Hi. I'm a pretty old WoW player, been playing on and off since 2010, and on official servers since 2011. My last break from WoW started after killing Gul'dan in Legion, so it's been almost 10 years. Somewhere around the end of Pandaria I got interested in healing (before that I considered support roles to be something beneath me, but it turned out to be much more fun than in lineage2, which I had been playing since 2004, so I got into it pretty quickly). Over the years I also tried several other mmorpgs. Almost all of them were pretty forgettable, but one of them had a very interesting approach to healer gameplay, so I'll use it for comparison later. And now I've returned to my beloved WoW, and here's what I found...
Let's start with a little retrospective.
Back then, healing was kind of like a coloring book. You looked at the raid frames and threw your basic abilities at the frames that weren't full (Rejuvenation on my resto druid, for example). You kept Lifebloom on the tank 100% of the time. If someone dropped really low, you could throw out NS + Healing Touch. There was also an instant heal on a 15 second cd that let you follow up with a guaranteed crit Regrowth. If 5-6 people were injured, you had an aoe HoT, although it was pretty expensive. Ironbark if you knew someone was about to take damage. And Tranquility as your main powerful raid healing cooldown. That's it. It wasn't necessarily the easiest gameplay, but it was extremely clear and logical. You spent 70% of your time looking at raid frames, and the rest watching for void zones, stack/spread mechanics and other stuff.
Now let's look at what I found when I came back.
I played a little bit of Preservation Evoker, mostly out of curiosity since I completely missed Dragonflight. This spec has three problems. First, it has more buttons than your average healer. Second, it has way too much indirect healing. Things like HoTs that heal based partly on damage taken during the last several seconds. In a dungeon with only 5 players you can still figure out who would benefit the most from that HoT. But in a 20 man raid? That's a completely different story. Considering how insanely dynamic raids have become, spending a second and a half moving your cursor around the raid frames trying to find the right target is just madness. And the third problem is that way too many of its abilities require your group to be stacked together. You have that orb that applies Echo, "Temporal Anomaly". You have the green breath, "Dream Breath", which requires your raid to be relatively stacked in front of you (and by the way, this makes the spec feel like absolute garbage in M+, where your group is constantly running between packs). And then there's "Emerald Blossom", although most healers have something similar to that one. So basically, the game gives you a class/spec with extremely exotic mechanics, very high positioning requirements (in today's ridiculously fast-paced raids, seriously?) and on top of that makes you press more buttons than other healers. And the game never really explains why you should put up with all this headache.
My latest experience was Discipline Priest, Voidweaver.
And this one hit me really hard, because after leveling I was doing low M+ keys as Oracle, and Voidweaver turned out to be a completely different playstyle. This is where I started realizing just how much the workload of a healer has increased. What am I supposed to do? Well, apart from turning around to watch for ghosts, figuring out where to place green orbs so the raid doesn't get blown off the platform, soaking damage so the raid doesn't die, and all the other fun stuff.
Now let's talk about the rotation.
First, the dps rotation. And this part is EXTREMELY important because your healing comes from dealing damage.
- Keep 100% uptime on Shadow Word: Pain.
- Use Mind Blast on cd. Guides say around 70% of your healing should come from Atonement. If you miss your dps cooldowns, your healing suffers.
- Use Penance on cd. It deals good damage, spreads Shadow Word: Pain if there are additional targets nearby, and gives you Void Shield procs.
- Spam Smite because it extends Atonement.
Now the healing rotation.
- Power Word: Shield. Basically use it on cd. Again, I have to stop focusing on my dps rotation, look at the raid frames and find someone who's missing at least a little hp and doesn't already have Atonement.
- Periodically use Power Word: Radiance. And here's an important mechanic. You can spend one charge from time to time to keep Atonement on more raid members, or you can save both charges so you can use two Radiances together with Evangelism for big aoe damage.
- Use Flash Heal when it procs. It applies Atonement to yourself, costs less mana and also applies Atonement to an ally. Again, you have to take your eyes off the rotation, look at your raid frames and find a target that meets two conditions: missing hp and no Atonement.
- Use Holy Nova when 4 or more targets aren't at full hp. At least that's the number I came up with from experience. You might prefer a different number.
Now imagine a situation (and these happen all the time) where you have to kite, run around, soak something or carry a mechanic away from the raid. And this is where the real nightmare begins. You get back to your rotation and see that your dot has fallen off, Mind Blast isn't on cd, half the raid has no Atonement, and now you have to start this whole fucking carousel all over again. I'm deliberately leaving out the 2-4 minute cooldowns here, especially since disc and shadow share quite a few of them.
Now for comparison, the shadow priest rotation.
- Keep two dots up. (You can now apply them with a single button, the tentacle.)
- Mind Blast.
- If you have Insanity, cast Devouring Plague.
- Mind Flay as filler.
- Use Halo once a minute.
Why does a spec with less responsibility also have fewer buttons to worry about? Why is this happening?
And the funny thing is, it works perfectly fine for tanks. Yes, tanks also have a huge responsibility in both raids and M+. But their actual rotation has very few buttons. I tanked M+ up to around +16-17 on Brewmaster Monk. The rotation is extremely simple and newbie friendly, so to speak.
- Blackout Kick on cd.
- Keg Smash.
- Breath of Fire.
- Tiger Palm as filler, or Spinning Crane Kick depending on the number of targets.
- When the red stagger bar fills up, spend a charge of Purifying Brew.
And taunt your target directly or through the statue.
Again, I'm not talking about long cooldowns here. I think the difference is pretty damn obvious. And now let's get to why I mentioned other MMORPGs at the beginning. Look at ff14, for example. Healers work differently there. There isn't constant raid-wide damage. A healer isn't constantly coloring in raid frames (unless someone is intentionally standing in shit, lol). Instead, you do your dps rotation and use your mitigation abilities according to the encounter timers when raid damage is about to happen. So they came up with an alternative system for the healer role.
But modern WoW basically took both systems and threw them into one giant fucking mess. You have to maintain a dps rotation AND constantly use your basic healing abilities. Your attention is split between several things at once. Ideally you have to watch your dps rotation and your teammates' health bars simultaneously. And because you're a healer, you ALSO have to keep track of boss timers and know exactly when the raid is going to take damage. Because if you blow Evangelism and both Radiance charges too early, you'll be staring at your 75k hps, and by the end of the raid you'll seriously consider pressing Shift+Delete on your WoW folder.