redlib.
Feeds

MAIN FEEDS

Home Popular All
reddit

You are about to leave Redlib

Do you want to continue?

https://www.reddit.com/r/IndoAryan/controversial

No, go back! Yes, take me to Reddit
settings settings
Hot New Top Rising Controversial

r/IndoAryan • u/Icy_Function_5839 • 18h ago

Linguistics The cool script of the lions of Jammu & Kashmir: Namey Dogri Akkhar!

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes
0 comments

r/IndoAryan • u/Proper-Progress1691 • 15h ago

Linguistics Expensive 🤑🤑

Post image
47 Upvotes
23 comments

r/IndoAryan • u/Proper-Progress1691 • 6h ago

Linguistics Do you speak a p- Indo-Aryan language or do you spell an h- Indo-Aryan language? Grouping Indo-Aryan languages based on if their word for the colour yellow are cognates.

Post image
12 Upvotes
1 comment

r/IndoAryan • u/Proper-Progress1691 • 19h ago

Question Do people in this sub even understand the difference between tatsamas and tadbhavas in New Indo-Aryan languages?

13 Upvotes

Why don’t people understand the concept of Sanskrit borrowings (ie., tatsama) and natural descendant words (ie., tadbhava) from Middle Indo-Aryan Prakrits and Apabhramshas, in this sub?

5 comments
Subreddit
Icon for r/IndoAryan

IndoAryan

r/IndoAryan

"Spirit of the Cosmic Rhythm 卐 Spirit of the Wolf." CASTE SYSTEM MUST BE ENDED. A sub dedicated to the IA ethno-linguistic subdivision of the IndoIranian branch of the IE language family.

5.8k
2.8k
194
Sidebar
Subreddit Rules
1. Avoid Hate and Harassment

Treat all members with dignity.

Content targeting individuals or groups based on ethnicity, political beliefs, sexual orientation, religion, nationality, or regional identity is not permitted.

Keep discussions constructive.

Address ideas and topics rather than attacking other users personally. Attempts to identify or expose the real-world identities of community members are prohibited.

2. Do not post Unrelated to IndoAryan

Stay On Topic and Use Proper Flair

Posts should be relevant to the community's focus. Use the "Off Topic" flair for content that doesn't directly relate to the main subject matter. Unrelated content is only acceptable when it's tangentially related and serves an educational purpose. Alt-History posting are not allowed.

3. Opinion not supported by reliable sources

Support opinions and factual claims with credible sources. Reliable sources include peer-reviewed academic papers, books by established authors, and fact-checked reporting from reputable news organizations. Personal websites, opinion pieces, and editorial content do not qualify as reliable sources.

When sharing original research or personal analysis that isn't based on established sources, use the "Original Research" flair to indicate you're seeking community feedback on preliminary work.

4. Adding transliterations and translations

For scripts other than Latin, please add transliterations (preferably ISO 15919 or Harvard-Kyoto) and translation (if known) as not everyone would be able to read the script or understand the language.

Example:

Is টাকা (ṭākā/TAkA) a native word or a loanword?

Etymology of त्योहार (tyohār/tyohAr, festival)?

Any native word in Panjabi for ਜ਼ਿਆਦਾ (ziādā/ziAdA) ?

Etymology of କୋଡ଼ିଏ (koṛie/koRie, twenty) in Odia?

If not good with transliterations, one can use Google translate.

5. Spam and Trolling

Stay Focused on IndoAryan Studies

Content must relate to the scientific study of IndoAryan peoples. For content that is only loosely connected to this field, use the "Off Topic" flair. Spam and completely unrelated posts are not permitted.

No Trolling or Disruptive Behavior

Deliberately provocative posts or comments intended to upset or antagonize other community members constitute trolling and will not be tolerated. This behavior is considered a form of cyberbullying.

6. Porn is not allowed

No adult content even when related to IndoAryan.

7. Avoid Polemics

Avoid arguing merely for the sake of debate. For instance: Avestan is not derived from Sanskrit; Sanskrit or Tamil are not the oldest language in the world; and while proto-languages are not directly attested, their reconstruction follows rigorous linguistic methodology. These are well-established facts—do not dispute them without scholarly basis. See rule #3 for further clarity.

8. Avoid Politics of any kind.

No discussions of current political events—South Asian or otherwise. Focus solely on historical politics, and only when relevant to IA. Be sure to distinguish clearly between IA ideology and the academic study of IA.

9. No Meta posts about the sub

No meta posts or comments about the subreddit—violations will result in an immediate ban.

10. AI Contents

We strongly discourage AI-generated articles. We don't allow articles generated directly by giving a prompt like "Hi ChatGPT, what's the first language of India?" However, we accept AI grammar-corrected and paraphrased articles that don't add additional informational content. We also accept questions asking for a "peer review" of content by an AI system, like the sample question above. For AI summarized articles, should mention it. Do a thorough human-check for all of the above.

11. Neutral post titles

When sharing linguistic, genetic or historical research or maps, it’s important to use neutral, descriptive titles that reflect the scholarly nature of the content.

Neutral, descriptive titles that accurately represent the content

Focus on factual, scholarly information

Avoidance of inflammatory language that might detract from the educational value, inflammatory post tiles will be removed.

12. National boundaries and maps

Any boundaries shown on any map on this Subreddit should only be interpreted as indicating the scope of the dataset used (for generating the map) and should not necessarily be interpreted as favoring any definitive political or national boundary claims. Any discussions on boundaries shown on maps should be strictly related to IndoAryan and should not be related to current geopolitics. (Please see Rules #7 and #8 regarding polemics and politics, respectively.)

13. Guidance on maps

See Rule #12, Whenever possible, please try to post maps that do not show national boundaries (e.g., https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Blank_map_of_the_Indian_subcontinent.svg and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:South_Asia_non_political,_with_rivers.jpg show the Indian subcontinent without explicit national boundaries). However, this is not a requirement because map-generating tools may not necessarily have options to generate such maps without boundaries.

14. Guidance on Reposts and Cross-posting

Please avoid reposting discussions already posted unless there is any new insight on the topic.

Avoid cross-posting, we encourage original content in this subreddit. However, if there is a post on another subreddit that is very relevant to this subreddit, please send a modmail with the link to that post (on the other subreddit) and request the moderators to cross-post it.

15. Banning Guidelines

While moderators reserve the right to issue immediate bans at their discretion, we typically follow a progressive disciplinary process for most violations. However, abusive language directed at moderators and meta posts or commentary about the subreddit will result in immediate bans without following the standard escalation process.

Standard Escalation Process 1. First offense: Warning and/or 3-day ban 2. Second offense: 3-day and/or 30-day ban 3. Third offense: 30-day or permanent ban.

Language subs
  • r/sanskrit 37k
  • r/Hindi 217k
  • r/Urdu 53k
  • r/bengalilanguage 33k
  • r/punjabi 64k
Show 5 more
  • r/marathi 28k
  • r/Bhojpuriyas 2.9k
  • r/Odia 1.5k
  • r/hindustanilanguage 2.5k
  • r/Kauravi 125
Language subs 2
  • r/pali 1.9k
  • r/Sindhi 803
  • r/nepali 650
  • r/sinhala 852
  • r/Rajasthanilanguage 138
Show 4 more
  • r/kashmirilang 2.7k
  • r/konkani 4.0k
  • r/dogri 26
  • r/PahadiLinguistics 561
Related communities
  • r/IndoEuropean 20k
  • r/IndoIranian 315
  • r/Kalderash 746
  • r/Dravidiology 19k
  • r/SouthAsianAncestry 12k
Show 5 more
  • r/phenotypesSouthAsia 3.0k
  • r/Austroasiatic 321
  • r/austronesian 3.8k
  • r/ r/sinotibetan 321
  • r/ r/burushaski 194

2cd8ea8 ⓘ View instance info