EDIT: To clarify further, I am not trying to get paid out on mods that were not on the policy. I am not seeking the $1000 benefit for modifications. I am not trying to get paid for modifications, or any part of the vehicle, and removing them with the intention of lying. I am seeking that a stock car insured should be paid out as such, and salvage retention price reflects the same stock car price, not a modified car that wasn’t covered. I am not looking to inflate values, or have any intentions of fraud. I am trying to learn and understand if Progressive has a right to include things they did not insure for valuation. That being said, I am willing to remove mods that were not on the policy, with Progressive being aware that I am removing them, BEFORE ACV is determined.
\- Location: Florida USA
I’m dealing with a somewhat unusual total-loss situation and would appreciate input from insurance adjusters or anyone familiar with Progressive’s total loss process, particularly in Florida.
I own a heavily modified 2018 BMW M3 that sustained freshwater flood damage. Progressive has inspected the vehicle and confirmed it’s a total loss. I intend to retain the salvage and eventually rebuild the car.
The adjuster has requested a complete inventory of my aftermarket modifications, along with purchase invoices if available, before they can finalize the vehicle’s ACV.
Here’s my dilemma:
My understanding is that my Progressive policy includes only $1,000 in aftermarket equipment coverage. The vehicle has substantially more than that invested in modifications, including an aftermarket turbo system, fueling upgrades, and various other performance components.
The adjuster explained that Florida salvage retention values are determined through salvage bids, with buybacks typically ranging from 30–60% of the vehicle’s ACV.
My concern is that providing an extensive modification inventory and invoices could result in a substantially higher salvage bid, since the salvage buyer would be valuing a heavily modified performance car rather than a stock BMW.
However, if my policy only compensates me for up to $1,000 of aftermarket equipment, I could end up paying thousands more to retain my own car because of modifications that Progressive isn’t actually compensating me for.
For example, hypothetically:
Stock vehicle ACV: $43,500
Additional aftermarket compensation: $1,000
Stock vehicle salvage bid: $17,400
Salvage bid accounting for expensive modifications: $22,000+
In that scenario, providing the modifications could increase my payout by $1,000 but increase my salvage retention cost by $4,600 or more, leaving me financially worse off.
My questions are:
- Am I contractually obligated to provide Progressive with a complete aftermarket modification inventory and purchase invoices if I’m not seeking additional compensation for those modifications - especially since they werent disclosed to progressive pre incident?
- Does the $1,000 aftermarket equipment limit actually cap the additional value payable in a total loss settlement, or can modifications increase the vehicle’s payable ACV beyond that limit?
- Is it standard practice for salvage buyers to factor aftermarket equipment into their bids even when that equipment isn’t separately covered by the insurance policy?
- Can I elect to have the vehicle valued as a stock M3 for both the payout and salvage retention calculation, rather than claim any additional aftermarket equipment value?
- If I ultimately surrendered the vehicle instead, could I replace the aftermarket components with equivalent OEM parts and retain my modifications, assuming the arrangement was agreed upon before settlement?
I’m not looking to misrepresent the vehicle’s condition or provide false information. I’m trying to understand whether I’m required to pursue a valuation that could potentially work against my financial interests.
My reasoning is that if Progressive is essentially compensating me for a stock M3, it seems inconsistent for the salvage valuation to include thousands of dollars of aftermarket equipment that isn’t being compensated.
I’ve already asked my adjuster whether the modification inventory affects both ACV and salvage retention, or only the ACV. I’m awaiting a response.
I’d particularly appreciate insight from Progressive adjusters, total loss specialists, or anyone familiar with how salvage bids and custom equipment coverage interact.
Am I misunderstanding how the $1,000 coverage limit works, or is this a legitimate concern when retaining a heavily modified total loss vehicle?