I’m at an R2 and in the final stages of tenure here (local unit voting went well, so no issues anticipated). I like it. My spouse and I like the city, we’ve built a life here, and in a lot of ways this is a great situation, reasonable load, colleagues I get along with, students I generally enjoy teaching (some are painfully unprepared, but I suspect that's everywhere). We've built great professional and personal networks and have both come into our own here. We really love where we live currently and the community we've built.
One thing that nags at me is the budget. It’s been tight each year I’ve been here and the trend isn’t good. We’re in a state where the demographic cliff is going to land hard over the next decade. We’re better positioned than most institutions in our tier since we’re not one of the places you read about closing programs or going under, but you feel it anyway. There have been cuts, no merit pool increases, staff cut, hiring slowed, less research money. More administrative work is landing on faculty as staff lines disappear. Nobody’s job is at risk, but conditions erode a little every year, and I'm a bit worried given the headwinds in academia. It's not dire here, but it's also something noticeable. Some of my colleagues just say stay mobile, others say that they think it's bad everywhere, others say they think it's bad but aren't mobile themselves so they try not to worry... It's hard to truly know, since there's uncertainty about how uncertain things will become. But one thing I wonder about is that if I wait until the wheels are coming off, is that going to make it too late to jump off the ship.
I recently received an offer from an R1 that’s in much better shape financially, growing enrollment, state support, research resources, lower teaching load and more research-active people in my area. One catch is a new tenure clock, and it’s in a metro my spouse and I both like less than where we are. Not a bad place. Just not our place. We’d also be giving up a housing situation we can’t reproduce anywhere.
The money is roughly a wash after cost of living (though the trajectory at the R1 is likely better over the long term given that they can more steadily give raises and reward productive faculty), the job for me is clearly better on paper, and the community life in some ways may be less than ideal l (less walkable communities, different culture/mentality in that region, maybe worse traffic), or at least different in ways we aren’t as excited about. Again, it's not a bad place per se by any stretch, very desirable for many, but just really like our current place.
How do you weigh this?
Does a financially stable institution with research-active colleagues actually make you happier day to day, or does the neighborhood you live in and the people you see on weekends matter more than we give them credit for?
For those who left somewhere you liked for a better job in a place you liked less, did the job carry it? Any regrets? I was faced with a similar decision when I took this current job some years ago. The other school I turned down was more research intensive, but I preferred my current location. The thing is, my current place kind of works its faculty pretty hard and has high expectations. I've made it here and will have tenure, but it hasn't been easy. I often wonder if my life would have been easier had I taken the other job. The R1 who offered me this time will have high expectations too on research, but at least the resources will be more supportive towards being successful in that regard.
And for those who stayed through a slow budget squeeze, how did that look after five or ten years? Does "a little worse each year" compound into something much worse, or do you adapt?
TIA.