r/law • u/Confident_Salt_8108 • 21h ago
Executive Branch (Trump) Trump: Xi agreed to "joint guardrails" on AI
r/law • u/Confident_Salt_8108 • 21h ago
r/law • u/Mathemodel • 21h ago
r/law • u/wickywickyfresh • 15h ago
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
r/law • u/Byers616 • 23h ago
Should they do it? It would leave us with President Vance who I don't think would make a decent President either but he might be less dangerous than Trump.
The hard part might be getting 60 Senate votes to pass legislation per Section 5, but if there aren't at least 4 willing Republicans, they can always nuke the filibuster.
Then both chambers of Congress would be able to hold the vote to remove Trump's disqualification. If it doesn't get a 2/3rds vote to lift it, he would be disqualified from holding office.
Or would that be considered overreaching and damaging for 2028?
r/law • u/Fenomiminal • 10h ago
r/law • u/ggroverggiraffe • 14h ago
r/law • u/foodie_2598 • 20h ago
r/law • u/Fenomiminal • 16h ago
r/law • u/foodie_2598 • 10h ago
r/law • u/No-Pride-8979 • 17h ago
How aggressive should they be?
r/law • u/Confident_Salt_8108 • 3h ago
r/law • u/DoremusJessup • 11h ago
r/law • u/DoremusJessup • 17h ago
r/law • u/realnarrativenews • 13h ago
r/law • u/ggroverggiraffe • 17h ago
r/law • u/DeepState_Auditor • 11h ago
r/law • u/FollowingFeisty5321 • 17h ago
This hearing on January 11 will determine if you can be held in contempt for violating the "spirit" of an injunction. This week the last amicus curiae briefs were filed, so now there are a handful in support of reversing the contempt and a handful in support of upholding it.
Apple was held in contempt for violating a court order that prohibited them from banning apps having links or buttons to 3rd party payments in competition with their own In-App Purchases from which they collect a 30% fee. Apple circumvented this injunction by creating a 27% fee that, with transaction fees on top, made using 3rd party payments more expensive than their own In-App Purchases and implemented policies and mechanisms to ensure the links and buttons were ineffective if implemented. The effect was no developer implemented third party payments.
The core issue for Apple is the fee on IAP, they collect $10+ billion/year in fees from apps and to sustain that they need third party payments to yield a comparable fee if they must be allowed. Reversing the contempt would allow them to collect a maximal fee on 3rd party payments to the threshold of a non-prohibitive fee, which they argue in a related remand proceeding is 15%. Upholding their contempt could see them left with a lesser fee or no fee at all, as the 9th circuit appeal ruling recommended basing it on their costs incurred when apps use third party payments, which turned out to be nonexistent. So for Apple the stakes are very high.
Apple argues the contempt should be reversed because the fee was not explicitly prohibited by the text of the injunction. Various amicus curiae have posted in support arguing contempt requires a clear textual violation and without that there was "fair ground of doubt" Apple's conduct violated the injunction at all.
The DOJ, who will speak for 10 minutes during the hearing, support neither party. They argued that punishing the "spirit" of injunctions would adversely affect anyone subject to injunctions including the United States. They note contempt can be warranted within the context of rulings, but take no position on whether that is applicable to this instance.
Epic argues Apple mischaracterized the ruling, that the court found the prohibitive effect of the 27% fee violated the text of the injunction which was upheld on appeal. Various amicus curiae have posted in support of upholding the contempt, arguing that the text of the injunction must not be read in isolation but in the context of the ruling which was to allow third party payments in competition with Apple's IAP, that legalizing circumvention would render injunctions unenforceable, that an abundance of precedence punished similar circumvention, and that Apple's perjury, falsifying evidence and abuse of document privilege to conceal their plans eliminate any possibility of "fair ground of doubt".