r/Insurance • u/Sea-Path5087 • 19h ago
BMW Employee Totaled My Car
Location: Houston, TX
I took my car in to a BMW service center on October 24th to get my routine maintenance done. When I came back to pick up my car I was told that while one of their technicians was driving the car he got into an accident. I was told that the other driver ran a stop sign causing the accident. A few moments later they pulled my car into the service center and the front bumper had all the damage. They said they would take car of the repairs and put me in a loaner car.
A few days later I called my service advisor and he said that the other driver's insurance found that driver at fault but they were only willing to pay for 75% of the repair. He said they were trying to get that figured out first and didn't have an ETA on when I should get my repairs done, because insurance can sometimes take weeks, but I'm able to keep my loaner in the meantime.
Fast forward to November 19th I still haven't reached any update or communication on my car. I decided to send an email to corporate, the parent company as well as the VP of BMW detailing the situation. An hour later I received a call from the service center's general manager and asked me for details on what happened. I let him know and he said he would call the body shop in the morning and get back to me.
The next morning I then get a call from the sales manager saying the insurance company has said my car is a total loss and someone will come out early next week to do a walkthrough and get evaluation of my car. I do not have gao insurance all I have is car replacement assistance coverage. When I told him this he said we will wait until they say how much they will value the car and we will look at options from there. I told him in that moment that I did not feel like I should have to pay for anything out of pocket as my car was under BMW's possession at the time of the accident.
Later that night I get a call from the service advisor. He also tells me that my car has been totaled. He then says that since insurance has found the other driver at fault that BMW is not financially responsible for anything.
At this point I'm not sure what to do. I am looking into getting an attorney but is he right that BMW isn't responsible? I was also advised by a friend to not go and get any of my belongings out of the car yet because that could be agreeing to my car being totaled and releasing my car. Is that true as well? I need a few things out of my car but I know Texas laws are different than what I'm used to
since I had no communication from the service center I never received any information such as a police report, the employee who was driving the car, the other driver, their insurance, or an insurance claim number. When it first happened I called my insurance and they told me that since BMW is handling everything that I don't need to do anything additional. Because of this I still don't have any info and when I requested it in an email the sales manager told me they were working on it and the advisor that called later said he will have to ask a manager because there may be legalities where they can't share certain information.