r/PCB • • 5h ago

First ever PCB (feedback?)

Thumbnail
gallery
15 Upvotes

Zero use of AI. One night class per week and a lot of reading!

RPi 4b hat, 4 layers.
1/red: signal traces and power/ground zones;
2/green: ground plane;
3/orange: power zones, including 12v (batt/acc), 5v and 3v3;
4/blue: audio in and ESP related stuff.

12v to 5v 3A buck converter, ESP32-C3 to communicate between the RPi and headunit. What could I have done differently?

Thanks!


r/PCB • • 13h ago

HIGH power nice esc

Thumbnail
gallery
48 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

Just wanted to share my latest design: a high-power 16S 200A ESC, intended for automotive applications such as lightweight electric vehicles.Originaly did it for my internship that's why i documented things, get to create a public github of it because it is intended for a bench too not a big confidential desing for the company originaly it wasn't asked to me at all, i proposed to do that on bonus, i will use it on my small ebike i think we can push this design over 300A or more need to test the cooling but thanks to TOLT mosfet a great cooling is easily achievable.

It features:

  • Infineon OptiMOS 5/6 MOSFETs in TOLT packages (top-side cooling)
  • Proper bulk capacitors and MLCC decoupling
  • INA241 inline shunt current sensing
  • STM32G4 MCU
  • Two separate PCBs: one for power and one for control

I've tested it using DPT to check Vds voltage overshoot and switching transients. I couldn't accurately measure Eon and Eoff due to my inline shunt resistors, but the results look great so far.20V overshoot too 50 percent overshoot at 200A on phase same result at 328A (due to slower turn on and off time too di/dt similar)

I'll also upload my FOC code to the same repository later on.

PS: on bottom view the small 1mohm sensing resistor are not final one and i didn't do the DPT with thos final one are 2 9W 0.2 milliohm resistors

If you're interested, feel free to check out the project, and maybe leave a star if you like it!

GitHub: https://github.com/mathieupommery/NICE_ESC

Any feedback or suggestions are welcome!


r/PCB • • 7h ago

PCB isolation slots smaller than JLCPCB's 1 mm minimum?

4 Upvotes

I'm designing a 60 W AC/DC flyback charger based on Power Integrations' RDR-838 reference design.

The reference PCB appears to use non-plated isolation slots narrower than 1 mm. However, JLCPCB specifies a 1 mm minimum for non-plated slots.

I understand the reference board wasn't necessarily manufactured by JLCPCB, but how are manufacturers achieving narrower isolation slots? Is this a fabrication capability limitation, or am I misunderstanding the specification?


r/PCB • • 8h ago

About to produce my first proper PCB. How badly wrong can it go?

4 Upvotes

I have been working on my first proper PCB for about six months and I'm very close to the point where I'm going to have some engineering samples manufactured and assembled.

Background: there is none. This is a hobby project which I sort of span off something I did for work a while ago and it snowballed into consuming a significant amount of time, with immense scope creep and it's gone from something that was just going to be for learning/development and a couple of boards which would be mainly for personal use, to something that I am seriously considering turning into a commercial product, or at least it'll be the backbone of a potential commercial service.

The board is an asset tracker. I know these are widely available already but none meet the specific requirements I had in mind originally...and mine is extremely flexible now.

Four layers, 96x48mm, and has RF (LTE/LoRa and GNSS). Power is via battery, USB, external DC input (all can be connected simultaneously, with DC prioritised over USB; it will charge the battery too). The brains is an RP2350A.

Disclaimer: I am not an electronics expert and I have used AI to help with the schematics and part selection. I did a rough layout myself, and I am paying JLC to do the routing. There has been a bit of back and forth as me (and AI) have spotted small issues which the JLC engineer has happily rectified. I have tried my best to meticulously follow the hardware design guide for every chip on the board, some of which are very stringent (anyone who has put an RP2350A on a board will know about that inductor). I'm obviously not an expert but it looks to me like JLC has done a pretty good job with the first pass of the routing, and the impedance control seems to follow best practice. The PCB does not have antennas; there are U.FL connectors for both modules and they are on opposite edges of the long sides of the board and the areas around the RF traces are densely stitched with vias.

I've done some PCBA quotes with JLC and it looks like I can get the first 6 boards manufactured for just under US$100 each all in, which is great because it's below my target price. There are three hardware versions of the board which are virtually identical other than using different modems (two LTE and one LoRaWAN) and I'm going to panelize all three and then get two panels assembled as the engineering samples as this seems the most economical way to do it. I obviously really want the first versions to just work, although I am anticipating there will be at least one issue. I've become so obsessed with trying to ensure perfection with the v1 samples that I keep going through the schematics triple-checking them, re-reading all of the datasheets to make sure I've done everything right, and I'm sometimes even having nightmares about it. Each time there's something minor I find that I want to change although most of these would probably not cause the boards to be a complete failure.

So after all that my question really is: what else is there that can go wrong, even if I get everything right? Can JLC mess up the assembly and send me dead boards? Can parts be oriented wrong because datasheets have got incorrect diagrams?

Really appreciate any input, and as I said I'll post up some schematics and the layout for review once I get the latest version from JLC.


r/PCB • • 1h ago

Is it safe not to isolate the MCU ground?

Post image
1 Upvotes

Can anyone experienced with this help me?


r/PCB • • 14h ago

[Review Request] 4 layer RP2040 + USB-C board, 50 x 49 mm, KiCad 10

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

Hi r/PCB, I would like a review before I order this. It is a small RP2040 board with USB-C, 7 LEDs, BOOT and RESET buttons and a push switch.

Gallery order: 1 top composite, 2 to 4 3D views, 5 to 8 copper layers L1 to L4, 9 full schematic, 10 to 14 schematic zoomed in sections, 15 stackup and impedance table.

Board

  • 4 layers, FR4 Isola 370HR, about 62 mil, 1 oz copper on all layers
  • L1 parts and USB pairs, L2 solid GND, L3 3.3 V plane, L4 other signals
  • 50 x 49 mm L outline, four M4 plated holes tied to GND, all parts on the top side
  • USB pairs: 5.0 mil trace, 4.0 mil gap, 90 ohm differential, on L1 over L2
  • 6 mil min track and space elsewhere, 8 mil min drill, 8 mil drill to copper, 12 mil tented through vias, IPC Class 2, 1 A max
  • KiCad DRC and ERC are clean
  • Layout was scripted and most non critical nets were autorouted, so it is not hand tidied

Questions

  1. USB pairs at 5/4 mil on L1. The fab table says 89.7 ohm, my field solver says about 94.5 ohm. Is that a yield risk?
  2. The stackup table shows 0.5 oz inner copper, but I am using 1 oz inner. Does that change the impedance enough to worry about?
  3. Five tented 12 mil ground vias in the RP2040 centre pad. OK, or should I move or fill them?
  4. The USB-C footprint is custom from the datasheet (0.40 mm holes, 5.5 mil annular ring, 0.60 mm shell slots). Anything wrong?
  5. 8 mil power neck downs at the RP2040 pads (16 mil elsewhere) with a 1 A max. Fine?
  6. L4 routing: return paths, anything crossing plane gaps, anything a fab would flag.
  7. One sided assembly with a through hole push switch and USB-C. Any assembly problems?

KiCad 10.0.8. I can share Gerbers or the project if that helps. Thanks!


r/PCB • • 4h ago

Looking for a solid toolset (or workflow) for designing proper FPGA-level PCBs — what are people actually using successfully today?

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone,
I’m looking for recommendations on a complete or near-complete toolset that can handle proper PCB design for FPGA boards (not just simple breakout boards). Think multi-layer boards with high-speed interfaces, careful power integrity, decent length matching, proper decoupling, etc.
Has anyone here put together a reliable combination of tools that actually works well for this level of design as an individual?
I’m especially interested in:
• What schematic + layout tools people are using successfully for FPGA boards
• Any supporting tools for SI/PI, length matching, constraint management, etc.
• Whether you’ve managed to build a workable end-to-end workflow without needing the full enterprise packages
• What’s currently considered the strongest option available to individuals in 2026
If you’ve gone through this process yourself and settled on something that actually works, I’d really appreciate hearing what you ended up with and why.
Thanks in advance.


r/PCB • • 8h ago

Is soldering a shared ground line on the underside of a perfboard good practice?​

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

​Hi everyone,

​I'm new to soldering on perfboards/protoboards (until now, I've only used Arduino breadboards). I'm currently wiring up a small circuit with tactile pushbuttons and LEDs.

​To keep the top side looking clean and reduce wire clutter, I decided to create a common ground rail on the underside of the board by bridging/soldering the ground connections together, and I plan to route the remaining signal/power wires normally.

​Is this a valid and reliable technique on perfboards, or are there downsides I should watch out for (like short circuits or cold joints)? I've attached photos showing the top side with wires, the board without wires, and the underside soldering.

​(P.S. Apologies for the messy solder joints—this is my very first time soldering!)


r/PCB • • 1d ago

DDR3 Routing

Thumbnail
gallery
48 Upvotes

I have a dream/half-baked design to build a custom CD transport and player around the old MacBook Pro slot loading CD drives.

I've AI-ed together a prototype which is based round an RK3308 SoC and 512MB of DDR3 (I want to run embedded Linux so I can do CD ripping to a network share and also bluetooth / WiFi streaming). I've also built a HW prototype using a USB-SATA adaptor and Rock Pi S (a SoM board using the RK3308).

I'd engaged a HW engineer via Fiverr to do a schematic review and then lay out the main PCB (also have a drive flex, LCD display breakout board and front panel button PCB which are simple by comparison). However the engineer did a good (AFAICT) schematic review but was then unable to continue with the PCB routing.

Just wanted some advice basically on how hard is DDR3 routing actually, and can I delegate it to Fable or an autorouter (I'm a SW engineer with no real HW or PCB design expertise), or should I try and find another engineer?


r/PCB • • 8h ago

Designed a PCB in under 3 minutes with TurboPCB, then milled, solder-masked and drilled it on my desktop CNC

Thumbnail
reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/PCB • • 1d ago

[Review Request] RNS-E AMI V2.0

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

With this PCB I want to replace the original Audi RNS-E AMI with this more advanced one. I know the BAP protocol the original AMI talks over CAN with the navigation system.

But its very outdated, I thought about making a V2.0 with ESP32 S3, Bluetooth, USB connection, DAB+. With the same connector as the original one and the same pinout.

It is very important it works in an automotive environment, this is why I tried to add some esd protection.But the things I worry most about, is the DAB antenna and the analoge audio part, that has a separate ground. The DAB part is based on this ESP32 DAB+ project https://github.com/PE5PVB/SI4684-DAB-Receiver/ .

DRC runs with no errors but I am still quite nervous about ordering it, because some of the components aren't cheap. I am open sourcing it like all my projects if this works. But this is by far the most pcb I have made yet.

EDIT: https://github.com/korni92/RNS-E-AMI-V2 here is the upload of the files.


r/PCB • • 1d ago

JLCPCB, OSP finish... Watch out, it's now the default.

62 Upvotes

So I ordered a couple of different orders of PCBs from jlcpcb, and the first ones came in looking weird, (non hasl), so I double checked my orders, and jlcpcb is defaulting to the OSP finish by default.

I hope I can get the next batch of board built before the finish degrades. dammit.


r/PCB • • 1d ago

What are the general and hole diameters for 2.54mm pitch pin headers (such as the ones on an ESP32)?

4 Upvotes

I am using EasyEDA.


r/PCB • • 1d ago

[Review request] Second revision of my first ESC

Thumbnail
gallery
25 Upvotes

Hello reddit. This is the second design revision of my ESC project. The first time I posted on here someone gave me really good feedback, and I have implemented a lot of that in this new revision. Any feedback on this will be appreciated.

Things to note:

  • Designed to run on a 4S LiPo
  • Should handle 50 amp bursts of current (for a few milliseconds).
  • Low side current sensing
  • 2040uF bulk battery rail capacitance

Key parts:

  • STM32G431CBT6 microcontroller
  • Infineon BSC010N04LS MOSFETs
  • TI DRV8300 gate driver
  • TI INA241 current sense amp
  • Planning to use MT6701 encoder in SSI mode
  • TI LMR51430 buck converter

Thanks!


r/PCB • • 20h ago

Thread SED Weather Sensor - PCB Design

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/PCB • • 23h ago

Using Nexar while waiting for Altium MCP access

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/PCB • • 13h ago

no idea what im doing

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Made this PCB with claude. Its for a keyboard. I have a comp sci background but no skills in electronic engineering/ with PCB’s.

The stuff at the top includes a battery, power switch, power led, a trackball sensor, and theres a rotary knob on near the bottom right.

Can you spot any glaring problems?
What is the state/ capability of AI right now with these?

Helpful learning resources are very appreciated


r/PCB • • 1d ago

How many revisions until a PCB is good?

5 Upvotes

Hi,

I started at a startup and need to do a little bit planning. The PCBs are medium complex, 4 Layers and eurocard size (10*16cm estimated) - how many revision are normal until a PCB is considered good? What is your average?


r/PCB • • 1d ago

𝗧𝘄𝗼-𝗖𝗵𝗮𝗻𝗻𝗲𝗹 𝗜𝟮𝗖 𝗗𝗶𝗴𝗶𝘁𝗮𝗹𝗹𝘆 𝗔𝗱𝗷𝘂𝘀𝘁𝗮𝗯𝗹𝗲 𝗚𝗮𝗶𝗻 𝗢𝗣𝗔𝗠𝗣 𝘂𝘀𝗶𝗻𝗴 𝗦𝗟𝗚𝟰𝟳𝟬𝟬𝟰𝗩

Post image
1 Upvotes

In this video, I introduced an adjustable two-channel non-inverting amplifier module. The OPAMP gain can be adjusted using any microcontroller via I2C commands. Pretty handy for building a mixed-signal circuit.

I designed the schematic and PCB in Altium® Develop and tested the circuit using the SLG47004V header board and an Arduino UNO.

More details: www.youtube.com/watch?v=MP_SMJrL52o


r/PCB • • 1d ago

Evaluation board prototype to custom PCB

3 Upvotes

I have built a prototype medical device using Texas Instruments evaluation boards with limited electrical engineering knowledge, and don't possess the skills to create my own PCB based off my prototype. The device already has functional firmware and software. It is for medical biosignal acquisition, so must be medical regulatory grade for future human use. I am hoping to hire a company or contractor to create a custom PCB based on my prototype. I have been looking at upwork and Fiverr, but are there any other companies that anyone recommends that could take my evaluation board prototype and apply medical regulatory requirements to create a custom PCB?


r/PCB • • 20h ago

[Review Request] 4-layer AIO drone board: ESP32-S3 FC + 4-in-1 AM32 ESC + ELRS RX, 2S, 55×115 mm

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/PCB • • 2d ago

From zero PCB to my first custom THT PCB -- would love some feedback!

Thumbnail
gallery
98 Upvotes

r/PCB • • 1d ago

Anyone know where to get small capacity Micro-SD cards.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/PCB • • 1d ago

STM32 Board review

5 Upvotes

Hi Guys,

Could I get some help looking over my first STM32 Board? This is supposed to be a control board for a buck boost converter

Thank you!