r/StructuralEngineering • • 10h ago

Structural Analysis/Design Does the lack of a common standard for zooming/panning/orbiting/scrolling drive anyone else nuts?

34 Upvotes

It seems like nearly every software I use tries to use a different system.

Then you also get software like RAM Concept which has the most obnoxious orbiting tool I've encountered. I've got no idea what point it is rotating around.


r/StructuralEngineering • • 19h ago

Career/Education 8 Years in Tekla Steel Detailing, but I'm Losing Hope in This Career. Need Honest Advice.

5 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm from India and have been working in steel detailing for around 8 years, mostly on Tekla Structures. Over this time, I've handled industrial, commercial, and pipe rack projects.

Right now, my plate is pretty full—3D modelling and model updates, GA/shop/erection/part drawings, RFIs, clash checks, and coordination with other teams. The more dependable I get, the more tasks land on my desk, but that hasn't translated into better pay, real appreciation, or decent work-life balance. Getting approval for basic leave is a struggle, and recognition is rare.

At 8 years in, I'm seriously rethinking whether to stay in detailing or pivot. I'm open to picking up new skills or starting fresh in a new area if it makes sense, I just don't want to make a rash move at this stage in my career.

For those who've been through this space:

  1. Is there real long-term career growth in Tekla steel detailing in India?
  2. Would shifting toward BIM management, structural design, or connection design make more sense?
  3. Are overseas roles (Middle East, Europe, etc.) realistic and worth pursuing right now?
  4. Is leaving the industry completely after 8 years practical, or am I throwing away too much leverage?
  5. If you were in my shoes at year 8, what move would you make?

I'm looking for grounded, practical perspectives rather than generic motivation—whether that means pushing for a title/pay reset, switching firms, looking abroad, or changing tracks altogether. I don't want to look back in 5–10 years feeling stuck in the exact same loop.

Appreciate any honest thoughts and experiences.


r/StructuralEngineering • • 2h ago

Structural Analysis/Design How do you model the sloped floor swimming pool in Etabs?

3 Upvotes

I have never analyzed and design swimming pool. I understood for the horizontal floor but I don't have the slightest idea how do I do it in slanted floor mainly what complications may arrive while designing it.

Swimming pool is in the ground. -RCC to be used and structural walls to be used on sides and floor.


r/StructuralEngineering • • 16h ago

Structural Analysis/Design Framing doubt for a 1.6m wide beam carrying floating columns

1 Upvotes

Hi there i am a fresher structural engineer working in a small structural consulting firm in India. I have been working on a G+9 residential building where i this framing shown in the image below. It is the plan view of that frame.

There are 4 columns in it, C26 and C27 are the floating columns, GB1 is the beam on which the floating columns sit on it is shown in yellow color in the image and column C50 and C49 are the columns that support the GB1 beam.

The locations of the floating columns caused us to have a very wide beam of width 1600mm which is partially supported on column C49 as the column size is limited by the architecture. Now as this column only supported only half the width of the beam my seniors told me to model a cantilever which is shown as the red hatch in the image. When i asked them about the reason for the cantilever they told me that it was to support the beam or else it will be unstable.

They told me to model it in etabs as shown in image below. So in the image the yellow center line is the GB1, the 2 blue lines are modelled as rigid arm between floating column and GB1 so as to take in account the eccentricity without an instability error in etabs. the red line is the hatched cantilever i which i talked about my senior told me model it as a normal beam.

Now the thing is that in reality the GB1 will sit on column C50 and C49, but in the model it is instead first transferring it full load on that cantilever and then through it to the column which i think is inaccurate. And due to the same that cantilever failed in shear it shear stress was around 9.3 N/mm2 almost 3 times more than the limiting values as per the Indian code.

I told the seniors about this and also how this is not a real behavior, their response was to design that cantilever for only half load that is coming on it now. When i asked for the reason, they told me that the column C49 only cover half width and rest half is that cantilever so the load on it will also be 50-50% between them. Even with that half load it took the section of 1.5m depth for that cantilever bring the shear stress in limit which still required shear reinforcement.

My doubt is that do we even need that cantilever here. My thought is to design that wide GB1 beam as a flat slab instead and check moment in both directions and shear around the column C49 for punching shear.

Can anyone clear me out on my situation and my thoughts on it.


r/StructuralEngineering • • 22h ago

Career/Education Payrise after obtaining RPEQ

1 Upvotes

Structural Engineer in QLD. Looking to get my RPEQ next year with 5 years ish experience. Will be undertaking sign-off responsibilities as well. How much payrise should I be asking for? Currently sitting ~100k + super