r/buildingscience • • Jan 19 '21

Reminder Of What This Sub Is All About

94 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

There's been a bit of spam in the mod queue lately and I figured it'd be useful to touch base and remind folks what this space is really all about.

It's not a job board or a place to promote building products (unless you're talking about some brand new membrane dehumidification product that nobody's ever seen before). It's not a place to have people help you figure out how to unlock a door. It is a place to discuss questions about how products work or fail, field techniques, research literature, adjacent relevant fields of research, and field practices. Remember that this is a unique science subreddit in that we occupy the space between research, manufacturing, and field reality. We are one of the best examples of applied science out there. So let's think about content through that lens. Let's share things that advance the conversation and help people take their learning to a deeper level. All are welcome, just don't spam pls.


r/buildingscience • • Jan 26 '23

Building Science Discord

Thumbnail
discord.gg
9 Upvotes

r/buildingscience • • 42m ago

Question Waterproof Old Basement Slab?

1 Upvotes

1950s home with typical slab. Unfortunately, it was painted at some point and that of course never adhered well due to moisture and the slab itself crumbles in spots. It's fine for an unfinished space but needs to be properly sealed before I finish the basement. The rear of the home is a walkout and have considered both exterior and interior drain along front of the home, just for as much moisture management as possible. We are on a ridge though so it's mostly just natural clay soil moisture we have. No bulk water issue.

Anyhow, I was considering a few options:

  1. Dimple mat adhesive and taped seams, including around the entire CMU wall. The goal being that the moisture is completely stopped under the wall. I am thinking the dimple mat air space itself still provides a better capillary break. But I can't imagine it doesn't become completely wet/humid... Equilibrium with the slab and soil though? And don't see it actually "drying" in any way and if the outter else left open it's just opportunity for moisture (and mold) to release into air. I'll seal it off entirely.

Then adavantech subfloor floated. Flooring over that. All completed floating. Nothing securing through the dimple mat. I don't think I'll bother with foam under subfloor.

2. Liquid applied waterproof membrane. This would require some sort removal of my painted subfloor and don't want to do that. But perhaps this would be more reliable than the dimple mat? But I don't know if dimple mat provides a better moisture and capillary break? Not sure if the science but the air gap of dimple mat and not having to rely on the membrane adhesion is better. This saves some space but simple mat isn't that tall.

3. Some plastic vapor barrier and concrete poured over the top. Then subfloor and flooring. I'd still do it all floating but this is most expensive and also tallest since I suspect concrete would need to be at least 2" if not more? And I'd admittedly fear subfloor directly on this concrete, though maybe that's unfounded. Since I have the vapor break under it.

Any advice on each? Which is preferred? Science behind? Pros / cons? Other options?

The CMU wall I'm going to just leave gap behind when I install my walls. For one, leaves space for running some utilities but also ensures I have complete air flow for drying and the entire space has dehumidifying and will pull returns in that make sure ever separate space draws out the air.


r/buildingscience • • 1d ago

Vaulted ceiling insulation strategy for 1960s house

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

I'm renovating a 1961 mid century modern inspired split level house that I purchased recently and have not moved into yet. It had original acoustic tiles glued to the drywall of the living room vaulted ceiling that were ugly so we tore the whole ceiling out. The house is fully insulated with 1960's fiberglass bats, the original version that has no R value printed on them and are only 2-3 inches thick at best and definitely less than R10. Obviously we should replace the ceiling insulation and air seal while it's open, but I'm struggling with the best way to do it.

We are in climate zone 5a with hot humid summers and variable winters that can be cold and snowy.

The rafters are only 2x6's, which is why there is a beam supporting them in the center. That doesn't leave a lot of room for insulation. The roof has 2ft overhangs/eaves all around that are open into the living space, and have a vent in them. This roof continues up over the upstairs bedrooms to form a gable, but there is no ridge or gable vents. The roof shingles were replaced in 2018 and solar panels were added to this vaulted section a few years ago, so adding any exterior insulation is impractical at this time. It's also impractical to fur out the rafters to add more depth as the ceiling isn't that high; the point where I took the second picture from at the railing the floor to ceiling height is only 80".

Initially I was thinking of using Rockwool bats in the cavities with a smart vapor retarder on the inside, but that only gets R23. Our GC is recommending closed cell spray foam that is sprayed about 4" thick and can achieve R34 and air seal as well. Initially I was concerned about closed cell spray foam from both the environmental and off gassing issues perspective. Is it the best way to solve this problem?

We will also insulate the attic area adjacent to this section of roof, but for that the GC is recommending to blow in insulation over the room ceilings and not spray foam under the roof deck. We would air seal what we can before adding the insulation.


r/buildingscience • • 16h ago

I think I created a triple moisture barrier (facepalm)

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

r/buildingscience • • 14h ago

Going from 1.0 to 0.1 ACH50 might save us only $15/month. What else makes it worthwhile?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/buildingscience • • 18h ago

If I air seal my attic and rim joists, do I have to replace the boiler in my basement?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/buildingscience • • 18h ago

If I air seal my attic and rim joists, do I have to replace the boiler in my basement?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/buildingscience • • 21h ago

IWI vapour-open systems

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/buildingscience • • 1d ago

Pole Barn / Woodshop Insulation

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/buildingscience • • 2d ago

Question Interesting video. I know I've always just trusted my spray foam subs. Is anyone doing a deep dive with the spray foam installations? QA/QC-wise? Talking to the sub and lead man about substrate moisture content, ambient temps, ambient relative humidity, reviewing the TDS and spraying parameters...

Thumbnail
youtu.be
21 Upvotes

Interesting video. I know I've always just trusted my spray foam subs. Is anyone doing a deep dive with the spray foam installations? QA/QC-wise? Talking to the sub and lead man about substrate moisture content, ambient temps, ambient relative humidity, reviewing the TDS and spraying parameters - mixing temps and ratios, calibrating the spray nozzle, etc., etc.? Vetting the training (and certifications) of the crew and spray man?

It's not like we can be in the house watching the installation either. I wouldn't go in there even completely tyvek-suited up with a backpack air-pack on.

In other words, being proactive up-front to prevent problems like these? Granted, I'm sure these types of situations are rare.

What's the appropriate level of BS "best practices" with regard to spray foam installations?


r/buildingscience • • 1d ago

Question Hanging hammock swing indoors

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I’ve had a hanging hammock swing hanging from the ceiling in my room for 2 years, I regularly use it and it’s been fine. I’m rearranging my room and want to move it across the room. I became curious and looked it up, and found many people saying it’s dangerous to put it up in a house such as mine (second story room with an attic above, house built in 2012, presumably 2x4 joists, according to what I’ve seen I most likely have engineered roof trusses with bottom chords as ceiling joists).

At first I thought that, at worst, I could build a wooden reinforcement and go into the attic to install it. But I took a quick look in my attic and I can’t even see the joists because the insulation is so deep, and I’m afraid if I did go up there I’d fall through the ceiling because I can’t see anything. Even if building a reinforcement to hang the hammock, I have no idea what I’m doing as far as roof structures go, and I’m afraid I will do something wrong.

Any help or guidance is so much appreciated. I’m neurodivergent and this swing is a calming thing for me that I need. If it helps, I’m around 150lbs and am including pictures:
•My type of hammock swing
•The bracket I will be using
•A few pictures of what it looks like in my attic above the room I will be using
•The picture without insulation is above my garage and might give a better idea of how my trusses might be laid out
•A picture of where I’m wanting it to go in my room indicated by a yellow magnetic stud finder on the ceiling


r/buildingscience • • 1d ago

Continuous external insulation installers

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/buildingscience • • 2d ago

Question Zehnder ComfoFond-L (brine ground loop ERV preheat) in a cold climate: anyone sized or installed one in the US?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/buildingscience • • 2d ago

Has anyone taken the BPI energy auditor exam recently?

0 Upvotes

r/buildingscience • • 2d ago

wood floor above slab

2 Upvotes

Im doing a wood floor on top of a slab. Construction documents include a build up of a 3/4" subfloor directly on top of slab with 1/4" cork underlayment between 3/4" finish floor and subfloor. theres no room for any sleeper framing as this 1-3/4" build up due to door heights / clearances. Slab was poured in July, is 4" thick with 12" thickened haunches in areas, and includes a 15mil vapor barrier below. Zone 6a

Not sure the best way to put the subfloor down. I think using glue as opposed to mechanical fastners may be best option?

I know this isnt exactly a building science related question, but ive been hesitant to start because of potential moisture in the slab not having anywhere to escape? Project sequencing is looming though. Looking for any advice! thanks!


r/buildingscience • • 2d ago

Mold beneath sleeper floor system

Post image
2 Upvotes

Mold in floor

So my customer had someone build addition over concrete patio 2-3 years ago. Photo above is during construction. Guy did spf sleeper floor system and 3/4” t&g no vapor barrier. Homeowner has tested for mold. Aspergillosis and penicillin are of charts beneath floor. They want to rip this out, mitigate and put back together. My thought is rip sleepers out. Seal slab and lvp on top and learn to live with 2”heights difference. Main concern tho is preventing any further organic growth. Anybody have some insight or SOP that applies here?


r/buildingscience • • 2d ago

Question How are radiant heated film floor heat systems in the market?

2 Upvotes

I’ve been very confused lately. I’m an installer and I do tile floors and different floating floors. I’ve gone to a few local trade shows and the past two NWFA shows to understand what I can offer for radiant heat on the floors. I know there’s a lot of perspectives on floor heat in general but what I’m really confused about is how major retailers are still selling heated film systems for heated floors and they claim ETL certified. Everyone is telling me at the these shows that they are not UL approved anymore and most inspectors will ask you to remove it since it doesn’t have a built in ground protection. Are people just taking the risk and not following code?

I’ve been suggested other solutions but I feel like I’m missing something since it still on the market. Would love some guidance and clarity.


r/buildingscience • • 3d ago

Question Euro-style flange-less windows with exterior insulation, installed "outie"

9 Upvotes

Hi all, I will be building a relatively modest but high performance "pretty good house" myself in the next year in northern VT (zone 6A).

The plan right now is 2x6 construction w/ celluose, CDX + VP100 WRB, plus 2.5" RockWool ComfortBoard continuous exterior insulation, 1x3 furring, and LP SmartSide 76 lap siding.

We'd like "outie" windows for deep interior sills and a more traditional look from outside, but also wish to do euro tilt and turn turn triple glazed. This presents window detailing challenges.

At least one US supplier of euro windows (Broga) includes an extra profile on the bottom that I believe is specifically to support external sills, but it is hidden in an install manual with no other mentions I can find. Is this type of profile a standard addition to these windows in Europe when a sill pan is needed like this?? I have an inquiry out to Broga on this as well to confirm if this bottom profile can be used in the manner I'm hoping.

Looking for a sanity check on this proposed window detail and if anyone else has solved this issue before. Personally, I'm into very new territory designing these kinds of details myself instead of just finding a suitable one online somewhere with discussion. Not drawn here, but jambs would be the same as the head but without the Z-flashing, with the siding caulked directly to trim instead. Also not drawing - exterior trim frames would likely be shop-made with pocket screws on the back, then nailed directly to the buck.

Thanks for any insights here.


r/buildingscience • • 3d ago

1980s Florida home — Wood framing against concrete block walls is wicking moisture (13–17%). Mold found. How do I permanently fix this?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

I recently purchased a home built in 1983 in Tampa, Florida, and I’m trying to figure out the correct way to address moisture along the bottom of my exterior concrete walls without spending thousands on the wrong solution.
The house has thick concrete block exterior walls with wood framing installed against them, insulation, and drywall.
During some remodeling, we discovered moisture and mold behind the baseboards along the exterior walls. We had mold testing performed, which identified Stachybotrys in some of the affected areas.
Here’s what we’re seeing:
● The tile floors themselves are testing dry.
● The wood framing/baseboards against the exterior concrete walls are measuring approximately 13–17% moisture content, with some areas as low as 9.6%.
● The higher readings tend to be near windows and along the bottom of the walls.
● We found some dark mold growth around nails and along the bottom of the wood.
● The concrete walls themselves don’t appear visibly wet.
● Indoor humidity is generally around 45–55%.
● Some of the mold appears to be historical, but I’m trying to determine whether moisture is still entering.
My theory is that the wood is absorbing moisture directly from the concrete block walls, or that humid air is condensing inside the wall cavities.
This is Florida, so the outdoor humidity is obviously high much of the year. I’m concerned that even if I replace all the affected wood and drywall, the same problem will happen again unless the wall assembly is corrected.
I’ve had contractors offer to waterproof/seal the exterior foundation and lower concrete walls, but I’m not convinced that’s the actual source of the moisture. I don’t want to spend $10,000–$16,000 on foundation waterproofing if the problem is really condensation or moisture wicking from the concrete.
My questions for anyone experienced with Florida concrete block construction:

  1. Is it normal for wood framing against concrete block walls to measure 13–17% moisture in Florida?
  2. Could this be capillary moisture transfer from the concrete into the wood rather than an actual foundation leak?
  3. How do you properly separate wood framing from concrete block walls to prevent moisture wicking?
  4. Should there be a vapor barrier, rigid foam insulation, sill gasket, or some other material between the concrete and wood?
  5. How do you prevent condensation inside these wall cavities when the AC is running and it’s hot and humid outside?
  6. Would exterior waterproofing help, or could it potentially trap moisture inside the walls?
  7. What’s the proper way to rebuild these walls so they can dry and won’t develop mold again?
    I’m looking for a long-term building-science solution, not just spraying mold killer, painting over the concrete, or replacing wood only to have the problem return.
    Has anyone dealt with this in an older Florida concrete block home? What actually fixed it?
    I’d especially appreciate input from Florida contractors, building-envelope specialists, or anyone familiar with moisture management in hot, humid climates.
    Thanks in advance!

r/buildingscience • • 4d ago

Best way to insulate crawlspace?

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes

r/buildingscience • • 3d ago

Advice on crawlspace

Post image
1 Upvotes

I live in a 1952 home in Minnesota. I want to improve my crawlspace situation for better indoor air quality and thermal comfort. The crawlspace is below my kitchen area, and connects to my full basement in the utility room (picture of that connected area above). It has an HVAC supply and return duct in it.

Currently my crawlspace has a radon vapor barrier (15mil) taped to rigid foam board around. There is also fiberglass insulation on the subfloor.

This is how I am thinking about the steps, but would love advice.

  1. Remove fiberglass insulation from subfloor.
  2. Spray foam the rim joists around the crawlspace.
  3. Insulate the HVAC ducts

Do I need to put in a dehumifier in the space? Should I try and close off the access point more with a board in this area? Do I need to spray foam any of the subfloor?

Thanks for advice and happy to provide more information if helpful.


r/buildingscience • • 4d ago

Smart vapor barrier for 1890s renovation

4 Upvotes

I’m trying to decide which smart vapor barrier is better for my 1890s farmhouse renovation. Foundation/ new floor system has been repaired and replaced. I’m getting closer to insulating (northern Michigan winter coming soon). Going back and forth between ProClima Intello plus vs Certainteed Membrain. Exterior of the house is original lap siding over the studs which is covered by vinyl siding ( I’m hoping when the vinyl was added there is a house wrap but I won’t be certain until I replace the windows. I’ll add the house wrap everywhere I am able if it isn’t there when the vinyl comes down for the windows.

I am leaning towards the Intello plus based on my research, only part that I am nervous about is sealing up the wall cavity too good as the house was never originally like this and there has been absolutely no rot. Current plan is to insulate with rockwool, then add smart barrier over the studs, then 1/2 inch osb to prevent further racking etc. drywall after.

Any thoughts? I haven’t reached out to either manufacturer to check thier opinions on osb going over the top and how that changes vapor permeance