r/TrueFilm • • 8h ago

You Can See Everything: The Real Intent of "Who's On First"

140 Upvotes

I just rewatched YCSE in theaters and took my brother (his first time), and he picked up on a really brilliant dimension to the Who's On First scene that I myself didn't catch the first time. All credit for this insight goes to him really.

I saw some critique of Nathan for focusing too much on Elizabeth's use of "can" vs. "capable of", and apparently boiling down Theranos' lies to mere semantic confusion, driven home by showing her Who's On First, her not getting it, and Billy using it to say that "her mind just works differently". Even I thought the first time that he was focusing too much on this aspect of things when the scope of Theranos' fraud was way, way bigger.

But my brother pointed out that Nathan actually doing something way more devious and brilliant: to Elizabeth and Billy, he is seemingly giving them an out, by allowing them to latch onto his "semantic misunderstanding" framing to portray Elizabeth as some tragically poor communicator, a hapless victim of her so-called "literal thinking" getting lost in translation. But them acting like this explanation is sufficient is itself incredibly damning in a way neither of them appeared to realize in that scene.

The whole crux of the Who's On First routine lies in the deliberately confusing use of words - the joke, as Nathan explains in case wasn't obvious, is that "Who" is the name of the player who is on first. But to adopt such a misleading framing when dealing with investors, the public, and hundreds of millions of dollars at stake is absolutely unacceptable in any world, no matter how firm your grasp of semantics. And yet neither Elizabeth or Billy seem to understand this at all - Billy, delusional idiot that he is, even says "I'm so happy you showed this to us", seemingly missing that it makes Elizabeth look staggeringly, spectacularly incompetent at best, and utterly dishonest and manipulative at worst. And it makes both of them look like people with the audacity to (still) believe that everyone around them could be THAT stupid.

Which is why the criticism that Nathan was reducing the Theranos case to semantics and words misses the point: that framing was just for Elizabeth and Billy, to set up the trap he lays for them in the Who's On First scene, which is the punchline he intends for us, the audience. The horror of the fact that they believe such a misunderstanding is an adequate rationale/alibi, from watching a comedy routine where the confusion is very much the point. And they completely take the bait.


r/TrueFilm • • 16h ago

What are your thoughts on "My Dinner With Andre?" Spoiler

20 Upvotes

I just now finish My Dinner With Andre (1981) and really quite liked it, but I watched it by myself so now I need to kinda just talk about it. I'm just kinda going to ramble, I want to hear what everyone else has to say.

I found Wally and Andre's argument quite interesting. From articles I have read, many people have different interpretations on the views of the two and who they more sympathize with, and I think that's interesting. In my mind, the film showed Andre and Wally as both being correct, but also both being naïve or arrogant.

I felt, and Wally seemed to as well, that Andre's stories were ridiculous and pretentious. Even Andre seems to agree, but nonetheless throughout the film acts extremely self-important despite disparaging himself for his adventures earlier. He flippantly brings up the Nazis multiple times, even comparing him and his friends spiritual experiences to the Nazis. He seems to think he is making a profound point here, but Wally is noticeably perturbed by this. He compares New York City to a concentration camp, and rather arrogantly implies that the people comfortable there are too stupid to realize it's a prison while him and his fellow intellectuals will live in communes preserving the spirit of humanity with everyone else is existing as zombies. He compares calling a doorman "Jimmy" to chattel slavery. By being over dramatic, Andre is, intentionally or not, downplaying real suffering. He is a man of immense privilege, and why he calls himself out for this, still basks in that privilege throughout the conversation without noticing the irony.

Wally correctly points out that it is ridiculous to assert that one needs to go to Mount Everest to find meaning, and Andre does eventually agree with that and say it can be achieved at Antarctica or in one's own home. In fact, he says that he does quite like staying home and enjoying quite moments of simply being, and that he realized that he really does want to spend the rest of his life with his wife. So, despite his pretensions, he too finds comfort in simple worldly comforts.

Andre is right that simple routine numbs life, and it seems like rather than completely reinventing his life like he was trying to do with his adventures, the main thing that gave him a greater feeling of meaning in his life was just changing how he interacts with the life he already had. Similarly, Wally defends his mundane life, but on his car ride home is looking at the city in a much more personal and grounded way and re-experiencing the meaning it had already given him (as he had argued to Andre earlier that New York had just as much meaning as Mount Everest).

Andre kind of reminds me of that meme that goes "when someone has the exact same opinion as you but they express it in such an annoying and obnoxious way that you lowkey don't want to agree." Wally agrees with him about the state of modern society. He agrees about "sleepwalking" to arbitrary goals being a frustrating problem. Hell, Andre even ends up agreeing that he has found great meaning in his family connections (although it took an epiphany to reorient his way of looking at these connections). Wally is seemingly changed for the better from this conversation, having a chance to vent while always being prompted by Andre to change his outlook on the mundane aspects of his life (seen in the ride home). Perhaps Andre has changed too. It seems like his argument shifted multiple times over the course of the film, so perhaps he just needed a chance to argue these ideas with a friend to properly formulate and express the spiritual struggle he has been experiencing. It is unclear if Andre's contradictions are simply him being a hypocrite, or if he is changing his outlook on life simply by talking with Wally.

I think the most interesting irony in the film is the setting of the restaurant. Andre bemoans the alienation between people, and hates himself for his relationship with his apartment's doorman. Despite this, he only ever interacts with the waiter when they talk to him directly, and never pays them any real intention. Wally, on the other hand, makes eye contact with the waiter a couple of times. Its not much, but he notices the waiter more than Andre does. Us as the audience noticing the waiter more than either of them, as there are multiple shots either focusing on the waiter's face as he hears their conversation, or shows him working in the background while the two are oblivious. This culminates in the end of their conversation, where both realize that everyone else has been long gone and they are probably annoying the staff.

What do you think?


r/TrueFilm • • 16h ago

The Legend of 1900 as a counterpoint to Marty Supreme's philosophy

11 Upvotes

I watched Marty Supreme back when it was released in cinemas, and I remember not really connecting with him on a human level or seeing him as a real, flesh-and-blood character. To me, he was more like a walking symbol of pursuing your goals at all costs, "the American Dream", the "get rich or die trying" mentality, etc. Had loads of fun with the movie, though. This is just a reflection on the character himself.

I've recently watched Tornatore's The Legend of 1900 and, noticed that I had somewhat similar feelings. 1900 isn't a believable character, but he's not really meant to be one either. He's also more of a symbol. What struck me, though, is how different these characters are in what they symbolise, as if they're at opposite ends of the spectrum. Their entire philosophies on life, the freedom within it, and what they believe they deserve from it are completely different.

I find it interesting because I think it's generally easier to find cinematic characters more like Marty, who think the world is their oyster and belongs to them (Daniel Plainview from There Will Be Blood, Tony Montana from Scarface, The Wolf of Wall Street's Jordan Belfort etc.), rather than someone who sits at the complete opposite end of the spectrum. From the top of my head, I can only maybe think of Jim Jarmusch's Paterson (although to me he actually felt like a human, not just a symbol).

What do you think? Do you know more characters similar to 1900 here in his philosophy? I absolutely love this type of characters.


r/TrueFilm • • 5h ago

Racialized Gender Stereotyping in Hollywood

8 Upvotes

Now after watching new new hunger games film i can’t get this out of my mind so I wanted to talk about two things.

First of all Asian male representation in Hollywood media:

Regarding the hunger games franchise, this is only an example. I haven’t read the books, so when I found out Ben Wang was casted in this film I was pretty hyped. Going into this film I hoped that maybe his character was more of a leader, confident and stronger in a way, that type of characteristics. But once again the only Asian male in the entire film is a weaker, self conscious guy who’s exceptionally good at numbers/ math and used for comedic relief. We really need to stop this trope guys.

I could say the same thing about Asian females representation but this is different. Asian men are often deromanticized/desexualised. Asian women are being hyper sexualised or fetishized and often chase white boys.
That’s the same for many poc women in film, most couples are white male + poc/mixed female.
For example, in regard to the hunger games films in both the last films it was that paring. But it’s found in most films nowadays.

We almost never see the opposite, in comparison it’s just crazy and I’m wondering how not more people are seeing these two things. It’s 2026 and we’re still doing this.

Everyone deserves complex, well rounded representation in characters, that goes beyond cliches and stereotypes. Diversity in romance shouldn't just mean pairing women of color or mixed race women with white male leads while men of color are left out of romantic storylines altogether.


r/TrueFilm • • 12h ago

possible love - let's talk cheol Spoiler

5 Upvotes

his character and his dynamics are the hardest to read. the main four are well communicated but cheol is a more subtle character.

what do we make of cheol? what about his relationship dynamics? He's a wall flower voyeur around the main four but finds friendship with the gardener and sangwoo. those are the only two we see him come alive. what was lee chang dong trying to communicate about him there?

also really interesting is that shoe tying scene at the end - where the blue collar damoly is leaving and sangwoo who we realize at this point is an exploitative predator goes out of his way to loom out for cheol by stopping him and tying his shoe. so uncharacteristic for a villain. what do we make of that? who is sangwoo with that dynamic in mind.

what does it mean that cheol steals the whistle and it's implied there's a spirotual connection brw cheol and the gardener through that whistle?

share you thoughts on cheol below.


r/TrueFilm • • 2h ago

WHYBW What Have You Been Watching? (Week of (November 22, 2026)

2 Upvotes

Please don't downvote opinions. Only downvote comments that don't contribute anything. Check out the WHYBW archives.