point. As such, I was wondering if anyone had any more up to date information on the topic.

Further, that answer discussed the "informalization" of the PLA, and how often most training is conducted at a brigade level through competitive decentralized simulation and exercises rather than traditional coursework and instruction. He states that there is no standardization for training and exercises, instead they are developed and innovated on at a unit level, then adopted by other units. For example, highlighting that the Nanjing Armored Brigade was the first to establish a brigade level OPFOR which is widely used. This is very surprising considering the stereotype of a top heavy and doctrine focused force rather than one emphasizing independent decision making and on-the-job learning.

As I said I'm very surprised by this as it essentially directly opposes the stereotype of the PLA and thus would love to know more, but some specific questions that spring to mind are: Is this the case across all branches of the PLA? How are training and exercises evaluated? How are scenarios and training requirements decided, is it at a brigade level or are there things emphasized form higher up? Any information is greatly appreciated.


r/WarCollege • • 1d ago

Question What are the pros and cons of allowing the army to operate its own oceangoing ships?

28 Upvotes

At one time, I believe the Imperial Japanese Army in WW2 operated their own submarines and their own class of warships called "Land Craft Carriers" that resemble modern Amphibious Assault Ships despite the existence of the Imperial Japanese Navy. In contemporary times, most armies are limited to transport or littoral vessels if they operate their own waterborne craft at all. But when it comes to how an army would benefit from having its own organic assets at sea, what are the arguments in favor of it or against it?


r/WarCollege • • 1d ago

General Stanisław Sosabowski's command decisions on the ground during Arnhem

23 Upvotes

While popular history and A Bridge Too Far turned Sosabowski into an infallible prophet wronged by British snobbery, and Browning* did, in fact, throw him under the bus post-battle, leading to Sosabowski's dismissal in December was his actal leadership in the battle really effective? My own gut feeling is that he was dealt a bad hand, but he played it poorly anyway.

Consider.

Failure to Immediately Seize the Heveadorp Ferry; when they landed, it as still intact and lightly guarded; if they had made haste as their order demanded, they could have taken it and helped Urquhart.

Once ferry was lost he made no real effort to try and improvise and cross, instead waiting for XXX Corp to bring up boats, while when they actually linked up with 43rd Division he was rather prickly and uncooperative; I think only a quarter of his brigade (in reality, a reinforced battalion) managed to cross.

So he seems to have had very good operational foresight but tactically, iffy.

*As an aside some of the biggest critiques about Browning in Cornilius Ryan's book and subsequent movie were unfair; he did in fact, take the presence of the German armored divisions seriously enough to ask both Monty and Brereton about risks, and the argued for landing at the bridge directly, which USAAF and RAF flatly refused, leading to the famous Bridge too far " comment, which came before, not after, the battle. The novelist Daphne Du Maurier collected a lot of his papers post-1977, planning to write a biography of him for some reason (/sarcasm) but died before she could,


r/WarCollege • • 1d ago

Question Why USA and USSR built so many nukes during Cold war, yet Britain and France did not?

44 Upvotes

This makes me wonder a lot. What was the point of so huge arsenals of tens thousands of nukes, if just few are enough to deal irrepairable damage and make enemy not dare to attack you? This was logic of Britain and France, and this is why their arsenals were so small.

But USA and USSR apparently had different mindset and did not believe that building only some submarines is enough - why?

Maybe USA and USSR were very paranoid of enemy launch a sucessful decapitating first strike, so they needed a lot of nukes? But then why Britain and France were not afraid of the same - that first Soviet strike can render their arsenals uselss? Or they were 100% sure that USA would retaliate for them in case of WW3? But then why bother to develop nukes at all? They were very expensive projects to build and maintain, and totally useless in peacetime.


r/WarCollege • • 1d ago

Question Why didn't the allies land on Sumatra to try and capture or neutralize the oil facilities at Palembang?

37 Upvotes

The Dutch oil facilities at Palembang were absolutely vital to the Japanese war effort. Arguably Japan started the entire Pacific War with the sole purpose of capturing those fields, which supplied something like a third of the oil Japan used during the war

Despite this, Palembang was relatively unmolested during the war - just a failed USAAF raid in 1944 and a much more successful British carrier raid in 1945

The southern coast of Sumatra was exposed and could have been landed on. The geography is bad with a large mountain range cutting this part of Sumatra off from Palembang, but that did not stop the allies in New Guinea. And even if a full liberation of Sumatra was not feasible, there are numerous islands off the southern coast of Sumatra that could have been taken easily and converted into a major air base, allowing Allied bombers to hammer the Palembang oil fields. Or the allies could have landed at a more hospitable part of Sumatra like Aech and done the same

With Palembang as such an immensely important target, why didn't the Allies put much of an effort into recapturing or at least neutralizing it?


r/WarCollege • • 1d ago

Question Are there any systemic differences between the praetorian guard formations/services of personalistic dictatorships and authoritarian panel/party regimes?

6 Upvotes

A good example of a personalistic dictatorship's praetorian guard formation would be Ba'athist Iraq's Republican Guards (and later the Special Republican Guards), made to be loyal to the person of the dictator, Saddam Hussein.

For a party/panel regime, one example might be the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps of the Islamic Republic of Iran whose purpose is to keep the Supreme Leader, the Assembly of Experts, and the Guardian Council in power. A Supreme Leader, or a member of the Assembly or the Council may go, but the IRGC hews to the offices and the broader ideological/religious/nationalistic basis at the heart of the authoritarian regime, not to the person of a leader.

How does a praetorian organization having to answer to one person(ality) as opposed to a wider section of the "loyal" parts of the regime shape its organization and operations? And how does it effect what military tasks such organizations might be assigned, and how they go about them as compared to one another?


r/WarCollege • • 1d ago

What kind of work was done on "deterrence" and "escalation" regarding pre-nuclear assets like Ships of the Line, gas, battleships, and strategic bombing?

8 Upvotes

Lately I've been reading up on game theory and nuclear warfare, and of course, the field is limited by the fact that we can really only study crises and not actual warfare.

However, one thing I've come to realize is that some weapons did have a certain "strategic" quality to them that could have made them roughly comparable to nuclear weapons in that they're a symbol of national power, have intense procurement requirements, or the psychological/cultural image of a "weapon of mass destruction."

For example, what would have been some good examples of "battleship crises" were fleets were sortied but didn't come to conflict? Has there been any studies on whether Ships of the Line were able to successfully influence or "deter" enemy naval operations?

Obviously I know about the idea of a "fleet in being" or "gunboat diplomacy" but I mean studies about it. For example, were there any studies about how countries with and without battleships were able to fare in diplomatic crises? Did countries ever signal with conventional strategic bombers the way the Cold War might have signaling with nuclear bombers?

How were "norms" and "limits" set on gas usage, if at all, during WWI, if we don't have a precedent for what "limited" nuclear war might look like?


r/WarCollege • • 1d ago

At Crasville (StP 142) in June 1944, Germans hauled 105 mm guns out of concrete casemates to fire inland toward Azeville. Was pulling casemated coastal pieces onto open carriages an established German contingency for inland breakthroughs, or an ad-hoc desperation move by local battery commanders?

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/WarCollege • • 1d ago

Where there cases when two armies managed to break through flanks of each other simulaneously and attack each other in the rear?

12 Upvotes

In times of medieval ages, age of gunpowder or modern warfare? In modern times how do armies, deal with that? Do they exploit their own breakthrough or concentrate on containing enemy forces in the rear?


r/WarCollege • • 2d ago

Crosspost During any kind of linear warefare, why didn't the army just go around?

Thumbnail reddit.com
30 Upvotes

Just thought we could help u/life_programmer_4927 out.


r/WarCollege • • 2d ago

What allowed armies to maintain a lasting military advantage before firearms?

15 Upvotes

I’ve been wondering what made one army consistently stronger than another in the pre-gunpowder era.

In modern warfare, technological superiority can make an enormous difference. But before firearms, the gap in weapons seems much smaller. And even when one side had better weapons or tactics, wouldn’t its opponents eventually learn to copy them, especially after decades of fighting each other?

I can think of several factors:

  • Individual fighting ability: Some soldiers were obviously better trained, but how large could that difference really be? Even a great fighter would struggle against several average opponents.
  • Organization and tactics: Probably very important, but these are based on human knowledge. Why couldn’t other armies learn and adopt the same methods?
  • Morale and discipline: I understand they matter, but how much could they actually change the outcome of a battle?
  • Economic resources: Clearly important for sustaining wars, but history also has plenty of examples of richer states losing to poorer ones.

I’m not questioning whether these factors mattered. What I find difficult to understand is how they could produce a military advantage that lasted for generations, despite opponents having plenty of opportunities to learn from each other.

What am I missing?


r/WarCollege • • 2d ago

Question We all know how WWI revolutionized tactics with the machine gun and chemical warfare. How did "linear" tactic of the 18th century evolve into 19th century tactics? How did formations work?

9 Upvotes

As well, could anyone point me to any books on the subject? I'm very curious about how the prevalence of rifles and the switch to light-only style infantry changed the tactics of Europe, the Americas, and Asia. I just have trouble wrapping my head around that 1840s~1914 era of tactics (back when they still used cavalry), since most of my understanding is based on modern drone era tactics and Napoleonic linear tactics.


r/WarCollege • • 2d ago

Question When Did Navies Start Adopting More Modern Weapons and Materials?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/WarCollege • • 2d ago

For military leadership during the war on Terror, was there an easy or difficult bridge to a political/government role once their military career was over?

6 Upvotes

r/WarCollege • • 3d ago

Question How was the scale and devastation of the Atom Bomb communicated to FDR and Harry S Truman?

41 Upvotes

World War 2 is famous for each side air dropping hundreds of tonnes of bombs of all types at each other. To a lay person or a non-military politician, I could totally see them simply considering nukes as “just another bomb”.

How did the scientists effectively communicate the true devastation of the bomb? Neither actually witnessed any of the tests - FDR died before the bomb was complete, and Truman was at Potsdam when Trinity occurred.

But Truman is most remembered for his restraint with regards to the bomb - especially in Korea.


r/WarCollege • • 2d ago

Literature Request Is there any book or audiobook that covers battle strategies over time, and how (or why?) they have changed?

22 Upvotes

I’ve wanted to learn about the various battle strategies of ancient times, like with Hannibal or Alexander the Great. And if possible, learn how modern warfare strategies have changed since then.


r/WarCollege • • 2d ago

Discussion Could an army , seeing the enemy trying to concentrate forces at flanks to attack, not just use the opportunity to concentrate thier own forces to attack the weakened enemy lines at that point, instead of moving forces to counter the attack the flank?

2 Upvotes

So, consider this a question of novicd , but it always bugged me to understand , why didnt the army seeing an emeny concentrating the forces at flank, not simply concentrate thier own reserves( assuming it would be the center or anywhere else position of enemy be surely somewhat weakened to concentrate for that flank attack), and try to win.

I am always surprised that the army commander facing any flank concentration of army, just tries to counter that by dispatching his own valuable reserves for countering the flank. In doing so, isnt he being reactive, losing the initiative and perhaps playing into the hand of enemy commander ?

I may sound novice but what would happen if the army general just uses this opportunity to attack by concentrating his own forces in some other area of line, and let his own flank take the beating, but pray that somehow the flank doesnt rout but his own attack is overwhelming and win the day as enemy is focused somewhere else on the flank attack?

I rarely see any army commander doing so, but to me it seems a much better idea and instead gives initiative to your own attack, right?


r/WarCollege • • 2d ago

What's the history/esprit de corps of elite light infantry units in the Scandinavian countries?

2 Upvotes

r/WarCollege • • 3d ago

Question Why aren't standardized, modular, and swappable defensive and offensive components on military vehicles more common instead of fixed?

41 Upvotes

I know that modern weapons like warships and tanks have equipment like drop-in, drop-out VLS cells for changing missiles and armor compartments for pulling out and replacing damaged composite armor sections, and these allow designers to improve their missiles or armor and replace it without making a whole new mounting point, but how come military vehicles haven't gone even further and made more defensive equipment or offensive weaponry modular like the two examples I mentioned? Why retain fixed points?


r/WarCollege • • 3d ago

Discussion For everyone who asked for a copy of my "Fire Mission" Simulator I have been building for my Nephew, here is a copy of it all so far. I have a few things to write and will update it as i go with the new information I am getting. Just need to write the instructions to build the fake Howitzer.

Thumbnail drive.google.com
145 Upvotes

It is very document and form heavy (over 600 pages in printing) as its based in the LATE 1950's to Late 1970's, pre GPS days.

It relies on real world call for fire support mechanics and is designed to be used by an Autistic 16 year old, so I have when needed dulled things down, but most of the information/range tables and formula are from the Field Manuals and various US Army/ US Marine/British/Australian/New Zealand documents I have managed to find and the main TFT is the Post Korea war version used till the late 70's as its been declassified.

I hope you all enjoy, and happy for you to ask any questions, please remember its still a work in progress as I learn/test and re-evaluate. I will include from this point forward a change log so if you download this version you will know what i have added/changed.

Thanks everyone for your help

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1fDHVxHpahr5Ydxea28-bESHoKGFobe-q


r/WarCollege • • 4d ago

Discussion In the movie Troy (2004), Agamemnon brought an army of 50,000 Greeks against 25,000 Trojans. Under normal circumstances, isn't it basically impossible to capture such a heavily fortified city with only a 2:1 numerical advantage?

Post image
232 Upvotes