Sorry for the rant:
So I yesterday played in a Bracket 3-only Commander event at a LGS. There were prizes on the line (Some boosters, Promos and ither accessories like Gamegenic squires), so while the decks were restricted to Bracket 3, people were obviously playing to win.
Now, I understand that Commander is generally a social format. People joke around, watch games, and occasionally discuss plays. That's all part of the fun but there's a difference between spectating a game and actively participating in one you're not playing.
Enter this one guy.
Throughout the event, he was constantly hovering around different pods, watching games and inserting himself into decisions. Pointing out lines of play, suggesting what players should do, and generally providing unsolicited strategic advice and it wasn't just our pod. He was doing this to other tables as well.
At one point, he even revealed information about a card in another player's hand.
Like, dude. Seriously?
We're playing an event with prizes on the line. Hidden information is part of the game. You don't get to stand behind someone and effectively become their fifth player, especially when your commentary can influence the outcome. Eventually, I'd had enough and politely asked him to stop backseat planeswalking.
Apparently, I was out of line.
He got upset that I'd called him out, and rather than simply stepping away and letting people play their games, he started making an issue out of it and caused a scene. Something about the spirit of gathering I honestly couldn't remember, but I eventually called the store owner because now we are the last pod to finish and we have to pause the game because dude is now making a point to argue with me.
Eventually, I had to get the store owner involved and ask him to tell this guy to stop interfering with other pods.
His defence?
"It's casual!"
No, We're playing in an organised event. There are prizes on the line. just because it's b3 doesn't mean its casual, even if it is, it is still a massive dick move to come from outside the game and start revealing peoples hands, playing and tapping their lands for them and more.
But wait, there's more.
Because apparently the Commander gods have a sense of humor, the very next round I get paired into the same pod as this guy.
And wouldn't you know it, he proceeds to spend pretty much the entire game targeting me.
For SIX turns, almost every piece of interaction he has goes straight at my board.
Meanwhile, there's a Lathril player casually building an entire elven civilisation on the other side of the table. Elves everywhere.
But nope. Apparently, I'm the threat.
So I play through it.
Eventually, I manage to get myself into a position where I can eliminate a player.
Raph and Mikey go brrrr.
And naturally, after six turns of having my board treated like his personal punching bag, I decide to swing at him.
And this man has the AUDACITY to complain that I'M unfairly targeting HIM.
My guy, you've spent the last six turns throwing everything you have at me to make sure I am behind, while Lathril has been assembling the entire elven population of Kaldheim. Every single removal and counterspell dude had was pointed at me.
But apparently, when I finally get to do something about it, suddenly we're concerned about fair play and the spirit of casual Commander.
And that's really what frustrated me about the whole experience.
I don't care if someone targets me. I don't care if someone knocks me out of a game. That's Magic.
What I do care about is people who seem to think "casual" means they can interfere with other people's games, take things personally when asked to stop, and then complain when the consequences of their own gameplay decisions come back around.