r/Professors • • 21h ago

Weekly Thread Nov 21: Skynet Saturday- AI Solutions

2 Upvotes

Due to the new challenges in identifying and combating academic fraud faced by teachers, this thread is intended to be a place to ask for assistance and share the outcomes of attempts to identify, disincentive, or provide effective consequences for AI-generated coursework.

At the end of each week, top contributions may be added to the above wiki to bolster its usefulness as a resource.

Note: please seek our wiki (https://www.reddit.com/r/Professors/wiki/ai_solutions) for previous proposed solutions to the challenges presented by large language model enabled academic fraud.


r/Professors • • 11m ago

…so, what are you reading for pleasure?

2 Upvotes

u/Environmental_Bug662 kicked off a great thread about whether and how we read for pleasure during the term.

Now I’m curious about *what* you’re reading for pleasure.

I’m slowing working my way through Brave the Wild River: The Untold Story of Two Women Who Mapped the Botany of The Grand Canyon and just picked up Stitched (from the jacket, about two young gay men who join a long-standing competitive quilting circle).


r/Professors • • 5h ago

Advice / Support For an online T2 course do you hold back during Thanksgiving week?

0 Upvotes

This is my first time teaching a fully online course. So far every week has been an assigned chapter reading, a quiz on that chapter and alternating weeks of discussion board or an assignment working from the week's content. Everything starts on Monday at 12am and is due Sunday by 11:30pm.

The 16 week campus courses is using the week of Thanksgiving as Fall Break. How do you most of you handle the 12 Week online with a big midweek holiday such as Thanksgiving? Do you keep the momentum going or back off on some of the work a bit to let them chill for a couple of days?

Thanks,
Tandom


r/Professors • • 7h ago

Advice / Support My own textbook, which I put on reserve, apparently is missing. In all these years, that’s never happened.

13 Upvotes

Maybe I’ve been lucky- I’ve never had a text stolen from the campus library reserve before. They seem to be rarely used, but when it is used, it’s by a student who really needs it (waiting for book money to come in or just broke). Anyway- I’m not out much money but I’m disappointed that it’s gone. I’m not replacing it but I wonder how to address this loss to the class (it’s only one section and this is a new school for me / for this course) so I know it happened this Fall.
What would you do- write an announcement? Look to see who had checked it out for (in-library reserve use only)?
Just say nothing and chalk it up to end of an era?
If you think it’s something you’d send out /make an announcement for - what do you even say? I’m just gobsmacked.
I learned of this from someone who told me they went to go use it last week and it’s gone. He was bummed because he needed it for his final due in a few days.

HARRUMPH.


r/Professors • • 7h ago

Discussion What are your predictions for the future of academia?

0 Upvotes

AI assistants have completely upended academia as we knew it a few years ago.
-- students use AI on homework
-- journals are overwhelmed with submissions at least partially -- if not entirely -- written by AI
-- reviewers are using AI to referee papers
-- professors are using AI to grade assignments
-- AI assistants are proving theorems that had stumped humans for decades
Much of what we do now seems like a charade. And, everything from teaching to research will have to change. But, it's not obvious to me at all how things will change.

What are your predictions for the future of academia?

The only prediction I feel strongly about is that journals will go by the wayside. First, journals are overwhelmed with submissions. Second, none of the recent breakthrough results from OpenAI (e.g., the proof of the Riemann Hypothesis, and solving the Navier-Stokes problem) went through the traditional referee process. It's obvious that we don't need journals to "certify" results; the broader community will do this on their own. As such, I believe journals will be completely replaced by open repositories like arXiv and SSRN.

As for research and teaching, using AI assistants will become the norm (well, it is the norm already). But, it's really not clear to me at all how we should modify our teaching to account for this. And this is where I am particularly interested to hear others' thoughts.


r/Professors • • 9h ago

Rants / Vents Share your bad experiences at academic conferences.

132 Upvotes

Last week I participated in a conference. The format was hybrid, with my table being online with the public at a university and online. So, we were 3 people and we had 15 minutes each for our presentations.

The first person starts...they obviously didn't practice their presentation, they got the 3 minutes left warning and at the end they talked for 18 mins. Ok, no biggie. Second person's turn. The moderator announces that the person couldn't make it because of the time zone, but they have sent a video! The moderator starts the video... it was 23 minutes long with a 27-slides-PowerPoint. Yes, they reproduced the whole video.

So, it was finally my turn. I do practice my presentations beforehand, so I knew I could finish in 14 minutes...still, I was rushed and the Q&A was reduced to 3 minutes because there were no pauses between sessions and the next one was about to start.

I did send a strong worded email to the organizers for allowing a freaking 23 minutes video for a 15 minutes presentation.

Anyway, sorry for my English and, care to share your horror/funny stories?


r/Professors • • 10h ago

Rants / Vents Professors calling potential students?

21 Upvotes

I’m a professor at a European university facing declining enrollment. Management now wants faculty to call prospective students over the summer to encourage them to enroll. I consider this admissions telemarketing, not academic work. Is this happening elsewhere? Am I being unreasonable in thinking this is unacceptable?


r/Professors • • 11h ago

Why do they always go straight to the dean?

76 Upvotes

That’s the post. Why when students have a complaint, they go straight to the dean? They do not pass go. They do not collect $200.


r/Professors • • 13h ago

Humor Gram Theft Auto

26 Upvotes

Get ready for a new variant of the “dead grandma” excuse for missing tests

I cannot stop playing this game

Nothing else matters anymore!

I’m supposed to be setting a good example as the Professor


r/Professors • • 16h ago

Final assignment due final class (for us))

17 Upvotes

I've posted what they need to write about/cover last week so they have access to thinking in advance. So in theory if they wanted to submit that part of the assignment right now they could.

I've also posted the reading they canread inadvance of their in class handwritten on paper handed in before the end of class part. 300 - 500 words your opinion what YOU think. And explained this all last week.

Its like all the air went out of the room.

Fascinating.


r/Professors • • 16h ago

Research / Publication(s) Some Good News!

93 Upvotes

I read all the posts in this subreddit so I can commiserate with my colleagues and feel like I am not alone in trying to navigate grossly unprepared students and unsupportive administration, BUT, I found out last night my sabbatical application was approved! Who gets to spend 4 months travelling and writing next year? Me, that’s who.


r/Professors • • 19h ago

Continuing Education

4 Upvotes

Hello! I'm curious as to what everyone does in terms of continuing education within your discipline. Meaning, do you pursue certificates or attend conferences regularly? Look into publishing? Research opportunitis? Again, just interested to see what others do. Thanks!


r/Professors • • 22h ago

Rants / Vents Poor personal hygiene

103 Upvotes

Some of my students smell... terrible. I don't want to be mean but the only accurate way to describe the smell of their breath is like a dead rat in a blocked drain. And I don't know how to address it, but it's almost unbearable when they come to me for consultations. Shockingly, I'd say it's about 40% of my students. I have large classes, so I'm almost guaranteed to interact with such a student at least once per day.


r/Professors • • 1d ago

Advice / Support Financially well positioned R1 in good location vs. tenuous budget at R2 in great location

22 Upvotes

I’m at an R2 and in the final stages of tenure here (local unit voting went well, so no issues anticipated). I like it. My spouse and I like the city, we’ve built a life here, and in a lot of ways this is a great situation, reasonable load, colleagues I get along with, students I generally enjoy teaching (some are painfully unprepared, but I suspect that's everywhere). We've built great professional and personal networks and have both come into our own here. We really love where we live currently and the community we've built.

One thing that nags at me is the budget. It’s been tight each year I’ve been here and the trend isn’t good. We’re in a state where the demographic cliff is going to land hard over the next decade. We’re better positioned than most institutions in our tier since we’re not one of the places you read about closing programs or going under, but you feel it anyway. There have been cuts, no merit pool increases, staff cut, hiring slowed, less research money. More administrative work is landing on faculty as staff lines disappear. Nobody’s job is at risk, but conditions erode a little every year, and I'm a bit worried given the headwinds in academia. It's not dire here, but it's also something noticeable. Some of my colleagues just say stay mobile, others say that they think it's bad everywhere, others say they think it's bad but aren't mobile themselves so they try not to worry... It's hard to truly know, since there's uncertainty about how uncertain things will become. But one thing I wonder about is that if I wait until the wheels are coming off, is that going to make it too late to jump off the ship.

I recently received an offer from an R1 that’s in much better shape financially, growing enrollment, state support, research resources, lower teaching load and more research-active people in my area. One catch is a new tenure clock, and it’s in a metro my spouse and I both like less than where we are. Not a bad place. Just not our place. We’d also be giving up a housing situation we can’t reproduce anywhere.

The money is roughly a wash after cost of living (though the trajectory at the R1 is likely better over the long term given that they can more steadily give raises and reward productive faculty), the job for me is clearly better on paper, and the community life in some ways may be less than ideal l (less walkable communities, different culture/mentality in that region, maybe worse traffic), or at least different in ways we aren’t as excited about. Again, it's not a bad place per se by any stretch, very desirable for many, but just really like our current place.

How do you weigh this?

Does a financially stable institution with research-active colleagues actually make you happier day to day, or does the neighborhood you live in and the people you see on weekends matter more than we give them credit for?

For those who left somewhere you liked for a better job in a place you liked less, did the job carry it? Any regrets? I was faced with a similar decision when I took this current job some years ago. The other school I turned down was more research intensive, but I preferred my current location. The thing is, my current place kind of works its faculty pretty hard and has high expectations. I've made it here and will have tenure, but it hasn't been easy. I often wonder if my life would have been easier had I taken the other job. The R1 who offered me this time will have high expectations too on research, but at least the resources will be more supportive towards being successful in that regard.

And for those who stayed through a slow budget squeeze, how did that look after five or ten years? Does "a little worse each year" compound into something much worse, or do you adapt?

TIA.


r/Professors • • 1d ago

Got stressed, got weird

154 Upvotes

Today at a meeting someone pulled me aside and said something bizarrely rude to me with no provocation. Personal and weird in a "I'm just trying to help you by telling you nobody likes you" sort of patronizing way. I had never met this person before. Just a very weird moment. Nobody else heard it. Anyway, then I sat with my department chair, who asked me how I grade 100 10-page essays. In my flustered state I said "I don't give notes on late work". I absolutely do give notes on ALL work. I give pages of notes. It's sort of my super power. I don't know why my brain decided to lie. And I don't know why it decided on a lie that makes me look worse instead of better. So what do I do now? I can't email the chair and explain, cause that makes me sound insane.


r/Professors • • 1d ago

Make lecture attendance worth 10% of their regular grade and they will flood you with excuses for why they could not come. Make it worth 1% worth of bonus points and they will love you forever

494 Upvotes

and call you greatest teacher to ever live on Rate my Professor. Man, they will probably have ChatGPT write a heartfelt email to the Registrar that they should promote you.


r/Professors • • 1d ago

Augusta University is falling apart

88 Upvotes

Idk the title says it all. Experienced staff in fundraising and admissions leaving. The Provost relentlessly bullying department chairs to take words like sexuality and race out of class titles and course descriptions in the catalog (but calling phone to phone and refuses to put the instructions in writing). It's a chaotic mess with losing 8 Deans in a year, the latest being a Dean who sure looks like she was forced to go because of pushing back against ideology (except she had to sign an NDA so who knows). They're acting like it's 2025 in Florida, even after an election that shook up the governor and legislative branches. Threatening that if we don't make changes the legislature or Board will come after us. The president lost his shit and complained that the Faculty Senate doesn't ask questions that are "collegial" and scolded the faculty for daring to do anything other than give advice from committees. And faculty are being really hassled if their reading list doesn't fit into simple syllabus (good luck if you assign articles or videos!) along with all the other bullshit if your pass rate isn't 80 percent.

It's supposed to be health/STEM school and the Provost is flipping out because actually fail the ones who can't pads science. But she is also canceling all the other majors they could try instead-- hasn't been announced yet but of course in the rush to become Florida they have stealthily canceled sociology and are threatening math.

Nothing works, ther is zero direction, and the President is a weird fundie egoamaniac. I need the insurance for now but I gotta get out. What a turn this place has taken.

I need this job. I used to like it but the thought of self harm is way too much of late and no more, thanks


r/Professors • • 1d ago

Second interview! Looking for advice on how to answer a question.

5 Upvotes

At the start of the semester I decided I need to get off the sinking ship that is my university and went back on the job market. I had Zoom interviews with two uni's last week and I have a second interview with one of them on Monday. It will be a phone interview with the Dean.

The uni is a SLAC that is very similar to the one I'm at now, but with more students, more programs, and financially healthier.. It's also only an hour away and my current uni's biggest competitor.

I was provided with a list of questions I will be asked. The first one is "what are you looking for in your new position?" Is it ok to say "a uni that is financially healthier"? It's the truth and explains why I'm back on the job market in my second year at Sinking Ship U.

I've spent the last five years bouncing from one failing university to the next. Lost my job during one restructuring, left my second job just before a restructuring that eliminated my job, survived a restructuring at my current uni, but waiting for the axe to fall. I need some stability.


r/Professors • • 1d ago

Rants / Vents Help! Can’t speak because my tongue is sore from biting it too much

19 Upvotes

Just a Friday vent. Been biting the tongue a lot this term. Today was especially hard: Student tells me they can’t do their final presentation because they are leaving for family vacation the last 2 weeks of the semester. Bit my tongue something awful to avoid the things i wanted to instantaneously say:)

Side note: also stunned they thought a vacation was an a-ok reason to skedaddle during finals


r/Professors • • 1d ago

Advice / Support Changing Over the Break

18 Upvotes

Just looking for advice. At a conference, feeling reinvigorated, and changing some of my late work/attendance policies in the spring. Long story short, I'm a push over with no rules and students have consistently taken advantage. So I'm making some changes as a part of my professional growth.

My challenge: at a small regional university, a lot of my students have had me before, some for three years. My reputation precedes me- they know I'm a pushover.

So how do I go about presenting these changes? Do I just address it head on (a version of what I've written here)? Or do I just implement the new policies and see if students ask?

And as a final question, any advice for holding the line when students come to me expecting the usual extension or absent excuse?


r/Professors • • 1d ago

Humor Accidental Rorschach

17 Upvotes

So, I'm a creative writing professor and today in class we workshopped a student poem in which a car accident happens. We start our workshop by summarizing the work with a one-sentence "elevator pitch" about what the poem is about.

No one volunteered, so I offered. "It's a poem about a son and his father and the father dies in a car accident."

And the student was like, "that's not what the poem is about at all."

So, I was like, "Wow, I just shared more with you than anyone I know. Time to return to therapy."


r/Professors • • 1d ago

Teaching / Pedagogy Teaching Synthesis—Suggestions?

10 Upvotes

Curious how people teach students to synthesize sources when writing. I’m in STEM and teach a few foundational courses. I’ve never been formally trained in any sort of writing pedagogy—it’s a little embarrassing but I’ll admit I’ve been able to rely on students’ existing writing skills and their ability to emulate the writing style in the articles we read (which is mainly how I learned how to write lit reviews and introductions). Frankly, I’ve had a lot of success with this approach in the past, but the writing skills get weaker each semester and AI is only making it worse.

I need (and want) to be more intentional in how I approach this and scaffold writing skills so students don’t feel so intimidated that they’re immediately tempted to turn to AI. I’m thinking about focusing on informational synthesis early in the semester and moving towards argumentative synthesis later/in upper level courses but I’m really stuck on how to approach this and where to start.

Any suggestions regarding resources, activities, or even how to frame this topic while keeping it beginner friendly are massively appreciated. I don’t need them to produce flawless lit reviews by the time they leave my class, but if they have a semi-decent foundation in how to critically engage with a variety of sources I know it’ll benefit them as they progress through our curriculum.


r/Professors • • 1d ago

NSF Career updates

0 Upvotes

Any updates from NSF Career CBET?


r/Professors • • 1d ago

Happy Thanksgiving?

42 Upvotes

Another thing I've noticed as the years go by is that fewer and fewer students will wish you a nice holiday, a good break, etc. With in-person classes, I get more and even a few students who will initiate that as they leave. But even there, many just zombie-like float out as usual. In my online courses no, nothing, though I post good wishes to them. It's a bit sad.

Happy fall break to all here though! I am truly grateful for all the help, support and laughs I've received from you!