r/beetle • u/Fit_Relationship_338 • 2h ago
1973 Super Beetle stuck in 2nd (again) after hockey stick fix — what broke, and should I fix it or sell it as-is?
Looking for advice from people who know these transmissions better than I do.
My 1973 Super Beetle got stuck in 2nd gear. My dad and I pulled the engine and transmission, opened the nose cone, and put the hockey stick back in place. While it was out we replaced some gaskets because it was leaking — we took off some side covers, but we didn't really touch the internals of the transmission itself.
After putting the engine and transmission back in, we were able to drive it around the yard, and it cycled through 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th. But it would not go in reverse — the shifter would shift into the reverse position, but the car just would not move backwards.
While messing with it trying to get reverse to work, it's now stuck in 2nd gear again.
For context on the car itself: the engine runs great, there's very little rust if any, I'm in Georgia, and I only have a bill of sale for it — no title. I also only paid $6,000 for the car, which plays into how much it even makes sense to put into it.
A few questions:
- I'm trying to understand what actually happened here. My worry is that I may have broken something internally the first time, when I was originally trying to get it into reverse — that's the original incident that got us into this position in the first place. So even though we realigned the hockey stick, maybe there was still an underlying issue inside the transmission the whole time. Now it seems like it's just gotten misaligned again, and that underlying issue still persists, so nothing I do with the hockey stick will actually fix it. Does that sound plausible, and is there a way to tell whether it's just the hockey stick again versus something broken internally from the start?
- At that point, is it worth getting a whole new/replacement transmission altogether, or just not bothering with it at the price I got this car for?
- I'm planning to sell the car anyway and I'm getting close to being tired of messing with it. What's a realistic value for a 1973 Super Beetle with a great-running engine and very little rust, but a bad/stuck transmission and bill of sale only, sold as-is in Georgia?
- Would it be worth sourcing a used/rebuilt transmission and swapping it in myself before selling, or would I not get that money back out of it, given I only paid $6,000 for the car?
- If I paid a shop instead, what's a ballpark labor cost to swap or fix one of these?
Trying to decide if it's worth one more weekend, a shop bill, a whole replacement transmission, or just listing it as a project. Thanks in advance.