r/TrueFilm • u/TheTruckWashChannel • 11h ago
You Can See Everything: The Real Intent of "Who's On First"
I just rewatched YCSE in theaters and took my brother (his first time), and he picked up on a really brilliant dimension to the Who's On First scene that I myself didn't catch the first time. All credit for this insight goes to him really.
I saw some critique of Nathan for focusing too much on Elizabeth's use of "can" vs. "capable of", and apparently boiling down Theranos' lies to mere semantic confusion, driven home by showing her Who's On First, her not getting it, and Billy using it to say that "her mind just works differently". Even I thought the first time that he was focusing too much on this aspect of things when the scope of Theranos' fraud was way, way bigger.
But my brother pointed out that Nathan actually doing something way more devious and brilliant: to Elizabeth and Billy, he is seemingly giving them an out, by allowing them to latch onto his "semantic misunderstanding" framing to portray Elizabeth as some tragically poor communicator, a hapless victim of her so-called "literal thinking" getting lost in translation. But them acting like this explanation is sufficient is itself incredibly damning in a way neither of them appeared to realize in that scene.
The whole crux of the Who's On First routine lies in the deliberately confusing use of words - the joke, as Nathan explains in case wasn't obvious, is that "Who" is the name of the player who is on first. But to adopt such a misleading framing when dealing with investors, the public, and hundreds of millions of dollars at stake is absolutely unacceptable in any world, no matter how firm your grasp of semantics. And yet neither Elizabeth or Billy seem to understand this at all - Billy, delusional idiot that he is, even says "I'm so happy you showed this to us", seemingly missing that it makes Elizabeth look staggeringly, spectacularly incompetent at best, and utterly dishonest and manipulative at worst. And it makes both of them look like people with the audacity to (still) believe that everyone around them could be THAT stupid.
Which is why the criticism that Nathan was reducing the Theranos case to semantics and words misses the point: that framing was just for Elizabeth and Billy, to set up the trap he lays for them in the Who's On First scene, which is the punchline he intends for us, the audience. The horror of the fact that they believe such a misunderstanding is an adequate rationale/alibi, from watching a comedy routine where the confusion is very much the point. And they completely take the bait.