r/MuseumPros • u/SealedRoute • 8h ago
The Lucas Museum is weird
Below are “spoilers,” insofar as those exist for a museum. If you want to be surprised, please evacuate immediately.
The first gallery you encounter is, I guess, a primer for the rest. It’s supposed to be about the origins of narrative art. Unlike the rest of the museum, it has the suggestion of linear structure, placing you on a prescribed path. It’s mostly reproductions of the most famous art objects in history. The Venus of Willendorf is there, or its image at least, turning slowly on a screen. A miniature reproduction of the Sistine Chapel is early on. It’s organized chronologically until it isn’t. Enormous three-dimensional lamassu follow a Rosetti painting, which itself is next to a German Renaissance sculpture of St. Sebastian. It suggests that every fabricated decorative or ritual object in any visual medium, across history and all human cultures, is narrative art. A pretty wide net.
The Star Wars gallery is cool. Pew pews, but their extraordinary detail, suitable for stop-motion scrutiny, is evident.
The rest is loosely subdivided. Some galleries are dedicated to specific artists, like Maxfield Parrish or Frank Frazetta and his big-bosomed babes in metal bikinis riding lizards. Others are thematic, including topics like “Sports.” The effect is encyclopedic, both in terms of comprehensiveness and lack of discrimination. Frida Kahlo is there, one of her greatest self-portraits and the only one in a permanent, publicly accessible collection in Los Angeles, a city that worships her.
The works are presented context-free, beyond thematic grouping. This may be the most interesting choice Lucas made, and the one where you can tell that he decided to forego hiring a trained director. The only words you find on the walls are categorical—Science Fiction, Norman Rockwell, etc.—and the spare explainer plates next to individual works. The effect is, I’m guessing, exactly what Lucas wanted.
The Lucas feels like the ultimate example of a “shit I think is cool and could buy because I’m rich” collection. There is an emphasis on popular lowbrow art of the early- and mid-twentieth century, which I think is the heart of the museum. It’s what Lucas saw as a boy—serials, comic strips, the covers of pulp genre novels—that shaped the imaginations of Boomer directors like him and Spielberg. And it’s presented in a way that mimics a child’s encounter with it. No context, no or little awareness of, or interest in, larger questions of artistic influence, the role of commerce, etc. It’s just decontextualized visual sizzle, leaving you free to construct your own epics from what you find, using those archetypal narratives that Joseph Campbell talked about. They sell The Hero with a Thousand Faces in the gift shop.
Full disclosure. I’m not a museum professional but lurk here because I find the industry fascinating. I’m curious about what real museum professionals thought of the Lucas.