r/buildingscience • u/JustMtnB44 • 19h ago
Vaulted ceiling insulation strategy for 1960s house
I'm renovating a 1961 mid century modern inspired split level house that I purchased recently and have not moved into yet. It had original acoustic tiles glued to the drywall of the living room vaulted ceiling that were ugly so we tore the whole ceiling out. The house is fully insulated with 1960's fiberglass bats, the original version that has no R value printed on them and are only 2-3 inches thick at best and definitely less than R10. Obviously we should replace the ceiling insulation and air seal while it's open, but I'm struggling with the best way to do it.
We are in climate zone 5a with hot humid summers and variable winters that can be cold and snowy.
The rafters are only 2x6's, which is why there is a beam supporting them in the center. That doesn't leave a lot of room for insulation. The roof has 2ft overhangs/eaves all around that are open into the living space, and have a vent in them. This roof continues up over the upstairs bedrooms to form a gable, but there is no ridge or gable vents. The roof shingles were replaced in 2018 and solar panels were added to this vaulted section a few years ago, so adding any exterior insulation is impractical at this time. It's also impractical to fur out the rafters to add more depth as the ceiling isn't that high; the point where I took the second picture from at the railing the floor to ceiling height is only 80".
Initially I was thinking of using Rockwool bats in the cavities with a smart vapor retarder on the inside, but that only gets R23. Our GC is recommending closed cell spray foam that is sprayed about 4" thick and can achieve R34 and air seal as well. Initially I was concerned about closed cell spray foam from both the environmental and off gassing issues perspective. Is it the best way to solve this problem?
We will also insulate the attic area adjacent to this section of roof, but for that the GC is recommending to blow in insulation over the room ceilings and not spray foam under the roof deck. We would air seal what we can before adding the insulation.
