r/reloading • u/CBM64_SYS64738 • 8h ago
i Have a Whoopsie I’m an idiot: Don’t cross-contaminate your powder!
I’m an absolute idiot, and I’m posting this as a PSA about complacency and hubris in the hope others might learn from my idiocy.
After 36 years of reloading I finally managed to do what we all know not to do from day one, and that is accidentally cross-contaminate reloading powder. The result of my stupidity were .223 rifle rounds loaded with rifle powder contaminated with enough pistol powder to cause catastrophic failure (pics attached).
I disassembled the remaining ammo batch, and after weighing each load and pouring the powder into ice-cube trays, I see I’ve got significant traces of pistol HS-6 powder within the intended Winchester 748 rifle loads.
In the picture, you can see this in highlighted tray-slot #7 (HS-6 has larger and more silvery flakes than W748).
Looking at my reloading log book, I’m thinking what I did was not properly clear out the powder hopper when switching from reloading pistol rounds to rifle. Once again, completely my fault.
Now we know the cause, what were the results of this dumb-assery? I was on the bench sighting in the scope on my competition AR; a RightToBear Builder’s Grade 16” mid-length upper on a DSA lower. About 15 rounds of slow-fire into the session, a monumental “boom” instead of the expected “bang” occurs. I’m not hurt at all, but the magazine base is blown out and the upper receiver and bolt are ruptured. Looking at the bolt, it’s absolutely split and peeling like a banana. The results are the rifle in the top of one of the photos.
Now, here is where my damn hubris bites me even more in the butt. You might think I’d tell myself “Huh - there must be something wrong with my ammo, so I’d better stop shooting!” but you would be wrong.
With a series of competition events looming and dwindling time to sight in, I stupidly tell myself “The fault can only be with the rifle, and not my precision-loaded, boutique custom reloads!”. With this sense of self-righteousness I pull out my second AR and start sighting that in for use in the competitions using the same batch of reloads.
Another ten rounds in, and “Boom” - the exact same thing happens to my Bushmaster. The Bushmaster did not hold up quite as well as the RightToBear; the photo (rifle on the bottom) shows a lot more destruction to the upper and bolt.
Once again, I incredibly escaped any injury.
In hindsight, although I blew out two uppers I consider myself lucky in that I was able to identify the problem and implement a solution without injuring myself or anyone else.
Interestingly, while I was sure there would be no warranty available due to the use of wildly inappropriate reloaded ammo, I reached out to the customer service team at RightToBear and explained my Tomfoolery. They (rightly) confirmed the warranty could not cover that damage, but incredibly they gave me store credit of a sum way higher than I could ever have expected or deserved. They seemed genuinely glad I was OK, and were very generous despite me completely causing the issue. I’ve since bought a replacement Builder’s Grade upper and already have it configured on the same DSA lower (both lowers seem untouched and work fine). A big kudos to the RightToBear customer service team!
So, lessons learned:
- No matter how experienced one might be at reloading, it’s always possible to make a mistake. Don’t get too comfortable.
- Thoroughly clean out powders from hoppers, necks,drums, etc when changing loads.
- Always wear protective shooting glasses!
- Keep a reloading log and segment reloads into batches. Since I record and batch my reloads, I only have to pull a couple of hundred reloads instead of thousands.
- Always have first-aid on hand. I was lucky and didn’t need it, but it could have been very different.
- Always wear protective shooting glasses!
Thanks for tolerating my ramblings and stupidity; maybe this might help someone.
Cheers!