r/TrueFilm • • 1d ago

Casual Discussion Thread (November 21, 2026)

3 Upvotes

General Discussion threads threads are meant for more casual chat; a place to break most of the frontpage rules. Feel free to ask for recommendations, lists, homework help; plug your site or video essay; discuss tv here, or any such thing.

There is no 180-character minimum for top-level comments in this thread.

Follow us on:

The sidebar has a wealth of information, including the subreddit rules, our killer wiki, all of our projects... If you're on a mobile app, click the "(i)" button on our frontpage.

Sincerely,

David


r/TrueFilm • • 1h ago

Barry Lyndon and Alex (clockwork orange)

3 Upvotes

I was watching Barry Lyndon after clockwork orange and realized that the main characters are extremely similar.

Both are constantly saying ANYTHING they can to better their current circumstances because they are being interrogated and controlled.

They also click their heels together the same way after being transferred to a different command.

I never realized it, but I think these two movies are mirrors to each other and are the most similar in Kubrick’s filmography.

Alex is more of a sociopath, but
He has some concept of right and wrong because he said it’s a sin that he has to be tortured with Beethoven.


r/TrueFilm • • 1h ago

Harold and Maude (1971) by Hal Ashby Spoiler

1 Upvotes

The best way to approach this film is to not take anything literally, but see it through Harold’s eyes and try to gauge his feelings in each scene. Harold lives with his widowed mother in an opulent estate. He finds his life to be stale. He finds no pleasure in any activity. He is, in short, depressed. So much so that he often entertains the idea of committing suicide using different methods. The idea of death has begun to fascinate him more than anything in his dull life. He often goes to funerals to take a closer look at death. His mother, though aware of his state of mind, cannot fully comprehend it. She is an imposing figure. She tells Harold to get over his state. She thinks that a wife will make him happy. Of course, she arranges the dates and meets the dates herself. But when the dates get to know Harold, they are frightened and run away. The mother thinks she is helping Harold. She’s not. She can’t see that she has not let Harold grow up. He sees himself and thus appears on the screen as a teenage boy. Only once he opens his mouth to speak in that low-pitched voice can you figure out that he is a grown man.

At the funerals, Harold starts encountering this lady called Maude. She also visits them uninvited. But she’s a bit different. While the other mourners carry black umbrellas symbolising grief, and Harold carries no umbrella at all, signifying his emotionless state of void, Maude carries a yellow umbrella to the funerals. She has a spark around her, like a ray of sunshine. She goes around doing all these meaningless things-stealing roadside trees to park them in a forest, that stupid breathing, visiting funerals and whatnot, but they are not meaningless to her. She gives Harold a new pair of eyes to look at life with, to find joy in little experiences, to do things that one cares about in this limited lifespan. She looks like an old lady to Harold because she sits on the opposite end of the spectrum to this immature boy. She has faced her haunting past, she has owned a black umbrella, and she has learnt to cherish every single moment of this aimless life. She does not fear death anymore. She teaches Harold that each flower of a meadow is different, that individuality exists and matters.

Harold thinks that he should spend his whole life with Maude. That she is the girl for him. But this is not a romance story at all. This is a coming-of-age story. Maude gives Harold a reason to live, and leaves. She cannot be there forever. Harold is sad. For a brief moment, he thinks about killing himself again. But now, he knows a bit better; he values life a little more.

PS- Loved the Uncle Sam parody. Was relevant in the 1970s; is relevant in the 2020s.


r/TrueFilm • • 2h ago

How "Manhunter" Explained the Psychology of a Killer

6 Upvotes

Michael Mann's crime-drama masterpiece, "Manhunter," celebrates its 40th anniversary this year. Even all these decades later, "Manhunter" remains at the top of its genre. In spite of its deceptively simple setup, the film ascends its superficial trappings, becoming a psychological study just as much as it is a thriller. The film by no means explains every last trauma that Francis Dollarhyde experienced in childhood--in fact, those details are left out, and we're forced to speculate what kind of harm was done to him as a kid. However, certain scenes, such as Francis snuggling up against Reba in bed, clue us in to the fact that Francis' wounds are, largely, related to abandonment. A feeling of rejection. Thus his fantasies of being wanted, loved, and accepted. It all stems from a painful rejection as a child, and now as an adult, Francis seeks to fill the void in his heart by creating fantasies which satisfy his desires.

Francis gains infamy for stalking and then murdering families, all the while pretending to be a loving member among them who is loved and accepted. When the fantasy becomes too much to contain in his head, and he needs a physical element to make it seem realer, Francis pays a visit to the family in question, and murders them, then engages in sexual activities with the mother's corpse. On the surface, he could be mistaken for an aimless killer. However, these are not just crimes of passion, they are plotted over an extended period, and serve an overarching fantasy. Francis, in his killings, isn't just letting off steam, rather he's collecting a debt. He's stealing affection from families because of his own lack of affection during youth. Abandonment and abuse from a young age taught Francis a harsh lesson, that love does not come voluntarily from others, and at the first chance, the people around you will hurt or leave you.

Thus, love, as he sees it, must be taken. Stolen before it can be revoked or denied to you. This of course is not real love, but Francis has come to accept this as a form of substitution. In a sense, he can get what he's always wanted, but not in a complete form. Not in its purest form. In fact it's in a ruined form, but ruined is what Francis has learned to accept. Anything other than ruined might very well overwhelm Francis, who is used to settling for heinous alternatives. Thus, when Francis is finally given voluntary affection from Reba, this is confusing and scary to him. And lovely. But as a man controlled by his traumas, Francis is seemingly incapable of letting a good thing go untainted, and thus he finds a way to ruin this love too. If only to continue the tragic pattern of his life.

I've got a great video on this topic that everyone who loves "Manhunter" should definitely check out! Click here to watch it!

Thanks for reading!


r/TrueFilm • • 2h ago

What is actually going to happen with genAI?

0 Upvotes

I'm terrified of this technology and mostly wish it had never been made, but it's very obvious that at some point soon genAI will look good and convincing enough to meet the vast majority of peoples' standards. And in 15-20 years, save for those directed by a few celebrated auteurs, I'm not sure how many traditionally-made films will get greenlit, if you can save millions (hundreds of millions in some cases) by prompting any kind of movie into existence. How could somebody justify all those expenses when we seem headed to a world of complete and instant audiovisual abundance?

Does anyone seriously believe we're not headed to a world where the film industry isn't a tiny fraction of what it is today, in say 20 years? I'm so tired of genAI discourse revolving around aggregated headlines and circlejerk anti-AI posturing - I'd like to hear others' thoughts about what they think is actually going to happen, where this is all going.


r/TrueFilm • • 3h ago

Weapons (2025) is not a good movie. It just has lots of potential.

0 Upvotes

I first saw Weapons in theaters. I remember the hype going in, and thinking it was full of entertaining bits throughout, but feeling jipped walking out of the theater as the total pointlessness of it set in. 
Now rewatching it, i get to feel a constant sense of all the wasted potential going on moment by moment.

Yorgos Lanthimos would have eaten a story like this UP (mostly because The Killing of a Sacred Deer is what every film in this strain in the past decade wants to be (and in fact he kind of does in Kinds of Kindness)), crucially because Cregger does not understand the emotional level of this story at all. Anger is one that is spelled out in indirect dialogue many times, and that’s what i felt lacking so hard in this cavalcade of adult children all failing to care about others and the children; in this satirical parade of awful people and the American mindsets they represent, Cregger conveys no anger in his filmmaking. It’s all just a goof to him.
This suburban environment is portrayed with a kind of ‘every suburb’ portraiture with the darkness dialed up, yet as the story goes on I almost forget there’s a school-shooting level tragedy that’s just occurred. i don't feel any ambience of grief or paranoia that isn’t coming directly from a character we’re following. I know this butts against something I believe Weapons is going for, in that we see how the suburbs - a systemic ecosystem of unchange and domestic ignorance - reacts by ignoring everything.

But sharper filmmaking and the ability to linger on the backgrounds would actually convey this. For the most part I find sequences riddles with lazy techniques like a sudden crescendo in volume hard cutting scenes away with a ‘THOOM’ when there was more to explore after the outbursts of drama. And to me the score is doing very boilerplate work, where a really good score would add a lot to conveying the complex emotional state of this community and situation. The score is well-produced, but all it is is thumping ‘action’ music put on top of scenes with action, or scary held string notes to tell us a scene is suspenseful. Compare it to the song that plays in the opening sequence of the children naruto running away through the night - they play a George Harrison song, which is a choice (complimentary). Because it pulls you into seeing more than what you’re seeing. Perhaps getting the metaphorical undertones behind the film’s hook: that the environment you’re about to see is one that ruins people, and these children‘s flight from this place on some level is a good thing. Until you realize literally where they’ve gone.

And frankly his grasp on creative and surreal symbolism falls short - he litters the movie with “What the fuck”s but also litters it with horror cliches; what he can come up with always stops short of the delirium that the juggled narrative framing device builds up to. All he has to offer is “what the fuck” because he doesn’t know what depths this script is summoning from thematically, the complex real-world counterparts invoked and pitted against each other here. If he did, he would lock in and say something with all these juicy ingredients. Instead he shows the long-reaching uber-masculine ideal that rules this town with patriarchal corruption, incompetence, and authoritarianism with the blind trust of its civilians; and the useless therapy-speak, hemming and hawing leftist educators with vices. And you say “gosh guys aren’t both sides bad”. They’re literally in bed together. Not able to do a damn thing about making sure their children grow up safe and healthy. Well excuse me but I think in reality one is doing a lot more for that then the other. Like a lot more.

Aunt Gladys is this really potent figure, because her look and manner and supernatural wrench thrown into this mystery halfway in point to lots of real world analogues. Her clownish, ‘obvious’ demeaner while manipulating everyone like putty fits into the griftocracy of the past decade. Her ‘fun’ belying evil works as a manifestation of alcoholism/drug abuse, which is central to Weapons’ perspective on the abusive home, sitting as the central location to each storyline and representing the broken home right within the suburbs that is protected by the unspoken law of total familial privacy (see patriarchal control) that is coded into the suburban unit, and how a child in this place gets no help from anyone.

But can we please compare the depth and personal concern Cregger puts in here to a David Lynch (especially in Twin Peaks/FWWM). Cregger seems to want to do a Lynch, and has taken away (foolishly) that part of what made that work was Lynch just throwing ideas at a wall without further wrestling with or exploring the meaning behind them, and keeping it apolitical. So Gladys brutally murders a gay couple and targets educators, intoxicates a suburban parental unit into drones, weaponizes children, creates tragedy then stokes the trauma of it to radicalize people into weapons, annnnd she’s just a meme. A witch, which I think is a choice Cregger makes that actively breaks off his story from its thematic depth. He literalizes the witch hunt. And it’s clear he’s going for a catharsis on this: Oh it’s actually an agent of evil and we can stop them (and boy do they). But I don’t find this cathartic when you’re thinking if what this whole damn story means in our world, and what it’s influences were saying through art. Dumbing the premise down to this level to entertain a mass audience is downright insidious on some level. I get the feeling Cregger doesn’t actually want any of this pointed satirical buildup to make the subjects of said dark satire uncomfortable or culpable in any way. And again, I know this butts against a semi-valid analysis of the film in that it opens with a narrator telling us from the beginning everyone failed to solve what happened and covered it up - and it ends with the children all in a catatonic state staring blankly at their ‘rescuers’. But all the messiness and thematic cowardice up to this makes that deeper point not land at all to me.

So much of the observational nature of the script stays on paper. Cregger can clunkily tell at us what’s really going on, with classroom chalkboards and tv nature documentaries and characters saying it. But it reads like an alibi, as his filmmaking does nothing to embody or highlight anything beyond the popcorn thriller. It makes watching Weapons more aggravating for me because why put all this in there. People have debated that a negative response to Weapons arose from people feeling mislead by the premise into expecting a more serious film. Well I think the film itself is doing this misleading; why put all this THEME in there if you just wanted to make an action movie. And so the premise limits how much bonkers imagery and ideas you can play with, while the eventual reveal of crazy shit makes all that came before pointless. Torn between two worlds - post-elevated genre horror that tries to play both sides and lands in a boring middle because of it. I could watch a 2010s elevated horror film or a 1970s horror film and get a potent dose of each instead of being fed breadcrumbs. Let’s see this type of movie compete with The Devils in the same year. Would really throw in some perspective of how scared so many horror movies are now. That big payoff at the end is one true moment of thrilling cinema, but then its a double edged sword that cuts apart all that came before it - you realize Cregger never cared about those kids either.

Theres been a trend in all these bubbling up horror directors recently, where they are getting supported by people kinda hoping they're next one is going to be when it goes from good to great - but i would lump the vibe i get from all them with Emerald Fennell, nepo-core with artists donning the garb of elevated horror that came before but being glib, shallow, and uncaring about the real world issues inherent to the art theyre copping. I can guess two reasons everyone dogs Fennell but champions these guys. In fact i want to shoutout Widow’s Bay because it struck me while writing this how the tone of that is very much like what im complaining about, but it works and is done incredibly well. Maybe with the lack of cultural zeal for non-prestige tv in the current media landscape these people are making glib horror movies for what would make great episodic dark comedy television. I loved Resident Evil a lot more - it is equally glib and throws away the themes it had going for it at the end. But it’s a Resident Evil movie. Cregger wants to make rollercoasters, so hopefully that’s what he sticks to - and puts his standout technical abilities to show. Instead of roping our collective traumas of the last  10 years into it.


r/TrueFilm • • 3h ago

The simple brilliance of 1917.

0 Upvotes

Hi all, long time lurker, first time poster on this sub. I lack the analytical depth of many of you, but felt this might be the place for a brief discussion on one of my favorite "Blockbuster" films of all time, 1917. You may laugh me out for my rudimentary analysis - but still wanted to share.

From the get-go, the movie has a clear setup: a young, upbeat and plucky Lance Corporal Blake, and a slightly older, more mature and hardened Lance Corporal Schofield. The two appear to have become what we would equate with "workplace friends", at best.

Blake is selected to deliver the halt-order on an attack that would jeopardize the lives of 1600+ men as the Germans have strategically withdrawn, unknown to that batallion of the British Army. General Erinmore clearly knows he will be intrinsically motivated to save his brother. Schofield gets blindly selected to tag along by Blake before he even knows the assignment.

In a conventional Hollywood drama, the plot would be predictable: Schofield sacrifices himself valiantly (or is heartbreakingly) killed in action supporting Blake in saving his brother. Blake arrives just in time, and the attack is called off, saving thousands.

Instead - we get a shocker. A little less than halfway through the runtime, Blake is stabbed by a German pilot (who he was trying to rescue from a crashed plane), and dies unceremoniously, completely flipping this seemingly predictable script on its head.

Now, we have the previously (seemingly) disinterested Schofield, left to deliver the orders. He has no sympathetic connection to his objective beyond pure discipline and commitment to duty. No drive to save a family member, no deeply personal motivation, just a raw execution of orders from his superiors. Perhaps there is an element of wanting to do right by Blake, but this is somewhat downplayed until the end of the movie when he seeks out Blake's older brother to give him the news.

Further, Schofield doesn't actually save the day. He arrives late, after the entire first wave has gone over the top, meaning that several hundred men were likely already dead as a result of his unstated "failure" on the journey, when he got knocked unconscious.

Overall, for a "mass appeal" movie such as this,


r/TrueFilm • • 5h ago

WHYBW What Have You Been Watching? (Week of (November 22, 2026)

2 Upvotes

Please don't downvote opinions. Only downvote comments that don't contribute anything. Check out the WHYBW archives.


r/TrueFilm • • 8h ago

Racialized Gender Stereotyping in Hollywood

9 Upvotes

Now after watching new new hunger games film i can’t get this out of my mind so I wanted to talk about two things.

First of all Asian male representation in Hollywood media:

Regarding the hunger games franchise, this is only an example. I haven’t read the books, so when I found out Ben Wang was casted in this film I was pretty hyped. Going into this film I hoped that maybe his character was more of a leader, confident and stronger in a way, that type of characteristics. But once again the only Asian male in the entire film is a weaker, self conscious guy who’s exceptionally good at numbers/ math and used for comedic relief. We really need to stop this trope guys.

I could say the same thing about Asian females representation but this is different. Asian men are often deromanticized/desexualised. Asian women are being hyper sexualised or fetishized and often chase white boys.
That’s the same for many poc women in film, most couples are white male + poc/mixed female.
For example, in regard to the hunger games films in both the last films it was that paring. But it’s found in most films nowadays.

We almost never see the opposite, in comparison it’s just crazy and I’m wondering how not more people are seeing these two things. It’s 2026 and we’re still doing this.

Everyone deserves complex, well rounded representation in characters, that goes beyond cliches and stereotypes. Diversity in romance shouldn't just mean pairing women of color or mixed race women with white male leads while men of color are left out of romantic storylines altogether.


r/TrueFilm • • 11h ago

You Can See Everything: The Real Intent of "Who's On First"

173 Upvotes

I just rewatched YCSE in theaters and took my brother (his first time), and he picked up on a really brilliant dimension to the Who's On First scene that I myself didn't catch the first time. All credit for this insight goes to him really.

I saw some critique of Nathan for focusing too much on Elizabeth's use of "can" vs. "capable of", and apparently boiling down Theranos' lies to mere semantic confusion, driven home by showing her Who's On First, her not getting it, and Billy using it to say that "her mind just works differently". Even I thought the first time that he was focusing too much on this aspect of things when the scope of Theranos' fraud was way, way bigger.

But my brother pointed out that Nathan actually doing something way more devious and brilliant: to Elizabeth and Billy, he is seemingly giving them an out, by allowing them to latch onto his "semantic misunderstanding" framing to portray Elizabeth as some tragically poor communicator, a hapless victim of her so-called "literal thinking" getting lost in translation. But them acting like this explanation is sufficient is itself incredibly damning in a way neither of them appeared to realize in that scene.

The whole crux of the Who's On First routine lies in the deliberately confusing use of words - the joke, as Nathan explains in case wasn't obvious, is that "Who" is the name of the player who is on first. But to adopt such a misleading framing when dealing with investors, the public, and hundreds of millions of dollars at stake is absolutely unacceptable in any world, no matter how firm your grasp of semantics. And yet neither Elizabeth or Billy seem to understand this at all - Billy, delusional idiot that he is, even says "I'm so happy you showed this to us", seemingly missing that it makes Elizabeth look staggeringly, spectacularly incompetent at best, and utterly dishonest and manipulative at worst. And it makes both of them look like people with the audacity to (still) believe that everyone around them could be THAT stupid.

Which is why the criticism that Nathan was reducing the Theranos case to semantics and words misses the point: that framing was just for Elizabeth and Billy, to set up the trap he lays for them in the Who's On First scene, which is the punchline he intends for us, the audience. The horror of the fact that they believe such a misunderstanding is an adequate rationale/alibi, from watching a comedy routine where the confusion is very much the point. And they completely take the bait.


r/TrueFilm • • 14h ago

possible love - let's talk cheol Spoiler

5 Upvotes

his character and his dynamics are the hardest to read. the main four are well communicated but cheol is a more subtle character.

what do we make of cheol? what about his relationship dynamics? He's a wall flower voyeur around the main four but finds friendship with the gardener and sangwoo. those are the only two we see him come alive. what was lee chang dong trying to communicate about him there?

also really interesting is that shoe tying scene at the end - where the blue collar damoly is leaving and sangwoo who we realize at this point is an exploitative predator goes out of his way to loom out for cheol by stopping him and tying his shoe. so uncharacteristic for a villain. what do we make of that? who is sangwoo with that dynamic in mind.

what does it mean that cheol steals the whistle and it's implied there's a spirotual connection brw cheol and the gardener through that whistle?

share you thoughts on cheol below.


r/TrueFilm • • 15h ago

TM What is the most underrated film of all time?

0 Upvotes

And why is it My Fellow Americans?

Check the cast. Elite all around. Don’t miss the character actors like Rebhorn, Brimley, and Heard. It’s a furious comedy, but also a buddy road movie, and political drama, and much more.

Great script, great direction, and really tour de force performances from Lemmon and Garner. They play off each other so well, it’s close to Lemmon and Matthau.

Really interesting twist, and perfect pacing. Laughs + drama and hits so many good notes.


r/TrueFilm • • 18h ago

The Legend of 1900 as a counterpoint to Marty Supreme's philosophy

11 Upvotes

I watched Marty Supreme back when it was released in cinemas, and I remember not really connecting with him on a human level or seeing him as a real, flesh-and-blood character. To me, he was more like a walking symbol of pursuing your goals at all costs, "the American Dream", the "get rich or die trying" mentality, etc. Had loads of fun with the movie, though. This is just a reflection on the character himself.

I've recently watched Tornatore's The Legend of 1900 and, noticed that I had somewhat similar feelings. 1900 isn't a believable character, but he's not really meant to be one either. He's also more of a symbol. What struck me, though, is how different these characters are in what they symbolise, as if they're at opposite ends of the spectrum. Their entire philosophies on life, the freedom within it, and what they believe they deserve from it are completely different.

I find it interesting because I think it's generally easier to find cinematic characters more like Marty, who think the world is their oyster and belongs to them (Daniel Plainview from There Will Be Blood, Tony Montana from Scarface, The Wolf of Wall Street's Jordan Belfort etc.), rather than someone who sits at the complete opposite end of the spectrum. From the top of my head, I can only maybe think of Jim Jarmusch's Paterson (although to me he actually felt like a human, not just a symbol).

What do you think? Do you know more characters similar to 1900 here in his philosophy? I absolutely love this type of characters.


r/TrueFilm • • 19h ago

What are your thoughts on "My Dinner With Andre?" Spoiler

21 Upvotes

I just now finish My Dinner With Andre (1981) and really quite liked it, but I watched it by myself so now I need to kinda just talk about it. I'm just kinda going to ramble, I want to hear what everyone else has to say.

I found Wally and Andre's argument quite interesting. From articles I have read, many people have different interpretations on the views of the two and who they more sympathize with, and I think that's interesting. In my mind, the film showed Andre and Wally as both being correct, but also both being naïve or arrogant.

I felt, and Wally seemed to as well, that Andre's stories were ridiculous and pretentious. Even Andre seems to agree, but nonetheless throughout the film acts extremely self-important despite disparaging himself for his adventures earlier. He flippantly brings up the Nazis multiple times, even comparing him and his friends spiritual experiences to the Nazis. He seems to think he is making a profound point here, but Wally is noticeably perturbed by this. He compares New York City to a concentration camp, and rather arrogantly implies that the people comfortable there are too stupid to realize it's a prison while him and his fellow intellectuals will live in communes preserving the spirit of humanity with everyone else is existing as zombies. He compares calling a doorman "Jimmy" to chattel slavery. By being over dramatic, Andre is, intentionally or not, downplaying real suffering. He is a man of immense privilege, and why he calls himself out for this, still basks in that privilege throughout the conversation without noticing the irony.

Wally correctly points out that it is ridiculous to assert that one needs to go to Mount Everest to find meaning, and Andre does eventually agree with that and say it can be achieved at Antarctica or in one's own home. In fact, he says that he does quite like staying home and enjoying quite moments of simply being, and that he realized that he really does want to spend the rest of his life with his wife. So, despite his pretensions, he too finds comfort in simple worldly comforts.

Andre is right that simple routine numbs life, and it seems like rather than completely reinventing his life like he was trying to do with his adventures, the main thing that gave him a greater feeling of meaning in his life was just changing how he interacts with the life he already had. Similarly, Wally defends his mundane life, but on his car ride home is looking at the city in a much more personal and grounded way and re-experiencing the meaning it had already given him (as he had argued to Andre earlier that New York had just as much meaning as Mount Everest).

Andre kind of reminds me of that meme that goes "when someone has the exact same opinion as you but they express it in such an annoying and obnoxious way that you lowkey don't want to agree." Wally agrees with him about the state of modern society. He agrees about "sleepwalking" to arbitrary goals being a frustrating problem. Hell, Andre even ends up agreeing that he has found great meaning in his family connections (although it took an epiphany to reorient his way of looking at these connections). Wally is seemingly changed for the better from this conversation, having a chance to vent while always being prompted by Andre to change his outlook on the mundane aspects of his life (seen in the ride home). Perhaps Andre has changed too. It seems like his argument shifted multiple times over the course of the film, so perhaps he just needed a chance to argue these ideas with a friend to properly formulate and express the spiritual struggle he has been experiencing. It is unclear if Andre's contradictions are simply him being a hypocrite, or if he is changing his outlook on life simply by talking with Wally.

I think the most interesting irony in the film is the setting of the restaurant. Andre bemoans the alienation between people, and hates himself for his relationship with his apartment's doorman. Despite this, he only ever interacts with the waiter when they talk to him directly, and never pays them any real intention. Wally, on the other hand, makes eye contact with the waiter a couple of times. Its not much, but he notices the waiter more than Andre does. Us as the audience noticing the waiter more than either of them, as there are multiple shots either focusing on the waiter's face as he hears their conversation, or shows him working in the background while the two are oblivious. This culminates in the end of their conversation, where both realize that everyone else has been long gone and they are probably annoying the staff.

What do you think?


r/TrueFilm • • 1d ago

I watched The Substance and I hated it, but everyone else seems to love it and I can’t see why.

0 Upvotes

I have watched The Substance after it was recommended to me by one of my friends. He is a cinephile and, in my opinion, has good taste. More often than not, we enjoy similar kinds of films. Therefore, I immediately wanted to watch this film after he told me that it is in his top 10 of all times.

(Obviously, the rest of this post will include spoilers of the film.)

I hated the film. Most definitely the worst I have watched this year. I started hating it halfway through and, once finished, I felt almost mad by how bad it was.

There is so much I could say it was wrong with it, but the main thing is that the whole premise doesn’t make sense. Elisabeth is scared about ageing and what this means for her career and she hopes to re-experience youth again by using the substance… yet, she does not share any memory with the young version of herself, who in practice is a whole different individual. What exactly is the benefit of using the substance then? The protagonist does not get to experience her youth again; she absolutely gains nothing from the whole experience. In fact, all of the consequences of using the substance are negative to her. The whole premise doesn’t make sense at all.

Another thing I disliked intensively is how nothing is subtle in the film. Men in the entertainment are gross and misogynistic? Let’s make sure to show this by dedicating a whole minute to a gross men eating gross shrimps in a gross way with a gross closeup of his mouth. The entertainment industry dehumanises and hyper-sexualise women? Let’s have Sue perform the raunchiest, most stripper-worthy choreography on her fitness tv show. And so on… it genuinely felt like the director didn’t trust the audience to grasp the very basic metaphors of this film so she made sure to shove them down our throats in the most obvious ways.

I spoke with my friend about these things and he was extremely surprised that I didn’t like the film. According to him, I was taking the film too seriously that I missed the “true meaning” of it (the whole satire on the entertainment industry and how it treats women), but I got these themes perfectly and, to be honest, I don’t think they are particularly original or explored in a meaningful way here. He also said that the film is meant to be camp and I didn’t get that. I don’t think this film is camp. I think this is a film that wants to be camp, but it takes itself too seriously to be so. If it was really camp, I would’ve forgiven many of the film’s ridiculous scenes, like the whole Sue-builds-a-secret-room-in-the-bathroom thing. Instead, I just think they are nonsensical. To be fair, the final act is the only part I enjoyed and that I could clearly see as camp (when Elisabeth goes to the new year show as a monster).

I have also discussed the film with other people and, again, I seemed to be the odd one out as they all liked it. Similarly, the reviews online are good, and ratings on websites like IMDB are good too. I’m lost as to why… If I wanted to watch a body-horror film about ageing women there is Death Becomes Her, which, while hardly being a masterpiece, is at least fun. Again, if I wanted a film about the struggles of an ageing actress then there is Sunset Boulevard. If I wanted a film that satires the whole entertainment industry… where do I even begin with the alternatives? I just think The Substance is a terrible film that has nothing of value to offer.

Now, I know very well that I don’t have to like something only because it’s well received by other people. I can appreciate when a film is not for me, yet I can still understand while others might appreciate. The Substance, though… I just don’t think is a good film at all and I believe it should not be so well regarded. I’m really stumped as to why this film is rated highly and now I’m genuinely questioning myself whether I really missed something. Or maybe my taste in films is actually crap? Or maybe the hype around this film is more powerful than the film itself?


r/TrueFilm • • 1d ago

FFF Nowhere to Hide (1999), directed by Myung-Se Lee - Is it any good?

4 Upvotes

Looking through an old laptop recently, I found this review I wrote about 15 years ago. The movie sounds pretty cool, but honestly, I don't recall a single frame.

Does anyone else know it and what were your thoughts? Is it worth a rewatch?

Thank you!

"Although frequently over-the-top, this Korean-language thriller’s highly-stylized aesthetic is what makes it so unique, even if one can never take it very seriously. Meanwhile, it features a terrific performance by Joong-Hoon Park as a violent slob of a cop in the Popeye Doyle tradition.

The slaying of a gangland leader puts the Homicide Division’s best detectives, Woo (Joong-Hoon) and Kim (Dong-Kun Jang), on the trail of an assassin named Sungmin (Sung-Kee Ahn). As one might expect, the two cops are yin and yang: Kim is a conventionally-handsome, introspective family man, while Woo is a blustery, mean-tempered bear of a cop whose first instinct is usually force. But saying he’s tough would be an understatement. In the film’s opening montage, Woo takes on an entire gang of hoods in a warehouse single-handedly, displaying an agility that would make Sammo Hung nod in recognition.

Writer/director Lee liberally cuts back-and forth from that pitched fight to Kim and the others from the Homicide Division, who strut around carrying metal pipes, which they use to check the air in criminals’ heads. They resemble a pack of vigilantes more than police, and that, the filmmakers seem to argue, is the reason they’re so effective at their jobs. Like many classic cop movies, success in “Nowhere to Hide” requires tossing out the proverbial rulebook and resorting to excesses like torture and beatings; however, there are blackly-humorous touches that take some sting out of the brutality (at one point, the entire division decides to beat up on a suspect, but in their unbridled enthusiasm, they trash their own headquarters, too).

The subject matter has the potential to be thought-provoking, but the story occasionally gets lost amidst the hyperactive visuals. “Nowhere to Hide’s” first third is a seemingly-non-stop tumult of freeze frames, slow-motion, punk rock guitar riffs and sound-mixing straight out of a spaghetti Western. Now don’t get me wrong; the blitzkrieg of sight and sound does get the adrenaline pumping to a certain extent, which is probably Lee’s intent. My only criticism is it doesn’t ebb and flow the way, say, Kar-Wai’s equally-playful “Fallen Angels” does; rather, it talks in a steady stream of exclamation points as a Michael Bay flick might.

Luckily, once the central investigation kicks in, the visual excesses seem appropriate, what with the lengths Woo, Kim, and the others are willing to go to collar their killer. Moreover, especially during the second half, Lee actually seems to tone things down, as if realizing the performances and plot were now sufficient to maintaining his audience’s attention. The movie continues to be inventive, albeit in ways film buffs may find derivative: the occasional emphasis on powerful images over continuity, a la Seijun Suzuki; voyeuristic first-person tracking shots similar to Shohei Imamura.

Although “Nowhere to Hide” concerns the Homicide Division as opposed to narcotics, like “The French Connection,” the plot involves surveillance and pursuit (including a memorable set piece involving a train) and cops who play it close to the edge. Detective Woo has the same distinctive hat-wear and smile suggesting a punch to the face that Gene Hackman packed, and once the film races to its conclusion, it leans more heavily on Joong-Hoon, who conveys surprising depths to this unapologetic thug. As he explains to a beautiful co-conspirator (Ji-Woo Choi) of Sugmin’s whom they hope to bring around to their side, he knows his job, and that’s nailing the bad guy by any means necessary.

Woo is so convincing at not seeming self-delusional that the denouement – one of those “waiting by the side of the road, hoping for the woman whose boyfriend you just served justice to will give you the time of day” shots, seemingly borrowed from “The Third Man” – is rather poignant."


r/TrueFilm • • 1d ago

Robert Bresson praised the 1981 James Bond film, For Your Eyes Only.

68 Upvotes

"It filled me with wonder, because of its cinematographic writing…if I could have seen it twice in a row and again the next day, I would have done.”

These were the words Bresson used to praise For Your Eyes Only. Bresson was staunchly against anything theatrical in his films, he always aimed for the natural. He never had professional actors. That's why it is so interesting to me and other fans of his work to hear that he fell in love with this particular James Bond film! I am just guessing here but perhaps he liked the minimalist visual style of the movie? I am not a huge FYEO fan myself but what I do like about the film is its basic down to earth quality. Take the raid on the warehouse which was just two groups of men and some machine guns in a dusty old building. I always find it interesting when you hear elite auteurs enjoying mainstream entertainment. For example, Andrei Tarkovsky actually enjoyed the first Terminator movie! Not too surprising given his concern about high technology but still, one wouldn't expect him to enjoy any mainstream entertainment!


r/TrueFilm • • 1d ago

Using filmmakers' own favourite films as a way into new areas of cinema

21 Upvotes

One of the ways I find films I wouldn't otherwise come across is going through the lists filmmakers have made of the films they love or recommend. They tend to lead somewhere a critics' poll wouldn't: a director's influences, older films from other countries, the odd thing you'd never have picked up yourself.

I've been putting these together in one place. So far I have lists from Martin Scorsese, Spike Lee, Quentin Tarantino, Francis Ford Coppola, Mike Leigh, Stanley Kubrick, Andrei Tarkovsky, Ingmar Bergman, Guillermo del Toro, Hirokazu Kore-eda, Bong Joon Ho, Wong Kar-wai, Luca Guadagnino, Joachim Trier, Lynne Ramsay, Joanna Hogg, Steve McQueen, Paul Schrader, Ari Aster, Edgar Wright, Sofia Coppola, Wes Anderson and Richard Linklater, each linked to where the filmmaker published it. I also mapped which directors voted for which in the 2022 Sight and Sound directors' poll, which turned out to be a good way of seeing who influenced whom.

Does anyone else find films this way? And does anyone know of lists I'm missing, from interviews, books, letters, old magazine pieces or anywhere else a filmmaker has written down what they'd recommend?

This is the list I have so far: tryfaro.app/guide/filmmakers/

This is a map I put together based on the 2022 Sight and Sound directors' poll. More for fun than function: tryfaro.app/map/directors-poll-2022/


r/TrueFilm • • 1d ago

The Face of Another(1966)

6 Upvotes

A film by Hiroshi Teshigahara, known for one of the most significant contributors in Japanese new wave and adapted from the book by Kobo Abe(They collaborated together in Woman in the dunes too, another brilliant film).

How the appearance of us can influence how we think about others and how it changes our self perception is a core theme of this film, but thats not it. Post World War Japan is a huge context here. The main character(Okuyama) is a burn victim and his face is severely disfigured because of an industrial accident. He is self pitiful to his situation because it happened in a mundane way and thinks if it happened during a war it would had some kind of prestige. Eventually he gets a mask prepared by a curious surgeon who is interested to see Okuyama’s evaluation socially and in his family life. There is a subplot which follows another burn victim from the atom bomb incident. So in the film, we follow two characters where one is trying to escape his scar with fake identity, and another one is with Okuyama’s preferred version of disfigurement.

The film is also an exploration of male ego and the insecurity in the intimate life in the ongoing rapid change after the war in the society. At the same time, it explores that whether the war is the main reason behind the growing detachments of victims of society or the uncontrollable speed of the industrialization just doesnt have time for that.

From the very first moment, you can understand its gonna be a visual treat. The set design of doctor’s chamber feels surreal whenever the plot goes there.

I dont think there is any word needed to say about Nakadai’s performance here, he is legend for a reason. The thing i liked most that after he gets the mask, its not like he is just acting without the bandages, they actually used prosthetic on his face, so when he is going out with mask it looks stiffy and kind of uncanny, and the unnatural facial reactions contributes to it too.

Overall a great film, and timelessly relatable no matter whats the setting here. If you are a fan of works of other directors in the new wave or watched woman in the dunes, or just finding something to watch which looks stunning and provides you room for thoughts, you definitely should try this out. Thanks!


r/TrueFilm • • 2d ago

Looking for movies with a similar narrative catalyst to Paper Tiger in the sense of "you saw something you weren't supposed to see"

32 Upvotes

Old, new, foreign, domestic, looking for other movies where a character comes across something they weren't supposed to and is forced to deal with the consequences of such.

Edit: To be more specific -- looking for movies where the characters aren't intentionally looking or investigating it, they just happen to stumble across the situation by accident.

One of my favorite parts of Paper Tiger was the family's unintended involvement in what James Gray described as the "ocean of malevolence" that exists underneath us at all times but that we usually never get exposed to.

Maybe something like

Witness (1985) Eyes Wide Shut (1999) Green Room (2015)

Edit:

Lot of good recommendations so far so I'm going to collate them into an updated list:

Rear Window (1954)

Blow-Up (1966)

Blow Out (1981)

Blue Velvet (1986)

Blindspotting (2018)

The Parallax View (1974)

Klute (1971)

All The President's Men (1976)

Fallen Idol (1948)

Race with the Devil (1975)


r/TrueFilm • • 2d ago

Question for people who saw You Can See Everything in the theater

39 Upvotes

Saw it last month and thought it was incredible, and I intend to see it in the very near future, pending its availability screening-wise in my area. How did the audience at your theater react when Amanda Seyfried told Billy Evans that she thought Charlie Kirk was a pussy? Which theater did you see it? This moment got the biggest audience reaction at my screening (Greendale, Wisconsin, October 31). My friends have been steadily seeing it since it came out, and have also commented on the audience reaction at this moment, and I am curious about this.


r/TrueFilm • • 2d ago

About Elly (2009) discussion

6 Upvotes

I watched this movie a couple of days ago and I’m still thinking about it, because i seem to stand behind the “villains” of the story. Although I know in Farhadis fils the characters are usually morally ambiguous and can’t be categorized under “bad” or “good”, but after i took a good look on some reviews of the film i found most people agreeing on the characters in the film being in the wrong for throwing Elly under the bus like that instead of protecting her honor by saying that Elly didn’t immediately agree on going to the trip.
The way i see it, the characters beside Sepideh had the right to cover for themselves since they didn’t know Elly was engaged. The burden of telling the truth was unto Sepideh only even if she felt pressured by her husband and friends. I don’t know if this is a weird take but it’s been bugging me since i loved the movie but i cant seem to find anyone to agree with me on this.


r/TrueFilm • • 3d ago

Shoot the Piano Player 1960

10 Upvotes

I have recently watched this truffaut film, which I really really enjoyed since it amaglamtes so many genre so smoothly that you often find yourself flooded with distinctive emotions at once.

Though, I really want to discuss the main character Charlie, whom I perceived completely different from how it is been discussed by the makers and other film goers. While I understand that a good film and a good character can be perceived anyhow and that's what makes it great but I really want to know and discuss how you think about it if you enjoyed or seen the film.

I feel the charlie as a kid got into music to get away from the influence and behavour of his brothers, which he found probably too toxic or violent. He seen music as an escape from the family since he never felt belonged there especially when it comes to brothers.

Though, when the same music got associated with violence, and guilt, he went away from that as well. I feel he played charlie very tenderly in the start when you see him proposing his wife and being with her. But then as soon as the fame hits, he find himself behaving the same way all other men do such as being rigid, arrogant, conscious about his image and lusting over pretty women (infedility).

He does completely opposite of what he thinks which is reflection of probably the influence of the family and the society expectation of how men should behave. He doesn't want to do it but yet he does because he couldn't surpress the instinct that he developed because of the society or the family.

Later on when we see him playing in the bar, you see him again retrospecting, trying to be tender, dealing with guilt but at times the influence does get strong and he act as a typical man which he is always running away from. Here he is too confused and too restrained, doesn't know who he is, what he wants, he is just drowned in too much thoughts.

In the end, when he goes back to the family, he is in guilt that he has become what he always repelled. But then lena comes and says that he is proven innocent, the hope returns but then faith and destiny pulls him back and takes him to exactly what he feared, which is that he will end up alone with no love and become like his brothers.

While there are a lot of nuances but i feel this is how I mainly saw the character and how he performed it. Love to know what all of you think.


r/TrueFilm • • 3d ago

Who are the modern Kaels and Eberts?

84 Upvotes

I look at my bookshelf, and among the many biographies of actors and directors, screenplays of the best written films in history, and film theory and history treatises are a fair number of film criticism collections, the best of which were penned by Roger Ebert, Pauline Kael, and other critics from decades past.

While I know the landscape has changed and we no longer get reviews in newspapers, in Sunday morning syndicated shows like Siskel & Ebert at the Movies, or see published collections of critics' best or most influential reviews, but who are the voices worth reading today in the realm of film criticism?

I have found myself liking a lot of David Ehrlich's pieces in IndieWire and David Chen on his podcast, but there have to be more. Who am I missing and where can I regularly find their work without needing to get past a paywall or deal with the inanity of one-line letterboxd nonsense?