r/Outlander • u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. • Jan 17 '22
8 Written In My Own Heart’s Blood Book Club: Written in My Own Heart's Blood, Chapters 13-25
June 1778, Philadelphia and surrounding areas - Jamie is still at the cabin outside the city with a bad back, hoping to get back to Claire. Lord John is attended to in the Continental camp by Denny Hunter. His eye is badly damaged. Claire and Jenny are now keeping Hal at LJG’s house and have drugged him so no one will know he is there.
William is on duty assisting the exodus of Loyalists from Philadelphia. He is approached by Captain Richardson who is looking for Hal and LJG, but William doesn’t know where either of them are. He is still struggling with the fact that he is Jamie’s son.
Ian and Rachel are with the Continental army at Valley Forge preparing to go to Philadelphia. They discuss Ian’s past and his marriage to Emily. Lord John, assisted by Dottie and Denny manages to escape the Continental Camp.
William finds himself at a brothel, the very same one from a few days ago. In an effort to save a prostitute from being abused by a Major Harkness William pays for the night with her. William is determined not to sleep with her, but ends up doing so.
Jamie is determined to leave the cabin and after a second night there sets off for the city. Lord John is found by Continental soldiers and pretends to be one of them. While walking back to Philadelphia Rachel and Ian come across the Loyalists and the British army leaving the city. They spot William and when Rachel gives him the news that she and Ian are to be married William hits Ian. They get in a fight that ends with Ian’s arrest at William’s command.
While riding back to the city Jamie sees Ian being marched the other way with the British. Jamie finds Rachel and learns what happened. He goes to find William and insists that William have Ian released, otherwise Jamie will reveal who he is to William’s superiors.
Back in the city Claire goes to collect herbs and on her way there runs into Benedict Arnold again. He gives her a ride and she can’t help but like the man. She wonders when he will turn traitor and if it might be something she said that would cause that, since they really have no idea if they can change history.
Jamie makes his way back to town and arrives at Lord John’s house to find Jenny holding a gun on the Duke of Pardloe. Jamie diffuses the situation between Hal and Jenny only to have Denny Hunter come in. Hal explodes at Denny for his involvement with Dottie and goes into another asthma attack. Leaving Hal in the care of Denny Jamie leaves to find Claire.
Jamie finally reunites with Claire and she tells him about her drunken night of sex with Lord John. Jame also tells her how it was with Mary McNab. They end up having sex in the potting shed.
The section closes out with Lord John being sworn in as a Continental soldier.
- What does Jane mean when she says “Ever think that maybe a whore has a sense of honor, too?”
- What do you think of Rachel and Ian as a couple?
- Do you think Jamie would have followed through with the threat to reveal himself as William’s father?
- Jamie tells Claire that she thinks with her body. What does that mean?
- Why do you think Claire wants a violent response from Jamie when they finally make love after his return?
- Any other thoughts or comments?
•
u/AutoModerator Jan 17 '22
Please do not reveal events from future books, or from later chapters of the current book the club hasn’t covered yet. Show talk is okay up to the current book. The number of pages listed are based on the Kindle edition of the books, which matches up with the hardback versions of them.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
15
u/Dolly1710 Long on desire, but a wee bit short in clink Jan 17 '22
Re the whore's honor. I think it will have been widely accepted at the time (and probably still is by large sections of society) that a prostitute is somehow sub-human - incapable of showing feeling, morality, honor or other virtues because they have already sold their chastity.
Overlooking the fact that Jane wasn't exactly doing it through free will, she was reminding William that their jobs don't define who they are and that they probably aren't so dissimilar in the mind once you strip away the prejudices.
10
u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Jan 17 '22
I thought there was so much to unpack from Jamie and Claire's reunion that, since it's broader, I figured I'd put it under a separate comment.
Jamie is struggling with his feelings in the run up to seeing Claire again, but I think one of the things that comes through is his real desire to keep himself in check, be fair to her and understand what went on. For me, his despair and love for Claire shows again when he turns to prayer, because he's really hurt, and yet objectively wants to make it about her and not about how he feels. And he's able to do that a bit by remembering Mary and putting himself in Claire's shoes.
But I love that his excitement to see her and hold her again seems to be the predominant feeling as he walks into the house, not losing a moment to ask for his wife. I'm glad she wasn't home, even though I went "great, another obstacle," because it was pretty perfect that he came back to her once she reached her happy place once more.
It kind of broke my heart to hear Claire's explanation of her night with John, because their grief comes across so strongly ("and I have not one single notion what we said, but we were talking about you"). And I understand Claire's anger at Jamie's initial reaction, because she and John were going through hell, and Jamie's being cynical about it, focusing on the act then and not their feelings.
Claire doesn't know how to define what John gave her. She eventually settles on "triage," but I think “catharsis” is an appropriate word as well. She had been good at numbing herself, and was upset that John had allowed himself to grieve fully, and he brought down her walls by sharing that, because she couldn’t numb her own pain anymore. He took away the numbness, but in putting his own grief on hers, allowed her to start healing, to feel her own feelings but with a sense of support. He gave her a safe space to grieve, with someone trustworthy who understood her loss. And I think Jamie is upset at John but also himself once he hears that, because he understands what Claire means, and that doesn't match his earlier perspective of things, when he lost it on John.
In the end:
In other words, “Whatever the fuck happened, we are going to get through this.” I don’t know, I just love Jamie's sense of conviction, and honesty and matter-of-factness about it. And once they reach the end of their conversation, what he may be troubled most about is whether Claire agrees with that or not, given that he asks “Are ye my wife?”
There was a moment in this discussion that I wasn't sure about:
What is he thinking? That they enjoyed it? That Claire wanted to leave him behind and isn’t being honest about the circumstances? I don’t remember this moment in Cross Creek.
5
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jan 17 '22
3
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jan 17 '22
2
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jan 17 '22
2
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jan 17 '22
2
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jan 17 '22
2
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jan 17 '22
6
u/Cdhwink Jan 23 '22
“He knows that Claire has this unique language she can express herself in when words fail, and now she got to speak it with someone other than him.”
I was trying to say something like this but I am never this eloquent!
Glad you finally got here with all your insightfulness. u/thepacksvrvives
🤦🏼♀️post in the wrong place again.