r/EDH • • 23h ago

Question I was told I committed a “social faux pas” at Commander with friends last night—but I don’t know why?

816 Upvotes

**UPDATE: Another friend has suggested we have a Rule Zero conversation as a group to discuss this issue. That should hopefully resolve this.**

Me and five friends were playing precons out of the box. I was playing Mardu Surge, with [[Zurgo Stormrender]], with one friend playing the [[Stella Lee, Wild Card]].

In my prior (6) commander games as a new player, I’ve mostly used decks I’ve made myself based around lore or themes, while my friends use “fairly solid” or “strong” out of the box or upgraded precons. I am often knocked out of the game in 3-5 turns, and this time, I was hopeful I’d be able to at least deal meaningful damage before anyone could cripple my board at a weak spot (1-2 creatures on the board, no commander or buffs). An example deck I’ve been running is here (ManaBox).

I played this deck in a 1v1 against a friend’s Bracket 3 Ghidorah deck, and almost got my token generation up before I was wiped and destroyed for 20 damage (with 2 health remaining). I’m used to not winning my games, but seeing a deck finally work well together and then get crushed was a little demotivating.

My friends encouraged me to borrow or buy more precons, as my themed decks, while being lore specific and unique, simply “aren’t strong enough for the rest of the pod”.

Over around four to five turns, I slowly build up my board, preparing to deal with Stella Lee. I’ve been told that anyone who can pilot a spellslinger deck accurately is a strong threat, so I decided to target my friend running Stella Lee and dealt minor (2 damage) attacks to the Stella Lee player using [[Grenzo, Havoc Raider]], also exiling the Lee player’s cards—these turned out to be islands and mountains, and I was sternly told that “messing with lands is a faux pas, we can heavily hurt you for that”

Eventually, I summoned Zurgo, and attached [[Infantry Shield]], creating four tapped and attacking 1/1 Warrior tokens, and swinging with Zurgo and then the Warriors for 7 damage. Much later, about 40 minutes (didn’t keep track) into the game, I drew [[Divine Visitation]], and turned the next summoned warrior tokens into 4/4 Angels, bringing my friend down to 16 health.

I was then told what I did was incorrect, and was then hit with creatures from my friends and counterspells from the Stella Lee player when trying to regain my (now wiped) board. I had to leave early for work, and scooped, and was told my friends would be discussing this with me tomorrow as to the etiquette of this, and they told me “commander is a social format. The goal is not to win. It’s to talk with friends.”

How can I improve as to not have something like this happen again?


r/EDH • • 20h ago

Discussion How do I communicate that no one wants to play against a bracket 5 in a pod of 3's.

243 Upvotes

So recently my pod of 3-4 kitchen table friends started going to a new lgs in our town (the only lgs in our town). This store is a month old, so it's fresh. Their fnm is hosted by the owners nephew or something. There is absolutely zero structure to fnm. I've gone twice. Last Friday there were 15-20 players there. This past Friday there were 10-12. No one swaps pods once they sit. When they sit at a table, that's where they sit from 7pm-11pm.

Now, I asked in their discord before we went the first time what the general power level is. I got one answer, and it wasn't from the guy who hosts it. Someone said, "I think we usually do 3?" I said ok (assuming I understood what they were saying). I asked that because I wanted to play at the appropriate bracket, so I brought three decks that I consider high 2, mid 3, and high 3.

Both nights, the power level has been right around where they said it was, except for one guy. I've had him at my table all night, both nights. He only owns two decks, and they are both 100% proxied out to high bracket 5. One is Kefka, and one is Tevesh Szat, Doom of Fools. They're both a nightmare to play against. It's not fun.

So this past Friday, after he comboed out (again), I asked him if he wanted to try one of my decks to play at our power level. His response was, "that's ok, I don't mind holding back". I laughed it off, but he doesn't get thats not the point. We don't like playing knowing he's tutored three winning combos into his hand and can end the game whenever he wants.

How do I communicate this to him. He's a super nice guy, and I actually do like playing with him. His decks are just not appropriate for a casual fnm. I feel like I can't talk to the host, because like I said, there's no structure to this fnm anyway. I want to be polite, but I also want to be clear that this isn't fun for us. Like I said tho, he literally doesn't own any other decks.

There are also 3 brand new players that have been there both nights and they're playing precons. They literally have zero chance, and it's hard for them to learn the mechanics of the game with Chains of Mephistopheles on the battlefield every game.

Looking for some advice on how to navigate this situation.

EDIT: Thank you for helpful responses, however I should be clear, the goal is to try and encourage him to play at our power level. I don't want to just say, "I don't like your decks so play with someone else". We do like this guy, so I'm trying to navigate it gracefully. Thank you.


r/EDH • • 12h ago

Question Fynn stresses me out.

72 Upvotes

A friend of mine has recently got a Fynn the fangbearer deck and it's just plain annoying. Its play pattern is simple and repetitive:"turn one play a deathtouching 1/1, turn two play fynn... Etc." It keeps killing all of our pod because, aside from me and that person, the others are pretty new to the game, one plays a scarab god deck, the other runs the mono green foundations precon. I have a few decks, but they all are too slow compared to the fynn player's, but I can't really make them faster without making them unfair for the others.

Is this a fair complaint or am I just bad?


r/EDH • • 15h ago

Social Interaction I guess I have my own LGS story now too

44 Upvotes

I’ve been reading all kinds of LGS stories on these subs since I joined the masses a year ago, and after tonight I now have my own story to add to the collective:

I don’t get to go play at card shops often, in fact tonight was my 4th time getting to go out and play at a card shop ever; I went with my best friend and met up with 2 other good friends of mine at a card shop they’re regulars at. The planets aligned: husband at work, kids at grandparents, unexpected bonus day off from my job - it worked out perfect so I packed up my cards, made some phone calls, and skipped out the door!

So playing Magic went awesome and I have 0 qualms about any of the gameplay. I got my butt kicked but still had a blast! My gripe was about the absolute troglodyte that kept hovering around our table trying to show me his pokemon cards. I thought he was a staff member when I first got there, I was polite, complimented his pokemon shirt, and went about my business. Then about 30 minutes later this dude comes up to me and says “I see you like mew, your friend ______ says you have a sick mew and Mewtwo collection.” Ok that’s fine, nothing weird here right? I was like yeah I have a bunch of cards from when my sister and I were kids and I started collecting again with my kid until they stopped being interested so I started to sell them off.” I assumed he was just making chit-chat, I mean we’re at a card shop and everything right? Then he said something I don’t recall and I replied with “yeah my husband is working tonight so I came here to play Magic with my friends.” Dude winks at me and says “husband eh little lady?” I immediately was creeped out, but the way he was interacting with my one friend made me think THEY were good friends. He even called my friend his “other son” a few times so I thought his overly friendliness with the people at our table was because he knew them all. I just ignored him after the weird husband comment and focused on our game. After our first game finished my 3 friends got up to get drinks/use the restroom/buy some merch, this guy comes back over and is like “hey wanna see my Mew cards? I have the Booty Mew.” Ok man, sure, I’ll look at your card photos. He starts showing me all the “Booty Pokemon” cards he has in his collection (all Pokemon cards with their cartoon butts showing in the art - like the famous “butthole pikachu” and Eevees with their tails up, that kind of stuff) and kept asking me if I liked Booty Pokemon as much as he did. Like what the fuck my dude? My friends came back to the table and I said “hey let’s get the next game going” so I could politely but very obviously disengage myself from Weird Booty Guy. Yeah no such luck. He just went and sat next to my friend and kept trying to show me his weird ass slabbed booty cards and kept reaching across our table and asking “oh I bet this one is from when you were just a kid!” and winking at me. I was super creeped out at this point, so I texted the 2 of my friends we were playing with “are you guys friends with this guy cause he’s giving me the ick.” I gave my best friend a nudge and The Look (thank god he was with me, we’ve been best friends for 28 years so he knows The Look well) and he immediately pulled a board wipe, ended the game and was like “hey we gotta head out, thanks for inviting us!”

Now in the defense of my other 2 commander comrades, I know them well and they would have absolutely shut this shit down if I had said so, but I legitimately thought they knew and were friends with weird guy, it was my first time there, and I really didn’t want to make a scene. On the way out they were both like “I’ve only seen that guy one other time and we thought you might have known him by the way he was acting and hanging around, next time please let us know someone is making you uncomfortable so we can take care of it. We don’t care if we know them or not, you shouldn’t ever feel uncomfortable coming out to play Magic with us.” They walked me to my car and made sure Weird Booty Guy was nowhere to be seen.

Now that it’s over with, it’s kind of funny. I’m a 40 yr old married woman, I haven’t had a Skeever creep on me like that in years; shit, maybe he wasn’t even creeping and I was just catching the ick cause he rubbed me the wrong way from the get-go. I just wanted get my experience off my chest, because who else outside of this sub (and my play group) would understand? I mean, I’ve been warned plenty just from visiting these subs, I just didn’t think it would happen to me so soon out of the gates 🤣 thanks for coming along with me on this journey lol I plan on going back because everything else about my LGS trip was fun and I’m not about to let Weird Booty Guy get in the way when I have the rare opportunity to get out and play commander with my friends!


r/EDH • • 13h ago

Discussion When’s the last time a deck “clicked” for you?

36 Upvotes

I was testing out a [[Will Riker, First in the Field]] deck and my brain kind of went “holy shit I love this”. A deck which clicked. A playstyle that feels really addictive and I enjoy all the deck’s synergies and the funky style of outramping the green decks. And I’ve had that feeling with a few other decks, like my Gogo or Q. It’s a wonderful feeling. Of feeling like your deck is perfect. When’s the last time you guys felt like that? Felt like you had made a “perfect” deck? One made for you.


r/EDH • • 5h ago

Discussion Help me understand what I did wrong

24 Upvotes

I need help understanding the stack and what I did wrong during a game.

To preface, Im a new player, Ive been playing Magic for years, but only started playing Commander a few months ago.

The other day I was playing with a few people that have all been playing for a few years now, the guy in rotation before me was in his first main phase and plays [[One, Borg Evolved]]. He taps his mana, plays the card and reads off what all the card was and did. After he is done, he goes to tap more mana to play another card and I go 'before you play anything else, in response to the creature you just played, Im going to play [[Pongify]]' and I tap my mana and play the card. As I do I immediately get fussed at by another guy at the table and told that I can't just play that card, that I have to wait until there is a phase change before cards like pongify can be cast and I need to learn how to stack works.

Can someone clear this up for me, how do creatures and the stack work?


r/EDH • • 16h ago

Discussion What is your favorite color /color combo?

21 Upvotes

This is just a post for me to yap about enjoying MTG.

Im Izzet until I die, I love combo and storm too much. I built orzhov aristocrat vampire tribal just so I can play low power games with a combo finisher.

I run a [[Rielle, the Everwise]] deck that I plan to turn cEDH. Its more frail than the heavy hitters of the format but its pure value potential is unmatched. Where its not quite possible to be turbo, it does run looots of infinites, it's very toolboxy. Between copy spells, redundant effects, and fat card draw, Rielle can just dig for any assortment of pieces. Then just pilot the win correctly.

My other deck is [[Clavileño, First of the Blessed]] and honestly I might scrap this low power deck to just make it full aristocrat combo. It aims to leverage cheap attackers into card draw and 4/3s to sustain value while chunking at health totals a bit. With the help of pingers and damage naturally occuring, this deck then pivots to its wincon: the combo turn. With a sac outlet and a pinger I just need a doubler like [[Teysa Karlov]] or mass reanimate like [[Living Death]] and its not hard to chunk each opponent for 20 life or so.

Izzet storm will never not be my bread and butter.

Aristocrats has definitely peaked my interest, Clav may just become a Markov Aristocrats deck.

I like a deck that has a set "win turn". It helps me navigate games a lot better when I have a determined win as opposed to creature strats that aim to go wide or cheat a board.


r/EDH • • 8h ago

Discussion I feel like liliana's caress effects are so bad for discard decks... (rant)

19 Upvotes

I built a Tinybones deck that I've always wanted to build since I pulled him from a pack in the first Jumpstart set.

I watched a bunch of videos on how to build the deck, and all of them tell you to include "whenever an opponent discards a card, they lose X life / take X damage" effects.

It feels weird, ngl, since my plan is to get everyone to hellbent and basically turn off my own enchantment. I can see effects like that in wheels decks, since everyone is constantly drawing and discarding, but in pure discard, I feel like I'd rather run anything else instead.

Like, let's think about it: if I drop [ Liliana's Caress ] on turn 2 and my opponents each have 6 cards in hand, sure, I can deal 12 to 16 damage—but after that, it just turns off once they're hellbent, and it starts feeling like an enchantment that does nothing at all.

So I spent my turn 2 making a tempo-negative play that disables itself when I actually achieve my game plan, when I could've played a threat, more discard, more removal, etc. And don't even get me started on topdecking it in the mid-to-late game—it feels truly awful.

Sure, my opponents will eventually draw more cards so I can get some extra chip damage in, but it feels like I'm adding a random side quest to my game for no reason.


r/EDH • • 4h ago

Discussion Urza Lord High Artificer in bracket 3?

18 Upvotes

[[Urza Lord High Artificer]]

I know Urza has a very powerful reputation for good reason. If I made my deck without any stax and without any infinite combos, would it be too strong for bracket 3?

I want to make it budget anyways, and just go for combat damage wins beat down, big artifacts deck, but Im socially aware enough to not make people groan at me asking to try it out. Even with just combat damage I wasn't sure if Urza is still too efficient of an engine? Cause I was planning on adding spellskite, lightning greaves, a few counterspells etc for protection. I just don't want to annoy the randoms I play against at the new shop I've been going to.

Anyone here have experience with a lower powered Urza? And If it's too powerful for bracket 3, can I get some suggestions for another artifact commander y'all like here?

Edit: thank you for all the replies. I found out I'm an idiot cause I didn't know [[Urza, Chief Artificer]] exists. And that's so much better for the power level of what I want to play. I figure I can potentially make it a bracket 2 deck if I want to as well, which is a big benefit because everyone at the shop plays b2-3


r/EDH • • 56m ago

Question What deck really wants Necropotence (in bracket 3)?

16 Upvotes

I know, I know, one of the most generically powerful cards ever printed, and the correct answer is probably “any deck that can reliably create three black mana”.

I picked up a beautiful foil copy at Magic Con on a whim and I would like to do it justice. I’m interested to hear about any commanders that use and abuse Necropotence to its full potential. I don’t see it often in bracket 3 games but when it does come down, it draws a lot of attention, so I’d like to find a way to use it beyond just pure value, especially since catching stray hits in combat is more meaningful the lower you go in power level.

My first thought was [[Teval, the Balanced Scale]], if you pay something like 30 into it and discard down to 7 at end of turn each exile trigger creates a zombie token, so it’s essentially pay 3 black and X life for an army in a can (plus the best 7 cards in the top X of your library).

Any other fun applications?


r/EDH • • 10h ago

Deck Help Recently started playing, build deck and lost every game

12 Upvotes

Hello, I only started playing recently after my partner introduced me to the game and started building what I thought was a pretty decent first deck, here it is, but regardless of what deck of him I play against I’m losing every round.
I’ve read the rules and looked through the subreddits for quite some time and do win if I play some of his decks so I don’t think it’s a lack of knowledge, it’s just that my deck isn’t good enough.
Thing is I have a hard time cutting and replacing cards because I don’t know what would work best, so I thought that maybe I could ask here and gain a few helpful suggestions and the like!
I do want to keep it mono-black and I think I’ve gained an emotional attachment to Vito so I’d hate to replace him, but I’m open to any criticism that you guys can think of.
TIA
-JJ


r/EDH • • 17h ago

Question LF Tips for Finding Cards to Slot In

8 Upvotes

TL;DR: Without digging through hundreds of other peoples' decks on edhrec or similar, how can I better search for and select cards that would make my deck competent?

After looking at MtG through the window for a long time, I've finally found a group where I could play Commander with. I love the deckbuilding aspect of the format but when I bring them into the game, you can tell there is a big power gap. I see that my board is slow or that I run out of hand while they are setting up engines and creating scary boards by turn 4/5. Granted, I'm pretty new to Magic but I've played Cardfight! Vanguard and Shadowverse and the Yugioh Tag Force games so I'm pretty familiar with card games at least.

Anyway, in an effort to catch up, I've watched deckbuilding videos and I think I've become familiar enough with the concept of synergy and building around your commander and using the oracle tags on Scryfall. But a lot of said videos are also naming cards which I am only becoming aware of for the first time. And I'm like, "Wow, how did I never see or think of this?"

Which brings me to my main question: How can I better search for and select cards that would make my deck competent? I'd rather not look at other decklists because 1) There's a lot and a lot of them don't exactly sort by what their cards do for the deck (usually it's sorted by card type) and 2) That doesn't exactly translate well when I want to move on to a new deck that has a different gameplan or colors, or when it's a commander that's not popular

Decks I've constructed. Note: These decks were constructed using the group's regular tournament rules in mind: Bracket 2, 100$ dollar budget (TCGPlayer).

As an exercise, I'm looking to build two other decks:

  • Otaku Golbez - [[Golbez, Crystal Collector]] that would ideally win using [[Luck Bobblehead]], but not opposed to using regular Golbez strats. May have cards that trade your stuff with your opps'
  • Christmas Time - Some red-green (optionally also white) deck and a gameplay that revolves around gifting stuff to other players.

r/EDH • • 4h ago

Deck Showcase Show off your old border decks

7 Upvotes

I love old-border cards, especially from Antiquities, and I’d love to see your creations for inspiration.

I have an old-border Sliver Queen deck myself, and I’m always looking for ways to improve it. I’m already planning to swap out a couple of cards for cheap mana counter spells like [[Daze]] and [[Mana Leak]]. I honestly prefer the classic old-border aesthetic, but [[Lavabelly Sliver]] is just too powerful not to include.

Here’s the decklist if anyone wants to check it out!
https://moxfield.com/decks/Kn-t8-mjOU6fUV3PmhHM8w


r/EDH • • 6h ago

Deck Help Mono-White Mana Ramp/Removal Suggestions pls

5 Upvotes

Here is my newest baby:

Ghalta the Defender

I won my first three games with this Deck! But knowing the deck list I assume it needs more ramp/removal. I think there is enough draw and AoE. I just know having almost no targeted removal for enchantments/artifacts/etc, will be a problem. Please share your thoughts!


r/EDH • • 6h ago

Question Self discard/wheel commander recs?

5 Upvotes

I’m looking to build self discard deck as it’s one of the 2 archetypes I would say I’m missing for graveyard/reanimator/aristocrats strategies except for something artifact related. I tried [[Celes, rune knight]] because I really enjoyed the play pattern of being able to shape my hand and yard with her etb I just struggled with what to do with the rest of the deck as I don’t care for making another persist combo deck as I already have one of those. Maybe wheels could work as well.


r/EDH • • 1h ago

Discussion How do you play Y'shtola?

4 Upvotes

So I have a Y'shtola deck, and I've built here is a generic, boring, very commander dependent way. Kill spells, stax pieces, mana rocks, pillow fort, and a small amount of equipment to help her hit harder.

Problem is that the deck really doesn't "win" unless my opponents are playing attack heavy creature decks. In a game with another control deck, nothing really happens.

More over, I always get complaints from my pod when ever I pull her out.

My current idea is a Goad-esk strategy to incentive my opponents attacking each other, but I was wondering if anyone else had ideas how to make her?


r/EDH • • 15h ago

Social Interaction At the Singapore airport LF 1 or 2 for a couple commander games.

4 Upvotes

At the Singapore airport LF 1 or 2 for a couple commander games. 2 of us here now till tomorrow morning. Bracket 3 is mostly what we have on us but we're fine with Bracket 2 or 4. Will have a room here too but there are tons of good spots to play. Hit me up


r/EDH • • 2h ago

Deck Help Selesnya Angels Help!

3 Upvotes

I’ve been playing [[Giada, Font of Hope]] for a while and wanted to switch things up with [[Sigarda, Font of Blessings]]. I’m hoping to have a deck that’s a little easier to ramp up and offers a bit more protection.

The plan is to go full aggro with Angels while slowing opponents down with a few stax pieces.
The tutors are primarily there to help me consistently assemble [[Brisela, Voice of Nightmares]] by finding [[Bruna, the Fading Light]] and [[Gisela, the Broken Blade]]. They can also grab protection pieces like [[Avacyn, Angel of Hope]], [[Darksteel Angel]], or [[Shalai, Voice of Plenty]] when needed.

I’m also torn between running [[Finale of Devastation]] or [[Chord of Calling]]. I like the instant speed flexibility and convoke on Chord, but Finale makes for such a good finisher. Which would you recommend for this deck?

I’d appreciate any suggestions on cuts, additions, or general improvements! I have also tagged all cards in the deck currently to help explain choices I’ve made if that helps.

Thanks!

Decklist: Host of the Heavens


r/EDH • • 2h ago

Discussion Jean-Luc Picard, Luminary

3 Upvotes

I've just picked up the precon and am enjoying the play style and theme of this deck. Having been a fan of TNG, seeing all the characters and ships is great thematically. However, I do want to upgrade it while keeping the space theme. Nothing crazy just perhaps some space craft etc.

How are people playing this commander? Are you sticking with spacecraft, or building artifact engines? Curious to hear peoples opinions.

[[Jean-Luc Picard, Luminary]]


r/EDH • • 4h ago

Question Cards like Infested Thrinax?

3 Upvotes

I"m looking for cards like [[Infested Thrinax]] that basically make up for getting board-wiped. Not sure exactly what to search for on scryfall as far as tags. I see [[One with the Kami]] and [[Tobias, Doomed Conqueror]].

Anything else with a similar effect?


r/EDH • • 8h ago

Deck Help How to make Ashnod, Flesh Mechanist decent in B3 ?

3 Upvotes

Hi,

Disclaimer : potato english.

I'm looking for advices with my [[Ashnod, Flesh Mechanist]] deck and how to make it stronger in order to hold in B3. Actually, it's mostly a B2, and make the table scared by the fast mana, since i mulligan until a get a fodder on turn 2 and 3 most of the times.

For deckbuilding, i put myself some rules : no gamechanger, no card > 5€ and budget should be around 60-75€ as well.

Decklist : https://moxfield.com/decks/JXhpY0kL4UuUPrGP5U5mrw

I tried to go with a lot on the activated abilities direction instead of an full artifacts deck, and the "Card leaving the graveyard" theme, but i'm struggling right now. So, how can i make this better ?


r/EDH • • 11h ago

Question I need suggestions.

3 Upvotes

Yall probably see posts like this all the time, but I need suggestions.

I’ve played magic for about ~5 years, started playing commander about 1-2 years ago. Unfortunately it’s been largely 1v1s with my friend, but over the past few months we’ve gotten the opportunities and time to play in some pods and hit up our LGS. I build my own decks, and proxy my own cards because this hobby’s too expensive lol.

I need deck suggestions :) like a lot of people, I end up scrolling edhrec a lot, get nowhere. But I also get tunnel visioned a lot, and stuck in thinking so many decks theoretically play the “same” even though they’re obviously unique. Just a me thing 🤷🏻‍♂️

I play mid bracket 3 - low/mid bracket 4 (give or take some game changers, but Overall pretty good power)

So far I’ve built:

• Vivi - Rarely play it - high power b4
• Toph, the first metalbender - landfall + artifacts, b3
• Pantlaza Sun favored - blink focused - just every Dino but it can pop off like a b4
• Primo the unbounded - 0/0 creatures - b3
• Tam, the possibility - Super friends - new. I’d estimate high b3 low b4
• Rin and Seri inseparable - made a custom proxy and got it signed by the characters VA. Just a bunch of kitties, go wide. My newest

I have an obvious trend with Naya, which I don’t want a 4th naya deck haha. I tend to win heavily by combat, which is fine but I wanna mix it up. I like higher complexity decks, that make me think. But also it’s always fun just seeing stuff work. Just don’t want it to feel the same every match, given why me and my friends play decent power but not high b4.

At the moment I was thinking building Lord of Riots, but in my mind I think “that’s basically rakdos primo”. Maybe mono red Kratos, but idk. Suggestions everyone :) whats your fav deck? Any tips to add some creativity to myself haha.

Thanks for reading.
TLDR: Any commander suggestions? / whats your fav / most fun / most underrated deck?


r/EDH • • 18h ago

Discussion Don't play with your food.... Story of an epic Self-Immolation!

3 Upvotes

In what can only be considered a cautionary tale of forgetting how the stack operates, let me present to you tonight's incredible facepalm.

Still giving some play-testing to my (fairly) recently completed first homebrew, an assassin deck led by Ezio Auditore. The LGS had a Star Trek specific event last night, thus I couldn't go and try the deck out with my pod for FNM, so have been playing it on Manabrew this evening against 3 AI opponents (I still don't trust playing randoms online!). What can I say, I'm excited to try it out! I'll skip a lot of the setup and get to the good bit.

I was comfortably in a winning position against the last remaining opponent (I didn't quite have lethal damage on the board against them, but nearly so), and had just finally drawn my Lab Man + Leveler combo for the very first time. I also had Sorin Markov in-hand, and could have cast him to combo off with Ezio and get the win... but I've already done that a couple times, so thought it would be fun to win with the other combo this time instead. I also had Basim Ibn Ishaq in play, who draws a card whenever you cast a Historic spell, so decided to first play Lab Man, and then Leveler, knowing the latter would trigger Basim's draw ability, thus win me the game. And was then promptly reminded the stack doesn't work like that; Basim's draw triggered *before* Leveler exiled my library... oops! So I'm left with an even more impressive board state, and empty library. Opponent is on 30+ life, and I decide NOT to swing out because I wanted the combo to trigger on my following upkeep, knowing he couldn't possibly hope to hit me for creature damage, even if he played a couple bruisers with haste next turn.

He proceeds to cast Living Death, and won since I decked out on my next upkeep, with Lab Man busy cooling his heels in exile! The only thing that made this whole ordeal worse is that it was against AI opponents, and so nobody but me was there to enjoy the sheer boneheaded nature of my play. Well, hopefully this mediocre retelling of the story here will serve as a reminder for folks... forget how the stack operates at your peril!


r/EDH • • 1h ago

Deck Help Cheap card draw engine into Toughness-Matters deck

2 Upvotes

Hi, my first commander deck was Abzan Armor and I still LOVE IT! I already made quite a few changes to make it 100% toughness matters deck, but only problem I have sometimes is that my board have many lands and not enough cards in hand to play.

Sometimes I dont have Felothar to tap and sometimes I dont have creatures to spare. Its not like its every game, but Im looking for some card draw engine in this theme that would prevent these scenarios.

I will appriciate any tip!

also thers the deck if you are interested:

https://moxfield.com/decks/eD9xWg2Cu0CNVtiKd6ProQ