Hey everyone, I’m at my wit's end with my 1998 E39 530d (M57, 184hp, manual) and I really need some advice before I throw more money at it.
The Original Problem:
The car had violent vibrations, bucking/jerking, and metallic clacking sounds, especially around 2,000 RPM (right around when the turbo spools/under load).
The car already has:
• Brand new Dual-Mass Flywheel (DMF) and clutch.
• New shock absorbers.
• Wheels are brand new and completely straight.
• I haven't replaced the engine/transmission mounts yet—I have the new parts ready to install next week—but the current ones aren't completely destroyed).
• Previous owner said he checked the injectors, but I might get a check on them.
What I just did (thought it was the pulley):
I inspected the crankshaft pulley (harmonic balancer) and saw that the vulcanized rubber was visibly torn. I was 100% sure this was the root cause, so I bought a brand new harmonic balancer, tensioners/idlers, and belts.
I had a local mechanic (a good Mercedes specialist, since I don't have a reliable BMW indie nearby) install everything.
The Current Situation (Much Worse):
Right after picking the car up, it is completely undriveable.
It’s now making loud metallic CLACK noises even at 1,000 RPM.
Looking at the engine bay while it runs, the new pulley seems to be wobbling/shaking a lot.
Every time it makes the loud clacking sound, the engine (especially the air filter box side) jumps violently.
Diagnostics & Mechanic's Opinion:
The mechanic told me he thinks it’s an injector or fuel pump issue when the turbo spools and suggested taking it to a diesel injection specialist.
However, the last time I checked with INPA, the injector correction values at idle looked fine(-0.3,0.4,-0.2 etc..)
I did previously have a Crankshaft Position Sensor fault code stored in INPA but now idk why my INPA stopped working a few months ago.
My Questions:
- Could the mechanic have installed the new Corteco pulley incorrectly (e.g., missed the dowel pin on the crank hub or torqued it unevenly), causing this wobble and making the car way worse?
- Or could a bad injector / fuel delivery issue / failing crank sensor really cause the engine to jump and clack this violently even at 1,000 RPM?
- What should be my next step here? Should I tow it back to the mechanic to double-check the pulley installation first, or look into the crank sensor/injectors?
Any help is massively appreciated!