r/progressive_islam • • Sep 18 '26

Mod Announcement 📢 Attention Everyone! This is an announcement, a reminder, and it is also a WARNING

44 Upvotes

We are going to make this absolutely freakin clear. r/Progressive_Islam is not a place for propaganda, apologism, whitewashing, or justification of crimes committed by governments, regimes, political parties, movements, or armed groups. We do not care who the perpetrator is, what flag they fly, what ideology they claim to represent, what religion they claim to follow, or what geopolitical enemy they happen to have. Whether it is the Israeli government, USA, Western imperialist powers, the Iranian regime, the Chinese government, the Russian government, the North Korean regime, or anyone else, the standard is the same. You do not get a free pass to excuse atrocities simply because you hate one side more than the other. We have enforced this before, and we will continue to enforce it.


During the years of the Palestine crisis, particularly throughout 2023-25, a large number of the people who came into this subreddit specifically to defend Israel's conduct, justify what was happening to Palestinians, or repeat blatantly apologetic narratives were outsiders with little or no previous participation here. We banned them. However, there were also some people who had been genuine participants in this community for a long time, people who had previously made useful posts and comments and had otherwise contributed positively. When some of those users repeatedly crossed the line into whitewashing and justification of Israeli abuses, we banned them too. Your contribution history does not give you immunity from moderation.


And the same standard applies to Hamas.

Hamas did not emerge as some ordinary secular nationalist organization; it was founded by Sheikh Ahmed Yassin out of the Palestinian Muslim Brotherhood and was explicitly Islamist from its creation. Its 1988 charter described Palestine as an Islamic endowment and envisioned an Islamic state governed by Sharia. After Hamas seized control of Gaza in 2007, it established an authoritarian system in which political opposition and peaceful dissent were suppressed, critics, journalists and activists were arbitrarily detained and in some cases tortured, and executions were carried out after proceedings that failed to meet international fair trial standards. Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International also documented Hamas forces using excessive force against demonstrators, including during the 2019 “We Want to Live” protests, when more than 1,000 Palestinians were detained. Hamas has also imposed or enforced various religiously motivated restrictions on social life, including restrictions on women's dress and mobility, gender segregation in many settings, and rules affecting women's participation in public life.

We did not make a specific announcement post about Hamas's rule and abuses during 2023-25 because the overwhelming reality facing Palestinians was the devastation being inflicted on Gaza by Israel, and we did not want Hamas to become another excuse for shifting attention away from Palestinian suffering. But now is the time to talk about it as well.

Condemning Hamas's authoritarianism and abuses does not mean supporting Israel, the occupation, the blockade, collective punishment or the destruction of Gaza. It means applying the same standard we apply everywhere else.

  • Some people may point to Hamas's 2017 Document of General Principles and Policies and say that Hamas had changed, abandoned its earlier positions, or therefore deserves to be trusted. The document certainly changed some of Hamas's language: it accepted the idea of a Palestinian state along the 1967 borders while still refusing to recognize Israel, but it did not formally replace the 1988 charter. And besides, history gives us plenty of reason to be cautious about taking political assurances from theocrats. The Iranian revolution brought together liberals, nationalists, leftists and Islamists. But once Khomeini consolidated power, his Islamist camp suppressed and eliminated former political allies while Iran was transformed into a clerically dominated Islamic theocracy. The Taliban provide another much more recent example: before returning to power in 2021, they publicly promised that women would have their rights; yet after coming to power they subsequently closed secondary schools to girls, severely restricted women's employment and movement, and imposed extensive restrictions on women and girls. So no, we are not going to treat a political document or a promise of change as a magical eraser for years of authoritarian rule and documented abuses. People are entitled to be skeptical, and nobody here is required to trust Hamas simply because it issued a new document.

That same principle applies to Iran

(This is going to be longest section because we have encountered the Iranian Regime apologists far more in number than the other apologists combined)

As we have already explained in our previous announcement, this subreddit has had to deal with people coming here specifically to defend or propagandize on behalf of the Iranian regime. There were people who tried to dismiss the Iranian uprising entirely as CIA or Mossad propaganda, who attempted to portray ordinary Iranians protesting against the regime as foreign agents, and in one particularly disgusting case, someone even claimed that civilians who had been killed in a hospital were all Mossad agents and that their deaths were therefore justified. We banned all of them. Our position on this has been completely consistent:

  • you can criticize particular opposition groups, political factions, foreign governments, protesters, or individual actions. What you cannot do is use conspiracy theories and regime apologism to justify the oppression of an entire population.

And before anyone starts pretending that this is some sudden position we invented yesterday, no. We have been taking this position for years.

The Iranian regime has a long documented history of repression. During the 2009 post election unrest, Amnesty International documented thousands of arbitrary arrests, deaths on the streets and in detention, torture and other ill treatment. Then came 2017 to 2018 protests, the November 2019 fuel price protests with deaths, mass arrests and executions.

Then came the Woman, Life, Freedom protests following the death of Jina Mahsa Amini in September 2022. UN fact finding mission concluded that her death was unlawful and that state authorities were responsible for the physical violence that caused it. The same mission documented credible figures of up to 551 deaths, including at least 49 women and 68 children, and found unlawful killings, mass arbitrary arrests, torture, sexual violence and other serious abuses.

This subreddit was openly supportive of the Iranian women who were protesting at that time, and that was not some random temporary mood. We documented it ourselves. Dr. Shabir Ally and Dr. Safiyyah Ally publicly condemned the killing of Mahsa Amini's and the Iranian government's enforcement of compulsory hijab, Dr. Khaled Abou El Fadl delivered his October 2022 khutbah addressing the brutality of the Iranian state's coercive system, Mufti Abu Layth also addressed the situation in Iran at the time. Our subreddit responded with strong support for the protests.

And The recent crackdown that happened in 2026 produced another enormous death toll, although the exact figure remains unknown because the authorities imposed a massive communications blackout and access to reliable information was severely restricted. The figures reported at the time varied enormously.

Iranian authorities themselves gave figures of roughly 3,000 deaths. Reuters reported an Iranian official saying that at least 5,000 people, including around 500 security personnel, had been confirmed dead. HRANA reported 3,308 confirmed deaths at one stage, with thousands of additional cases under investigation, and later reported 5,002 verified deaths and another 9,787 under review. By 28 January, a UK government country bulletin said estimates from some sources placed the death toll at approximately 12,000 to 20,000, while the same bulletin noted that one human rights organization had 6,221 confirmed deaths and 17,091 additional deaths under investigation. Other investigations, including accounts from Iranian medical personnel, produced estimates exceeding 30,000, while some later reports cited figures as high as 43,000.

We are deliberately laying this out because we are not going to pretend that every number floating around the internet is equally reliable. Claims of 20,000 or 30,000 deaths in an extremely short period require much more verification, and claims of 50,000 deaths are even more problematic; we have not found a credible independent source establishing such a figure. Likewise, nobody should take a highly speculative number from an anonymous or opaque source and present it as settled fact.

But uncertainty over the precise number does not mean that the killings did not happen. Multiple independent human rights organizations documented mass killings, unlawful use of force, arbitrary detention, torture and other abuses. Human Rights Watch has subsequently documented an ongoing campaign of executions against people arrested in connection with the protests, including at least 29 people executed in connection with the December 2025 to January 2026 protests between March and August 2026, with many others still facing execution.

In other words, this subreddit does not need anyone coming here to explain to us that the Iranian regime is somehow innocent because the United States and Israel oppose it. That argument has never worked here, and it never will. We are fully capable of recognizing Western imperialism while simultaneously recognizing Iranian state repression. Those things are not mutually exclusive.

And since some people inevitably need this explained every single time:

Condemning Iranian oppression does NOT mean that we support American or Israeli military actions against Iran. The two positions are perfectly compatible. The war itself has produced documented civilian harm. The UN Human Rights Council received information concerning extensive civilian casualties and destruction resulting from U.S. and Israeli attacks, and the UN backed fact finding mission has now found reasonable grounds to believe that U.S. forces committed war crimes in strikes including the attack on the Minab girls' school and strike affecting residential areas. All of that can be condemned at the same time. We have not seen anyone here recently trying to whitewash American crimes in the way some users have tried to whitewash Iranian crimes, but make no mistake: if someone starts doing it, we will deal with them exactly the same way.


Now we come to the reason we are making this announcement right now.

Over the last couple of days, we have had multiple accounts come into this subreddit making comments claiming that the persecution of Uyghur Muslims in China is nothing more than CIA propaganda, Western propaganda, or some fabricated narrative designed to attack China. Some of these accounts had no prior participation in this subreddit whatsoever, and their first contribution here was effectively to defend or whitewash the Chinese government's treatment of Uyghurs. Others, unfortunately, were people who had participated here before and had a history of otherwise normal contributions.

Let us be very clear about how absurd this is. There is an enormous body of documentation concerning China's treatment of Uyghurs and other predominantly Muslim minorities in Xinjiang. The UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights conducted its own assessment, including 40 in depth interviews with people who had direct knowledge of the situation. It concluded that the extent of arbitrary and discriminatory detention of Uyghurs and other predominantly Muslim groups may constitute international crimes, in particular crimes against humanity. The UN has also documented concerns relating to arbitrary detention and forced labour. Human Rights Watch continues to document arbitrary detention, torture, mass surveillance, forced labor, family separation and religious and cultural persecution.

So when somebody strolls into a Muslim subreddit and casually tells everyone that the persecution of Uyghur Muslims is just CIA propaganda, or that the Uyghurs actually deserve this, that is not some brave act of anti imperialist skepticism. It is an attempt to erase or dismiss an enormous body of documented evidence and the lived experiences of the people who have been subjected to detention, torture, forced labor, religious repression and family separation.


And frankly, it makes us sick to our stomachs seeing people who are perfectly willing to recognize oppression when it is committed by a Western government suddenly develop an entirely different moral standard when the perpetrator is China, Iran, Russia or their allies.

We have noticed something else that needs to be addressed. Because this community generally has a strong anti imperialist tendency, comments defending the United States, Israel or other Western powers receive far more attention than comments defending non Western oppressive governments. Some comments that should have been reported are instead left unreported, allowed to slide, ignored, or sometimes even upvoted, simply because the commenter happens to be attacking the Imperialists.

Nobody gets permission to justify crimes against humanity because the perpetrator happens to be an enemy of the United States or the West. NOBODY. Your politics do not matter here. Your ideology does not matter here. Your opinion of capitalism or socialism does not matter here. Your opinion of NATO does not matter here. Your opinion of Israel does not matter here. Your opinion of Iran does not matter here. Your opinion of China does not matter here. Your opinion of Russia does not matter here. The victims do not become less human because their oppressor happens to be anti Western.

And this needs to be understood once and for all: WE WILL BAN PEOPLE FOR THIS. WE DO NOT CARE HOW LONG YOU HAVE BEEN SUBSCRIBED. WE DO NOT CARE HOW MANY POSTS YOU HAVE MADE. WE DO NOT CARE HOW MANY HELPFUL COMMENTS YOU HAVE WRITTEN. WE DO NOT CARE WHETHER YOU ARE HERE EVERY DAY. WE DO NOT CARE WHETHER YOU WERE ONE OF THE MOST RECOGNIZABLE REGULAR CONTRIBUTORS IN THE SUBREDDIT. IF YOU REPEATEDLY START WHITEWASHING, DENYING OR JUSTIFYING SERIOUS ABUSES BY A REGIME OR POLITICAL ACTOR, YOU WILL BE BANNED.

We are not going to sit around having endless arguments with you about whether your propaganda is really propaganda. We are not going to listen to lectures about how we are secretly Western puppets because we condemned China. We are not going to listen to accusations that we are Zionists because we condemned Iran. We are not going to listen to “but what about America?” every freakin time someone is held accountable for what their own government did. Whataboutism is not a magic eraser. The crimes of one government do not cancel out the crimes of another.

This also does not mean that you are forbidden from acknowledging that a particular oppressive government has done something useful. An oppressive government can build highways, hospitals, schools, railways, dams, universities or other infrastructure. A ruler can introduce a policy that produces a positive result in one particular area. You are perfectly free to discuss and praise the specific thing that was done. What you are not free to do is use that one thing as a shield for everything else. “They built hospitals” does not erase torture. “They built highways” does not erase mass detention. “They improved literacy” does not erase forced labor. “They oppose American imperialism” does not erase massacres. One positive policy does not grant a government a lifetime exemption from moral scrutiny.

There is zero tolerance for this kind of propaganda and apologism here. Criticism of governments is allowed. Criticism of political movements is allowed. Criticism of protesters is allowed. Criticism of opposition groups is allowed. Disagreement over historical interpretation is allowed. What is not allowed is denying documented atrocities, deliberately whitewashing them, or trying to justify crimes against humanity because you happen to support the perpetrator politically.

This is not up for debate. We are not negotiating this standard. We are not making exceptions because you are a regular contributor. We are not making exceptions because we agree with your politics on everything else.

Anyone who cannot accept this standard is free to leave the subreddit.

And anyone who thinks this warning does not apply to them because their favorite regime is “supposedly” a “gOoD aNtI iMpErIaLiSt oNe” can consider this warning directed specifically at them.


r/progressive_islam • • Jul 27 '26

Mod Announcement 📢 r/Progressive_Islam ’s official stance on LGBTQ+

180 Upvotes

Our official stance is that there should not be bigotry and they should not be punished by death.

-That's it.

“What about sexual intercourse with someone of the same biological sex? What about the gender spectrum?” - r/Progressive_Islam doesn't have any official stance on them, it's upto every individual to look for arguments and evidences from both sides and come to their own conclusion over the permissibility/impermissibility of homosexuality and matters relating to the gender spectrum.

This is not a new announcement. This has always been our stance. You can check what was written in the 5 year old LGBTQ+ discussion thread

r/progressive_islam does not advocate a particular stance on homosexuality’s permissibility. But what is a unanimous position of us is that there should not be bigotry and that they should not be punished by death.

https://www.reddit.com/r/progressive_islam/comments/r615zt/monthly_lgbtq_discussion_thread/

So,

  • Someone writing some violent threats or dehumanising post/comment pointing towards LGBTQ+ people - they will get their content removed and will receive a ban.
  • Someone respectfully saying that they believe sexual intercourse with someone of the same sex to be haram, or that there are only two genders - they are allowed on this subreddit.

The progressive Sunni scholars who are most frequently promoted on this subreddit and have a significant number of followers - Dr. Shabir Ally, Mufti Abu Layth, Dr. Khaled Abou El Fadl, Javed Ahmed Ghamidi, Dr Adnan Ibrahim - they believe the act of homosexuality (sexual intercourse) to be prohibited in Islam, & at the same time they also believe that there is no capital punishment for the sexual intercourse unlike classical fiqh (at least that's what I could figure out from the contents that had been shared on our subreddit in the past. You can use the search bar to find those old posts on our subreddit).

Scott Siraj al-Haqq Kugle, Ludovic-Mohamed Zahed, Imam Daayiee Abdullah are some of the Muslim thinkers who have argued that intercourse with someone of the same sex is allowed and some of them have officiated gay marriage and users who believe homosexuality is permissible often quote references from their works when discussing homosexuality on our subreddit.

We allow both perspectives to be shared on this subreddit as long as you present them in a respectful way and don't break any subreddit rule. But we do not allow the promotion of the ultra conservative understanding which prescribes capital punishment.

To summarize:

  • You believe gay marriage and the sexual act is permissible? - ok ✅
  • You believe gay marriage and the sexual act is haram? - ok ✅
  • You believe that there is no fixed number of gender? - ok ✅
  • You believe that there are only 2 genders? - ok ✅
  • You believe the other side is wrong? - ok ✅
  • You disagree with the other side? - ok ✅
  • You want to bully, harass, threaten or harm the other side? - not ok ❌

Is that clear?


The reason I'm writing all this is because often times when someone respectfully says that it is not permissible in their view or that they disagree - some others start reporting their comments. But we do not remove such comments, we only remove the posts and comments where the user bullies, harasses or threatens the other person. So hopefully you will stop reporting every post and comment you disagree with, because as long as those contents don't break any subreddit rule they're going to stay.


r/progressive_islam • • 3h ago

Informative Visual Content 📹📸 Interesting video of scholar Dr.Sofia Rehman talking about KAEF's book "Speaking In God's Name". She gives a sneak peek into the contents of the book and specific controversial topics that are tackled.

13 Upvotes

r/progressive_islam • • 1h ago

Question/Discussion ❔ GTA 6 Hysteria

7 Upvotes

Why is this important!!!

These people made the Pokemon game Haram once upon a time.

Two years ago they were pushing defense's of child marriage, 150 000 children have died due to child marriage in the last decade.

Now they in unison seem to be uniting to complain about GTA 6 and Halloween.

What is wrong with these people.

Seems to be just a culture war and a battle for control and power that they then use to abuse people in the community who don't agree with them.

Yaqeen says GTA 6 is pornography, meanwhile a actual prostitute who fed a dog is going to heaven because Islam is meant to be against harm not nonsense.

What are these people prioritising, I don't understand, do they have a decent plan for the community, or is there plan "anti-degenerecy" while they signed off on actual direct red pill degeneracy 2 years ago.

Purity culture and control is really what they seem to want above all else.


r/progressive_islam • • 3h ago

History The painting of Plato (Aflāᚭōn) in the Islamic world, charming wild animals with the sounds of his wondrous musical instrument, thereby surpassing his rival Aristotle. It was produced by Madhu a Mughal court painter during the reign of Emperor Akbar.

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/progressive_islam • • 3h ago

Question/Discussion ❔ Progressive in NL?

8 Upvotes

I’m (30F) wondering if there are other women here (particularly in the Netherlands) who have had a similar experience when looking for a spouse.

I’ve been using Muzz (I hate this app with a passion), but I haven’t really spoken to anyone there because many profiles seem incomplete, with little or no bio, which makes it difficult to tell whether someone is genuinely serious.
On the other hand, on apps like Bumble or Hinge, I often come across men who aren’t open about being Muslim or who are looking for something really casual, which isn’t what I’m looking for.

I’m curious whether others have experienced the same difficulties and whether there are progressive Muslims, especially women, living in the Netherlands who feel similarly.
I’d really appreciate hearing about your experiences and perspectives.

Edit
I’d love to hear from progressive Muslim men in the Netherlands too. u/Zetakin, thanks for sharing your perspective.


r/progressive_islam • • 21h ago

Fun@Weekends | [Saturdays & Sundays Only] US and Saudi manipulation of Afghan people through extremists(Read desc)

Post image
51 Upvotes

During the Soviet–Afghan War, the US and Saudi Arabia poured money and weapons into Afghan mujahideen factions through Pakistan to fight the Soviets. For the US, weakening its Cold War rival served American interests. Saudi Arabia helped bankroll that effort, while Pakistan directed support toward factions that suited its own agenda. Afghan people were fighting and dying in a war that foreign governments saw as an opportunity.

And the foreign influence went beyond weapons. The US and Saudi Arabia were backing Afghan mujahideen against the Soviets, while Saudi Arabia was also exporting Wahhabi extremist ideology to counter Soviet influence. MBS later said Western allies(especially USA) had encouraged that overseas religious extremist funding.

So when people talk about extremism in Afghanistan as if it appeared out of nowhere, they leave out how powerful countries helped fund and strengthen hardline factions because it served their interests at the time. The religious beliefs of the fighters and the geopolitical ambitions of their sponsors didn’t have to match but just needed a common enemy.

Some mujahideen had real reasons to resist Soviet occupation and a repressive government but most were manipulated by these countries. They helped decide which factions got the money, which got the weapons, and which became powerful enough to shape the country’s future.

And once the Soviet-backed government collapsed, those competing factions fought over power and tore the country apart. The Taliban emerged out of that destruction. They weren’t simply the same organization the US had armed in the 1980s, but the war and the factions strengthened by foreign support helped create the conditions for their rise.

First, afghan people suffer through invasion and civil war. Then extremists exploit that suffering with promises of order and salvation, only to oppress them all over again.

Sources:

US State Department — US assistance to the Afghan resistance through Pakistan⁠

National Security Archive — Documents on the Afghan war and foreign support⁠

Congressional Research Service — Afghanistan’s history and the Taliban’s emergence⁠

https://www.reddit.com/r/progressive_islam/s/sqJFhEhJF7


r/progressive_islam • • 1d ago

Informative Visual Content 📹📸 "Honor Killing" in Iran: Father Murdered His Teenage Daughter Because He Believed She Was a Lesbian

Thumbnail
gallery
193 Upvotes

Sogand Sayyadi, a teenage girl from Kermanshah, Iran, died on November 14 shortly after her father took her home from school. He is accused of murdering her. The suspected motive was that she was in love with another girl.

According to accounts from classmates and people close to Sogand, the school found out about the relationship and called her father. Sogand repeatedly told the principal her life would be in danger if she went home. When her father arrived, he reportedly beat her in front of school staff, leaving her bleeding and barely conscious. Even after seeing that, they let him take her home.

Sogand died shortly afterward in a fall from the fifth floor of her family home. Authorities arrested her father on assault and provisional murder charges and detained the principal on suspicion of negligence. Investigators are still examining whether she was pushed or died by suicide after the assault.
She told them she was afraid for her life. Then they saw him beat her. What more did they need to see before they stepped in?


r/progressive_islam • • 13h ago

Advice/Help 🥺 Marrying someone outside the religion

7 Upvotes

Salam beautiful people!

I (30M) have found myself in a bit of a situation and really to navigate thru this. I was raised a Muslim and over the years, my faith has worn off. I still identify as a Muslim tho. And this sub is what my views most align with. So with that out of the way, let me get straight into it.

A lil bit on my background:
I’m 30M. And I was raised by Indian muslim parents, in India. They still in India and they’re def liberal for Indian Muslims. My mum has predominantly lived most of her life surrounded by Muslims and that has shaped their world view - which probably makes her more conservative than my dad, who I think is somewhat more open minded.

I used to live in the U.S. and in the most liberal state at that - Massachusetts. Living there has greatly shaped/reinforced my liberal views. I have moved to London/UK a year ago, and as any single 30 yo, I have been going out getting to know women with the intention of settling down and getting married.

My situation:
I have gone on dates with Muslim girls, and it didn’t work out with them, from reasons such as lack of chemistry, difficult logistics, being in different stages of life, being ghosted, disagreement on the timeline for marriage, etc etc. It’s really hell out there.

So, I decided to go out with someone who’s not a Muslim.
And I went out with someone (non Muslim, Buddhist) who I thought was cute. I wanted to see what’s out there. On the first date, we really hit it off. I wasn’t even sure what I wanted from this, but we both kept it low key and chill in the beginning. We started going out frequently, and I have realized she’s a very understanding, kind, and a sensible woman. It’s kinda crazy how we are so aligned in our thought process.

It’s been 4 months now, and we see each other every single day. We have both become a big part of each others life.

My parents dilemma:
I have 2 older brothers and they both are very successful in their life, alhamdulilah and I’m very happy for them. We are a close knit family. And I like it that way. They both had an arranged marriage, and they both seem happy with the partners they found in the AM setting.

My parents are now having a very hard time coming to terms with the fact that the girl I’m seeing is a non muslim. This is reallly taking a mental toll on them and consequently on me, because I really care about them, even tho I don’t fully agree with their views on my relationship. I understand where they are coming from.

My parents worry:

  1. this will never work out.
  2. I will not be happy in this relationship.
  3. this relationship won’t last for long.
  4. if I do marry, then children that are born in this marriage, won’t be Muslims the way I was raised (ahem ahem)
  5. I was brainwashed at an early stage in life, and I’d always want to adopt the Muslim way of life. And I’d not be happy in the long term if I do end up marrying her.

Things my parents don’t know yet but I know for sure will bother them:
- my gf’s biological dad had passed away before she was even born. And her mum lives with a man who she never got married to.
- my gf’s relationship with her mum and step dad. It’s very complicated and she’s not close to them at all. She doesn’t even care about their approval/ taking blessings.

My own cognitive dissonance:
I have always had great respect for my parents and although we were encouraged to make our decisions in life from early on, I’d always discuss big decisions with my parents, and my brothers. Their opinion really matters to me. They know that. And, they keep asking me to breakup with my gf. And in a way, they are absolutely ruining my relationship by being so negative about it all the time.

But with that said, I really love my gf despite all the differences we have (read, religion).
I enjoy the time we spend together, and I really wish my parents were supportive of my choice in this situation.

I’m really at a loss with what to do. How would you think about this situation if you were in my shoes?


r/progressive_islam • • 6h ago

Opinion 🤔 Anfal 50-66

2 Upvotes

Anfal 50-51

50-AND AS YOU SEE THE ANGELS CAUSING THOSE WHO DISBELIEVED TO DIE, STRIKING THEIR FACES AND REARS, AND TASTE THE PUNISHMENT OF THE FIRE.  

51- THIS IS BECAUSE OF WHAT YOUR HANDS SENT BEFORE YOU, FOR INDEED ALLAH IS NOT UNJUST TO HIS SLAVES.

There are angels appointed to cause people to die, they are the angels of death.  

It is reported that during the battle of Badr the angels Allah the Highest sent took part in the fighting, and were not only for the morale and spiritual support of the Muslims.  This is known to have happened in the battle of Honin also.  

The death of the disbelievers sends them to the Hell-Fire where they will taste the punishment they always denied.  

We all have our deeds recorded and written down in our book of deeds.  This record does not miss anything.  Allah the Highest mentioned about this record many times in the Quran.  Allah the Highest said: “AND THE BOOK WAS PUT DOWN, AND YOU SEE THE EVIL DOERS FEARFUL OF WHAT IS IN IT, AND THEY SAY: WOW TO US, WHY DOES THIS BOOK NOT LEAVE A MINOR OR MAJOR DEED WITHOUT BEING RECORDED, AND THEY FIND WHAT THEY DID THERE, AND YOU LORD IS NOT UNJUST TO ANYONE”.  (S: 18 A: 49)

And said: “AND EVERY HUMAN WILL HAVE HIS DEEDS TIED TO HIS NECK AND WILL BRING HIM FORTH A BOOK HE WILL FIND OPEN * READ YOUR OWN BOOK, YOU ARE SUFFICIENT TO ACCOUNT FOR YOUR OWN DEEDS”.  (S: 17 A: 13, 14)

And said: “THE DAY WHEN EVERY SOUL WILL FIND WHATEVER GOOD IT HAS DONE PRESENT, AND WISHES IT IS A LONG DISTANCE FROM WHATEVER EVIL IT HAS DONE”.  (S: 3 A: 30)

This book is never unjust, in fact it leans to our favour in that the bad deeds are recorded as they are, while the good deeds are increased and multiplied.  Allah the Highest said: “ALLAH IS NOT UNJUST BY AS MUCH AS AN ATOM, AND WHEN A GOOD DEED IS DONE, IT WILL BE MULTIPLIED, AND WILL GIVE FROM HIS BOUNTY A GREAT REWARD”.  (S: 4 A: 40)

Allah’s messenger prayer and peace upon him said that Allah the Highest said: “O my slaves, I have prohibited myself from being unjust and have forbidden it among my slaves, so do not be unjust to each other.  O my slaves, these are but your deeds I record for you, whoever finds something good, let him thank Allah, and whoever finds otherwise, he should blame himself only”.  (A: 5; 160 & Muslim: Ber)

We should therefore not wait to do good deeds, or to repent from doing bad deeds as we do not know when will our lives come to an end, for this is only within Allah’s knowledge, and can happen any time, regardless of our age or state of health.  

Anfal 52

52- THIS IS LIKE PHARAOH’S PEOPLE AND THOSE BEFORE THEM, THEY DENIED ALLAH’S AYAHS, AND ALLAH HAS TAKEN THEM TO PUNISHMENT BECAUSE OF THEIR SINS, AND ALLAH IS MOST POWERFUL AND IS SEVERE IN PUNISHMENT.  

 Allah the Highest has policies and practices with people on earth; it is that Allah the Highest sends us guidance in the form of Ayahs.  Allah the Highest sends the prophets and messengers and sends them the Ayahs, for guidance and for proof of their prophecy.  

People are given time and leeway, but should they persist in rejecting Allah’s Ayahs and in disbelieving, they will certainly be severely punished. 

Allah the Highest gave the example of the people of pharaoh and those before them.  The people of pharaoh are particularly important as they had many signs, more than any other people, and they disbelieved in them all.  They were given plenty of opportunities, but they persisted with their denial and disbelief.  

Allah the Highest states that He is Most Powerful, for then he can punish severely, if he so wishes, and no one can prevent or stop His punishment, may be only through the pleading of the prophets and messengers and the righteous people, and His Mercy.  Yet, should Allah the Highest wills to inflict his punishment on other people, there is  no stopping of such punishment and there is no protection or escape for those people.

We should never think that being left without punishment despite of sinning is a sign that Allah the Highest does not care and does not intend to do something about it.  This is giving the sinner time to either repent or to let him/her commit even more sins, which is giving leeway.  Then the punishment will be most severe.

 

Anfal 53-54

53- THIS IS BECAUSE ALLAH WAS NOT TO CHANGE OVER A BOUNTY HE BESTOWED UPON PEOPLE, UNLESS THEY CHANGE THEMSELVES, FOR INDEED ALLAH HEARS AND KNOWS ALL THINGS.

54- LIKE WHAT THE PEOPLE OF PHARAOH AND THOSE BEFORE THEM USED TO DO, THEY DENIED THE AYAHS OF THEIR LORD, THEREFORE WE DESTROYED THEM BECAUSE OF THEIR SINS, AND WE DROWNED PHARAOH’S PEOPLE, FOR THEY WERE ALL TRANSGRESSORS.

Allah the Highest created mankind and provided us all with many bounties.  All the bounties are available for the believers and the disbelievers equally.  This goes for the things we need for living, such as the food and air etc.  Also prophets, messengers, religions and guidance are given to everyone, but only some of mankind take heed, and use such bounty.   

Allah the Highest created us all good and pure, and then we changed over to whatever we were going to be.  We have to move away from Allah the Highest for this bounty to be removed.  We instigate the change.

The first and foremost step of perversion a person does to deviate from his pure nature is to disbelieve in his Creator, or to worship partners besides him.  To believe, follow and obey a different guidance other that what Allah the Highest sent down, which can be in the form of a doctrine, ideology, etc. is a form or worshipping partners besides Allah the Highest.  This starts our change, which is later followed by the Changes which Allah the Highest introduces in our hearts.    Allah’s messenger prayer and peace upon him said: “People’s hearts are between two fingers of the Merciful’s Fingers, He turns them any way he desires”.  (M: Qadar; 17 & Ma: Doaa; 2 & A: 168)

This changes what we say and what we do, which is recorded, and consequently, Allah t he Highest changes His bounties upon us, taking them away. 

Allah the Highest might take away the comfort and happiness we gain from any provisions we have, making such provisions a source of their misery and unhappiness instead of pleasure and contentment.  One might have a family, but they do not become a source of joy.  

Allah the Highest gives us the example of Pharaoh and his people, they had great civilization and power, but it did not do them much good, did not protect them from Allah’s punishment, and they left great buildings and monuments, which were of no avail to them from Allah’s Wroth.

They rejected the many signs and miracles they were shown, and they were therefore punished by the very last miracle they saw, the parting of the sea, which was also the miracle of the destruction of Pharaoh and his army.

It shows that Allah the Highest is not severe with the disbelievers from the beginning; they are given plenty of time, chances and opportunities, before their final punishment.   Allah the Highest said: “INDEED, ALLAH HAS FORGIVENESS FOR PEOPLE IN SPITE OF THEIR TRANSGRESSION”.  (S: 13:6)

Therefore, the believers should not lose hope and should not be allured by the fact that the disbelievers and transgressors are given time and chance to change.  The true believers should be patient and persevere on their path as Allah the Highest commanded saying: “BE PATIENT AND PERSEVERE, AND THIS IS ONLY FOR ALLAH, DO NOT GRIEF FOR THEM AND DO NOT BE UPSET BECAUSE THEY'RE PLOTTING * INDEED, ALLAH IS WITH THOSE WHO ARE PIOUS AND PROTECT THEMSELVES FROM ALLAH’S DISPLEASURE, AND WHO ARE MOST RIGHTEOUS AND CHARITABLE”.  (S: 16 A: 126-127)

Not many of us will doubt that the state of the Muslim nation changed for the worse.  We are weak, meek and technologically backward.  We are taking advantage of by the stronger nations, who occupy some of our land with troops as in Iraq and Afghanistan, and the will of most the rest of the Muslim countries are not totally independent.    

As a religion, Islam is under attack in the west, and sometimes from some Muslim quarters.  We do not have Allah’s support, or at least His full support and we should ask ourselves why?

The Muslims suffer many ailments of the heart and soul.  We love money more than ever before, and fear for our lives and comfort more than we ever did.  The wealth some of us gained from petrol and development, did not make us stronger, but weaker; did not strengthen our character, but weakened it.  

We see more covered women in our countries, and more bearded men than we ever did.  We see more people praying in mosques, and going on Hajj and Omrah.  In the mean time, we see more lying, cheating, stealing, bribery adultery, homosexuality and other ailments than ever before.  Character wise, and morally, the Muslims are getting worse.  Indeed, we are collectively, except for some, a poor example and a misrepresentation of our religion, Islam.  

It is not strange that Allah the Highest abandons us.  Should we want Allah the Highest to support us again, we should put things right and correct ourselves first before asking for His Support.

 

Anfal 55-58

55- THE WORST CREATURE TO TREAD ON THE EARTH ARE THOSE WHO DISBELIEVED AND DO NOT BELIEVE.

56- THOSE WHOM WHENEVER YOU HAVE A COVENANT WITH THEM, THEY BREAK THEIR COVENANT ON EVERY OCCASION, AND ARE NEVER PIOUS OR PROTECT THEMSELVES FROM ALLAH’S DISPLEASURE.

57- WHENEVER YOU MEET WITH THEM IN BATTLE, BE HARSH WITH THEM TO MAKE THEM AN EXAMPLE OF THEM, AND SO THAT THEY MAY TAKE HEED.

58- AND IF YOU FEAR BETRAYAL FROM SOME PEOPLE, THEN PUT PEACE WITH THEM ASIDE, FOR ALLAH DOES NOT LOVE THE TRAITORS.

Allah the Highest endowed human beings with the great gift of the mind, which gives us the ability to understand, comprehend and choose.  Therefore, we are sent guidance and are judged according to our choices.  This is different from animals and other creatures which are driven by their instincts only.  Therefore mankind is honoured and considered superior to other creatures on Earth.  Allah the Highest said: “AND WE HAVE HONOURED THE CHILDREN OF ADAM, CARRIED THEM ON LAND AND SEA, PROVIDED THEM OF ALL GOOD THINGS, AND FAVOURED THEM GREATLY OVER MANY OF WHAT WE CREATED”.  (S: 17 A: 70) 

When we disbelieve in our creator, we abuse the best quality and gift we are given, which puts us on the level of other creatures walking the earth, and even worse.  Allah the Highest tells us reasons for that: 

  1. Their disbelief and their insistence on not believing.  It is not because they do not know the truth, but they knew the truth, which they do not want to follow.
  2. Breaking their covenant every time they make a covenant.  The Jews of Medina made a covenant of peace and mutual defence with Allah’s messenger, prayer and peace upon him, and the Muslim, but they did not keep it.  They tried to assassinate Mohamed, prayer and peace upon him, several times.  They did not support the Muslims in Ohud when the disbeliever’s army attacked them.  They plotted with the disbelievers to come to attack the Muslims and promised to help them.  
  3. They are never pious and never protect themselves from the displeasure of Allah the Highest.  They do not uphold morale principles such as honesty, truthfulness, sincerity, decency, etc.  

 Allah the Highest commands us to fight them hard in battle, to be harsh with them, and to make an example of them for others.  This is how the Muslims should meet with the disbelievers in battle.  Allah the Highest also said: “MOHAMMED, ALLAH’S MESSENGER AND THOSE WITH HIM ARE HARD WITH THE DISBELIEVERS BUT COMPASSIONATE BETWEEN THEMSELVES”.  (S: 48 A: 29)

In Ayah 58, Allah the Highest is commanding us that once we know of the betrayal of people we have treaties and covenants with, we should withdraw from such agreements and take action to pre-empt their plotting.  

The Jews are still now as they have always been, not trustworthy, and not people known to honour their treaties and agreements, betraying their trust, lying and twisting the truth.  Allah the Highest warns us about them, and we should always take heed.

Anfal 59-60

59- AND THOSE WHO DISBELIEVE SHOULD NOT THINK THAT THEY ARE AHEAD, FOR THEY ARE NOT DIFFICULT FOR US.

60- AND PREPARE FOR THEM ALL THAT  YOU CAN OF POWER AND HORSES TO STRIKE FEAR INTO THE ENEMIES OF ALLAH AND YOUR ENEMIES, AS WELL AS OTHERS YOU DO NOT KNOW, BUT ALLAH KNOWS, AND WHATEVER YOU SPEND IN THE CAUSE OF ALLAH WILL BE PAID BACK TO YOU IN FULL, AND YOU WILL NEVER BE TREATED UNJUSTLY.

The battle of Badr was an example of when the disbelievers who were more powerful, and felt ahead of the Muslims and has more power over them.  Yet, in the first major battle, the disbeliever’s 1000 men strong army was defeated by the 317 men strong Muslim army.  They lost 70 men and another seventy were taken prisoners.

We should never be allured by the power of the disbelievers, and we should not let it defeat our will.  Also being wealthier and better off financially, does not make one superior or out of Allah’s reach.  Allah the Highest said: “AND WE TURN THEIR HEARTS AND SIGHT OVER AND OVER, AS THEY DID NOT BELIEVE IN THE FIRST PLACE AND WE LEAVE THEM BLINDED IN THEIR TRANSGRESSION”.  (S: 6 A: 110)

We may look at all the strong and powerful in the past, individuals and empires, when they because they were unjust and wicked, perished, leaving behind them signs of their presence and previous deeds.  Allah the Highest commands us to look throughout the Earth, look at the history of mankind to see what happened to those before us.  “SAY: WALK THROUGH THE EARTH TO SEE WHAT THE END OF THOSE WHO WERE BEFORE WAS, FOR MOST OF THEM BELIEVED IN PARTNERS WITH GOD”.  (S: 30 A: 42)

The Roman Empire left remains and monuments of its power, injustice and wickedness.

The Greek town of Pompeii enjoyed prosperity and great comfort for its time.  In the meantime, promiscuity and prostitution were widespread.  Pompeii was destroyed by the eruption of a massive volcano, which led to an earthquake which led to a massive tsunami.  The town was destroyed totally, but its people and buildings were preserved, as a witness to what happened to them.

Allah the Highest commands the Muslim Nation to be always strong on all sides.  Having a strong army is most important for the nation to have freedom in its land and of its will.  Until recently, horses were a great source of military power, now we have aeroplane, tanks, rockets, guns, etc.  The principle remains the same, to have strong armed forces to strike fear into the hearts of our enemies and potential enemies, deterring them from having any designs on our land and what we hold dear.  Maintaining such power of well equipped and trained armed forces is a mandatory duty upon all Muslim countries and for its leaders to keep.

Keeping such power and fighting when necessary, involves the spending of our wealth as well as suffering and loss of life.  Whenever this is done in the cause of Allah, Allah the Highest rewards it most generously.  Allah the Highest said: “THE PARABLE OF THOSE WHO SPEND OF THEIR WEALTH IN THE CAUSE OF ALLAH IS THAT OF A GRAIN OF CORN, FROM WHICH GROW FORTH SEVEN EARS, IN EVERY EAR THERE ARE SEVEN GRAINS, AND ALLAH INCREASES THESE MANY MORE FOLDS FOR WHOM HE WILLS, FOR ALLAH IS ALL EMBRACING AND IS ALL KNOWING”.  (S: 2 A: 261)

Those who die in the cause of Allah, the Martyrs, live in Paradise with their Lord.  Allah the Highest said: “AND DO NOT THINK THAT THOSE KILLED IN THE CAUSE OF ALLAH ARE DEAD, THEY ARE BUT ALIVE WITH THEIR LORD AND ARE PROVIDED FOR * REJOICING BECAUSE OF THE BOUNTY ALLAH PROVIDED FOR THEM, AND GIVING GLADE TIDINGS TO THOSE THEY LEFT BEHIND, THAT THERE IS NO FEAR UPON THEM, NOR WILL THEY BE SADDENED *  REJOICING BECAUSE OF THE BOUNTY FROM ALLAH AND IN HIS GRACE, INDEED ALLAH DOES NOT DENY THE BELIEVERS THEIR REWARD”.  (S: 3 A: 269-271)

Failing to do this, leads to the weakness of the Muslim nation, as is happening now, we lose our land, freedom and freedom of will.  Allah’s messenger, prayer and peace upon him, told us about this when he said to his companion Thowban: “How would you be Thowban when the nations go for you as those eating go for a big plate to have take part of it”.  Thowban said: “Is it because we will be few Allah’s messenger?”  He said: “No, you will be plenty then, but meekness will be thrown into your hearts”.  Thowban said: “And what is it”.  He said: “Loving this life and hating to fight (in another narration hating death)”.  (D: Malahem; 5 & A: 2; 259 5; 278)

This Hadith describes clearly the current state of the Muslim Nation.

 Anfal 61-63

61- BUT IF THEY SEEK PEACE, THEN RESORT TO IT (PEACE) AND PUT YOUR TRUST IN ALLAH, FOR ALLAH HEARS AND KNOWS ALL THINGS.

62- BUT IF THEY WISH TO DECEIVE YOU, THEN ALLAH WILL BE SUFFICIENT FOR YOU, HE IS WHO SUPPORTED YOU WITH HIS HELP AND WITH THE MUSLIMS.  

63- AND MADE PEACE BETWEEN THEIR HEARTS WITH PEACE TOGETHER, FOR HAD YOU SPENT ALL THERE IS ON EARTH YOU WOULD NOT HAVE GATHERED THEIR HEARTS WITH PEACE TOGETHER, BUT ALLAH DID, FOR HE IS MOST EXALTED IN POWER AND MOST WISE.

 Allah the Highest is not commanding the Muslims to be strong in order to fight all the time, but in order to uphold peace and to protect themselves.  Peace has to be based on power, for the aggressors or potential aggressors should realize that we can defend ourselves and the things we hold dear.  

We learn from history that peace is kept better between two parties when both parties are strong.  Whenever one of them weakens, this may provoke the other to attack.  

Whenever our enemies, the ones we fight seek peace, we should accept and resort to peace too.  Allah the Highest also said: “YOU, WHO BELIEVE, ENTER INTO ISLAM AND PEACE ALL OF YOU, AND DO NOT FOLLOW THE FOOTSTEPS OF SATAN, FOR HE IS YOUR CLEAR ENEMY”.  (S: 2 A: 208)

Strength and peace go together, hand in hand.

Allah the Highest is telling us that in taking the peace option, we should put our trust in Him to protect and look after us; therefore, we should not fear peace.  We should trust Allah’s support in both war and peace.  Whenever we are obeying Allah the Highest, we should know that we are under his care and protection.

Allah the Highest is reminding us that He did for us what no money or power can do, which is bring the Muslims hearts together with peace and tranquillity.

There is a good example in what happened when the Muslims of Makah migrated to Medina.  The Ansar (supporters) who were the residents of Medina, were very hospitable and generous to the migrants. They took them into their homes, and shared what they had with them.

Also the two Muslim tribes of Medina, Awse and Khazrag, were sworn enemies before Islam, and fought frequently, their last big battle was a few years before Allah’s messenger’s migration to Medina.  When they embraced Islam, they became brothers in Islam, they loved each other, and they never fought again.

No one could have achieved this through spending all the money on Earth.  It was achieved through Allah’s bounty and grace.  Some things cannot be bought with money, and love is one of them.

We should always remember that, whenever Islam and Faith rules between the Muslims, the Muslims will enjoy peace and love amongst them and will always be united, for this is a bounty that comes from Allah the Highest only. 

Anfal 64-66

64- O PROPHET; ALLAH AND THOSE WHO FOLLOW YOU OF THE BELIEVERS ARE SUFFICIENT FOR YOU.

65- O PROPHET; ENTHUSE THE BELIEVERS TO FIGHT, IF THERE ARE TWENTY OF YOU, PATIENT AND PERSEVERING, THEY WILL DEFEAT TWO HUNDRED, AND IF THERE IS A HUNDRED, THEY WILL DEFEAT A THOUSAND OF THOSE WHO DISBELIEVE, FOR THEY ARE PEOPLE OF NO UNDERSTANDING.

66- NOW ALLAH LIGHTENED YOUR BURDEN AND HAS KNOWN THAT THERE IS WEAKNESS IN YOU, SO IF THERE IS A HUNDRED OF YOU PATIENT AND PERSEVERING, THEY WILL DEFEAT TWO HUNDRED, AND IF THERE IS A THOUSAND, THEY WILL DEFEAT TWO THOUSAND BY ALLAH’S PERMISSION, FOR ALLAH IS WITH THOSE WHO ARE PATIENT AND PERSEVERE.

Allah the Highest is telling His messenger prayer and peace upon him that what he needs to defeat an enemy is to have Allah the Highest and the believers who followed him on his side only.  Then Allah the Highest commands his messenger prayer and peace upon him to enthuse and encourage the believers to fight when there is need, then stresses that the number of the fighters or soldiers is not the decisive factor in battle but it is the believers being patient and persevering when facing the enemy in battle.

The believers should be patient in enduring the hardship, suffering and injury in battle, and persevering in their obedience of Allah the Highest and in their struggle with the enemy without losing heart.

Such group of believers should be able to defeat ten times as many disbelievers.  This meant that the believers should not turn away or withdraw when facing an army ten times as many, however, Allah the Highest eased the burden for the believers, and made it that they should not turn away from an army twice as big.  

In reality, the Muslims fought battles with armies more than twice as big and won, for example:

  • In Badr, the disbeliever’s army was about 1000 men which was nearly 3 times as many as the Muslims army which was 313-317.
  • In Ohud, the Muslims were 700 while the disbelievers were 3000 men, more than 4 times as many.  The Muslims won the battle until the archers disobeyed Allah’s messenger prayer and peace upon him and cam of the mountain, exposing the back of the Muslim army.
  • In the battle of Yarmok, the Muslims army was 30000 men and they defeated the roman army of 250000 men, more than 8 times as many.
  • In the battle of Qudisyah, the Muslim army was 36000 men and they defeated a 200000 strong Persian army, five and half times as many.

The Muslims did not generally win their battles because of superiority in number and equipment, but via their strength of faith and reliance on the help and support of Allah the Highest.  Victory comes from Allah the Highest and happens with His permission only.

The Muslim nation faces many stronger enemies at present, they are stronger because of their better and more advanced armies.   We should not fear them or feel intimidated by their superior power, for if we have faith, are patient, persevering and rely on Allah the Highest, we should have the upper hand, for we are promised Allah’s support then, which is all we need.  Our strength comes from within us, and from Allah the Highest, not just in our numbers and equipment. 


r/progressive_islam • • 18h ago

Question/Discussion ❔ Do you have different Islamic beliefs than your parents/family

11 Upvotes

I don't practice or do certain things that my family does. For example, the tradition of when someone pasts, everyone visits the family house to read quran to get good deeds for the one who passed away. Or making dua after completing fardh prayer and not during sujood. Or not kissing the quran and touching your forhead and treating quran translations the same way as the original Arabic quran.

I've been told I'm being modern and that I'm listening to young people on the internet. I'm not, I don't get my Islamic information from random people on Insta. If I have a question, I look for information where there is evidence from the quran, and strong hadiths. If my parents tell me something about Islam, I will fact check it to be sure. For years I would be told put on hijab during adhan but then encourage to remove my hijab at weddings or when there is non-mehram, how does this make sense?

I'm not a good Muslim but learning the difference between real Islam and culture has helped me grow my imaan, Islam isn't suppose to be difficult and extreme, there is moderation in everything.


r/progressive_islam • • 7h ago

Question/Discussion ❔ why did Muhammad permit men to beat their wives after Umar requested it?

1 Upvotes

Hey guys, hope everyone is doing well!

So my question is:

Why did Muhammad permit men to beat their wives after Umar requested it, and why did he criticise those men only after women came complaining? Why didn’t he simply forbid it again? Instead of just critizing the men?


r/progressive_islam • • 16h ago

Question/Discussion ❔ Quranic Scholarship and Interpretation

4 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I thought this would be the best place to ask about this. I’m a recent convert to Christianity but very intrigued by Islam. I think the Quran is undoubtedly amazing in standing out amongst poets at the time, and many could not recreate it. If I understand correctly, the Quran is believed to be the perfect Word of God.

Learning Arabic and the meanings properly would render the most authentic translations. My question is, is there growing scholarship or views that allow for nuanced or allegorical interpretations of certain verses around scientific claims? If I’m not wrong it states humans were made from clay? The Bible has a lot of allegory in the Old Testament, and a lot of the early church fathers didn’t take a literal approach to scripture.

I’m not part of Muslim spaces, but in this space, is it taboo to say that parts of the Quran shouldn’t be taken literally, especially scientific or historical claims? I understand that for many this would undermine the divine origin of the Quran, which is arguably the foundation of Islam.


r/progressive_islam • • 22h ago

Question/Discussion ❔ Muslim marriage subreddit

10 Upvotes

That sub reddit has to be rage bait. It has to be rage bait. It cannot be real 😭😭😭🙏

Istg I read it and I wanna crash out. Like this makes my faith drop to the hell for marriages like the amount of rules n regulations and mind games they all got like gng 🔪🔪🔪🔪☠️🔪 it is such an echo chamber as well.

Anyways what are yall thought on that sub reddit.

I read it to rage bait myself.


r/progressive_islam • • 17h ago

Advice/Help 🥺 Urgent appeal to support a vulnerable orphaned family in Yemen

4 Upvotes

Peace be upon you, dear brothers and sisters. Please help save this orphaned family in Yemen from eviction and ensure their survival; they are struggling to secure their daily necessities and have no source of income or support—after God Almighty—other than you. Even a donation of just $1 can help alleviate some of their suffering. May God reward you with goodness. 👇 https://www.gofundme.com/f/per-favore-aiutate-una-famiglia-orfana-dello-yemen/wa/o?utm_campaign=fp_sharesheet&utm_content=amp30-treatment-2&utm_medium=customer&utm_source=whatsapp&lang=it_IT 😪🤲


r/progressive_islam • • 1d ago

Answer this from Sunni perspective only After reading this I'm seriously wondering if it's actually even possible to be Sunni & Progressive! How can one be a Progressive Sunni when Sunnism is so full of these? Can the Progressive Sunnis of this subreddit please explain why are you still Sunni?

Post image
36 Upvotes

r/progressive_islam • • 18h ago

Opinion 🤔 "Conservative" Muslims and logical fallacies

4 Upvotes

As-salamu alaykum waRahmatu Llahi waBarakatuhu.

Several times conservative muslims like to criticize different ideas by simply saying "it is western", "we cannot westernize", "this guy is a reformist", etc. But none of those things are actually valid arguments, a western guy can be right and we might be wrong, being western does not mean it is bad, and the fact you are being following something for millenia is no argument. It is a bunch of ad hominem and ad verencundiam fallacies, hardly do we see a single valid argument

"Conservative" Islam and the robbust neoasharism will inevitably lead to our downfall if it keeps this way

Any objection people may have is also always dimissed as 'liberalism', we see it all the time in channels like Blogging Theology. But it is possible to object to certain things from other paradigms also, it is possible to object to it using greek philosophy, it is possible to object to it using discourse ethics, deontology, etc etc.

All the conservative muslim discourse is intellectually bankrupt because it will always be 'muhhh liberalism bla bla bla'


r/progressive_islam • • 19h ago

Question/Discussion ❔ I cant get over that nothing is certain

4 Upvotes

The stuff am saying is slowly making me depressed eating me up for years when ever i pray i feel like am lying to my self bec ion really beleive in any thing anymore even not beleiving has no evidence for me js like beleiving does

i came from a muslim north african family thats kinda conservative my questions about relegion was always answered poorly like when ever i asked abt smth was answered by "bec god wants us too" or even w shame and discust it started that i couldnt get over a lot of stuff in relegion and a lot of this stuff was forced on me like covering my hair as an example i was always told that id cover it since i was a kid when i get puberty at a point when got puberty and i got it early i cryed so much cus i knew i didnt want to

it was never how i wanted to look like and never made since though they told me i couldent leave my house without it

And away from sexism i always saw in relegion i always heared sheiks talking about god torturing people js cus they dont beleive even they re good ones and i always though if he is the most merciful is that really mercy and why did he gave us no evidence about him being here is all god do is stop us from living life and tourturing people ?

How do people actually get them self to beleive in this its horrible i feel so discusted from every body around me

Am js asking if this is smth really everybody experience or am gonna live like this untill i really grow up and js get upset when i remember until i forget again


r/progressive_islam • • 1d ago

History Mullā ᚢadrā argues that all Existence is one fundamental reality manifesting in different degrees of intensity. The essences by which we categorise things are mental labels. God the One is simple & pure Being, Existence itself & is the totality of Existence.

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

r/progressive_islam • • 1d ago

Question/Discussion ❔ Trying to find my place in Islam after growing up with so much religious guilt

3 Upvotes

I was born and raised in Australia in a Sunni Muslim family. I went to Islamic school my entire life, so Islam was always present in my upbringing. However, I wouldn’t say I ever developed a particularly strong personal connection to it.
My family situation was complicated. My parents are separated, we weren’t particularly close as a family, and there was a lot of fighting growing up. I love my family, but my childhood wasn’t particularly happy.

My mum had an extremely difficult life herself, and I recognise that. However, she was also very angry and quite controlling, particularly towards us girls. My older brother was generally allowed to do whatever he wanted, whereas my sisters and I were constantly scrutinised. What we wore, whether we wore makeup, whether we prayed, whether we read Quran, whether we were doing enough religiously.

There was a lot of religious guilt and shame. I remember being desperate to get married and move out because I wanted to escape that environment.
I grew up with the impression that practically everything was haram. I remember things like birthday candles being considered haram. There were so many rules, so many things to be cautious about, and so much emphasis on what we shouldn’t be doing.

As an adult, I’ve realised that I don’t actually have much of a personal relationship with Islam. I’m not particularly interested in reading Quran. I’ve tried listening to Islamic podcasts and learning more, but I often find myself losing interest and switching to something else. I have ADHD, and I’ve always struggled to engage with that kind of learning, particularly when it feels like an obligation.

I also struggle with prayer. Sometimes I feel incredibly guilty when I miss salah. Other times, I can miss prayer after prayer without feeling particularly bothered. I don’t really understand that contradiction.

I’m now married with two children of my own. My husband’s family is very religious, and they also have a tendency to consider a lot of things haram. My husband is more open-minded, thankfully, and we can have conversations about these things.

My daughter is six. She attends a non-denominational school that still teaches Islamic religion and values, and she’s been coming home learning about the prophets and Islam.
I genuinely want my children to have a connection to their faith. I want them to know about the prophets, understand Islam and have a sense of their Muslim identity.
But I also desperately don’t want to recreate my own childhood.

I don’t want my daughter growing up feeling ashamed of herself, her clothes, her interests or the things she enjoys. I want her to enjoy music, celebrate birthdays, have fun and just be a child without constantly worrying about whether she’s doing something haram.
And yet, I still have all that guilt ingrained in me.

For example, sometimes I look at my daughter and think: she hasn’t even memorised Al-Fatiha yet, but here we are singing K-pop Demon Hunters at the top of our lungs. And then I feel like a terrible Muslim mother. I start questioning whether I’m failing her by not teaching her Islam properly.

I think part of me is still afraid that my mum was right about everything. What if all these things really are haram? What if I’m taking Islam too lightly? What if I regret not being more religious?
Another thing I struggle with is that I sometimes feel genuinely afraid to even question certain things about Islam. I know this might sound irrational, but I sometimes feel as though every time I question or doubt something, something bad happens and I interpret it as a sign that I’m doing something wrong. For example, my husband and I were once having a conversation on the phone about hadith. I was questioning how reliable some of them are, given that they were written and transmitted by men centuries ago, and how many seem to reflect quite sexist attitudes or perspectives that appeal predominantly to men. My husband said he wasn’t knowledgeable enough to have an answer and suggested we research it together. Literally seconds later, his car was hit by another car. He was standing right beside it, and the place where the car was struck was exactly where he had been standing. Had he been there just a couple of minutes earlier, I genuinely might have lost my husband. We were both shaken, and I remember us wondering whether it was some kind of sign from Allah, as though we were being warned not to question our religion. I know that might sound irrational to some people, and logically I understand that accidents happen, but I cannot explain how frightening that felt. Sometimes I feel like I’m almost afraid to think critically about Islam because what if I’m somehow being punished for it? Does anyone else experience this kind of fear or associate unfortunate events with having questioned their faith?

And here’s where I’m struggling: I’m not necessarily interested in becoming more religious myself. I don’t have this overwhelming desire to pray five times a day, read Quran regularly or become deeply involved in religious learning. But I also don’t want to go to hell. I don’t want to feel like I’m constantly doing something wrong, either.

I think I want to find a version of Islam that I can genuinely connect with, rather than one that is built around fear, guilt and an endless list of things I’m not allowed to do.
I came to this subreddit because I want to learn. I want to understand different perspectives, particularly on the things I’ve grown up being told are haram. I want to question some of those teachings without feeling like I’m questioning Islam itself.

I suppose my biggest question is:

How do you develop a genuine relationship with Islam when your upbringing has made you associate religion with guilt and restriction?
And, perhaps more importantly, how do you raise Muslim children to love their faith when you’re still trying to figure out how to love it yourself?
I’d really appreciate hearing from people who have experienced something similar, particularly those who grew up in conservative Muslim households and have found their own way of practising Islam as adults.


r/progressive_islam • • 21h ago

Opinion 🤔 Found this on someone’s story on aurah

1 Upvotes

“To the men and the women-When we stand for salah, we cover as Allah commanded.
For men, the 'awrah is from the navel to the knees. For women, it is the entire body except the face and hands. ? But was modesty meant only for prayer? Did those boundaries stop mattering once you stepped off the prayer mat? A The rules of 'awrah weren't created just for salah-They apply in public, around non-mahrams, and outside of worship too. So why do we treat modesty like a temporary uniform, instead of a consistent mindset? ( Ask yourself-Are you truly covering your 'awrah, or just covering for prayer?”
Please share ur opinions?


r/progressive_islam • • 1d ago

Rant/Vent 🤬 husband hunting lmao

29 Upvotes

hi I’m 24f and have started to properly search for my naseeb. I think I’m better off alone at this point due to how ignorant these men are.

Even when they seem like they support basic human rights and are half-decent, they ultimately always end up being misogynistic/homophobic/racist to some degree. It feels like ultimately these men want someone submissive and is incredibly homely.

Most of them are incredibly hypocritical and hold such huge double standards. It’s starting to get really normalised how these men have premarital sex but still demand a virgin wife. It’s so disgusting.

I feel like I’m at a crossroads where on one hand alhamdulilah I am practicing and do love Islam and do want to find my husband, but on the other hand I just genuinely refuse to deal with these men any longer!

To list out a few interactions:

• ⁠A man has told me that he frequently watches porn, which I find disgusting, and then proceeded to tell me that everyone has watched it and any man who says that they haven’t is lying to me.
• ⁠Berating my university degree when he didn’t go to university?! Lmao
• ⁠Man demanding that he wants me to not work after marriage, I then asked if he can afford my expenses- then proceeded to call me shallow and materialistic. Mind you, I’m Alhamdulilah able to already provide these things for myself.

It’s honestly getting berating at this point 😭


r/progressive_islam • • 1d ago

Opinion 🤔 Anfal 36-49

0 Upvotes

Anfal 36-37

36- THOSE WHO DISBELIEVE SPEND THEIR MONEY TO TURN PEOPLE AWAY FROM ALLAH’S PATH, THEY WILL SPEND IT, AND IT WILL BE THE CAUSE OF THEIR SORROW AND REGRET, AND THEN THEY WILL BE DEFEATED, AND THE DISBELIEVERS WILL BE ALL GATHERED TOGETHER IN THE HELL-FIRE.

37- THIS IS IN ORDER THAT ALLAH DISTINGUISH AND SEPARATE THE EVIL FROM THE GOOD, AND THEN PUTS THE EVIL ON TOP OF ONE ANOTHER TO PUT IT ALL IN THE HELL-FIRE, INDEED THEY ARE THE LOSERS.

We see the disbelievers spend a great deal of money, and with it time and effort to misguide people and turn them away from Allah’s Path.  We see these concerted efforts on the TV, Satellite channels, magazines and books.  Allah the Highest said: 

“MANY OF THE PEOPLE OF THE BOOK WISH TO TURN YOU BACK TO BE DISBELIEVERS AFTER YOU HAVE BELIEVED, OUT OF THEIR ENVY”.  (S: 2 A: 109)

They might call us uncivilized, backward, and whatever else, but are never happy with us doing the decent thing, or being in harmony with Allah the Highest.  

Allah the Highest always tests and tries the believers, first to distinguish the good from the bad.  Allah the Highest said:

“DID PEOPLE THINK THAT THEY WILL BE LEFT FOR SAYING WE BELIEVE WITHOUT BEING TRIED AND TESTED * FOR WE HAVE TRIED AND TESTED THOSE BEFORE THEM, SO THAT ALLAH MAY KNOW THOSE WHO ARE TRUTHFUL AND KNOW THE LIARS”.  (S: 29 A: 2-3)

And Allah the Highest said: “ALLAH WOULD NOT HAVE LEFT THE BELIEVERS AS THEY WERE WITHOUT DISTINGUISHING THE EVIL FROM THE GOOD, AND ALLAH WOULD NOT HAVE LET YOU KNOW WHAT IS HIDDEN”.  (S: 3 A: 179)

In the Hereafter, Allah the Highest also separates the believers from the disbelievers, and the good from the evil, He said about it: “AND SEPARATE AWAY YOU EVIL-DOERS”.  (S: 36 A: 59)

Allah the Highest does not try people to know what is inside them, for Allah the Highest knows very well what is inside us and what is in our hearts, but Allah the Highest tests and tries people so that their actions will show their real believes and will be evidence for them or against them.  

Allah the Highest draws us a picture of the evil people being piled up on top of one another to be thrown into the Hell-Fire, which is a terrible picture.

We see this happening in the world around us, there is polarization of ideas and evil in countries throughout the world.  This polarization is not decreasing, but increasing, and this might be a kind of piling the evil on top of one another to deliver them a swift punishment, only Allah the Highest knows.

Anfal 38-40 

38- SHOULD THOSE WHO DISBELIEVE REFRAIN, THEY WILL BE FORGIVEN WHAT THEY DID IN THE PAST, BUT IF THEY RETURN TO DOING THE SAME, THEN THE EXAMPLE OF WHAT WE DID TO PEOPLE EARLIER HAS BEEN SHOWN.  

39- FIGHT THEM SO THAT THERE WILL BE NO TEMPTATION AND NO PROSECUTION AND THE WHOLE RELIGION BECOMES ONLY THAT OF ALLAH’S, BUT IF THEY REFRAIN, THEN ALLAH SEES AND KNOWS ALL THEY DO.

40- BUT IF THEY TURN BACK, THEN KNOW THAT ALLAH IS YOUR GUARDIAN AND ALLY, AND HE IS THE BEST GUARDIAN AND ALLY.

Allah the Highest is telling us about three important principles in these three Ayahs:

  1. Repenting from sin leads to total forgiveness.  This includes all sins, which involves disbelieving in Allah the Highest.  Allah’s messenger prayer and peace upon him said: “Islam pardons whatever sins committed beforehand and repentance pardons what was committed beforehand”.  (Muslim: Eman & A:4;205)

As for those who continue sinning, the same sins after Islam, they will have to account for their sins before as well as after Islam.  Allah’s messenger prayer and peace upon him said: “Whoever does good deeds in Islam, he does not have to answer for what he did before Islam, and whoever does evil in Islam, he will have to account for what he did before and after Islam”.  (Bukhari & Muslim & Darmy & Ahmed)

Indeed, Allah the Highest promised the sinful and idol worshippers who become Muslims, and do good deed, to be rewards by rewarding them for the sins committed as if they were good deeds do.  Allah the Highest said: “EXCEPT THOSE WHO REPENT, BELIEVE AND DO GOOD DEEDS, ALLAH WILL TURN THEIR SINS INTO GOOD DEEDS, FOR ALLAH IS MOST FORGIVING AND MOST MERCIFUL * FOR HE WHO REPENTS AND DOES GOOD DEEDS, HE HAS TRULY REPENTED TO ALLAH”.  (S: 25 A: 70-71)

  1. The Muslims Should be fighting the disbelievers who fight the Muslims and who try to tempt them from their faith, and corrupt their life and character.  Those who work on corrupting our Religion should be fought, but when they stop, we should stop fighting them.  

This fighting does not always have to involve taking arms against them, for there are other and possibly better ways, depending on the circumstances.  Words, education and giving good example may succeed where armed struggle does not.

Allah the Highest will punish such people now and in the future just as He did in the past, for Allah is the same God and the policy is the same policy.

  1. Should people turn their back on us, and we do not have any help and support in this cause, and should we have no allies of people, Allah’s support is sufficient.  Allah the Highest is the best Guardian, Allay and Supporter for the believers, and if we have Him on our side, and struggle as we should, no one can defeat us.  Allah the Highest said: “SHOULD ALLAH SUPPORTS YOU, NO ONE CAN DEFEAT YOU; BUT IF HE ABANDONS YOU, NO ONE CAN SUPPORT YOU AFTER HIM, AND IN ALLAH THE BELIEVERS SHOULD PUT THEIR TRUST”.  (S:3 A:160)

 

When we see that Allah the Highest is Not Supporting us against our enemies, we should look carefully at ourselves to see what is it we do that deviates us from Allah’s Path and deprive us from His help and support.

Anfal 41

41- AND KNOW THAT OUT OF WHAT YOU TAKE OF THE WAR BOUNTY, ITS FIFTH GOES TO ALLAH, HIS MESSENGER, THE CLOSE KIND, THE ORPHANS, THE POOR AND THE WAY-FARER, IF YOU BELIEVE IN ALLAH AND WHAT WAS SENT DOWN UPON OUR SLAVE, ON THE DAY WHEN THE RIGHT WAS DISTINGUISHED FROM THE WRONG, THE DAY WHEN THE TWO ARMIES MET AND FOUGHT, FOR INDEED ALLAH IS ABLE TO DO ALL THINGS.

All the nations and prophets before Mohamed prayer and peace upon him were not allowed to take the spoils and bounty of war.  Allah the Highest is allowing this for the Muslims in this Ayah.

Also Allah the Highest is giving a Fifth of this bounty to Allah’s messenger prayer and peace upon him and from this he gives the orphans, poor, and the way-farer.  Allah’s messenger prayer and peace upon him used to give this fifth of the bounty away to those who need it, particularly as there were many poor Muslims and many who left all their property and money behind when they migrated to Medina, and there were also orphans, widows and old people who could not fight.  From that fifth he also spent on his family and himself.  Mohamed prayer and peace upon him was never known to live in luxury, indeed he and his family always tightened the belt.  It was known for a month to pass without a fire being lit in any of houses, meaning not having cooked a meal.

The four-fifth of the bounty of war were distributed among those who fought in the battle.  Also the custom was that every man takes the bounty of the person he killed in the battle, which was his sword, shield, etc.   

One might consider this fifth to be like the Zakah of the war bounty, except that Allah’s messenger prayer and peace upon him was allowed to take out of it for himself, while he was not allowed that with the Zakah.

The Muslims accepted this rule happily and the fighters in a battle were happy to give of their war bounty to the less able ones, the orphans and the poor, and this was a sign of their strong faith.  Allah the Highest said: “BUT, BY YOUR LORD, THEY WILL NOT TRULY BELIEVE UNTIL THEY SEEK YOUR JUDGMENT IN THEIR DISPUTES, AND THEN FEEL NO UPSET IN THEIR HEARTS BECAUSE OF YOUR JUDGMENT, AND THEY SURRENDER TOTALLY”.  (S:4 A:65)

I would like to explain what the Way-Farer is.  He is a person away from home, who ran out of money or ran into difficulties, and needs help.  However, he is not near his money, blood relations or friends to ask them for help.  He is not usually poor or needy at home, but he is in this situation and is poor and in need while he is away from home.  He can be given of the fifth of the war bounty and also of the Zakah money. 

 

Anfal 42 

42- AS YOU WERE AT THE NEAR SIDE OF THE VALLEY, AND THEY WERE AT THE FAR SIDE OF THE VALLEY AND THE CARAVAN WAS BELOW YOU; HAD YOU DATED, YOU WOULD NOT HAVE MADE IT AT THE SAME TIME, BUT IT WAS SO THAT ALLAH MAY FULFIL A MATTER WHICH WAS TO HAPPEN, SO THAT ALLAH MAY DESTROY THOSE WHO WERE TO PERISH WITH CLEAR EVIDENCE, AND LET LIVE THOSE WHO LIVED ON CLEAR EVIDENCE, AND ALLAH HEARS AND KNOWS ALL THINGS.

The Muslim army was not very well equipped, as they did not expect to fight another army, but a trading caravan guarded by some forty men.  

Badr was a spring between Makah and Medina where people and caravans used to stop for rest and water and watering their animals.  The caravan of a thousand camels lead by Abu Sofian was planning to stop at Badr as usual.

Allah’s messenger prayer and peace upon him sent two of his companions to look out for the caravan and to gather news about the caravan.  When they arrived to Badr, they went to fill their skins with water and to water their animals.  There were two girls talking by the water, and they overheard one of them asking the other for what she owed her, and the other girl said that she will pay her in a day or two after making some trading with the caravan expected to arrive.

In the meantime, Abu Sofian decided to go ahead of his caravan to look at Badr and check for its safety.  He asked people if they saw anything unusual today, and they said that they just saw two men with their camels taking water.  He went to where they stopped and looked at the camel’s dung to find that it had date stones, which is often found in the dung of the animals from Medina.  

Abu Sofian rushed back to his caravan and took it to the sea shore road.  He also sent to the Makans to come out to save their money in the caravan which they did, and a thousand men strong army marched out of Makah to protect the Caravan.    Before the army reached Badr, Abu Sofian sent them that the caravan is away and safe from the Muslims, and they could turn back.  Abu Jahl however vowed to get to the water of Badr where they will feast, eat, sing and drink win for 3 nights, to be heard of, and in order to keep their prestige and status among the Arab tribes.  

Both armies were racing to get to the water of Badr before the other.  Allah the Highest sent cloud which rained over the Muslims as well as the disbelievers, the rain over the Muslims and in their way was not very heavy.  This allowed them to have water, water themselves and their animals, and in the meantime, it made the ground firmer and their marching faster.

The rain over and on the way of the disbelievers to Badr was heavier which turned the ground to mud and hindered their marching and progress. 

Consequently, the Muslims reached the spring of Badr first.

The Muslims took position according to the advice of one of the Sahabah to Allah’s messenger prayer and peace upon him to control the water and deprive the disbelievers of it.  The Makan’s army camped a little way from the spring of Badr but out of sight.  They sent two young men to get them water, and the Muslims caught them.  They were interrogated and even hit to tell about the size of the army.  This happened while Allah’s messenger prayer and peace upon him was praying, when he finished he said: “Do you hit them when they tell you the truth and leave them when they lie”.  Then he said: “Tell me about Qurish army?”  They said: “They are behind that sand hill on the other side of the valley”.  He said: “How many are they?”  They said: “Many”.  He said: “How many camels they slaughter every day?” they said: “Nine one day and ten the next”.  He said: “They are between 900 and 1000”.  He said: “Who of the nobility of Qurish are there?”  They said the names of many of them” He said: “This is Makah has thrown to you its most precious”.  

Next morning the army of the disbelievers marched to Badr.

Saad Ibn Moaz who was one of the leaders of the Ansar said to Allah’s messenger prayer and peace upon him: “Allah’s messenger, shall we build you a canopy and leave with you an animal to ride, then we meet our enemy, should Allah gives us victory against them, this is what we like, but if it is the other, you ride back to those we left behind who do not love you any less than we do, and had they known that there will be a battle, they would not have stayed behind”.  Allah’s messenger prayer and peace upon him said dawa for him.  They built a canopy for him where he stayed accompanied by Abu Bakr.  He went on praying and pleading to Allah the Highest for support and victory.

When the army of Qurish appeared from behind the hill, Allah’s messenger prayer and peace upon him said: “Allah, this is Qurish coming full of pride and arrogance, opposing You and rejecting Your messenger, Allah I beg you to destroy them today”.  

The Muslim’s and the disbeliever’s armies met that day without prior arrangement.  The Muslim army came from the near end of the valley; the disbeliever’s army came from the far end of the valley, while the caravan was traveling on the lower ground by the sea.  Had they planned to meet, they could not have arranged it as well as Allah the Highest did.

The battle of Badr was a landmark, for it was a day when Allah the Highest showed His clear support for the believers, and with that support they were victorious.  

Those who were killed of the disbelievers, were clear about their disbelief and those who had victory were clear about their faith and belief.

Anfal 43-44

43- AS ALLAH SHOWED THEM TO YOU IN YOUR DREAM AS FEW AND, HAD HE SHOWED THEM TO BE MANY, YOU WOULD HAVE LOST HEART AND DISAGREED, BUT ALLAH SAVED YOU, FOR HE KNOWS WHAT IS IN YOUR HEARTS.

44- AND AS HE SHOWS THEM AS FEW TO YOUR EYES WHEN YOU MET, AND MADE YOU LOOK FEW TO THEIR EYES, SO THAT WHAT WAS DESTINED TO HAPPEN HAPPENS, AND TO ALLAH ALL MATTERS ARE REFERRED TO BE DECIDED.  

Allah the Highest showed His messenger prayer and peace upon him a vision before the battle of Badr.  In this vision, he showed him the disbelievers to be few, fewer than they actually were.  This was to encourage him and the Muslims to fight and in order that they do not lose heart and disagree.  Seeing them as being few in the vision does not necessarily mean that they were few, but possibly that they were not strong.  This was the first battle of the Muslims against the disbelievers, and Allah the Highest did not want them to lose heart but wanted to encourage them to fight.  The vision was a reassurance as well as encouragement.  The Muslims could have disagreed and possibly withdraw before the battle had they thought the disbelievers army to be large, however, Allah the Highest destined for this first and decisive battle to take place, and His will have to be done.

On the day of the battle, the two armies faced each other, and Allah the Highest made both armies see the other as being fewer or weaker than they actually were.  This encouraged each side to go into the battle, so that the battle which Allah the Highest ordained to take place, takes place.

We notice in our lives that whenever fate takes its course, things happen regardless of the odds, and the unexpected happens.  

Believing in fate is an integral part of the Muslim Faith.  When Gabriel peace upon him went to speak to Allah’s messenger prayer and peace upon him in Medina in the form of a man and in front of the other Muslims, he asked: “Tell me about Faith”.  Mohamed prayer and peace upon him said: “It is to believe in Allah, His angels, His books and His messengers, the last day, and to believe in Fate, the good and bad of it”.  Gabriel said: “You said the truth”.  (M; Eman; 1)

Fate take place in our lives, all of us, we recognise it sometimes, and do not at other times.  It can be in meeting the person we marry, work, some fortune or misfortune.  It is Allah’s will for us, and we have to accept and be contented with.

Anfal 45-46

45- YOU WHO BELIEVE, IF YOU MEET A GROUP OF PEOPLE (FOR BATTLE) STAND FIRMLY, AND REMEMBER ALLAH A GREAT DEAL, SO THAT YOU MAY SUCCEED.

46- AND OBEY ALLAH AND HIS MESSENGER, AND DO NOT DISPUTE THEN YOU WILL LOSE AND YOUR STRENGTH WILL FADE AWAY, BE PATIENT AND PERSEVERE FOR ALLAH IS WITH THOSE WHO ARE PATIENT AND PERSEVERE.

In battle, standing firmly before the enemy, fighting, and not retreating, is usually a cause for victory.  It strengthens the resolve of the army and weakens the resolve of the enemy when they see that they fight men who do not fear death and do not run away.  Allah the Highest clearly forbad the Muslims from  turning away from the enemy in Ayahs 15 & 16 of this Sorah saying: “YOU WHO BELIEVE; WHENEVER YOU MEET THOSE WHO DISBELIEVE IN BATTLE; DO NOT TURN YOUR BACKS TO THEM * AS FOR THOSE WHO TURN THEIR BACKS TO THEM THEN, UNLESS THEY ARE PREPARING TO FIGHT, OR REGROUPING WITH OTHERS, HE WILL RETURN HOME WITH ALLAH’S ANGER, AND HIS ABODE WILL BE THE HELL-FIRE, AND THE WORST DESTINY IT IS”.  (S:8 A:15-16)

Then Allah the Highest commands the believers to remember Allah the Highest a great deal, for this comforts the heart and strengthens the spirit, which is very much needed while fighting in battle, and facing death, Allah the Highest said: “THOSE WHO BELIEVE AND THEIR HEARTS ARE COMFORTED BY THE REMEMBRANCE OF ALLAH, FOR INDEED THE REMEMBRANCE OF ALLAH COMFORTS THE HEARTS”.  (S:13 A:28)

Allah the Highest remembers us, when we remember Him, and Allah’s remembrance of us is a great support and help for the believers.  Allah the Highest said: “THEN, REMEMBER ME, AND I WILL REMEMBER YOU, AND BE GRATEFUL TO ME AND DO NOT DISBELIEVE”.   (S:2 A:152)

Allah’s messenger prayer and peace upon him said: “O people, do not desire to fight an enemy, and ask Allah for safety and security, but if you meet them in battle, be patient and stand firmly, and know that the Paradise is under the shadows of the swords”.  (Bukhari & Muslim & A:4;353,354)

During the time of battle, there should be no disputes or disagreements, and every soldier should obey his leader and their leaders.  Such disagreement happened before the battle of Ohud, which was the next major battle after Badr, which lead to the army going out to meet the enemy instead of fighting them inside Medina.  Also a third of the army turned back lead by Abd Allah Ibn Obi.  Also the archers Allah’s messenger prayer and peace upon him placed on the mountain and ordered never to leave their posts whether the army is winning or losing, disobeyed their orders and left when they saw the Muslim army winning.

We also see that this happened throughout the Islamic History.  The Muslims have always been strong and feared when united.  When they disagreed, disputed and divided, they weakened.  The Muslims as a nation are weak at present and our lands are occupied in some parts, and our will is not free, and this is to a large extend because of our disputes, disagreements and divisions, which we are clearly forbidden, and we see the outcome of such disagreements.

Anfal 47-49

47- AND DO NOT BE LIKE THOSE WHO LEFT THEIR HOMES TO FIGHT THE TRUTH, SHOWING OFF THEIR STRENGTH AND OBSTRUCTING PEOPLE’S WAY TO ALLAH, AND ALLAH KNOWLEDGE OF WHAT THEY DO IS ALL EMBRACING.

48- AND AS THE DEVIL BEAUTIFIED THEIR DEEDS FOR THEM AND SAID TO THEM: NO ONE CAN DEFEAT YOU TODAY AND I AM YOUR PROTECTOR, HOWEVER, WHEN THE TWO GROUPS SAW EACH OTHER, HE TURNED BACK ON HIS HEELS AND SAID: I HAVE NOTHING TO DO WITH YOU, I CAN SEE WHAT YOU CAN NOT, I FEAR ALLAH, FOR ALLAH IS SEVERE IN PUNISHMENT.

49- AS THE HYPOCRITES AND THOSE WHO HAVE DISEASE IN THEIR HEARTS SAY: THOSE HAVE BEEN ALLURED BY THEIR FAITH.  BUT WHOEVER RELIES ON ALLAH, INDEED ALLAH IS MOST EXALTED IN POWER AND MOST WISE.

 The disbeliever’s army left Makah with drums, singers, wine and plenty of food to eat ready to celebrate their expected victory over the Muslims.  They wanted to show their strength and superiority to all the other tribes, and wanted to uphold their superior status in Arabia.

They did not go to fight for a just cause, but to fight Allah’s faith and obstruct people’s path to Allah the Highest, who knew well what they were doing and why.

Armies go to battle showing their power before the actual fighting takes place, they do that to strike fear into their enemy’s hearts.  This is good to be done for a just cause, but not to suppress and overpower people, as we see superpowers do now.  Allah the Highest commands the Muslims to prepare great power to deter their enemies by striking fear into their hearts.  Allah the Highest said: “AND PREPARE FOR THEM WHAT YOU CAN OF POWER AND HORSES, TO STRIKE FEAR INTO ALLAH’S ENEMIES AND YOUR ENEMIES AND OTHERS YOU DO NOT KNOW, BUT ALLAH KNOWS, AND WHATEVER YOU SPEND IN THE CAUSE OF ALLAH WILL BE PAID BACK TO YOU IN FULL, AND YOU WILL NEVER BE TREATED UNJUSTLY”.  (S:8 A:69)

The believers however rely on Allah’s support and help besides their own power, while the disbelievers rely of their power only.

The devil whispers into people’s hearts to do what is wrong, until the wrong is done, and then the devil disclaims responsibility.  Satan’s way is usually by beautifying the wrong and making it sound good and appealing, giving reassurances and guarantees, but Satan always lies.  

On the Day of Badr Satan did that with the disbelievers, but when the two armies met, he abandoned them and turned away, as he saw the angels gathering to support the Allah’s messenger and the Muslims, which they did not see.  “AND AS YOU PLEAD TO YOUR LORD FOR HELP AND HE ANSWERED YOU: “I WILL REINFORCE YOU WITH A THOUSAND OF THE ANGELS, ARRIVING IN SUCCESSION”.  (S:8 A:9)

There were two unwilling groups involved in this battle:

  1. The Hypocrites who went out with the Muslims with the hope of getting the bounty from the caravan of Abu Sofian.
  2. Those who had disease in their heart, meaning weakness in their faith.  They were those Muslims from Makah who did not migrate as they did not wish to leave their money and property behind, and some of them went along with the army of Makah.

In this battle, the Muslims put their trust in Allah the Highest, for they knew that Allah the Highest is:

  • Exalted in power, that is His Power is supreme and superior to all, therefore those He supports, no one can defeat.
  • Wise, using His supreme power where it ought to be used.

r/progressive_islam • • 1d ago

Question/Discussion ❔ Repairing the broken bond between self and God

3 Upvotes

I have always operated from the position that although God is our lord and master, His primary emotion towards us is of love and he expects love AND reverence back.

So I practiced my faith very idealistically- no drinking, no zinah - even when no one would have known - doing the right thing even when no one’s watching, praying as much as possible, respecting my parents and the community etc.

Yet, it feels like I kept getting tested too much - time and money wasted in an abusive marriage, trauma, having my second (and good) wife losing a pregnancy midway later on..

This has driven me away and I find myself holding grudges against Allah for being way too tough on me, and not on people who don’t practice the faith and religion so idealistically.

My question has now been, what if you are upset that after all the struggle of being on the right path, you keep getting handed the short end of the stick?

How do you connect with God again?

The priests, my friends, or scholars just say the oft-repeated line, that “this is all a test and we are supposed to endure all the hardships”.

It doesn’t resonate with me.

And they have nothing more to offer, get anfry if you prod too much.

I still don’t drink or engage in adultery etc., try to be a good human, but I stopped praying, can’t get myself drawn to it again, stopped caring too much about Zabeeha (still, no pork) and I feel quite heartbroken spiritually.

I wonder if anybody has gone through this and found their way back to regular prayers and all?


r/progressive_islam • • 1d ago

Rant/Vent 🤬 After visiting makkah madina, I feel so worthless

1 Upvotes

I feel so numb. I've been such a bad muslim. I've wasted 18 years of my life n now the guilt of my sins wont leave me alone. I want jannah, i want jannah so so bad like every person but at the same time i dont want it because i never struggled for it and i cant no matter how hard i try because its still nothing compared to before n after Nabi Saw I heard the stories of Islam there and thats making me feel so bad i cant even explain in words, to the point I question whyAllah even created a worthless human like me, I'm just a human nothing else. Also, I shouldnt say this but im so so jealous of sahabas, bibi fatima, hazrat ibrahim to every single person, bird, camels alive at that that to the rope from which camel of Muhammad PBHU was tied. Now that i think of it, They were also just humans,like me when created but they were clearly infinity times luckier than me when Allah chose them. How is this fair? and I hate feeling like this