r/buildingscience • u/JayReddt • 11m ago
Question Waterproof Old Basement Slab?
1950s home with typical slab. Unfortunately, it was painted at some point and that of course never adhered well due to moisture and the slab itself crumbles in spots. It's fine for an unfinished space but needs to be properly sealed before I finish the basement. The rear of the home is a walkout and have considered both exterior and interior drain along front of the home, just for as much moisture management as possible. We are on a ridge though so it's mostly just natural clay soil moisture we have. No bulk water issue.
Anyhow, I was considering a few options:
- Dimple mat adhesive and taped seams, including around the entire CMU wall. The goal being that the moisture is completely stopped under the wall. I am thinking the dimple mat air space itself still provides a better capillary break. But I can't imagine it doesn't become completely wet/humid... Equilibrium with the slab and soil though? And don't see it actually "drying" in any way and if the outter else left open it's just opportunity for moisture (and mold) to release into air. I'll seal it off entirely.
Then adavantech subfloor floated. Flooring over that. All completed floating. Nothing securing through the dimple mat. I don't think I'll bother with foam under subfloor.
2. Liquid applied waterproof membrane. This would require some sort removal of my painted subfloor and don't want to do that. But perhaps this would be more reliable than the dimple mat? But I don't know if dimple mat provides a better moisture and capillary break? Not sure if the science but the air gap of dimple mat and not having to rely on the membrane adhesion is better. This saves some space but simple mat isn't that tall.
3. Some plastic vapor barrier and concrete poured over the top. Then subfloor and flooring. I'd still do it all floating but this is most expensive and also tallest since I suspect concrete would need to be at least 2" if not more? And I'd admittedly fear subfloor directly on this concrete, though maybe that's unfounded. Since I have the vapor break under it.
Any advice on each? Which is preferred? Science behind? Pros / cons? Other options?
The CMU wall I'm going to just leave gap behind when I install my walls. For one, leaves space for running some utilities but also ensures I have complete air flow for drying and the entire space has dehumidifying and will pull returns in that make sure ever separate space draws out the air.
