I’m a plumber who’s fixing another plumbers shower valve screw up for a customer. Long story short, valve needs to come out, it’s a bathtub with a full tile surround about 3 years old.
Is it possible to remove a few tiles, cut a hole in the backerboard so i can replace the valve, put a new piece of backer board in, waterproof the seams between the replacement patch and the existing board, then retile?
I have been told by two tile guys that the entire surround must be replaced as you cant waterproof a section like that. I know nothing of tile, i accept that replacing the whole thing is probably the safest solution, however i can’t wrap my head around why it isn’t possible to
1: remove tile
2: leave 2-3” of backerboard protruding past the tile that is remaining untouched
3: install the new piece of backerboard and slather reguard or other waterproofing material over the seam
4: retile
Is it actually impossible or is it just a tedious annoying job that is not lucrative enough?
Thanks