I'm seeking advice from insurance adjusters or anyone experienced with disputed liability claims, particularly when both drivers have the same insurance company.
****
TL;DR: I was involved in a T-bone collision while traveling through a green light. The other driver, also insured by GEICO, claims we were traveling on the same street and that I struck her while she was turning left. She has a supporting witness who claims she was pumping gas nearby, but no witness approached us at the scene, to my knowledge. I believe the damage photos contradict their version. GEICO is trying to hold me liable. I'm waiting on traffic and Flock camera footage while personally contacting businesses and residents for surveillance video. My biggest frustration is repeatedly having to explain the same facts to GEICO without feeling that my evidence or concerns are being consistently understood or addressed. How can I get a thorough review of the evidence?
Photo evidence https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1LqFanP3Y8bDQm4nzoMLyFrJCIAgF8PY-
****
I'm in California, and I'm concerned about how GEICO is investigating an accident where the drivers have fundamentally different accounts.
- What happened — November 5, approximately 11:40 a.m.
- I was traveling southbound on 29th Street, a one-way street in Sacramento.
- I entered the intersection of 29th and J Street with a green light.
- The other driver was traveling eastbound on J Street, also a one-way street, and entered the intersection from my right.
- I attempted to brake but couldn't stop in time, and the front of my black Honda struck the side of her white Chevrolet Malibu in a T-bone collision.
- My husband was a passenger in my car. The other driver was alone.
- We pulled over onto J Street and exchanged driver's licenses and insurance information.
- No witnesses approached us or identified themselves at the scene, to my knowledge.
- We did not call the police at the scene.
- I filed a claim with GEICO approximately two hours later.
- I subsequently filed a police report after learning that the other driver was providing an entirely different account of the accident.
2. The other driver's version and her witness claim:
- We were BOTH traveling southbound on 29th Street.
- She was making a left turn onto J Street.
- I allegedly sped up and struck her vehicle while she was turning.
- A witness who claims to have been pumping gas at the corner gas station supports her account.
3. Why I'm questioning the physical evidence
I have photographs of both vehicles' damage that I believe are inconsistent with the other driver's account.
- The damage to my black Honda is concentrated on the FRONT-RIGHT side, not the front-left.
- If both vehicles were traveling southbound and she was turning left, I would expect different points of impact.
- I believe the damage is more consistent with my account of a T-bone collision involving vehicles approaching from perpendicular streets.
I've asked GEICO to:
- Have additional qualified personnel or a specialty team review the damage photographs.
- Evaluate the points of impact under both versions of the accident.
- Consider whether accident reconstruction software or another reconstruction method could help explain the damage.
- Explain how the actual damage could be consistent with the other driver's version.
The supervisor told me they don't have accident reconstruction software available and that she would show the photographs to her team for their
Photos-
https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1LqFanP3Y8bDQm4nzoMLyFrJCIAgF8PY-
4. My concerns about the witness
The witness claims she was pumping gas at a station on the corner of 29th and J Street when she observed the collision.
Here's what concerns me:
- No witness approached us at the scene, as far as I observed.
- She claims to have been at a specific location that might be independently verifiable.
- I asked GEICO whether they could verify her presence through a gas purchase receipt or other documentation.
- GEICO indicated they generally don't investigate to that extent and are relying on her statement.
I've also formally asked GEICO to question the witness further:
- When did she approach the driver or drivers?
- Where were the drivers when she approached them?
- How many people were involved in the accident?
- If she only spoke with one driver, where was the other driver?
- Why did she not approach while both drivers were still at the scene?
The supervisor has agreed to personally contact the witness.
I understand that a witness isn't required to approach the scene or provide a receipt. However, if her statement is the deciding factor in assigning liability, shouldn't GEICO make some reasonable effort to verify her location and ability to observe the collision?
5. Evidence I'm actively trying to obtain
I'm still waiting for requested camera footage, including:
- Traffic/street camera footage from the area.
- Flock camera footage that may have captured the vehicles traveling before the collision.
In the meantime, I've been personally contacting businesses and residents along both streets to find surveillance footage that could establish where each vehicle was traveling immediately before the accident.
6. My biggest frustration with GEICO's handling of this claim
My frustration isn't simply about how long this is taking. It's that I've spoken with GEICO so many times, yet there doesn't seem to be a consistent understanding of the accident, the conflicting accounts, or the evidence I'm asking them to evaluate.
7. Additional concerns I've raised with GEICO
The driver also has a pattern of bad driving behavior. A res light violation and driving and texting in the last 12 months. Her car has been impounded twice. She has an expired paper license on her car today.
Thank you to anyone willing to share their experience or professional insight.
---